
This is a version of an article I wrote for The Sunday Business Post in Ireland on how an Irish diaspora candidate for president could help the Irish economy turn around. I am contemplating a run for the job.
I am not a logical choice for president of Ireland. I have lived outside the country for 32 years, I am not a politician -- rather a journalist, author and businessman.
Frankly I'm outside the box. But the inside the box logical candidates have not been doing well no matter where you look in the world.
The world contagion has been spread mostly by groupthink and false certainties from experts singing from the same spreadsheet.
In Ireland we hear the catch cries and same old slogans and we frankly don't believe them.
We must learn to speak the truth.
Here is one such:
The European Union bailout is unfair. It cripples Ireland. It defies logic that you can cut incomes, hurt the poorest and raise taxes and recover from a recession.
We must seek new terms.
Voters need to send that message, and it needs to be heard in Paris and Berlin.
We should also look at our corporation tax, but with an idea to lower it, not raise it.
Northern Ireland is looking to do that too.
Such an act would ensure more inward investment, business leaders tell me. It would also give Ireland a valuable bargaining chip with Europe.
Europe has been good for this economy but we need to engage them no longer as supplicants, but showing some sharp elbows too.
We desperately need to look outwards, as an island nation, not inwards any more.
I learned early on to question easy assumptions and tackle hard issues. I left Ireland at age 26 in 1979, knowing no one in America but using my GAA skills in Chicago and San Francisco as a marvelous lever to set up a network of friends.
I started my own business in California later that same year. I now have four successful publications in New York and have created hundreds of jobs over that time.
In the United States I learned the virtues of candor and straight talk, especially during the immigration battles leading to the Donnelly and Morrison visas and peace process when I spent two fraught years as the intermediary between Sinn Fein and the White House in the run up to the successful IRA ceasefire.
I was also the first to establish contact with then Governor Bill Clinton and to interest him in the Irish peace effort, a point he graciously acknowledged at an Irish American event three months ago.
So how can a president help? As a door opener, the power of the presidency is in personal contacts, meeting and talking with key figures using the prestige of the office.
In my experience, senior Fortune 500 American executives are very flattered when Irish ambassadors visit and always refer to them warmly. The strength of this group lies not just in the United States but in the global reach of their contacts and companies.
Presidents can definitely secure the first meetings, make the case and then hand over to a dedicated team.
The creation of Diaspora business networks is something I have been doing for the last twenty years.
With our magazine Irish America, newspaper the Irish Voice and in our website Irish Central, we have created the annual Business 100, Wall Street 50, Legal 100, Top 50 Science and Technology and Top 50 Silicon Valley Irish lists, the latter in conjunction with the Irish Technology Leadership Group. The best and the brightest attend those events.
Meshing those with Irish business networks would have a powerful impact and help make Diaspora Direct Investment (DDI) a reality.
A president could play a powerful role in expanding important networks across the United States, Canada, Australia and Britain by attending and linking them with similar networks of businesses in Ireland.
Mentoring systems, job creation ideas and long term relationships could be created. To counter the bad publicity about Ireland, a cadre of job corps members of our best and brightest young leaders could visit, explaining that contrary to reports, the young Irish are as dedicated as ever.
Farmleigh in 2009 was a starting point, but it can be greatly expanded. The work of the Worldwide Ireland Funds has also been invaluable.
How does DDI work? How did MBNA end up in Leitrim with 1,700 jobs, or Coca-Cola in Ireland were it not for Irish American senior executives, who all things being equal, decided heritage clinched the deal?
How did Chuck Feeney end up investing billions in Irish education were it not for his Fermanagh roots?
How many more are out there across the U.S. and indeed Britain, Canada, Australia and Europe? But this resource must be worked and worked again.
Ireland is one of the greatest brands on Earth, yet it has become damaged and needs repair.
I was keenly aware of that when I asked The New York Times columnist Maureen Dowd, no relation but a long time friend, to accompany me to Ireland for the Obama visit.
She is the most popular opinion writer in America. She wrote two superb articles that had Tourism Ireland very happy indeed,
I think there are 30-40 journalists out there like Maureen Dowd who would write glowingly of Ireland if we gave them the opportunity to visit Ireland, the brand that sells itself once the person visits.
