An American from The Bronx bids farewell to Ireland
By: Mary Catherine Brouder | Published Tuesday, January 8, 2013, 1:02 PM | Updated Tuesday, January 8, 2013, 1:02 PM
Saying goodbye to things isn’t as easy as it looks. Anyone who has ever left home, even for five minutes, will tell you that.
Maybe that’s how the idea of the “
Irish goodbye” (slipping wordlessly out of a room) was born: it’s much easier to avoid the emotional strain of parting ways than to confront it head-on.
After spending more than a year and a half here in Ireland, I’m taking my first trip in ten months to my native home. If I can’t find work in Ireland, I’ll join the estimated 43% percent of Americans aged 25-34 who live at home with their parents. And I'll be one of at least 65,300 people who have left Ireland this year in search of work(Ireland has seen the highest net emigration this year since 1989).
Lately, life feels a lot like that Keane line, “Everything’s changing and I don’t feel the same.”
After 12 weeks, I bid farewell to my journalism students at our holiday party - just as I had finally gotten to know them all. I spent my free time looking at new, smaller apartments, where my sister can live, just in case I don't return to Dublin.
And today, my cousin Dawn called to announce that she officially moved out of the house she had been renting and into her brand-new permanent home. Her old house was the place where she had generously allowed my sister and I to live when we first arrived in Ireland.
It was in that house where we watched Dawn’s daughter Kate grow, learn to speak, and use the potty. I don’t know how many times we danced with Kate around the kitchen to Sam Cooke’s “Wonderful World.”
We made many a memory in that house, and now it’s somebody else’s home.
Even my old favorite museum is changing. A few weeks ago, I watched in dismay as the Yeats exhibit at the National Library was being dismantled.
Initially, I came to Ireland with my Dad and sister last summer, just for a few months, to receive treatment at a holistic clinic. After several months of treatment, I returned to full health, and was offered work at a start-up web company. The job started in March, so I went home in February, and officially returned to Ireland for as long as it would have me.
I spent the entire 7 hour flight from JFK to Dublin airport bawling my eyes out, as I thought about everything I was leaving behind.
While packing up my things recently(the job didn't quite pan out as planned), I came across a notepad in which I had scribbled a few tear-stained notes during that flight. I wrote:
“Places always look more beautiful when you’re leaving them... Even the faded blue-and-red intersecting lines of your empty notebook page stare back with vivacity and beauty – like they’re taking mischievous delight in calling you to take account of the loveliness you never took the opportunity to cherish before.”
As I prepare for the possibility that I may not return to this country for a long time, everything around me, like those lines on my sheets of paper, is a reminder of what I may not have fully appreciated.
Good conversations with my sister’s now ex-boyfriend, Mark. Endless laughter, dancing, and silly chats with our cousin Dawn. Learning from, and listening to stories with, my Dad. Music, music, and more music, with many new and inspiring friends.
Spending this time, this borrowed time, living with my older sister in a city full of so much culture and history, was a gift.
When we were young, my sister Cornelia was the one who walked my brother and I to school – made sure our zippers were all zipped, and buttons buttoned – but she was also the first one to shake a wet tree branch over our heads on a rainy day. She always looked for ways to make us laugh – even on damp mornings on the way to school – and taught us never to take anything too seriously.
The childish admiration I have for my older sister has only grown after our nearly two years together in Ireland.
I think that’s what I’ll appreciate the most about my time in Ireland: the unique opportunities I’ve had to build, or strengthen, relationships, which I never would have had the chance to, if I had never left home.
None of us is the same person today that we were yesterday.
The people we meet, the knowledge we earn, and the activities in which we participate in a day undoubtedly make us different, changed somehow, from the way we were the day before.
I am not the same person I was before I moved to Ireland.
In my short time here, I’ve lived, I’ve loved, and I’ve learned. I’ve been lucky enough to have met some wonderful people, and make memories that I will cherish all of the days of my life.
