Brian Friel admitted copying my work says neurologist and author Oliver Sacks
Famed Irish playwright used passages word for word from Sacks’ New Yorker article
World-famous neurologist and best-selling author Oliver Sacks has claimed that renowned playwright Brian Friel borrowed an article he wrote ‘word of word’ in one of his most famous plays.
British-American Sacks is reported as suggesting that Friel is guilty of ‘cryptomnesia’ rather than ‘plagiarism’ according to the Sunday Independent newspaper.
The paper quotes from an article by Sacks for The New York Review of Books where he refers to passages of his work being recreated in Friel’s 1994 play Molly Sweeney.
The play is about a woman who has been blind since she was 10 months old and has her sight restored in her 40s with shattering consequences.
Sacks writes: “Perhaps the term ‘cryptomnesia’ needs to be better known. The very word ‘plagiarism’ is so morally charged, so suggestive of crime and deceit, that it retains a sting even if it is unconscious.”
The report adds that the author then says that Friel’s play Molly Sweeney, first staged in 1994, makes extensive use of material from a 1993 article Sacks had written for The New Yorker, using ‘entire phrases and sentences’.
The Sunday Independent says that in a 1993 article in The New Yorker, titled 'To See But Not See,' Prof Sacks recounted the case of a man in Oklahoma who had his sight restored after a lifetime of blindness. He wrote how the man subsequently had great difficulty in trying to cope with being able to see.
In his current article for The New York Review of Books, Prof Sacks says: “In 1996 when the play was on in New York, I read a review of a new play, Molly Sweeney, by Brian Friel.
“It was, I read, about a massage therapist, born blind, who is given sight by an operation in middle life, but then finds this unprecedented ability to see profoundly confusing.
“I was startled by this, because I myself had written and published in The New Yorker, just three years earlier, the case history of a patient with an exceedingly similar story ‘To See and Not See.'
“When I obtained a copy of Friel’s new play, I was not surprised to find it brilliant and original in conception and style, but I was surprised to find, over and above the thematic similarities, entire phrases and sentences from my own case history.
“I wrote to Friel, and he responded that he had indeed read my piece, and had been much moved by it and the more so as he had feared he was losing his own vision.
“He had also read many other case histories of the restoration of vision. Friel concluded that he must have inadvertently used some phrases from my account, but that this was completely unconscious, and agreed to add to Molly Sweeney an acknowledgment of the sources of his inspiration.”
- Gay wedding cakes latest target of anti-gay...
- Racist incidents in Ireland up by 85 percent...
- An open letter in strong defence of capitalism.
- A Magdalene Laundry US adoptee who holds...
- Irish radio presenter suspended after anti-Isra
- Nelson Mandela was against IRA decommissioning.
- Baby dies in horror birth at Belfast hospital...
- Gay teacher fired from Catholic school after...
- Sarah Palin is saving Christmas
- Families as well as Catholic Church and governm
Curitiba, You ask me "what's the massive difference?" between English and Irish people (in support of your argument that "Ireland is aThe perfect gift for Christmas, a stay at an Irish hotel
I know of one very Irish guest house operated by an Irish couple in Connecticut, near my wife's hometown. She and I have spent a few nights there arouNelson Mandela once considered a terrorist by many Irish political leaders
You should hear in the USA the right wng extremists calling Nelson Mandela all kinds of names and insults...........Why because he is black. These riVirginia governor slammed by doctor over plain cigarette pack rejection
YOur welcome to smoke - and take a decade off you life from lung cancer, throat cancer, nicotine scaring the arteries which provides places where pla