The West's Awake


The West's Awake by Cormac MacConnell

Singing the blues of Eurovision - Jedward gear up to compete again - VIDEOS

Posted on Friday, March 09, 2012 at 08:37 AM

RSS


Recent Posts

Archives

submit to reddit

Illustration by Caty Bartholomew
There is a schizoidal element to the perennial Eurovision Song Contest which has always fascinated me.

About everyone on this island says that they scorn it and that it is not worth watching. But the show, which will be with us again soon, has one of the highest viewing audiences of the year. And Ireland has won it more often than any other country.

There was an era when we won it almost every year. That era is well and truly over and has been for a long time. Mostly nowadays we don't even qualify from the semi-finals to compete on the big final night.

Relatively trivial events like song contests should not matter at all but dammit, to me at least they do, especially if there is a European competitive dimension and especially under our current social and economic circumstances.

I know I'm mostly a fool, but at a time when we have our begging bowl constantly pushed in front of our European betters it is somehow sad that the island famed for song and music and dance and craic can no longer musically compete even at the pop music level. It's maybe a deeply indicative reality of where we are across the whole scale.

Back when we won the Eurovision almost every year we were able to send fine singers with fine songs into the competition. Many of the songs were submitted by amateur songwriters from all over the country to the national broadcaster RTE which organizes the preliminary national competition to select the Irish entry.

The winners invariably had a Celtic flavor, uniquely Irish, sung by good Irish performers and reflecting the realities of the year.

At a time when the North was ablaze with civil strife, for example, there was a compelling poignancy about the young Derry girl Dana singing the gentle "All Kinds Of Everything.” It swept the boards.

Our Johnny Logan created history by winning not just once but twice, and one of his winners, ironically, bore the title "What's Another Year?"

All those victories were a matter of great national pride. The singers and the songs represented us proudly and well.
-----------------
Read more: 
Five murdered Irish emigrants will be reburied in a new grave today- VIDEO

The ten very best ways to spend St.Patrick’s Day this year
-----------------
The national competition was staged recently by RTE. It was clear from the very beginning of the show that there could only be one winner.

There are Dublin twin boys called (I think) John and Edward Grimes who trade under the musical name of Jedward, and they are all the pop rage at the moment. Crowds of their teenage fans turned up at RTE when the news spread they were competing.

I'm sure they are lovely lads and I wish them well in their careers, but the truth is that they look ridiculous to anyone of my generation.

They can't really sing, and they are losers on the Eurovision scene. They were also the Irish entry last year, attracted a deal of tabloid coverage because of their appearance and staged antics, and came nowhere in the competition itself.

Frankly they embarrass me. They are the epitome of the crazy Euro pop music scene.

They have their hair blonded and spiked amazingly high atop their heads. They dress like creatures from outer space in blazing costumes of plastic stuff and what looks like metallic piping.

On the credit side, they bring such an amazing element of acrobatic ability to their performances that you almost don't notice they cannot really sing.

The songs chosen for them by those behind them are high energy yokes -- boppity-bops -- with no Irish flavor to them at all.

The teenagers, especially teenage girls, are blown away by them. A high percentage of the national vote is via the texting which suits that teenage generation.

Therefore, Jedward will be representing Ireland again in the Eurovision Song Contest this year and, beyond any reasonable doubt, they will lose again. They might not even qualify for the final.

That should not matter at all but somehow it does. This contest is actually a highly politicized affair. The voting patterns on the final night from all over the continent follow regional linkages.

East Europe votes solidly for East Europe no matter what the song sounds like, and it is likewise with West Europe. It is somehow pathetic that the Irish are wounded if England does not give us as many votes as we give them. But that is the truth!

Tensions are nearly as high on the night as they are at a soccer match. And in the end our Jedward will lose again.

The winning country has the honor of staging the competition the following year. It is a major tourism boost which would suit us very well at the moment. That won't be happening again, probably ever. I feel ridiculous even writing this, but it is a major talking point just at the moment.

