What’s next for Commissioner of the New York City Police Department, Ray Kelly?
Posted on Thursday, September 30, 2010 at 08:56 AM
RSS 
Recent Posts
- 'The Great Gatsby' author F Scott Fitzgerald’s death and burial another Catholic lesson
- Anthony Weiner running for New York mayor and the Italian mob and Irish Americans strong ties
- Victor Navasky lauds Thomas Nast - American cartoonist known for his racist Irish ape-like drawings
- Immigration is not the problem - history of anti-Irish behavior reflecting on the Chechnyan bombs in Boston
- The good old anti-British days - Margaret Thatcher haters and spats in New York during World War II
Archives
Almost 13 million viewers tuned in to see Tom Selleck’s return to a network TV drama last Friday. The CBS show Blue Bloods features Selleck as the Irish American police commissioner of New York City.
Selleck, thus far, has received solid reviews for his commanding performance, though some folks noted that he has been seen wearing the blues of the NYPD uniform. This even though actual New York police commissioners -- such as the current Irish American one, Ray Kelly -- prefer snazzy suit jackets and ties.
This, of course, is only a small detail. Especially when there is a much bigger question to be asked when it comes to police commissioners who may or may not be seen on TV a lot in the near future.
More and more people are starting to wonder not about what Ray Kelly happens to be wearing, but where he will be wearing it.
The big question is this -- is Kelly going to try and become the first New York City mayor with an Irish name since Bill O’Dwyer back in the 1950s?
Just this week, The New York Observer, which fancies itself the ultimate insider chronicler of New York, ran a long profile of one of Kelly’s most trusted advisors, NYPD Deputy Commissioner for Public Affairs Paul Browne.
Browne, as the article notes, “grew up in a small apartment in the Bedford Park section of the Bronx, one of four children of Irish immigrants.”
Browne, the article also notes, “is a former newspaper reporter who has become…a loyal friend and an adviser to Police Commissioner Ray Kelly. If you compare their resumes side by side, you will find that for most of the past two decades, wherever Mr. Kelly has gone, Mr. Browne has sat in the seat right behind him, if not next to him.”
In short, it seems as if Kelly does decide to make a run for City Hall in 2013, he will have a fellow Irishman by his side.
However, even though one longtime friend of Kelly notes that the top cop is an “attractive candidate,” there are some obstacles.
“I don’t think New York City will ever be able to say thank you enough to Ray Kelly for the job he’s done,” says Tom Kelly (no relation), who, aside from being a friend of the commish’s, also happens to be a writer and co-producer on Blue Bloods.
Kelly adds that it is “literally unprecedented” for an Irish American top cop to have such high approval ratings not just across the five boroughs, but also in African American neighborhoods where tension between residents and law enforcement can run high.
However, Kelly also notes that the commish would have to raise a lot of money at a time when many millionaires and even billionaires (Mike Bloomberg anyone?) can fund their own campaigns. In addition, the minefield of mayoral politics may simply not interest Kelly.
There is also the matter of whether or not the commissioner would run as a Republican or Democrat. The latter field, as always, is very crowded.
This summer, New York Daily News political analyst Joshua Greenman sized the race up this way: “Look at the lineup of likely (mayoral) contenders: Bill de Blasio, the city's public advocate; John Liu, the controller; Christine Quinn, the City Council speaker; Scott Stringer, the Manhattan borough president; Anthony Weiner, a U.S. representative. Some have talent…but they've got one glaring thing in common. All served in the City Council.”
Some feel this makes these possible candidates tired and compromised in the public eye. Kelly, on the other hand, “is an obvious heir to the three-term mayor and beloved as the driver of the most far-reaching transformation of city life in the last decade -- the continued, miraculous decline in crime, an especially impressive accomplishment given declining personnel and the ongoing terror threat. Plus, the guy seems to have innate charm.”
There is always the private sector where Kelly could make plenty of money. Some have said he might go to Washington to run the FBI.
There is, of course, one other option. Kelly, who is 70 years old, could sit back and let someone else take over City Hall, and wait to be offered the job of top cop yet again.
“They would be a half-wit not to offer him the job,” Tom Kelly concluded.
(Contact Sidewalks at tomdeignan@earthlink.net or facebook.com/tomdeignan)
Selleck, thus far, has received solid reviews for his commanding performance, though some folks noted that he has been seen wearing the blues of the NYPD uniform. This even though actual New York police commissioners -- such as the current Irish American one, Ray Kelly -- prefer snazzy suit jackets and ties.
This, of course, is only a small detail. Especially when there is a much bigger question to be asked when it comes to police commissioners who may or may not be seen on TV a lot in the near future.