We must learn from the past, from the incredible success of the IDA back in the 1970s when Ireland was in at least in as bad shape. They set up the conditions for worldwide companies to come into Ireland.
They bought the land, they created the tax deal, they even paid staff briefly and hand held at every stage of the process. We must use that example for tourism and other major prospective employers.
First we must stop the lip service about the 70 million world wide Diaspora and get down to working it. Rhetoric and bowls of shamrocks bring goodwill but do not bring jobs.
Here are some concrete proposals from the Diaspora in the areas of tourism and education. We should think about subsidizing fares so that an American can fly here for the same price he can from New York to Los Angeles.
We need more flights into Ireland from destinations such as San Francisco, Los Angeles, Texas and Washington, D.C. We need to do what it takes to secure those flights.
When visitors get here they should receive preprinted coupons for saving on meals, hotels and rental cars. European visitors could receive the same discount package also.
In the world of Groupon and Citydeal it is what everyone is expecting. Americans love a bargain, but they also love to spend.
On off peak months, low fares and direct service from across the U.S., Canada, Australia and further afield can sustain an industry that is so vital to Ireland’s future.
Similarly in education, research shows that thousands of people with Irish ancestry would love to take distance courses on everything from the Irish language to history, literature and the arts.
I know the government has taken recent initiatives in both these fields, but such action can be accelerated with presidential support leading the charge.
Some might ask how I could do all of this, given the limited nature of the president’s powers under the Constitution. It goes without saying that I would at all times operate on the basis of total respect for the constitutional boundaries of the role. But we are in a situation of national crisis.
A practical president fully committed to helping achieve a goal of increased employment could achieve a remarkable amount in my opinion. Is feidir le cheile.
Niall O’Dowd is founder of Irish Central.com, Irish America magazine and the Irish Voice newspaper.
39 Comments
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Switch to the desktop site to post a comment.howareya | Jun 30, 2011, 11:23 AM EDT
Niall, if you get to be president, can you fix the car rental debaucle in Ireland? I know people that refuse to go back due to the shenanigans pulled by some of the agencies with their CDW and Super CDW and hidden charges etc etc. And Aer Lingus discontinued their direct flights from the west coast a few years ago which is a shame! Maybe you could reinstate that!
tullyallen | Jun 16, 2011, 03:44 AM EDT
Is this a bad acid trip
Collette2 | Jun 14, 2011, 07:01 AM EDT
Well there's the audacious, in the circumstances, Vatican entourage landing on the shores next year, expecting all the frills of state due. Better start saving for that, having to pay to pray as did the Brit's and others worldwide.
casualMBA | Jun 13, 2011, 09:25 PM EDT
@antoman-in a misfit of abstinence yesterday I bypassed reading of your cousin's demise. my condolences to your family.--returning to Ireland's economic troubles - The former Dean of Stanford University's Graduate School of Business Michael Spence writes "...By and large, successful high-growth countries set growth and development objectives as high-priority goals and then essentially experiment their way toward improved performance, using theory, common sense, and sensible guidelines as aids..." - The "best and brightest," then, say there is as much art as science in the economic and political solutions of a nation. An excellent reason, I might add, for Ireland to deal with its crisis of billions and its approaching centennial by investing in some equitable land settlement for the 250,000 acres of FitzGerald lands confiscated by the English crown. It needs to invest somewhere. Why not in setting its conscience correct?
WoundedKnee | Jun 13, 2011, 02:32 PM EDT
Posted by Trealach on Jun 13, 2011, 06:50 AM EDT "it's 100 million worldwide". No, you're way wrong. The Irish Diaspora is almost a billion. Haven't you heard?
Trealach | Jun 13, 2011, 06:50 AM EDT
@joycean - it's 100 million worldwide, and the President represents ALL those people, whereas Mr. O'Dowd clearly only wants to represent 40% of them. I am well aware that there is "No right" for any Irish person to work and live in the US, as there is "NO right" for ANY American to work or live here, BUT IF Mr. O'Dowd is as 'well placed' in the US as HE claims, then let him start with establishing THAT RIGHT for the people he want's to represent. Mr. O'Dowd seems to be ignorant of the fact that he relinquished his right to become President of Ireland, when he swore allegiance to a Foreign Flag. IF Mr. O'Dowd want's subsidised flights for his fellow countrymen to visit Ireland, then let the US Government subsidise them. The average "spend" by American tourists is so low, that there would be NO REAL financial gain for Ireland. As I have previously said, American tourists ALREADY receive the Tax Rebate on VAT (Sales Tax) which is in excess of 1/5th (21%) of what they spend. Does the US give that concession to Irish tourists - NO!
