Hero-worshiping Obama is not the answer to Ireland's problems
Posted on Tuesday, May 24, 2011 at 05:01 PM
RSS 
Recent Posts
- Ireland as Britain's wind farm - weighing up the pros and cons of ugly and heavily subsized Irish windfarms
- Justin Bieber's perfectly judged comment on Anne Frank - "Hopefully she would have been a belieber"
- The Irish property tax problem - everyone wants to own some and no one wants to be taxed on it
- American fans right to ignore the World Baseball Classic
- Will Ireland's emigrants catch a break on property tax?
Archives
It seems everyone in Ireland is feeling great about themselves after the visit of President Obama yesterday. It was the ultimate feel‑good day, with the most powerful man on Earth and "coolest President ever" shaking hands, kissing babies and schmoozing with the Irish people for a few hours. The President delivered a speech in front of tens of thousands at College Green in Dublin, a beautiful, mostly sun-drenched setting that looked spectacular yesterday. The speech itself, however, was pure cotton candy: tastes good, but when you try to swallow it there's nothing there. If you read it, rather than listen to it, you'll see what I mean.
Yesterday I said it would be "mostly feel-good platitudes and little else." Platitudes may be not quite right, but feel-good Irish-America boilerplate surely is. Yet, that hasn't stopped people describing the speech as "inspiring" and "electrifying."
If people were inspired that's great, but it was a transitory moment. The Obama-high will quickly pass. He won't be back until after he's out of office. He will be very little help to the people of Ireland, who are in the middle of the worst crisis since the early 1920s. He is, after all, the President of the United States. It's not his job to help Ireland.
Yet all over America - and in Canada and Australia and elsewhere - there are people who have a deep affection for Ireland, who can and will help Ireland. People of talent and experience. Creative, clear-thinking people who do actually understand Ireland, have ideas that could help the country and should be taken seriously when they say they want to help.
A week ago one of those people, former San Jose Mayor Tom McEnery offered a critical analysis of where Ireland is now and where we are heading. He also offered three concrete suggestions as to what we should do next. McEnery's plan is to utilize the diaspora, don't "lose them in a jumble of compliments and forums." McEnery says we should put a successful Irish-American, like Intel's retired CEO Craig Barrett, in charge of Ireland's development agency. It's a fantastic idea.
The doors that are already opened to someone of Barrett's stature, the knowledge and experience he would bring to the table and the common language Barrett shares with the heads of those businesses we need to target for investment would be massive advantages for Ireland as it competes with other EU nations for American and other inward investment.
McEnery {photo} has other ideas on a global Irish entrepreneurs support system and a role for committed, successful Irish-Americans (and others) in the Irish legislature - a revised version of the current Seanad (Senate), the weaker upper house of the Irish parliament.
McEnery's call to action deserves attention, but I fear it has fallen on deaf ears. Such proposals are a challenge to those currently in positions of power here. They also represent a gamble for all, a leap of faith in those children and grandchildren whose stories were cheered yesterday.
The Obama visit was a fleeting moment. It's over and the problems here remain. McEnery is talking about something long-lasting, with the potential to generate work and wealth, to lift the Irish people, possibly save them the fate of another lost generation and to begin to build the broader, non-geographical linked-up Facebook Irish nation that will benefit those "away" and "at home."
Yesterday was a dream day in the middle of a long nightmare. Now as the dream fades the nightmare looms again. It's time to wake up, get to work and grab the helping hand being offered. It's long past time Ireland brought the diaspora on board to help steer the ship. Things could hardly be worse, but the talents and goodwill of the diaspora can lead to our best days.
{Photos from Google images and ITLG.org}
45 comments
odonnell521 | May 26, 2011, 07:27 AM EDT
Sometimes in life we need to be inspired . . . to make up for all the crumudgeons who write columns and spout hatred on Fox TV for a living. As far as the diaspora is concerned, welcome their input and support but watch out for the retired CEOs whose main advice will be lower taxes (for the rich) and get rid of regulations (to make it easier to make a profit with protecting public health and safety). It was a winning formula for them here in the States until the rich and powerful lost control of the election process and a man named Obama showed us what hope and change could look like again. And maybe, just maybe, we'll get rid of the last of the so called "conservatives" at the next election.
Report abuse
TheYank | May 26, 2011, 03:02 AM EDT
McNamara31,
If I said his grandparents were silver spoon folks I was wrong. I only meant that by the time Obama came to live with them they were relatively comfortable/well off. More money in the household than in young Clinton's or young Reagan's.
