On September 11, 2001, after the planes hit the World Trade Center, Father Mychal Judge ran into the North Tower alongside the firemen he served. Soon after, he was recorded as the first victim of the terrorist attacks.
Extremely proud of his Irish heritage, Robert Emmett Judge was born in Brooklyn on May 11, 1933, to two Irish emigrants from Co Leitrim. At the age of 16, he answered his calling to the Franciscan vocation and entered St. Joseph’s Seraphic Seminary in Callicoon, New York, where he was received into the Franciscan Order on August 12, 1954.
In 1957, he graduated from St. Bonaventure University, the Franciscan school near Olean, New York. He was ordained into the priesthood on February 25, 1961.
After taking a vow of poverty, Judge became committed to helping impoverished New Yorkers and those in minority groups such as gays, the homeless, immigrants, and AIDS sufferers. In 1992, he became a Chaplain for the Fire Department of New York (FDNY).
Father Mychal Judge. (911Memorial.org)
On the morning of September 11, 2011, Father Mychal rushed from his friary at St. Francis of Assisi Church on 31st Street to the scene at the World Trade Center. He was at the North Tower command center administering prayers, but after the South Tower collapsed, he was fatally injured and needed to be carried out of the building. NYPD Lt. Jose Rodriguez performed last rites moments before the North Tower collapsed.
The FDNY Chaplain was filmed by the Naudet brothers, who happened to be making a documentary about firefighters, praying inside the World Trade Center before it collapsed. Footage later shows firefighters tending to Judge after he was fatally injured.
A photo, captured by Shannon Stapleton for Reuters, of Judge's body being carried by other responders amidst the chaos emerged as one of the most iconic photos of the day.
Father Judge's body was laid at the altar of St. Peter's Church.
New York firefighters & rescue workers are seen Sept. 11, 2001, carrying Franciscan Father Mychal Judge, a chaplain with #FDNY who died while giving last rites to a firefighter on #September11 (CNS photo/Shannon Stapleton, Reuters) #WorldTradeCenter #NeverForget pic.twitter.com/yjqhyFHP86
— Catholic News Service (@CatholicNewsSvc) September 11, 2021
A fellow friar at St. Francis of Assisi, Father Patrick Fitzgerald, first met Judge during their formative years in the Franciscan order. Their friendship began on September 11, 1951, exactly 50 years to the day that Judge lost his life in the terror attacks.
“He was very good to a lot of people,” Fitzgerald recalls. “He was selfless.
“When people would give him gifts at Christmas time, he would write them the nicest letter and then bring them down to AIDS patients in the Bailey House on Christopher Street. They wound up with the nicest sweaters, scarves, and even Irish caps,” he told the Irish Voice, sister publication to IrishCentral.
“I know that he was very proud to be Irish. He knew the details of his mother and father’s emigration and had traveled to Ireland many times.”
A recovered alcoholic, Judge celebrated his 23rd year of sobriety in 2001. No stranger to addiction, he instilled courage in the many lives he touched.
“A lot of young men whom he helped get into sobriety will tell you he was ‘Father Mike.’ He really mirrored for a lot of men the great image of a father,” says Brian Carroll, a former Franciscan friar and colleague of Judge.
David Fullam, a retired lieutenant in the FDNY and formerly stationed at Ladder 24 where Judge was chaplain, has fond memories of the Irish American.
“He married me and my wife, Linda. He baptized my daughter, Shannon, and blessed my wife when she was pregnant with our second child,” Fullam told the Irish Voice.
“He was truly something special. He had certain charisma and charm.” He remembers Judge’s wit and how he liked to crack a joke.
“Even when I asked him to marry us a year in advance, he said, ‘I cannot do it, I have funeral that day.’ I was really disappointed before he stopped me and said, ‘Dave, it’s a year away, I don’t know what I will be doing, of course I will marry you.’
“I was overjoyed,” the firefighter recalls.
After receiving minor burns on the job, Fullam was admitted to the hospital late one night and was surprised when Judge appeared in the early hours of the morning.
“I was just amazed that he showed up. You don’t expect people to visit after midnight. He sat and spent some time with me, making sure that I was okay.
“He apologized to me for not bringing wool socks. Whenever you visit a firefighter they always had wet feet as their boots are soaked," Fullam explained.
When the news came that Judge had lost his life in the terrorist attacks, Fullam raced to the firehouse on 31st Street where Judge’s body was laid out in a makeshift shrine.
“When we got the news that afternoon, we weren't that far away. They had him laid out in the firehouse,” Fullam recalls.
“He is the only one that had an open casket funeral. I was happy I was able to kiss his hands. I think he knew that God had taken him for a reason. He was there for everybody else.”
In 2026, 25 years after the 9/11 attacks,FDNY Pro Films released "Remembering Judge":
*This column first appeared in the Irish Voice newspaper, sister publication to IrishCentral, in September 2014. Last updated September 2026.
Comments