So as I pack my bags, and prepare to leave this home away from home, at least, I can quote my high school’s Latin motto with a clear conscience: “Ac fui.” I was there.
44 Comments
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Switch to the desktop site to post a comment.WoundedKnee | Dec 15, 2010, 04:26 PM EST
Dublinjas ---Why the references to Romania? Has our columnist in training made some reference to that country that you found objectionable? You seem bitter.
getlives | Dec 15, 2010, 01:20 PM EST
I find it really hard to believe that after reading this article so many people had such negative, nasty,insignificant things to say. This is a story written by a young girl who is obviously emotional about leaving a place she has loved and enjoyed for another- a story about new beginnings and saying goodbye to a time in her life well spent. Grammatical errors and digs at salary etc etc- really people? Really? Seems like people should get off the internet and GET LIVES- its ten days before Christmas, how about a little bit of peace love and understanding?
Dublinjas | Dec 15, 2010, 12:46 PM EST
Next time go directly to Romania and enjoy your stay with your gypsy pals, Maybe they could give you some pointers in begging and setting up scams, Until then don't let the big green door etc etc.
RobbCobb | Dec 15, 2010, 12:27 PM EST
Thank you for all of your insights Mary. Best wishes, God speed and good luck with all of your new adventures and endeavours. Think on how much more you'll have to reflect upon when you're my age (46). Just remember "you may have to grow old, but you don't have to grow up" :)
jamieLM | Dec 15, 2010, 10:40 AM EST
You're right, billjoyce. It's great to be in touch with your roots. Best wishes, Mary C., wherever you choose to live and I'm glad you're in good health. I'm sure you'll be back to Ireland again. Btw: MaryeMoore makes some good points. MaryeM is a poster and not a columnist writing for I.C., so she can be excused for making a few "typos." The editor of I.C. is responsible for seeing that his columnists use correct spelling, punctuation, and grammar, and proofread their columns. Maybe this isn't an editorial priority on this site. Just saying. Mary C. does write very interesting stories that are enjoyed by many of us.
billjoyce | Dec 14, 2010, 01:48 PM EST
I spent some time in Ireland many years ago and it was absolutely one of the best memories I will evr have. Even the ups and downs are memorable in their vaporous reflections. If anyone can go to live if their heritage is there DO IT and you'll be better for it
Ajreaper | Dec 14, 2010, 01:43 PM EST
Mary, LOL, I doubt you thought some would find the need to point out, what to them, are the shortcomings of this piece. In my case I enjoyed reading it and I hope as you leave one dream behind you are actively persueing another and are succesful in running it down.
cavantown | Dec 14, 2010, 11:37 AM EST
To maryemoore...you know that old story about "people in glass houses" ...well...you must be cringing and wincing at your own post... kind of a blatant error "lages" in the midst of your diatribe. Poor soul, you must have felt so important writing it...only to make a boo boo yourself. Bloody well funny...like someone giving a spiff with toilet paper on their shoe. And you were looking for a job as a proof reader...again, I suggest that if you have a job...you'd best be hanging on to it. Nothing like having to wince and cringe at oneself. hehehehe Thanks for the chuckle.
dottiedolittle | Dec 14, 2010, 10:36 AM EST
I am not a person who envies, and I would not change the life I have lived, enjoying my children , granchildren and great grandchildren, but for a moment I did feel a twinge. Ireland is so beautiful and welcoming. Hopefully I may yet return once more for a short time.
maryemoore | Dec 14, 2010, 10:35 AM EST
@cavantown: Yes, I am aware that this particular article was a personal reminiscence. However, it does not excuse bad grammar. Your sarcasm proves that you did not get the jist of my criticism, namely that this site is careless in its editing of all types of subject matter. That fact grates on those of us who still have standards when it comes to intellgent prose, no matter how it is written-either as serious commentary or relating personally to a topic. Unfortunately, according to a recent study published in the New York Times, the United States lages far behind many other countries in education and standards. Proof positive is the lax quality of what passes as acceptable writing on a site that is produced by a newspaper of so-called professional writers and editors. I enjoy, the news from "home" but wish I did not have to read it, constantly cringing at basic writing mistakes.