If I said his grandparents were silver spoon folks I was wrong. I only meant that by the time Obama came to live with them they were relatively comfortable/well off. More money in the household than in young Clinton's or young Reagan's.
Report abuse
McNamara31 | May 25, 2011, 09:33 PM EDT
Yank "His grandparents were well off" ???Obama's grandfather worked on oil rigs during the Depression. After the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor, he enlisted in the service and marched across Europe in Patton's army. His grandmother Madelyn, went to work on a bomber assembly line. After the war, the couple studied on the G.I. Bill, bought a house through the Federal Housing Program and, after several moves, stayed in Hawaii where his grandmother worked her way up from a clerk to a bank vice president and his grandfather sold furniture.Sounds like they were an example of hard work paying off.
Report abuse
Searlit | May 25, 2011, 08:12 PM EDT
@ Yank, Blah, blah, blah. Sorry, I couldn't help myself. I agree with oct2447. It was an Irish love fest, and I enjoyed watching all of it on RTE.
Report abuse
oct2447 | May 25, 2011, 06:53 PM EDT
What a wet blanket!! So the Irish turn out for one of their own and feel good about it and give a welcome that is befitting the man and the Irish people......that is not "hero worship" and what a welcome lift......don't rain on the parade.
Report abuse
stmungo | May 25, 2011, 03:49 PM EDT
Att: Skibberrean. These postings are supposed to be about O'bama not the previous Pres. Bush.
Report abuse
shamrock99 | May 25, 2011, 01:40 PM EDT
Most American hope that Obama's pathetic presidency is a "fleeting moment" in our history.
Report abuse
Yankee724 | May 25, 2011, 01:37 PM EDT
The Skibberrean guy has it right.Obama is The Muslim Socialist in the White House. He won in 2008 because he IS an expert on sounding so authoritative, when there is nothing but lies and BS in his substance. He won because people didn't REALLY know what he stood for until it was too late. He won because the people who voted for him are on welfare and wanted "Obama money", as they call it. Why didn't you KEEP The Manchurian Candidate in Ireland until after the 2012 election. Sounds like he suckered a few Irishmen too!
Report abuse
RedBranch | May 25, 2011, 01:17 PM EDT
Spot on Yank, keep pushing the diaspora and you're not alone there. Monday was the definition of a symbotic relationship, where everyone got something out of it. Dublin had a good feel to it over the weekend with people dancing at 12:30am at the top of Grafton St.and I for one appreciated the heavy Gardai presence which is a must if you want to make tourists feel safe. On the speech I was alarmed with the repetition of the word 'responsibility' I counted seven times; was it a lecture to grow up? was it a reference to being responsible for our debts as the Treasury Secetary believes? is it to be more responsible on the world stage and join NATO? what do you think Yank? Does Obama really want us to shun our 'irresponsible past' or am I stirring the sugar at the bottom of the cup too much?
Report abuse
TheYank | May 25, 2011, 01:09 PM EDT
jamieLM,
No problem. I'm not insulted by the misidentification.
No problem. I'm not insulted by the misidentification.
Report abuse
TheYank | May 25, 2011, 01:08 PM EDT
I'm not entirely sure Obama is as self-made as made out below - his grandparents were well-off, paid for top HS and Columbia (too? not sure) - but there's no denying he had many obstacles to overcome to get where he is today.
It is a significant and admirable achievement.
In terms of wealth, I think Clinton & Reagan were the ones who were the most "self-made" and I believe this underlies their success as politicians.
It is a significant and admirable achievement.
In terms of wealth, I think Clinton & Reagan were the ones who were the most "self-made" and I believe this underlies their success as politicians.
Report abuse
TheYank | May 25, 2011, 01:05 PM EDT
deburca
No no no no. No, the reason we had College Green is because of the hero worship.
No no no no. No, the reason we had College Green is because of the hero worship.
Report abuse
McNamara31 | May 25, 2011, 12:54 PM EDT
slainte39... I agree..."like crusaders" Perfectly said, and gave us all a good laugh as well!
Report abuse
McNamara31 | May 25, 2011, 12:52 PM EDT
Skibberrean.... Looking at the Gop possibilities; get ready for 4 more years. And now that they have endangered MEDICARE, the last nail is in the Gop coffin. First, they shot down healthcare for the everyday man. Now they are going after the frail and elderly; only to hand over the business to the corporate gods they worship.
Report abuse
45 Comments
Report abuse