More and more people are starting to wonder not about what Ray Kelly happens to be wearing, but where he will be wearing it.
The big question is this -- is Kelly going to try and become the first New York City mayor with an Irish name since Bill O’Dwyer back in the 1950s?
Just this week, The New York Observer, which fancies itself the ultimate insider chronicler of New York, ran a long profile of one of Kelly’s most trusted advisors, NYPD Deputy Commissioner for Public Affairs Paul Browne.
Browne, as the article notes, “grew up in a small apartment in the Bedford Park section of the Bronx, one of four children of Irish immigrants.”
Browne, the article also notes, “is a former newspaper reporter who has become…a loyal friend and an adviser to Police Commissioner Ray Kelly. If you compare their resumes side by side, you will find that for most of the past two decades, wherever Mr. Kelly has gone, Mr. Browne has sat in the seat right behind him, if not next to him.”
In short, it seems as if Kelly does decide to make a run for City Hall in 2013, he will have a fellow Irishman by his side.
However, even though one longtime friend of Kelly notes that the top cop is an “attractive candidate,” there are some obstacles.
“I don’t think New York City will ever be able to say thank you enough to Ray Kelly for the job he’s done,” says Tom Kelly (no relation), who, aside from being a friend of the commish’s, also happens to be a writer and co-producer on Blue Bloods.
Kelly adds that it is “literally unprecedented” for an Irish American top cop to have such high approval ratings not just across the five boroughs, but also in African American neighborhoods where tension between residents and law enforcement can run high.
However, Kelly also notes that the commish would have to raise a lot of money at a time when many millionaires and even billionaires (Mike Bloomberg anyone?) can fund their own campaigns. In addition, the minefield of mayoral politics may simply not interest Kelly.
There is also the matter of whether or not the commissioner would run as a Republican or Democrat. The latter field, as always, is very crowded.
This summer, New York Daily News political analyst Joshua Greenman sized the race up this way: “Look at the lineup of likely (mayoral) contenders: Bill de Blasio, the city's public advocate; John Liu, the controller; Christine Quinn, the City Council speaker; Scott Stringer, the Manhattan borough president; Anthony Weiner, a U.S. representative. Some have talent…but they've got one glaring thing in common. All served in the City Council.”
Some feel this makes these possible candidates tired and compromised in the public eye. Kelly, on the other hand, “is an obvious heir to the three-term mayor and beloved as the driver of the most far-reaching transformation of city life in the last decade -- the continued, miraculous decline in crime, an especially impressive accomplishment given declining personnel and the ongoing terror threat. Plus, the guy seems to have innate charm.”
There is always the private sector where Kelly could make plenty of money. Some have said he might go to Washington to run the FBI.
There is, of course, one other option. Kelly, who is 70 years old, could sit back and let someone else take over City Hall, and wait to be offered the job of top cop yet again.
“They would be a half-wit not to offer him the job,” Tom Kelly concluded.
(Contact Sidewalks at tomdeignan@earthlink.net or facebook.com/tomdeignan)
16 Comments
See all comments
manhattan | Oct 06, 2010, 10:29 AM EDT
Mr. Queasy, SHY? oh no you see I was born and raised in Manhattan and the Bronx. I lived in the Bronx from 1963 until 1970. That qualifies as an expert of the subject. Now, you are the one who never answers a question, you never explained the where you live and what proof do you have about the reasons for the crime ridden dope haven that destroyed my neighborhood. Oh, I'm among friends? Never with you pal. Don't be a pinhead again where do you live?
Report abuse
DennisQ | Oct 05, 2010, 10:58 PM EDT
For a guy who demands answers to your questions, manhattan, you're pretty shy about offering any of your own. Just three short sentences in response to be asked your theory of the decline of the Bronx.
Surely you've given some thought to the matter, if only for the fact that you sound so confident. So what do you think are the reasons the Bronx went from being so grand to what it is today? Don't be shy. You're among friends. Tell us what you think.
Surely you've given some thought to the matter, if only for the fact that you sound so confident. So what do you think are the reasons the Bronx went from being so grand to what it is today? Don't be shy. You're among friends. Tell us what you think.
Report abuse
manhattan | Oct 05, 2010, 09:44 AM EDT
Yes, Riverdale is still white. Also, it;s safe,clean and one of the few decent places to live in the Bronx. Highways don't make slums "PEOPLE DO".
Report abuse
DennisQ | Oct 04, 2010, 02:43 PM EDT
The Bronx experienced a sharp decline in the 1970's, and there are a number of theories to explain why. Some blame housing projects; others blame the Cross Bronx Expressway. Still others blame bank "redlining." What do you say, manhattan?
