American in Ireland


Galway's shameful proposal to honor Che Guevara

Posted on Thursday, March 01, 2012 at 08:59 AM

RSS


Recent Posts

Archives

submit to reddit

The most famous image of Che Guevara -
by Irishman Jim Fitzpatrick.
Galway City Council wants to erect a statue to Argentinian revolutionary Che Guevara. Che, who was born in 1928, had Irish roots going back to the early 18th century. Che's distant ancestor Patrick Lynch was from Galway, which is the City Council's justification for wanting to erect a statue to a man who spent one night in Ireland, accidentally, thanks to fog at Shannon Airport. He never set foot in Galway.

Che's father did once try to explain his son's revolutionary ways saying the "blood of the Irish rebels" flowed in his veins. That is a load of hooey, as I'm sure Che's father knew, but that doesn't stop those Irish people who admire him from latching on to him as one of their own. Che's one night in Ireland was spent in Kilkee, Co. Clare, where last fall the townsfolk honored the memory of that one night with a 3-day festival. Galway obviously feels cheated that its 300-year-old link to Che is not getting the proper recognition, hence the statue proposal.

According to the Galway Advertiser the idea for the Galway statue came from a member of the City Council, Labour's Billy Cameron, who is "an ardent admirer of the revolutionary." Cameron is hardly alone. Che shirts and posters have been de rigueur for the hippest, coolest protesters and revolutionary-wannabees for decades. However, you're supposed to grow out of that phase. Cameron clearly has not.

____________
Read More:

Galway plans to build monument to Che Guevara slated by local millionaire

Irish politician a “puppet of U.S military”

Obama slaps ban on Irish musicians traveling to Cuba
_____________

The proposed statue has not made much news in Ireland, but one man, businessman and sometime political campaigner Declan Ganley, has been on a mission to scupper this plan for the past week. Ganley (@declanganley) is a Galway man himself and worries that such a statue would damage Galway's reputation, especially in America, hurting the chances of investment and putting Americans off visiting the city.

That seems a bit of a stretch to me. I doubt too many tourists would know much of Che beyond recognizing his face and, well, business is business.

However, yesterday, the Chairman of the House Foreign Affairs Committee Ileana Ros-Lehtinen issued a press release asking Galway City Council to reject the proposal to erect the Che Statue. "The romanticizing image that this monument would portray would serve to diminish the brutality that was committed by Che and the painful suffering endured by many Cuban-American families and his other victims far and wide."

Ileana Ros-Lehtinen is a Cuban-American and Cuban-Americans know far more about Che than the average American and, I daresay, than the average Irish revolutionary wannabee. And they don't like him, not one bit. Whereas the average American may not take much interest in whether Galway honors Che Guevara, people from South Florida and other Cuban enclaves may take a keen interest.

Galway City Councillor - Billy Cameron,whose idea
it was to erect a statue ofChe Guevara
The Cuban government has pledged to help pay for the statue so I guess Galway's Councillors can rest easy knowing Fidel's on their side. Whether the Cuban people admire Che as much as Councillor Cameron and the rest is impossible to say because, as Representative Mario Diaz-Balart put it: "Galway is a city where people have the right to vote, the right to worship freely, the right to speak freely, and access a free press -- all of which 'Che' Guevara and his murderous associate, dictator Fidel Castro, ruthlessly suppressed."

There's no way that Councillor Cameron or anyone who shares his views will take that seriously. They know better than those Cuban-Americans just like they knew better than to listen to all those exiles from Poland, Hungary, Czechoslovakia, etc.

There's a part of me that half hopes the statue goes up and is defaced and damaged by Cubans who live here in exile. There are some. Or, better yet, I'd like to think that when Cubans do finally shake off the shackles of Castro's rule some of them will find their way to Ireland and pull the statue down and curse those who put it up. It's a dream.

The proposal is hideous, but I'm not surprised by it. It suits the mind-set of a small segment of the Irish people. I'd love to know what Ireland's President, a Galway man too, thinks of the idea. I suppose I should just consider it fortunate that no one ever found any Irish link to Lenin or Stalin or Mao. Honoring one mass-murderer is enough.

