American in Ireland


Galway's shameful proposal to honor Che Guevara

Posted on Thursday, March 01, 2012 at 08:59 AM

RSS


Recent Posts

Archives

submit to reddit

The most famous image of Che Guevara -
by Irishman Jim Fitzpatrick.
Galway City Council wants to erect a statue to Argentinian revolutionary Che Guevara. Che, who was born in 1928, had Irish roots going back to the early 18th century. Che's distant ancestor Patrick Lynch was from Galway, which is the City Council's justification for wanting to erect a statue to a man who spent one night in Ireland, accidentally, thanks to fog at Shannon Airport. He never set foot in Galway.

Che's father did once try to explain his son's revolutionary ways saying the "blood of the Irish rebels" flowed in his veins. That is a load of hooey, as I'm sure Che's father knew, but that doesn't stop those Irish people who admire him from latching on to him as one of their own. Che's one night in Ireland was spent in Kilkee, Co. Clare, where last fall the townsfolk honored the memory of that one night with a 3-day festival. Galway obviously feels cheated that its 300-year-old link to Che is not getting the proper recognition, hence the statue proposal.

According to the Galway Advertiser the idea for the Galway statue came from a member of the City Council, Labour's Billy Cameron, who is "an ardent admirer of the revolutionary." Cameron is hardly alone. Che shirts and posters have been de rigueur for the hippest, coolest protesters and revolutionary-wannabees for decades. However, you're supposed to grow out of that phase. Cameron clearly has not.

____________
Read More:

Galway plans to build monument to Che Guevara slated by local millionaire

Irish politician a “puppet of U.S military”

Obama slaps ban on Irish musicians traveling to Cuba
_____________

The proposed statue has not made much news in Ireland, but one man, businessman and sometime political campaigner Declan Ganley, has been on a mission to scupper this plan for the past week. Ganley (@declanganley) is a Galway man himself and worries that such a statue would damage Galway's reputation, especially in America, hurting the chances of investment and putting Americans off visiting the city.

That seems a bit of a stretch to me. I doubt too many tourists would know much of Che beyond recognizing his face and, well, business is business.

However, yesterday, the Chairman of the House Foreign Affairs Committee Ileana Ros-Lehtinen issued a press release asking Galway City Council to reject the proposal to erect the Che Statue. "The romanticizing image that this monument would portray would serve to diminish the brutality that was committed by Che and the painful suffering endured by many Cuban-American families and his other victims far and wide."

Ileana Ros-Lehtinen is a Cuban-American and Cuban-Americans know far more about Che than the average American and, I daresay, than the average Irish revolutionary wannabee. And they don't like him, not one bit. Whereas the average American may not take much interest in whether Galway honors Che Guevara, people from South Florida and other Cuban enclaves may take a keen interest.

Galway City Councillor - Billy Cameron,whose idea
it was to erect a statue ofChe Guevara
The Cuban government has pledged to help pay for the statue so I guess Galway's Councillors can rest easy knowing Fidel's on their side. Whether the Cuban people admire Che as much as Councillor Cameron and the rest is impossible to say because, as Representative Mario Diaz-Balart put it: "Galway is a city where people have the right to vote, the right to worship freely, the right to speak freely, and access a free press -- all of which 'Che' Guevara and his murderous associate, dictator Fidel Castro, ruthlessly suppressed."

There's no way that Councillor Cameron or anyone who shares his views will take that seriously. They know better than those Cuban-Americans just like they knew better than to listen to all those exiles from Poland, Hungary, Czechoslovakia, etc.

There's a part of me that half hopes the statue goes up and is defaced and damaged by Cubans who live here in exile. There are some. Or, better yet, I'd like to think that when Cubans do finally shake off the shackles of Castro's rule some of them will find their way to Ireland and pull the statue down and curse those who put it up. It's a dream.

The proposal is hideous, but I'm not surprised by it. It suits the mind-set of a small segment of the Irish people. I'd love to know what Ireland's President, a Galway man too, thinks of the idea. I suppose I should just consider it fortunate that no one ever found any Irish link to Lenin or Stalin or Mao. Honoring one mass-murderer is enough.

