American in Ireland


Nothing unAmerican about USA's World Cup team

Posted on Wednesday, June 23, 2010 at 08:05 AM

RSS


Recent Posts

Archives

submit to reddit


Every four years the same articles appear in the Irish and British press about how Americans don't understand, don't 'get' soccer, err, "the beautiful game." They love to portray Americans, tediously, as looking for touchdowns or home-runs in soccer games.

The journalists who repeat these statements from Americans do so earnestly, not seeming to realize that it's an American way of saying soccer is a big yawn. Although people here can sometimes wax lyrical about the great defense in a 0-0 game that sort of scoring pace doesn't interest a lot of Americans.

However, this year those stories seem to be less common, possibly because it isn't just Americans who've been bored by this World Cup or possibly, just possibly, because they've realized that there are many Americans who do 'get' soccer.

Maybe that's why on Saturday the Irish Times ran with a different variation on the 'Americans & soccer' theme: conservative Americans don't like soccer because it's somehow "unAmerican" or even "Hispanic." As evidence Davin O'Dwyer cited Glenn Beck and G. Gordon Liddy, who uttered negative remarks about soccer, although only Liddy attached his argument to anything even vaguely "Hispanic."

I can't totally fault O'Dwyer, however, because I've come across similar views in the American press. In fact, last week NPR's web site published a piece that said much the same thing as O'Dwyer, basically claiming that race and ethnicity were contributing factors to Americans' failure to love the "beautiful game."

The race/ethnicity argument is laughable and it's a shame that someone outside America would repeat such nonsense. You only have to watch America's sports to realize how wrong that is: black stars dominate basketball and football and baseball features many, many players from the Dominican Republic, Puerto Rico, Cuba, Venezuela, Mexico, etc. Conservatives watch those sports, root for those players as much as liberals do. There's not much of a political angle in Americans sports.

Sure some Americans like soccer and some don't. I know plenty of Americans who don't like soccer. They find it boring or can't understand why anyone would watch or play a sport where the opposable thumb is an unnecessary appendage. I also know many Americans who love soccer. Political considerations have nothing to do with it: liberals and conservatives fit into both camps.

Among those who love it are many who've taken to watching the English Premier League and Champions League thanks to satellite television. Mostly these are men who are sports fanatics and who had a gap in their lives for live sports at 10am on Saturdays and Sundays or mid-afternoon on weekdays. European soccer was able to fill that gap.

These guys have a pretty good understanding of soccer. They're watching the World Cup pretty intensely and using the internet to source sports radio discussions or are using Facebook, Twitter, bulletin boards and chat rooms to get more information, analyses and opinions. The World Cup, like the Olympics, also attracts a lot of other American fans, people who'll watch this big festival of soccer, but who wouldn't consider themselves ardent fans of the game. Their interest will remain pretty high so long as the American team stays in the tournament.

All of which brings me to the most important issue of the day: the US team's must-win game against Algeria (10am on ESPN). If you watch you'll see the faces of the American players are the faces of America, their names are not solely Hispanic, but represent all of America and the players give every appearance of being extremely proud to wear USA on their jerseys when they play. UnAmerican? I don't think so.

What's more, Americans take can take great pride in the team because despite being far from the most talented side at the World Cup the USA team plays with real heart, never gives up and leaves it all on the field. What more could we ask for? Go USA!


7 comments

Page 1 of 1 pages
The Americans just don't like the low scoring. While it is a great experience to see a no hit game in baseball, that too can become a drag. A few years back, they lowered the mound in Baseball so that there would be more hits leading to more runs, when was the last time anyone saw a soccer game that ended 5-4 or 4-3. Watching goals being scored can be very exciting but it's never going to happen. I don't have the answer. I'll leave that to the pundits.
USA team was different. I think the old adage "the yanks can't play football" holds no weight anymore. neverless very interesting World Cup. Really...Japan's team.. Whats that? England's team.. to many individual players not enough team and Germany showed them a show. They have no say about that one goal. And of course the French! I was in Paris this last weekend and of course I had to ask. What a shame! Of course the way they got in but the way they played was terrible. They have the class/character of a goat. And the man at the hotel desk agreed.
jacersisityourself, A tough loss, but these things happen. I don't think the American media really understood how limited many of America's players were. They seemed to think that FIFA rankings meant US team SHOULD get to semi-finals. Uggh.

Could really have used a striker with a decent first touch and who had half an idea how to score, but wasn't to be. They gave it their all, which was all we could hope for. They had nothing left for extra time, unfortunately.
Whatever about the debate here, hafta say right now - tough luck to the USA soccer team who just lost to Ghana after extra time. If only those shots at goal had gone in... if only! Agonisingly close for the USA team, even before end of normal time if those shots had gone in instead of wide, the USA team would have been thru' to the next round. Great world Cup performance: the USA lads can hold their heads high and the people of the USA can be proud of them. As a soccer mad fella, I can tell you should be proud! Welcome them home as heroes of soccer in the USA.
Democrats like Pro-wrestling, huh? Figures. They prefer contrived to genuine.
ooconnell,

I don't know that I'd disagree with much that you write below. I have felt for years that the NY Times was trying to force soccer down our throats. They do that with women's sports too. It's that aspect - and the Times is only a small part of it - that has me hoping that soccer never becomes a big sport in America.

However, it doesn't stop me rooting for guys who clearly are proud to wear the USA jersey. My ideal scenario would be for America to win the World Cup, but for Americans to treat it like a big win at the Olympics - something to cheer, but not something that changes America's sporting culture.
You're not going to like me saying this, but in the US it does sometimes seem like soccer is the ethnic game of choice for for preppie kids of white middle class suburbanites, aka "soccer moms". Which is hilarious, since everywhere else it's treated like baseball is in America - i.e. a street-kid sport. But you get this kind of class inversion in other sports too - cricket is popular in India, elitist in Ireland. Rugby is working class in France, and maybe Limerick - but they are "Rugger-buggers" in much of the rest of the 26 counties. Especially south Dublin. And in fairness, while I know what you mean about the multiracial and ethnic aspect of sports in the US, the pointed thing about Hispanics is that they are still associated with _visible_ mass immigration, which does put the back up of a lot of (especially economically insecure) people there. If you add that to the preppie aspect and faintly finger-wagging liberal vibe from some quarters (one reason why the Metric system never took off there, I think), it doesn't help the cross-party loyalty. Actually, there was a study done about voting and cultural patterns in the US, that showed that e.g. NASCAR and NFL was bigger with Republicans, whereas Basketball and Pro-Wrestling was bigger with Democrats. I think.
Page 1 of 1 pages




Log into IrishCentral with your Facebook account


or sign-in directly

E-Mail:
Password:
 Remember me Forgot my password
Not a member? Register Now!
print this article Print
email this articleE-mail