Towngate | Dec 14, 2010, 05:27 AM EST
MARY: I am glad you enjoyed your brief dabble in diddle-e-eye-land! Your stay was always underscored by your comforting option to return home to Americania.I suggest without this escape route, your Irish experience might have been very different. Pity the poor native wretches who are trapped here without any means of escape! As you pack your supply of rose-tinted glasses and take your leave,your brain filling with thickening emerald fog, please consider the hypocrisy of ..'dis auld Oirish saying: "...Here's yer coat, and what's yer hurry!"
cavantown | Dec 14, 2010, 02:01 AM EST
Ah maryemoore...I see you can't sleep either. Well it appears to me that the story is about a person saying Bbye to Eire and Hello again to her homeland...and reminiscing about the wonders of each place. It is a blog and therefore written in the vernacular and I daresay I haven't heard a Yank say, "my brother and me" in "dogs legs" years. As for this being a news article...you would think a "writer" would have guessed by the title...it was a personal story...so I wouldn't think you should quit whatever job it is you have to wait on Irish Central hiring you. :)
maryemoore | Dec 13, 2010, 11:19 PM EST
The truth of the matter is that the grammatical mistakes ARE there and the story lacks clarity and cohesiveness. As a writer myself, I wince to see the caliber of what passes for "good" writing not only in this story but in many articles that appear on this site. I know you want to get the news out as quickly as possible but surely you must have a proof-reader or editor on your staff? If not, I am available at a reasonable rate!
Irishphotograph | Dec 13, 2010, 09:15 PM EST
@ haikued2 You are incorrect. I never said people who call names are losers. You are perceiving the facts at an 8 Grade level.
peterson | Dec 13, 2010, 08:19 PM EST
Ireland has an enchantment that lingers with Americans. That is what makes the "Emerald Isle" so unique.
haikued2 | Dec 13, 2010, 06:24 PM EST
Funny to say the least. one person saying that calling names makes you losers. I think the term "loser" fits in the "calling names" category. Anyway, the grammar did grate a bit, but all news media is essentially 8th grade level...oops, in America today that may be 12th grade level...but the real issue is that a. everything is changing; b. changing to either better conditions or worse; c. social conditions in our neighborhoods are changing as we walk out the door to get on airplanes to fly off to where we think the grass is greener; d. the grass may well be greener when we arrive, but can brown up quickly; e. fantasy living (n.b. having a concept of a place in our heads that simply is not valid) should be tested and when found to be valid, sometimes, fine, but more often invalid, go back home; and f. when you get home it will have changed, so suck it up and accept the facts of life. It isn't necessarily easy, but it is all we have.
Irishphotograph | Dec 13, 2010, 06:06 PM EST
@Yeffac I really hope you get to read this comment and therefore know. That a descendant of one of Ireland's greatest rebel leaders thinks you are a dope! You made this comment on somebody's grammar. I need say anymore. "God, know does anyonebody on this have any inkling of basic English? People just correcting the and I/ and me/. Get a life you losers!. I recognise no Irish quality in any of you haters and morons.
cavantown | Dec 13, 2010, 05:54 PM EST
To Dr. Trelawney...no need to call people names. The poster thought the author was wrong but was in fact wrong herself...pointing out the error is sufficient. Why would you think Irish Central would not pay those that work for it? Is it that you don't get paid for your work? Ah dear...that is too sad.
erinmcgurgan | Dec 13, 2010, 05:44 PM EST
"she allowed my sister and I..." and "...who walked my brother and I to school." Try "she allowed my sister and me..." and "...who walked my brother and me." Nothing worse than the kind of bad grammar that makes you seem pretentious and pseudo-educated.
