Across The Pond


Paddy Duffy Blog Picture
Across The Pond by Paddy Duffy

Get them while they're young - Catholic Church are experts at recruitment

Posted on Saturday, April 21, 2012 at 06:47 AM

RSS


Recent Posts

Archives

submit to reddit

Initiation into the Catholic club
Say what you want about the failings of the Catholic Church but they are experts at recruitment.

You're a paid up member of the club by the time you can even say "christening", and once you arrive at secondary school, Catholicism is so deeply embedded with ceremonies that contain a large social element and weekly reinforcement, that it will stay with you for the rest of your life, no matter how your views evolve.

You have to hand it to them - it's a pretty successful strategy.

It's a principle we could do with using a bit more. When you get people interested in a topic at a young age and convey a subject's importance early, the better it is for their development, especially if they get to actively participate in it and feel they can shape what goes on.

And at the moment, there is scarcely anything more important than making sure young people get to use their talents, have their opinions heard and get a chance to shape the world around them.

A campaign for the voting age to be reduced to 16 is currently gathering momentum, with a recent conference in Dublin dedicated to it as well as a nascent Facebook support page.

Lowering the voting age is laudable in and of itself - it absolutely makes sense that young people get to have their say on issues like national debt and climate change, especially since it's their generation that will have to deal with the brunt of hothouse fiscal compacts.

But without a massive corresponding overhaul of the way we approach civics and politics in the classroom and beyond, it would almost be like throwing good votes after bad.

A civics class might seem like 35 minutes you'd much rather be spending anywhere else, but it's a subject that is so much more than dry stats.

Giving young people the chance to have a say and a hand in local policies and decisions like health services, education and public amenities makes enthusiastic citizens of them from an early age, and responsible ones too.It stands to reason that young people will have more interest and respect for an initiative if they've helped set it up, or indeed set it up by themselves.

The more often young people do these projects, the better they get at them, the more beneficial public service as a concept becomes to them, the more established and valued youth participation becomes in the wider community. Apathy then has to up sticks and try somewhere else.

But just as important as embedding the concepts of citizenship locally through visible projects and action is a reimagining of how we deal with national and international politics. Nobody would ever say your opinion on music is invalid if you didn't know all the instruments in an orchestra, yet politics as a topic of discussion often has a kind of snobbish high cordon around it, a minimum qualification stipulation. It needs to be taken down.

Whether people think of them as such or not, everyone has political opinions - the key is to make that as relevant and interesting as possible, and give context as to where their ideas fit in the world.

I've run myriad courses over the years designed to do just that with youth groups of very different stripes and every time I do I'm astonished at the level and enthusiasm of debate.

For example, a simulated cabinet I ran with the teenagers of the Donegal Youth Council passed a budget that dramatically increased health and education spending, resolved that nuclear power was not a viable energy source and forsook hosting a major sporting competition to invest in rail networks, all within a few hours. Give young people that chance to talk and take action and watch them fly.

In the Catholic Church, expert HR people that they are, Confirmation is the sacrament that gives the chance for 12-year-olds to reinforce for themselves something their parents did for them at birth.

The secular world too needs to build a foundation for young people, all young people, to be able to participate fully in their communities and make the changes they wish to see, for themselves and for others.

That way, by the time they come to vote at 16 they'll not only be ready, they'll be able and willing too.