The plus side of that, maybe, is that there has been no mention of the euro crisis for days except for the news that our European masters have just put another three billion into our begging bowl to help clear our debts. That's because we are applying our austerity regime so faithfully.

The Lord between us and all harm...


Eurosong Winners 2012 - Jedward - Waterline:




Eurovision 2011 Final Ireland: Jedward - Lipstick:




14 Comments

See all comments

My beautiful grandson who is six years old has adored John and edward for the last 2 years, he refuses to call them jedward, A year ago I took him to their concert in Dublin (was dreading it) but watching him dancing in the aisle and cheering them on was worth it. We got to meet them backstage after the show, they were great with the kids, so polite and amusing when my grandson asked for a photo of them with his nannie, they made my day when one of them said will you be my nannie ? Ok may not be the best vocally but their manners won me over.
@Mr. MacConnell- as you see, you can't ever win when it comes to animals and music. Everyone gets angry and defensive, as if you insulted their grandmother. The lesson here: musical taste is in the EAR of the beholder. Thank goodness you didn't mention "Danny Boy". LOL Btw: I'm 39 and Jedward isn't my cup of tea, but each to his own.
OMG....half the time they are out of tune...TERRIBLE!!!!!!
@johnshiet: My comment was in defence of the brilliant Jedward boys against Cormac's pathetic and completely unjustified 'downer'. ~ That makes me an 'upper' I think. ~ But looking at your painful drivel @04.14 it is clear you would not be capable of understanding that. ~ ~ ~ Cursplutter: Thanks for that(I think!). Don't be surprised,I support anyone making an honest effort - as Edward and John Grimes are. Yaaay Jedward! ~ Booooo Cormac!
towngate: downers like yourself should at least have the good sense to remain hidden under your rocks.
hey cormac, odd topic but ok... got clicking around at lots of younger irish pop music, hopping back into trad some too... so I feel your pain re the punks dragging down the face of ireland's great performers... why isn't there a euro contest featuring trad music performers from all around? would highlight the bizarrely wide diversity you all have presumed to embrace with your euro dream... and final note: a pleasing discovery while cliking was group called the irish house party. so nice that I messaged my musician son about them. he dug the cliffs in the wee galeforce hours when there... adios.
When you say John and Edward Grimes can't sing, I fear you haven't listened to them as they most certainly can sing. They aren't singing the traditional Irish songs I suspect you crave, although I don't believe traditional Irish types of songs would get out of the semi-finals Ireland has to go through to reach the chance of winning the contest. The year is 2012 and life moves on. It's possible Jedward won't pass the semi finals this year in the way they did last year and if they do get the opportunity to compete in the final of course possible they won't gain higher than 8th position as they did last year, but the juries and public thought their song had the best chance at Eurosong. Support is what they need, not your naysaying. Support from Irish people for Jedward to do their very best. They will do their best. The Grimes' twins work ethic is second to none. They are in it to win it and my goodness they'll put on a fantastic show to demonstrate Ireland may have some problems at the moment but the joie de vivre of Ireland and its people is not lost. Man has a pair putting their best feet forward to show Ireland is not out of the game and will not only survive but prosper. To gain the Eurovision title and bring it back to a beautiful country promoting tourism and fun would be such a wonderful thing. They might just do it. As a resident of Germany I know where my vote is going.
Creakygate!!You're Back!! ;)) I didn't know you were a Jedward fan.
It's sad Cormac, that you still seem to be living in the last century. Ireland has moved on, Europe has moved on, the world has moved on. Ireland has endlessly tried to recreate the so called glory days of Eurovision since 1996. We tried resending one of your 'fine singer' Niamh Kavanagh with a 'fine song' in 2010 but she ended up being one of the real 'losers on the Eurovision scene' that year finishing 3rd last. And then of course, we went for the 'celtic flavour, uniquely Irish' route in 2006 with Dervish, and how did they do? Oh yes, they 'came nowhere'.......although last is technically somewhere isn't it? Jedward on the other hand did in fact come somewhere; they came a very respectable 8th place which