chuckyarla | Jun 13, 2011, 04:09 AM EDT
Ireland should declare all money can be banked and no questions will be asked , there is billions of money hidden , turn hidden money back into the market , no chatted or questions should be asked where it came from , have a amnesty on money
mamaginnty | Jun 12, 2011, 08:55 PM EDT
Oops, hope Niall O' does not think I was talking about him.
mamaginnty | Jun 12, 2011, 08:52 PM EDT
Automan sorry to hear the news, Never mind the Eejit, he has no pity for anyone but himself, just a sorry sack of rotten spuds. Ye can almost smell him when certain headlines come up.
KathyCallahan | Jun 12, 2011, 07:26 PM EDT
In addition, Niall is a tested and proven Mover, Shaker, Entrepreneur and Rainmaker. Niall O' knows how to turn big ideas and visionary business plans into viable, successful businesses that produce tangible and sustainable results for everyone. On another note. Tap into and target 70 Million Irish workforce living in the diaspora for massive job networking web site, meetings...Alkl for for hiring, creating jobs and recruiting.
JBRAFTREE | Jun 12, 2011, 05:42 PM EDT
Niall, While you're at it, get flights to Shannon non-stop from Chicago, and never mind this "Can only go to Dublin".
antoman | Jun 12, 2011, 03:27 PM EDT
@georgyboy/amputatedknee-Your comments are indicitive of your deteriorating mental health.Just saying.
GeorgeDillon | Jun 12, 2011, 03:15 PM EDT
trealach--you've just given us the trade of a madman. You want every Irish person tlo be given a work permit for the US? You've already given work and residence permits to countless millions of foreigners who can settle in Ireland whenever they choose, and you want us to repeat your mistake? Forget it, we Americans aren't goofs like you Irish.
GeorgeDillon | Jun 12, 2011, 03:11 PM EDT
antoman: "Perhaps I should run away and join a circus". Good idea--your credentials as a clown are second to none (except your alter ego sirpeter).
casualMBA | Jun 12, 2011, 03:11 PM EDT
One further note, Niall...Your pioneering work in Irish(American) media, with its improving networks of Irish American professionals, celebrities, and promising leadership has been observed, AND admired, by many of the caring, committed yet silent Americans with emotional bonds to Ireland... These people ARE an underutilized resource...Your article's Bill Clinton story illustrates this fact poignantly.
casualMBA | Jun 12, 2011, 02:32 PM EDT
Commendable article, Niall, and a commendable task described for the officeholder. I support your willingness to consider running for the mantle of the Presidency if only - while there are several valid reasons you could be a viable candidate - for the theoretical value of soberly considering the role of the Irish American d(D?)iaspora in the present and future of Ireland. Secretary hilliary Clinton addressed a Diaspora Matters conference last month. They are out there. Beyond Ireland's warm invitation and individual and informal groups of business initiatives, the utilization of the American Irish (now the D) Diaspora is pre-Hellenic in its representation.
Gearoid4 | Jun 12, 2011, 02:14 PM EDT
I am very sorry to hear about the tragic death of your cousin, antoman. At the moment things do see bleak, economically, socially and existentially in Ireland. It is a case of Ireland recovering it's spiritual soul and drawing on those great but undervalued strengths which her people exemplified in the past. I am talking about a belief in a divinely-constructed purpose in life which people have to discern and which provides sustenance during dark times. We all hope for a light at the end of the economic tunnel and it will surely come. But a personal belief in the God who made us is our primary strength.
antoman | Jun 12, 2011, 02:04 PM EDT
@Searlit-I hear you and thanks.I'm becoming an accomplished juggler to.Perhaps I should run away and join a circus :)
Searlit | Jun 12, 2011, 01:57 PM EDT
@ Niall, I like your idea of subsidizing the flights. I don't understand your point of lowering the corporate tax rate. What good is investment in computer technology, if the people can't afford the internet? The average citizen is able to afford less and less. Lowering the CTR in the US has led to a lot less revenue to rebuild infrastructure and fund education. It has led to more pollution, increased global warming, mountaintop removal, along with a host of other ills. The corporations have used all that excess cash to lobby and control the government through deregulation of the oil and coal industries, in particular.