{Photo of Cameron from Labour.ie}


33 comments

Next Previous Page 2 of 3 pages
What a reward for bad behavior, perhaps they should put up some busts of irish preists that also ruined lives. I read he killed a pregnant woman, shot her in the stomach.
Can we make a donation ? I was going to say: "I'll make a donation of warm urine on the statue"....However, that'll be done by a local Galweigen after a Friday night on the piss. Like fighting, destroying shop windows and basically causing unfettered (call the Guards?-HAH) Mayhem peeing on statues, through letter box slots and pooping on doorsteps it'll fit right in with an age old weekend ritual.
Can we make a donation ?
Should erect it next to the statue of IRA leader Sean Russell, Nazi fellow traveller in the Second World War.
Remember Lee Harvey Oswald , who idolized Castro and Communist Cuba ?--- Proud And Thankfull , Greenwich Connecticut
seanomelb,

Che fought for rights? I don't know. He went to Africa and S. America to spread his ideological revolution. I don't accept that he believed in the "unalienable rights" as delineated in the Declaration of Independence.
Yank thank you for replying,you must then admit that Che fought for the rights of the oppressed.He left Cuba to support the rights of Bolivians who were suffering under another tyrant.It's not about Cuba,it's about the people and freedom.
seanomelb,

"Maudlin?"

"Urging?" - "part of me half hopes" now counts as "urging?"

You want me to say the Batista regime was awful? It was. American policy was focused only on the global struggle and too often turned a blind eye to what was done by their allies. It was part of Truman's policy of containment. Didn't change til the mid 1980s. However, replacing the Tsar with Lenin was not a winner in Russia nor was it in Cuba. 7 years of Batista tyranny has been more than topped by 50 years of Castro's.
DaddyMac22,

Pride, maybe, but dignity? Well he didn't give a damn about the dignity of the human individual. He was an ideologue, a man who believed in the collective not the individual.

I have more belief in the dignity of the human individual in my little finger than Che had in his entire being.
The Yanks maudlin right wing crap is so boring.Urging Cubans to deface such a statute is despicable. Che fought for the oppressed and died doing so.I never hear THE Yank or is ilk condemn the Batista government.Batista was one of the most corrupt leaders in his time. The US shoveled arms to him to oppress the workers,especially those in the sugar industry. What a hypocrite you are Yank.
Che Guevara has more dignity and pride in his little finger than you have in your entire being.
The Irish always like to identify with far-off causes. The further off the cause the more they identify with it. That's why Bono gets more agitated about Burma (or is it Nepal--can't remember) than Ireland north or south. In this case, how come Galway doesn't honor the many Irish people who played important roles in Spain or Latin America? Che had no links with Ireland. A remote ancestor was a Lynch, 200 years earlier, that's not a link. Admiral Browne of Argentina was from Mayo, that's a much closer link.
I'm was born in Ireland and live in Miami.. Yes local Miami Cubans hate Che, some seem to even feel Baptista was a great guy. Yes Che killed, bloody cheek of a revolutionary to do so, really anyone rememeber a revolution with killing. Guess Irish Freedom fighters of 1916, War of Independence and before should be admonished for their acts. For many Guevara is a light, for others a source of debate and others a source of pain, a statue can be erected to recognize his place and possibly a plaque noting that he was an individual of deep passion that history has many differing views of where his place should be. Will the same debate take place when the Bush Library in Texas opens, by the way I hear he intends to donate his entire comic book collection. P.S. last year I was having a drink in a local bar in Miami when a Cuban Mother toasted the death of Teddy Kennedy, in her words, Kennedy's all as bad as Castro, Kennedy's to blame for their plight, really sounds smart.....
Like it or not Che Guevara is considered a hero and freedom fighter by millions of people around the world. Others consider him a terrorist. He's kind of like a Hispanic version of the I.R.A. I see no reason not to honor this world famous revolutionary for his Irish roots in Galway. If County Leitrim can claim Obama as a native son, why shouldn't Galway claim Guevara? And as for investors, their only concern will be whether they can make a buck in Galway, not whether there is a statue there honoring an Irish-Argentinian rebel.
To appease both sides the solution is quite simple. Take an existing statue and put a Che Guevara t-shirt on it. Available for free, the t-shirt, if you ask a student nicely I suppose.
Next Previous Page 2 of 3 pages




Log into IrishCentral with your Facebook account


or sign-in directly

E-Mail:
Password:
 Remember me Forgot my password
Not a member? Register Now!
print this article Print
email this articleE-mail