Periscope


Malcolm Gladwell says Irish are bad drunks

Posted on Wednesday, February 10, 2010 at 06:04 AM

RSS


Recent Posts

Archives

submit to reddit


The Irish are bad drunks who can't handle their liquor, like Italians and an obscure Bolivian tribe says Malcolm Gladwell in the latest issue of New Yorker.

The world's most famous pop psychologist bases his evidence on studies of various ethnic groups in New Haven in the 1950s.

He says that Italians at the time drank every bit as much as Irish did, but that family rituals and practices meant that the drinking took place in a structured environment.

The Irish it seemed just got drunk, here there and everywhere. When it came to admission to the local alcoholic center, only 40 Italian names were mentioned while there were literally hundreds of Irish.

Hey listen, 1950s New Haven doesn't sound like Nirvana to me either and I might like a few scoops before heading home for the nightly bacon and cabbage too.

A dollar to a dime the Italian Mama had a much better evening meal waiting with a nice glass of wine.


The Irish can't even stand up to the Cambia tribe in Bolivia says Gladwell, who drink 180 proof rum morning, noon and night, yet never get drunk or angry because it is all within a cohesive cultural structure.

Gladwell meanders on in his piece and throws in this gem.

"If you are good-looking and the world agrees that you are good-looking, drinking doesn't make you think you're even better-looking."

Huh? Methinks Malcolm might need a drop of the hard stuff to knock some of this nonsense out of him.




6 Comments

See all comments

I,m "glad" that Gladwell is "well" "Well" I hope he is "glad" all to confusing- for God's sake pass the Jameson"s.
I feel that Malcolm Gladwell may have had a bump or two from one of our Irish brothers back in the 50’s. Otherwise, how would we be finding this outwardly intelligent fellow tossing around poison as liberally as he seems to be? Poor lad. Or maybe he’s hanging out in some English watering hole slinging around his bravado in hopes of having some Brit to shout him a jar!
galdwell; we irish have a pint or two and some fine nector of the gods,irish whiskey now and then and enjoy it with a little confab with our neighbors. this 70 year old irishman has done this for a long time now and can take it or leave it the way me da has taught me. we are not bad drunks just happy. caldwell...........SLANTE!!!!!!!!!!.
This chap is spot on - did you ever see those Germanic peoples gulp down their massive steins. Their ladies are well able to handle a combination of hand filled jugs fulls of the brew that is so craved.
remind me to never invite Malcolm to a Wee Dram Session. The music may be too unstructured for him... Say, didja see the new girls working down at the local alcohol center???
Is Malcolm's essay an example of "extrapolation" gone amuck . . . or . . . is it merely a "filler" before his next book?
 




Log into IrishCentral with your Facebook account


or sign-in directly

E-Mail:
Password:
 Remember me Forgot my password
Not a member? Register Now!
print this article Print
email this articleE-mail