Some people blame the decline on the people who moved in after the middle class moved out, but that confuses cause and effect. The poor generally don't have the clout to push out the middle class. It hasn't happened anyplace else in New York. Riverdale is just as white today as it ever was. So is Middle Village. So is Gerritsen Beach.
Some people blame the decline on the people who moved in after the middle class moved out, but that confuses cause and effect. The poor generally don't have the clout to push out the middle class. It hasn't happened anyplace else in New York. Riverdale is just as white today as it ever was. So is Middle Village. So is Gerritsen Beach.
Report abuse
manhattan | Oct 04, 2010, 01:32 PM EDT
You won't answer Queasy because I don't believe you are in New York. In fact I don't know who the heck the mods are but I hope they keep you. God Bless Guiliani. Ray Kelly and the police dept. of New York.
Report abuse
DennisQ | Oct 04, 2010, 11:10 AM EDT
I'll answer your question, manhattan, when I'm allowed to post again. The mods have me in the holding pen.
Report abuse
manhattan | Oct 03, 2010, 03:01 PM EDT
When are you going to answer my question Dennis Queasy do you live in the POOR neighborhoods you profess to bleed for? Did you grow up in the neighborhoods I grew up in that are now drug infected hell holes? Did you ever go to Fordham road in the Bronx that had the beautiful parks, schools and churches and best shopping outside of Manhattan. Today it is a slum it took 30 yrs to do that. Were we poor? You bet but kept our neighborhoods from the destruction that is there now. Why did my poor Irish Mother-in-Law have to lock herself in her apt. at 4pm every day? Because those socalled POOR souls you cry for would start to menace,rob and even rape 70 year old women. So thats why we fled we had no choice. So pinheads like you that talk out of your a-- can spout the nonsense without telling who you are, your a coward and I m sure I will never get a answer.
Report abuse
Monsoonman | Oct 03, 2010, 01:26 PM EDT
Dennis do you pine for those halcyon days, pre Guiliani, when the streets of NYC were filled with pan handlers and thugs? As far as i am concerned, guiliani did a good cleaning up the streets of nyc and left a good script for others to follow. My folks went back to visit pre guiliani and they were mugged on the streets after being there no longer than an hour. When I went back there to visit, after Guiliani took charge, I took the subway to Brooklyn and came up the stairs to clean streets, no muggers and no pan handlers. We have the politically correct version of law enforcement you dream of out here in san francisco and oakland. Please do walk MacArthur Blvd at night, or take an evening stroll along market street in the city and let us know your experiences....BTW how can I highlight certain parts of my text in order to get my point across a bit stronger?
Report abuse
DennisQ | Oct 03, 2010, 06:05 AM EDT
I'm all for hearing the other side of the story when it's available. We can only guess what Sean Bell might have had to say had he lived. Or what any of a number of other dead men might have said about what provoked the police into killing them.
Commissioner Kelly does not seem to put much value on the lives of young Black men. Maybe that's why Mayor Bloomberg, who keeps him in office, did so poorly in the Bronx and in Brooklyn. Nor is Kelly much of a civil rights guy either. During the Republican convention in 2004, Kelly had anti-Bush demonstrators arrested and held without bail until the convention was over.
The apple does not far from the tree, it appears. Kelly's son, a Marine reserve colonel, is a reporter for Fox News. A fan website shows the young Kelly posing with right wing criminal Oliver North.
The number of dead bodies may be unsurprising given the technical support Kelly provided Haiti's notorious secret police, the Tonton Macoute. Frankly, I think New York can get along without a guy like Raymond Kelly. I don't think he'd be missed at all.
Commissioner Kelly does not seem to put much value on the lives of young Black men. Maybe that's why Mayor Bloomberg, who keeps him in office, did so poorly in the Bronx and in Brooklyn. Nor is Kelly much of a civil rights guy either. During the Republican convention in 2004, Kelly had anti-Bush demonstrators arrested and held without bail until the convention was over.
The apple does not far from the tree, it appears. Kelly's son, a Marine reserve colonel, is a reporter for Fox News. A fan website shows the young Kelly posing with right wing criminal Oliver North.
The number of dead bodies may be unsurprising given the technical support Kelly provided Haiti's notorious secret police, the Tonton Macoute. Frankly, I think New York can get along without a guy like Raymond Kelly. I don't think he'd be missed at all.
