Liam Neeson's public embrace of Islam has certainly landed him in the middle of a steaming controversy.
The Irish Hollywood star told the London Sun that he was considering adopting the religion because of his experiences in Istanbul while filming where he found the calls to prayer and beauty of its historic mosques very moving.
I knowLiam Neeson somewhat as we serve on the American Irish Historical Society board together and we often meet in Irish circles in New York.
He is as normal as a Hollywood superstar could be, courteous and genuine to a fault.
But there is no question that life dealt him a savage blow in March 2009 when his wife Natasha died tragically after a minor ski accident in Canada.
I had last seen them together at the American Ireland Fund dinner in New York where they were such a striking handsome couple and clearly in love.
Hollywood star Liam Neeson says he may convert to Islam
More stories on Liam Neeson from IrishCentral
FOX TV anchor Greg Kelly strongly denies rape accusation charge by woman he met
The death left him devastated. I remember meeting him long after it had occurred and he still seemed deeply shocked by what had happened.
It is understandable that after such an awful occurrence, which left him a widower with two young kids, Liam Neeson would question life's certainties and the received wisdoms we all take for granted.
His interview with the Sun was also notable for his statement that he was constantly searching for proof of God's existence and seeking out the latest books on religion.
It is clear from his hectic work schedule that he threw himself into his work after his wife's tragic passing. Hardly a month goes by that we don't see him in some movie or other.
But at a deeper level clearly he is searching too which is what he was saying in the Sun interview.
If Islam and its tenets gives him some insight and comfort well then why not embrace it?
The religion gets a bad rap in the west -- there are tens of millions who practice a moderate form of it that is no more militant than Catholicism.
Lest we forget the mote in our own eye let's not forget the crusades where Muslims in massive numbers were put to the sword by invading Catholic armies.
Liam Neeson is still on a quest no doubt, so we should not be surprised when he reaches some different conclusions along the way.
Unless we have walked in his shoes and suffered the unbearable loss he did we are in no position to pass judgement on his choices.