was the best result for Ireland in 11 years. That made me very proud as an Irish person. In case you conveniently forgot, the winner of Eurosong was decided by a 50% jury vote and a 50% public vote, not a 100% teenage generation vote. Jedward won BOTH jury and public vote, so having Jedward representing the nation is a very fair outcome in light of this. I for one amy glad to see Jedward represent us again this years as they represented us proudly and extremely well last year. They lifted the spirit of the nation during last year's Eurovision because they are natural entertainers with boundless energy and charisma. Their positive outlook on life is refreshing. They put an end to our Eurovision shame with the best result in over a decade. Sadly, your view of winning seems to be very black and white. Nothing less than first place seems to be acceptable. It is evident that first place isn't everything when you look at last year's Eurovision. Jedward's 'Lipstick' was the most successful charting Eurovision song of 2011 across Europe. So although Jedward didn't technically win, I think they were the real winners of Eurovision 2011. I look forward to seeing them in Eurovision 2012.
" ... those there were who came to mock ~ and yet remained to pray!" Cormac, your auld dribbling drivel of a blog does neither you or Ireland any credit. In a country slowly disappearing up its own fundament, these two glittering examples of clean-living, energetic and committed performers,reflect the aspirations of the current pop culture of young Ireland exactly and they will proudly represent their native country;yes,even the deepest musty country backwaters where curmudgeonly old begrudgers whose writings are far far worse than their singing!
As you said, there are mostly teenagers who like Jedward, teenage girls in Europe who are huge fans of these lads and who'll probably vote up their entire credit. Most of the votes in ESC comes from kids or teenagers, at least in Sweden, I think that sounds a lot better than some boring song your generation may think is better. About their singing skills they've got a lot of crap before, but now when even Simon Cowell have admitted that he was wrong, who are you to complain? I mean if more than 500 000 Europeans love the twins and their music, who are you to tell them they are wrong? I also wanna point out that Jedward finished 8th the last year, it was Ireland's best result in a decade, wasn't it? They also gained much more fans during that night, so this year their chanses are even bigger. I may not be able to change your point of view, but I can guarantee that I'll do my best voting Jedward to victory this year. 12 points from Sweden!
I'm glad you respect my view as I do yours, but please understand the reason I didn't vote for them last year was because I didn't watch it live, so the first time I saw them it was too late for me to vote. I was Impressed by them immediately, although my country gave them 12 points, so it didn't much matter. This year I am making sure I will watch and vote. I think 8th place for an act that is virtually unknown in Europe as they were is amazing and of course their song Lipstick was a hit all over Europe
Rosey, I hugely respect your view and I'm sure you understand mine a little too. I regret that Jedward'snomination does not please me.And I note that even you did not vote for them last year!!!
I think its a shame you can't get behind Jedward and support them in Eurovision. I am actually in my late 40's, living in Europe and I will be voting for them, and by default Ireland, for the first time in my life, as I love them and their positive attitude. They came a very respectable 8th last year, and have since aquired a huge fan base across Europe, that may give them an even better chance of winning this year. As for Tourism, do you know the amount of people who travel to Ireland from all over the world, spending money on tickets, hotels, transport, food, souvenirs ect just to see Jedward perform, their Panto sold out, as do all their gigs, and believe me its not only Irish folk in attendance, and its not Kids who can afford to travel from country to country to see them. The world has moved on since Jonny Logan and Dana, they were good in their day, but would not work now. John and Edward are up there with the favourites tipped to win and there are many people all over Europe excited at the prospect of them performing at Eurovision once again..what a shame some of their own countrymen are not amongst them
 




Log into IrishCentral with your Facebook account


or sign-in directly

E-Mail:
Password:
 Remember me Forgot my password
Not a member? Register Now!
print this article Print
email this articleE-mail