{Photo of Cameron from Labour.ie}


33 Comments

15 - 33 | See all comments

Hmm... lots of comments, both for and against the idea of a monument honouring Che Guevara. I visited the Che mausoleum a few years ago in Santa Clara while on holiday in Cuba and found it very interesting indeed. All Cubanos I spoke to revere his memory. He is referred to by one and all as "El Commandante." His grand-daughter doesn't seem too concerned though - she was happy to be photographed a while back, wearing a beret (and very little else) and crossed bandoliers filled with carrots.
che guevara was a revolutionary who fought to free the people of cuba from an american backed dictator.im sure al of you 20th generation bigots wouldnt refer to george washington as a killer or a butcher. your all just jealous cos he was more irish than you will ever be.
I have lived outside of Ireland which is why Im not a racist bigot to migrants who move to Ireland to find work unlike yourself. You dont even live here and youre a racist to those who move here.Youre bitter that the Irish dont conform to your 'Irish' American stereotype and arent still living in the time of the Field and The Quiet man. Remember what happened the yank in 'the Field George'. It still gets a cheer.
HAHA! George, you are a total retard! My step mam is from Mendoza. I have been to Argentina several times. My step sister lives in Valencia in Spain so Im well versed on Argentinian AND Spanish history AND culture! I dont drink alcohol so seriously cop on. Ive just realsied that you arent a genuine person with any gra for Ireland, you are simply a troll, both in prose and spirit! Che's granny was Irish, born and bred and she moved when she was in her 20s! Thats just a fact even though you try to change it, you cannot! I feel sorry for you! DO you speak Spanish like you speak Irish? With an American accent? Pathetic! No wonder 'Irish' Americans are thought of so badly in the rest of the world, with people like you shooting their mouths off Im not surprised.
We can always rely on the moron curdexter to show her ineffable ignorance. She reminds me of those drunk Irish women who urinate in public on a Saturday night--she knows no shame and doesn't care who'll see her. You know nothing about Che, you imbecile, and less about Argentina or its history. As I have pointed out earlier, --you're apparently too much of a stupid oaf to read with second grade comprehension-- the Lynch connection with Spain--and later Argentina--originated about ten generations ago. Unlike you, you poltroon, I have lived in Argentina. And I speak Spanish. You have never lived outside of Ireland, as is shown by your stupid narrow mind, ignorance and bigotry. And you know no other language than English--you're a mindless monolingual moron, curdexter!
Perhaps they want a statue to the 'Motorcycle Diaries' Che or the 'Poster Pin-Up' Che, rather than Congo, Bolivia and post revolution Che. Future statues to Gerry Adams will show a bearded, pensive figure rather than the one marching in beret, specs and black tie (was he trying to mimic Che in those bygone days?)History is always selective in the story it perpetuates, but here we have a choice; Lets ride the the 'pretty boy biker' Che out of town on a wheel and make sure you you have one toting a few guns, and preferably pointing them with a sneer...
On a related item Yank, sorry to see your last article (Irish Heritage Certificates) was pulled by IC. I guess freedom of speech only extends as far as your sponsers. Viva capitalism.
Che's grandmother, Anna Isabel Lynch was born in Co. Galway and moved to South America. hes got closer 'Irish' ties than you have Georgie. Jealous??
Collette" What "Irish roots"? Ten generations ago? That's nonsense.
Anybody famliar with his life story and his sense of justice, would have to recognise his Irish roots. There are worse who have gone down in history books.
One more thing. Why spend the money to build a worthless figure of a killer. Those funds could be better used to help those in need. That's what Che would want, right?
Che? This is a joke, right? What the hell people. Learn a little before you start building statues to a POS like this one.
Oh boy, Let's honor 'The Butcher of Havana" with a statue and show what uninformed idiots we really are!! Yeaaaaa!!!
Fulgencio Batista was not a great guy, and surely did eliminate opposing voices during his regime. The American gangsters were running much of Havana during his time in power. It was a great era for the wealthy Spanish Cubans and professionals that catered to them .The general Cuban population was struggling to survive. The American mob kept the money flowing within a designated circle. Castro and Guevera evolved from this situation. In Castro's case, he came to the US first asking for help with the corruption, was ignored, and spent his visit to the US in a hotel in Harlem. Am sure Guevera was involved in some assinations, but a mass murderer. No..
Che was a mass murderer and would enslave everyone in order to fee them. Had he been more successful he would be right there with Hitler and Stalin.




Log into IrishCentral with your Facebook account


or sign-in directly

E-Mail:
Password:
 Remember me Forgot my password
Not a member? Register Now!
print this article Print
email this articleE-mail