12 comments

Page 1 of 1 pages
The point the author is trying to make here is that, if as much effort was put into ingraining a sense of civic responsibility as it was to fixing religious doctrine then society may be more informed and balanced. "Half baked when it comes to life experience" "totally lacking in wisdom...inexperienced in life", and that is the reason to stop them from voting. If everyone that had half baked ideas and knowledge was restricted from voting, then you would see a sharp decrease in those going to the polling booths. There is possibly nothing more half-baked than religion itself. You believe an obviously made up story that put constraints upon your life and never question why, you afford reverence to those who dedicate their lives to something which is false but also over the years has abused its power and proven to be more caught up in land acquisition than providing "spiritual guidance". I have the notion that those opposed to the piece written here were raised at a time of "seen and not heard". Well unfortunately for you lot, things have changed, young people now have a voice to represent themselves. And one final point, just because you lower the age doesn't mean that ever 16 yr old is going to register, most likely the people who will register will be young, active member of society who deserve a right to comment on the world that they will be inheriting, so there's no need for your petty age envy!
I agree with the strange and insane belligerents below.lol.I think it would be generally agreed by those of us who have 16 year olds that kids at that age are a tad half-baked when it comes to life experience.Most 16 year olds radiate enthusiasm for life and independence of thought and action.But I think you are getting carried away Paddy.We'll let them know they are still a bit immature another while.It's good for them.
@jacersagain How on earth do you see fit to launch such a scathing attack on this article? It makes a perfectly good case for the lowering of the voting age. Young people are perfectly capable of articulating the changes they wish to see in legislation and the issues affecting them because believe it or not the world does not revolve around the older generation. Young people are some of the most proactive citizens you will encounter and frankly I think it's nothing short of a disgrace that you should infer they are incapable of making useful contributions to a political system. They are indeed a breath of fresh air and their involvement in political issues is widely welcomed by politicians - particularly when compared to a contrary indidual such as yourself with what I can only imagine to be a MASSIVE chip on your shoulder. It's hard to believe bigots like yourself still exist in this day and age but here we are. Young people deserve to have a voice as much as older citizens and your expression of them not being wise enough is so incredibly outdated it's disgusting. We're living in modern times - why don't you join us?
FOREIGNERS IN
>> Ah well now Paddy, I see you’re stumbling all over yourself to blame ICentral editors’ misunderstanding now, eh? Then like an ignorant imbecile, you print instructions for people to read your column. And you expect us to still see your pointless points? I read yr article above fully the first time and realised the headline and first paragraphs were just more anti-Catholic attention grabbing because you then go on to prattle on about 16yr olds and the vote. Young adults are totally inexperienced in life, totally lacking in wisdom. Your article above, exhorting a right for them to vote at 16, shows you haven’t grown up at all, still thinking like a 16yr old. There are no old heads on young shoulders and never will be, so forget it. Your column therefore is a waste of space on ICentral (like many of yours here) and a waste of my time for reading it.
Steps for reading my columns: 1) Read the whole thing from start to finish. 2)Realise that the focus of the headline was an editorial misunderstanding and you couldn't have missed the point more if you'd been blindfolded and been spun around three times. 3) Read the column again. 4) Stop being such breathtaking idiots and grow the hell up, you almighty shower of strange and insane belligerents.
LOL @ Georgie's comment. No one can be 'de-baptised'. Once you're baptised, that's it - your soul is free of original sin forever.
Oldboreen: In the debaptizing ceremony Duffy gets to throw water back at the priest.
A postscript to my posting Mr Duffy-I suspect that whether you care to admit it or not,you are a baptised Catholic.In which case, can we now look forward to your 'de-baptising'ceremony?? Do share the happy day with us-please!
I assume Mr Duffy, that you are prepared to direct similar criticism towards Moslems, Jews, Episcopalians,Mormons,Hindus,Marxists,Communists, Athiests,and just about anyone who's faith or belief, is sufficiently strong to ensure that their children are nurtured in that particular faith or belief! No,you're not prepared to concede that? Well now,there's a surprise!!!
This columnist (sic) Duffy is just a bigoted fool.
Ah Paddy Paddy Paddy! What an ignorant paddy you’re showing yourself up to be. The Catholic Church encourages baptism in a new born infant, not as a recruitment tactic, but to absolve the human soul of original sin as fast as possible and welcome the child into the Christian Community. Didn’t Christ say that “Unless a man is born again of water (Baptism) and the Holy Spirit (Confirmation), he cannot enter the Kingdom of Heaven”? I challenge you to levy your “recruitment” charge at Jesus Christ and see what you get in response. Oh, don’t worry… He will answer you somehow.
Page 1 of 1 pages




Log into IrishCentral with your Facebook account


or sign-in directly

E-Mail:
Password:
 Remember me Forgot my password
Not a member? Register Now!
print this article Print
email this articleE-mail