Across The Pond


Paddy Duffy Blog Picture
Across The Pond by Paddy Duffy

Former Naas Mayor Darren Scully and 'black Africans' - ignorance is no excuse for racism

Posted on Wednesday, November 23, 2011 at 08:12 AM

RSS


Recent Posts

Archives

submit to reddit

Darren Scully's political campaign poster
The town of Naas in Kildare is a sort of second home to me, as it’s where a good friend of mine from college now works and lives. As such, whenever I hear the town's name on the news, my ears tend to prick up.

Imagine my dismay then when I heard the unholy reason my ears pricked up earlier this week. The town’s erstwhile Mayor, Darren Scully, made the extraordinary announcement – on local radio, no less – that he was no longer going to be dealing with the constituency issues of "black Africans".

His reason? He had experienced aggression and bad manners from black constituents. When it was put to him that what he was doing was the essence of racism, his defence was that he was just being honest and forthright, that he didn’t think of himself as racist, that he has black friends and has great craic with the black taxi drivers talking about football, basically crossing off every square on the “I’m Not Racist But” bingo card.

Now there are some flat out, irredeemable goons in the Irish political sphere, but Scully really does shine out among them.

For starters, if he had a problem with rude people at clinics, he should have said so. If he’d said “I’ve been getting some grief at clinics, and I won’t be taking that anymore” then that would have been fine, so why the arbitrary targeting of black constituents?

I absolutely refuse to believe that black people are his or anyone else in professional politics’ sole transgressors. After all, without white people being aggressive and ill-mannered about political issues there’d be no such thing as talk radio.
-----------------
READ MORE:
More news on the Irish Government from IrishCentral


Irish immigrant viciously assaulted in the Bronx


Irish mayor quits over refusal to represent African residents - AUDIO

-----------------


And then there’s the issue of a public representative literally making discriminating decisions about who he serves based on a prima facie judgement which is as repugnant to his vocation as it is to humanity. His attempt to justify himself (there were some people from “other backgrounds” living in the area that he also did not deal with) only goes to show how ridiculous his views are.

Sadly though, Scully’s views are emblematic of a way of thinking that still exists, however outdated. A way of thinking that maintains it’s OK to say whatever drek you like so long as you’re “just expressing your opinion” or “just being honest”. A way of thinking that carelessly throws monstrous generalisations around in reference to the industry and motives of entire nationalities and ethnicities. A way of thinking that luxuriates unashamedly in its own narrow-minded conceit. I see it and hear it in all sorts of places, sometimes even within the comments section of this very website. It’s pathetic.

The most galling thing of all though is the sickening hypocrisy that lurks around the corner from this kind of feckless, witless bloviating. A friend of mine told me this week that there are reports in some local conservative media outlets in Canada that have been hostile to recent Irish arrivals, questioning their work ethic and such. If those reports became plentiful enough to be covered back home, those same fools who castigate the blacks and the foreigns here would be up in arms about how shoddily the proud Irish people are being treated, how at least when we went places around the world we worked for our keep dag nabbit, and how the Canadians are just a bunch of Brit lovers anyway, before rallying for a boycott of maple syrup, bacon, Due South, ice hockey, Gordon Lightfoot, politeness and Robin from How I Met Your Mother.

And while Darren Scully as Mayor jettisoned black Africans who live in his own town, if Paul McGrath was signing his book in Naas, or Samantha Mumba was opening a club in Naas, you know full well he’d be over to them so quickly he’d leave a plume of cartoon smoke behind him, with a corral of photographers in tow.

Naas is a commuter town, and as such it is inhabited by great swathes of people who originate elsewhere, both from other countries and from other parts of this country. Far from diminishing your environs there is great joy and value to be had from people living and working and playing with people who aren’t all necessarily from the same townland as you. And, in the same way Irish people have brought that joy and value to all corners of the world, my own life would have been a whole lot duller without the wide cultural influences I’ve been exposed to as a child, things like British TV, American politics, Jewish comedy, oriental cuisine, Latin music or black culture in general.

This week marks the anniversary of JFK’s death, and in an all-too-pertinent clip about Civil Rights he said no country can be free unless its citizens are free also. As Irish people and citizens of the world who know what it’s like to be on the receiving end of unfair and unfounded abuse, we must not tolerate such blind, mendacious prejudice when it happens to other people. It’s time for the likes of Darren Scully, and the woodwork emergers backing him up, to step out of their caves. They might learn something.

