American in Ireland


Open the pubs on Good Friday

Posted on Monday, March 08, 2010 at 09:08 AM

RSS


Recent Posts

Archives

submit to reddit

Part of the way we celebrate Easter in Ireland is that a certain percentage of the population suffers unduly on Good Friday because the sale of alcoholic beverages is banned. These people lead the annual moan about the pubs being closed for the day.

This year we got a head-start on the annual moan thanks to the fact that the authorities in charge of rugby have scheduled a big game between Leinster and Munster in Limerick on Good Friday night. The pub owners of Limerick, worried about the trade they might miss out on, are leading the campaign to be allowed to open for business on Good Friday.

Those for whom the DT's kick in at the very thought of Good Friday have joined the publicans in the bombardment of the airwaves with their plaintive cries asking us to feel their pain, their need.

This goes on annually. Every year the cries grow stronger and the sympathy for the sufferers greater. There is only one obstacle to the change needed by these poor people - the Catholic Church.

Or so they imagine. The airwaves are full of "this is not a theocracy" or "in this day and age the Church should not ..." and so on.

Well here's one Catholic that has heard their cry and is now joining the chorus: 'open the pubs.' Honestly, I've got no problems with pubs being open on Good Friday.

I'm no theologian by a long shot, but my little bit of research turned up no Church law requiring Catholics to abstain from alcoholic beverages and certainly nothing requiring that the civil law mandate that public houses be closed on Good Friday.

It's not a Church law. It's a government law based on an Irish custom. Maybe this custom is rooted in the traditional folk practices of Irish Catholics, but still it's an Irish custom and not a Church law. And like I said, as a Catholic I couldn't care less whether people buy a pint or ten on Good Friday.

However, as a resident and taxpayer and the father of impressionable youngsters living in this country I worry about it. I worry that as a nation we seem to need alcohol.

I'm not a teetotaler and enjoy being in the pub on occasion, but still I worry that the old customs are being replaced by new customs, such as celebrating the vomit, vice and violence that comes with too much drinking. The whole tone of city and town centers late at night is much more menacing than it was in the past.

Stereotypes notwithstanding, Ireland used to have one of the lowest per capita alcohol consumption rates in the EU. However, over the past 20 years Ireland has gone from being near the bottom to the top of the table. In 1990 the average Irish person consumed 6% more alcohol than the average American. By 2006 that gap was 40%.

Pubs used to be closed on Saint Patrick's Day too, but I don't feel less Catholic for that change having been made. The subsequent street violence and rioting have no impact on my faith. Same will be true on Good Friday. So go ahead and open the pubs on Good Friday.




15 Comments

See all comments

vincem13,

Are there places in America that have similar laws? I know there are towns and counties where alcohol sales are banned or severely restricted, but are there any places with a provision specifically for Good Friday?
I am an American Protestant and even I can see the rightness in the current law.
My point is that the closing of public houses is more custom than Church law and if people want to toss out a traditional Irish custom let's be honest about that. Those who want the law changed should not be using the Church as the whipping boy, but rather the laws of the land that developed out of the practices and customs of their ancestors.
Maybe I was a little too flippant in the post above, but it actually bothers me a lot that so many Irish people are quite easy about tossing away 1,500 years of Christianity and the customs and practices that are interwoven with it.
Joanhugh, Oh, I'm practicing all right, but probably won't make the first team.
mrkennedy I'm reserving judgment on Christina Gallagher.
To Ajreaper, "You cannot create laws to make people good Catholics or Christians" nor can you create laws to make people religious. In my experience "good christian" is an oxymoron.
This writer is a perfect example of what is happening in my beloved Ireland with so called Irish Catholics. Read the web site by Christina Gallagher, the STIGMATIST, as to what Our Blessed Mother has told her will be happening. Hasn't this past winter been a lesson in it self?
I agree with this article open the Pubs if the people want them open. I only disagree with one statement...the writer is not a Catholic or at least not a practicing Catholic
what would cucullin do? (WWCD?)
Good Friday is Bull ,Before the Concilium Tridentinum from December 13, 1545 to December 4, 1563 in twenty-five sessions for three periods Easter as we know it did not exist read about it Educate yourself ...Let no one Rape your brain.
SCRAP IT ITS A PEDOPHILE LAW MADE BY SEX ABUSERS
You cannot create laws to make people good Catholics or christians- those who wish to abstain will and those who wish to imbide will don't fool yourself into thinking a law for or against pubs being open on Good Friday changes what's in the heart of a man.
It is a Church law to abstain and fast on Good Friday!One day out of the year,not too much to ask!Those non -christian who may wish to party hardy can buy from the off-sales the night before!
Ireland has got plenty of serious problems right now. Irish bars being closed on Good Friday certainly isn't among them. There are many an Irish father (and some mothers too no doubt) who can well afford to spend a day away from a bar.
 




Log into IrishCentral with your Facebook account


or sign-in directly

E-Mail:
Password:
 Remember me Forgot my password
Not a member? Register Now!
print this article Print
email this articleE-mail