DrTrelawney | Dec 13, 2010, 04:25 PM EST
I'd just like to join Cavantown in identifying woodmontwoman as an idiot. If you are going to pompously correct somebody (as I do all the time) you had better know what you are talking about. Wonderful World was indeed by Sam Cooke. You may remember it from a key scene in Peter Weir's Witness. As to the person who suggested that Mary Catherine had a job as a journalist, you can't seriously believe this website pays the poor saps who write for it. Can you?
dessieglynn | Dec 13, 2010, 04:22 PM EST
What a bunch of "gobshites"
cjnoonan | Dec 13, 2010, 02:49 PM EST
wonderful - go maith!
cavantown | Dec 13, 2010, 02:27 PM EST
Um, previous poster woodmontwoman...Sam Cooke did indeed record "Wonderful World"...the song you are referring to is "What a Wonderful World" by Louis Armstrong...you would think someone would check their facts before making a public statement. Is that an apology we hear??? And to poster Dillon...ah boyo have you ever heard of writer's license? Or colloquialisms? I think you need to find a friend, maybe talk to DublinJas and you can berate the world together. hehehehehe And in the words of "Charlie"..."God Bless us, every one."
glorybe1929 | Dec 13, 2010, 01:30 PM EST
Nothing stays exactly the same for very long.We lived on our boat for 5 yrs and traveled the world I was a Roman Catholic for almost 69 yrs. and left the Institution in 2001. I had lived in Az. for 47 yrs, I now live in Colorado and have been here for almost 2 yrs. My husband and I live with our divorced daughter. We have four children, 7 grandchildren and 2 great grandchildren. We've traveled all over the world and enjoyed Ireland in 2001.We've had set backs that have taught us to Trust HIM even more than we were. At 81 I'd say, "Love the Lord your GOD and put HIM at the CENTER of your life and lead a life of Devine Providence. Have a RELATIONSHIP WITH HIM, BEFORE YOU HAVE A RELATIONSHIP WITH ANY PERSON. I promise HE will take care of you where ever you go.Put HIM FIRST! Lovingly in His Name...gloria
joanmoody | Dec 13, 2010, 12:52 PM EST
When Americans return come to Texas and not stay in NY or Boson.
CitizenWhy | Dec 13, 2010, 12:35 PM EST
The job situation for young white people in the US is bad but uneven. People have to be willing again to start at the bottom. Community college graduates in specific job training fields are getting jobs, at east on the east coast. In fact some graduates of "distinguished" colleges are taking certificates or 4-6 courses at community colleges to qualify for jobs.
CitizenWhy | Dec 13, 2010, 12:32 PM EST
Funny about "irregardless." It was first used by poorly educated, but very funny, US comedians insecure about their lack of education. Now it's taken to be a sign of a superior education - by some people. In effect it's now part of American usage. Pass over it with kindness or contempt, it's trivial.
CitizenWhy | Dec 13, 2010, 12:28 PM EST
I didn't know of the term "Irish good-bye." It's what I usually do. My parents, from Ireland, would never do that but I do it all the time at events.
donal1951 | Dec 13, 2010, 11:40 AM EST
I feel badly for the young woman, but as an earlier poster has already pointed out, the job situation in the USA is pretty bleak too. I am retired as a journalist and semi-retired as a clergyman so the economy has not affected me much. I already was living on a tight fixed income. But my cousin has advised me that given currency fluctuations and other problems, it would not be adviseable to consider moving to Ireland right now. I want to move from a rural area to one more urban where I won't have to drive a car 40 km round trip to see the doctor. That urban area could be in the USA or in Europe as I have an Irish passport.
broudskins | Dec 13, 2010, 11:39 AM EST
wow, people really are stupid and hateful, and petty in their comments below, grow up you bunch of weirdos
antoman | Dec 13, 2010, 11:34 AM EST
Next time come to Cork.