-----------------
READ MORE:
More news on the Irish Government from IrishCentral


Irish immigrant viciously assaulted in the Bronx


Irish mayor quits over refusal to represent African residents - AUDIO

-----------------


17 comments

Next Page 1 of 2 pages
Not sure how it is in Ireland, but in America, the majority of African Americans feel that they deserve special treatment and a hand out. I don't agree with that anyone deserves special treatment based on your heritage. That is not being racist either. I've known some pretty good, hard working African Americans that are just as polite and respect as any other.
Towngate: You have identified a rhetorical trick which I have seen Mass Immigrationists pulling in many settings. That is that they invent opinions which they ascribe to opponents of Mass Immigration, and then attack those opinions. Thus they are not arguing with opponents, but attacking their own creation and caricature. It's the tactic of charlatans and fools. Notice that Duffy attacks views which only HE has articulated! If the inane columnist Duffy has evidence of people who are opposed to Mass Immigration to Ireland also being hostile to Canada, he is free to use it in his piece. But of course he doesn't. So, being a liar and a fraud, he INVENTS bigotry in order to condemn it. I say fire Duffy, he's a worthless fool, his column is lies and his comments are bigoted badly-written garbage.
If people of African descent were truely "violent, primitive and savage," as most of the village idiots of the world believed, there would be many massacres committed against Caucasian people every second of the day because of the cruel and savage treatment committed by them against people of African descent for the past 400 years. But thanks to our Merciful Creator that the people of African descent are more forgiving and merciful than the people responsible for their past and present miseries.
Your Irish is fine (but there is a fada over the i in Buíochas -it is hard to put them on with some keyboards). I understand what you are saying, but I don't think that those communities are going to cope any better when public representatives are making statements like his.
Careful not to build this up. The man said what he said, he resigned promptly and that should be the end of the matter. The previous administration foisted virtually unbridled immigration upon communities and it was buiochas le Dia that they were able to cope as well as they did and that the problems have not been even more apparent. And I will accept any corrections on my abismal Irish.
Ah, thank you kinvara, you've salvaged my day!
A fine article, Paddy. Don’t mind Georgedillon, Tá sé glan as a mheabhair, tá mé cinnte dearfa de. B’fhiúntaí dó a bheith ina thost, George. However, if you must speak, why didn’t you reply to Paddy’s message in Irish? Instead you take a quote of his out of context. Do you really think Paddy is of the view that ‘Canadians are just a bunch of Brit lovers anyway’? Are you so foolish that you couldn’t see the satire? Once again your saving grace is your ability to make us laugh; just look at this gem of yours: ‘Why are bigoted imbeciles like him given a forum here?’ Yes George I quite agree…why are bigoted imbeciles given a forum here?
Towngate, due respect, but if I was to flag it up everytime I wrote something flippant in case somebody didn't get the wider context a) It'd be super lame and b) Every second phrase I ever wrote would be "Warning: satire imminent". As for dangerous language, I think "Brit lovers" is a pretty mild phrase in comparison to "violent, primitive and savage", an horrendous comment I've already flagged up and want removed post haste. Yet, save for Cathal, nobody else seems to be outraged at that. But I hope you prefer the next one Towngate! George, I refer you back to my "alpaire" comment below.
its a disgrace when a man speaks the truth he looses his job .ok he should have worded his statemant different.everyone is hiding behind this so called racist line.i know the black africans are here only for our welfare handouts as dundalk is full of them and newry there are none there.there is 10 mile seperating these towns.i also see their bad manners in banks post offices and shops they dont want to que they believe they should be servered first..they are living in all the plushest areas and drive people carriers to ship their large famalies around in.god bless ireland because there is big trouble around the corner for it as soon as the africans get a fot hold in.this is hard facts not racism
Paddy: I have dug deeper into that "The most galling thing .." para and of course you are not making a personal statement of your point of view; ~ but by 'hypotisising' the anti-Canadian bigotry, you still don't avoid responsibility for the use of the offensive terms. ~ Aaahhh, so this is a 'send up' of an imagined reaction to an imagined possible statement which might be made if a certain situation were to occur .... you can't blame us for getting hold of 'the wrong end of the stick', but it might help us when you are next being flippant about such a dangerous subject, that you avoid using terms like 'sickening hypocracy' in your opening sentence. ~ Peace. Looking forward to your next!
I couldn't agree with you more Paddy. Since this incident in Naas I have been looking at some of the comments online and it is absolutely depressing to see the vast numbers willing to back Mr. Scully and build on his unacceptable comments. I know anonymity emboldens bigotry but the casual "you know I'm right" racism is saddening. For anyone in 2011 to call black people "violent, primitive and savage" is beyond belief. If somebody actually said that to me in the real world I wouldn't know how to respond, I would be speechless. It is just so bitter and hate-filled. Joe, I hope for the sake of my children, that you are as far away from average as can be.
"the Canadians are just a bunch of Brit lovers anyway". Is there any limit to the imbecilities posted by this columnist Duffy? Who hired him to write here? Who the hell is he? Why are bigoted imbeciles like him given a forum here?
If anyone thinks that American blacks are a special exception then look at how blacks behave in Africa. Or just look at how they were totally over-represented in the riots that happened last summer in England. Blacks are violent, primitive and savage.
Scully is absolutely right. If you want proof just look at any major U.S. city with a large black population such as Detroit or Newark. Blacks are a menace anywhere that they are found.
Ah, George, just like in Field of Dreams I knew if I wrote it, you would come. Bhuel, tá cúpla focail agam ar aon nós, mar shampla "alpaire amaideach".I also know the words "foclóir Bearla", wherein you'll find words like bloviate and drek, and a whole load of other words of various origins. Towngate, I'm sorry you didn't like this article given how you're normally very complimentary about my stuff, but I think it is patently obvious given anything beyond a cursory glance of this article that when I refer to Canadians as "Brit lovers" I'm clearly performing a send up, and to be honest I'm baffled as to how it could be interpreted as anything else. Regarding everything else you say, well that's an honest disagreement, but I'm not all that interested in people who would revert to a racially indigenous Ireland, especially when that Ireland had its fair share of people discriminating in other areas. Besides, I'm sure the Boston Brahmin would have voted a similar way back in the mid 19th century.
Next Page 1 of 2 pages




Log into IrishCentral with your Facebook account


or sign-in directly

E-Mail:
Password:
 Remember me Forgot my password
Not a member? Register Now!
print this article Print
email this articleE-mail