Report abuse
manhattan | Oct 02, 2010, 08:24 PM EDT
Dennis Q,what neighborhood of poor people do you live in? I doubt you live in Jamaica. You know why? I presume your white? Do you feel safe? If you do congradulations If you have never been beat up or attached tell us how you accomplished that? Also, if your blaming Kelly because Sean Bell was shot by Police, I don't believe he was there that night. And of course there is the other side of the story that you Mr. Q won't hear.
Report abuse
kerryman201 | Oct 01, 2010, 06:30 AM EDT
@ DennisQ: excellent point
Report abuse
DennisQ | Oct 01, 2010, 06:06 AM EDT
In the last mayoral election, Bill Thompson pledged to get rid of Ray Kelly. Like Mike Bloomberg, Ray Kelly doesn't take much note of poor people, and if Thompson had won, New York would simply have another police commissioner. As the election turned out, Thompson won Brooklyn and the Bronx, and the poor areas in the other boroughs.
It is simply not true that Ray Kelly is universally beloved. If he ran for Mayor, he would certainly lose the areas that Bloomberg lost, and conceivably he'd lose Manhattan and Queens as well.
We have to take Ray Kelly's word for it that he's doing a bang-up job dealing with the terrorists. To hear him tell it, the cops are the reason that 9/11 wasn't followed by a wave of terror bombings. It's an unverifiable statement and it comes from the same guy who tolerates fiddling with crime statistics.
Ray Kelly has about the same "innate charm" that Mike Bloomberg has. If you live in a good area of the city and you're satisfied with the police services you get, you like Ray Kelly. But if you live in Jamaica, Queens, where the cops shot and killed Sean Bell as he left a nightclub, you are less impressed with the commissioner. Just thought I'd mention here that Bill Thompson, unsuccessful candidate for Mayor in the last election, pledged to get rid of Ray Kelly. Kelly and Bloomberg are established political figures who tune out the poor - who might as well not exist. Thompson won Brooklyn and the Bronx, and the underprivileged areas of the other boroughs - Harlem and Washington Heighhts in Manhattan; Jamaica in Queens, and
It is simply not true that Ray Kelly is universally beloved. If he ran for Mayor, he would certainly lose the areas that Bloomberg lost, and conceivably he'd lose Manhattan and Queens as well.
We have to take Ray Kelly's word for it that he's doing a bang-up job dealing with the terrorists. To hear him tell it, the cops are the reason that 9/11 wasn't followed by a wave of terror bombings. It's an unverifiable statement and it comes from the same guy who tolerates fiddling with crime statistics.
Ray Kelly has about the same "innate charm" that Mike Bloomberg has. If you live in a good area of the city and you're satisfied with the police services you get, you like Ray Kelly. But if you live in Jamaica, Queens, where the cops shot and killed Sean Bell as he left a nightclub, you are less impressed with the commissioner. Just thought I'd mention here that Bill Thompson, unsuccessful candidate for Mayor in the last election, pledged to get rid of Ray Kelly. Kelly and Bloomberg are established political figures who tune out the poor - who might as well not exist. Thompson won Brooklyn and the Bronx, and the underprivileged areas of the other boroughs - Harlem and Washington Heighhts in Manhattan; Jamaica in Queens, and
Report abuse
manhattan | Sep 30, 2010, 06:50 PM EDT
Ray Kelly is a class act. What he has accomplished in bringing the PD up on counter terroism is amazing and New Yorkers are grateful having him in charge of keeping them safe.
Report abuse
DennisQ | Sep 30, 2010, 12:17 PM EDT
When you go to make a criminal complaint to the Police Department in New York, the cops try to talk you out of it. It makes the captain look good if crime is going down. A lady I know fought off her attacker and called the police. When they arrived, they told her she wasn't hurt and they wouldn't take the report.
I myself was nearly run over in an intersection by a motorist making a left turn. I jumped out of the way, scraping my elbows and breaking my glasses. The driver stopped and said, "Do you want help getting up?" When I answered No, they drove off. Later, when I went to the precinct to report a hit and run, the officer corrected me and said that I was not hit. He also declined to take a report.
I've heard this is going on in other boroughs as well. It's difficult to believe that Ray Kelly doesn't know about it. New York is said to be the safest big city in America. Reported crime is all the way down.
I myself was nearly run over in an intersection by a motorist making a left turn. I jumped out of the way, scraping my elbows and breaking my glasses. The driver stopped and said, "Do you want help getting up?" When I answered No, they drove off. Later, when I went to the precinct to report a hit and run, the officer corrected me and said that I was not hit. He also declined to take a report.
I've heard this is going on in other boroughs as well. It's difficult to believe that Ray Kelly doesn't know about it. New York is said to be the safest big city in America. Reported crime is all the way down.
Report abuse
16 Comments

Report abuse