Fine Gael Presidential election candidate Gay Mitchell has been dragged into his own clemency row – just 24 hours after David Norris was forced to quit the campaign.

Details have emerged of a letter written by Mitchell in a bid to prevent a double killer being given a lethal injection on Florida’s death row in 2003.

The Dublin politician was Fine Gael spokesman on Foreign Affairs when he made the appeal on behalf of Paul Hill, an anti-abortion fanatic who murdered two people.

Hill, a former Presbyterian Minister, was convicted of the 1994 murder of a doctor and his bodyguard outside an abortion clinic in the US state.


Read More:

David Norris not the first to use office to help convict

Hate mail deluge for Irish blogger who exposed Norris support for rapist

David Norris would have made a fine president of Ireland

Gay Mitchell chosen to contest presidential election for Fine Gael


A campaigner against the death sentence, Mitchell wrote to Florida governor Jen Bush on Hill’s behalf. In his letter, Mitchell pleaded that Hill had committed a senseless crime but that ‘executing him would only perpetuate the cycle of taking life’.

Governor Bush ignored Mitchell’s plea and Hill, who claimed he was a martyr for the anti-abortion cause, was put to death by injection.

A spokesperson for Mitchell has denied to the Irish Examiner that the 2003 letter bears any comparison to Senator Norris’ appeal for clemency for a convicted child rapist.

“Mr Mitchell did it because he is an implacable opponent of the death penalty,” said the spokesperson.

“It is different to the Norris situation in that he was seeking that the death penalty be replaced by a term in prison. He wasn’t seeking mitigation.

“Mr Mitchell has also intervened on behalf of other prisoners facing the death penalty.”

Gay Mitchell speaking with Irish PM Enda Kenny