antoman | Dec 13, 2010, 11:23 AM EST
Georgeyboy is pleased of course to hear you're leaving and returning to his neck of the woods.Bon voyage and come back soon.
brennanirish | Dec 13, 2010, 11:12 AM EST
I am beginning to understand, by reading the comments below, that the real problems of Ireland are directly related to some of the obnoxious scum that inhabit the island......and now populate this website.
woodmontwoman | Dec 13, 2010, 11:03 AM EST
Wonderful World--it's not Sam Cooke who sings it, but Louis Armstrong. I thought a journalist would get her facts straight! This was the song my son chose for us to dance together at his wedding--may it be a wonderful world again. Hard times for so many.
GeorgeDillon | Dec 13, 2010, 10:23 AM EST
"my sister Cornelia was the one who walked my brother and I to school". If you want to make it as a journalist, write grammatically. Not every employer will be as careless in this regard as IrishCentral. It's "me", not "I".
Yerffac | Dec 13, 2010, 10:16 AM EST
God, know does anyonebody on this have any inkling of basic English? Feliciamaisey: there is no such word as "irregardless." Then we have our main sob story (Poor dear, you have to return to America. What about those who have nowhere to return to?)a journalist, no less, blooping basic English "let my sister and I" it is "my sister and me." Irritating bunch of whingers.
Dublinjas | Dec 13, 2010, 10:14 AM EST
As far as I can see you spent your time over here admiring The Roma and other unwelcome parasites, I am happy to tell you they will be the ones waving you goodbye.
feliciamaisey | Dec 13, 2010, 10:02 AM EST
Times are tough everywhere, and some of us have been in want of living in Ireland and struggling through than the US, so I find it ironic how easily some pack up and move betweent he countries as the money flows or dries up. The memories and experiences irregardless will last a lifetime, even if the jobs don't.
michaelcollins | Dec 13, 2010, 09:58 AM EST
its a shame you had to go.....we could of went out on a date.....your bleeding deadly(happy face)
Padraig8 | Dec 13, 2010, 09:44 AM EST
Hi All hope you realize that what goes around comes around. this too shall pass remember if you can the bad ole days of the past. Ireland was a place to get away from then came the irish tiger economy it will all change again do not lose hope. if you cant take the tough times then you should go crying to mom and dad for help. I lived through many booms and busts. Suck it up and quit crying this advice is free and from and old man of 86 yrs
Jamaicelt | Dec 13, 2010, 09:27 AM EST
I am one of the Irish who was actually planning to return to Ireland. I have put my house up for sasle et al. Now, thanks to incompetence, corruption etc,I have had to shelve those plans. I am FAR from happy.
mcdolan | Dec 13, 2010, 09:25 AM EST
I am very empathetic, having relocated to Ireland from the Bronx with my family 14 years ago. However, I have found a good life here and although unemployed for the last 26 months, I won't throw in the towel yet. Too much invested in making a new life, too many activities that I enjoy and could not replace were I back in New York. Besides, age is against me. I wouldn't want to grow old in New York, particularly since the business world has changed so much and I think I don't have a good chance of finding work that will provide for my family. I am sorry it didn't work out for you and your sister, but you have a lifetime of memories to take back with you. And, who knows, perhaps you'll be one of the Diaspora to return to sort out this country. Good luck to ye.
allicat4u2 | Dec 13, 2010, 09:19 AM EST
This letter confuses me...does she have a job in jouralism in Ireland? Well, whatever...there are NO jobs here in America as well...KNOW that my distant Irish relatives...NO JOBS...
OrenTruitt | Dec 13, 2010, 09:17 AM EST
Very sad what has happened to the Irish economy but, just like here in the US, the balloon was over-inflated and eventually had to burst. I still dream of living in Ireland....maybe after my children are grown my wife and I can spend extended time there (I doubt I can talk her into moving).