Searlit | Jun 12, 2011, 01:40 PM EDT
@ antoman, Sorry to hear that your cousin has passed. I hope you get some opportunity to alleviate the financial strain you find yourself in. For a time in the late 70's, I had to pay my electricity and let my phone go on alternating months to make ends meet. It was a very rough period! I'm rooting for ya!
joycean | Jun 12, 2011, 01:39 PM EDT
Trealach, That's 70 million worldwide; 40 million US. There is no "Natural Right" for Irish or any other nationality to immigrate to the US.
jimmybb | Jun 12, 2011, 01:22 PM EDT
trealach ;; niall has a huge right in going 4 president as unlike a lot of people in ireland unlike a most of us emigrants he cares about ireland you only have to go away 4 a few yrs to realise how great a place ireland is an irish people cant be cant be trusted to elect the right people [ie] electing sons n daughters of polouticians who got the potholes fixed on your road on election yr its alot easier 4 us foreigners to see whats wrong in ireland as were not at the coalface listening to the spin doctors as when am home twice every yr i have to listen to whats wrong with america from friends family neighbours theres lots of opinionmakers but no1 has the balls to stand up and do something niallo,,' dowd go 4 it as a fellow emigrant am proud dont know all u polocies but de valerea done it so why cant u
Pittsburghkid | Jun 12, 2011, 01:06 PM EDT
Why is Ireland unique? Because the Roman's never set foot on Ireland. The Irish expelled the Viking, and saved European Civilization during the Dirk Ages. Only to invite the English, which took them 800 year to expell. Now the Irish invited the European Union. The Irish mind does not think the same as the Romanizied European mind, and that is the Irish strength. European money will distroy Ireland. The Germans want to dump all their Muslim into Ireland, changing the Irish Culture for ever.
Trealach | Jun 12, 2011, 12:37 PM EDT
While the suggestions put forward by Mr. O'Dowd may, contain some small degree of merit, what he has suggested falls within the remit of the Minister for Foreign Affairs, and the Minister for Industry & Commerce as well as Irish Ambassadors. Clearly the man hasn't a clue as to WHAT the Constitutional role, obligations and limitations of the Presidency are. Neither does he realise that Ireland's corporate tax rate of 12.5% is effectively only 8%. He calls for some sort of "Tourist Spending Voucher" - yet ignores the fact that ALL tourists can re-claim the VAT (Sales Tax @21%) either in FULL by claiming directly from the Revenue Commissioners, or 80% by claiming it at the Airport prior to departure. It seems that Mr. O'Dowd can't differentiate between truth and fiction. He states that the diaspora (originally quoted by him as 40 million) now stands at 70 million, whereas in fact the Irish Diaspora spread throughout the world stands at 100 million. IF Mr. O'Dowd thinks that the Irish are going to be fooled by the semantics of a foreigner, then he really has no clue about Ireland and the Irish. He may be well known in his own little and limited world of journalism, but he certainly is NOT known in the country he want's to represent. IF Mr. O'Dowd is as influential as he claims to be in the Whitehouse, AND want's to serve/represent the Irish, then I suggest that he starts there, by securing the "natural right" of EVERY Irish National to work and live in the US. Afterall, no other nation has done so much for America, and history proves that. Start there Mr. O'Dowd and see how effective your perceived influence is.
fionageevagh | Jun 12, 2011, 11:44 AM EDT
Great vision. I remember your first newspaper venture in San Francisco, and I think I might have been one of your first subscribers at the table you set up at Fort Mason - but off you were to NY in no time as a successful journalist. And now to Ireland with ideas a plenty to get the economy moving again. I've always wondered why we couldn't mobilize like our Jewish brethren who, no matter where they live, give financially to Jewish causes in a big way including Israel. What they get back is priceless - an identity that stretches worldwide and doesn't end with one or two generations. Creating an ongoing pull to Ireland should galvanize people of Irish backgrounds everywhere, and agreed that bowls of shamrock is not the ticket. For me, the pull to Ireland is the arts in any form, literary, film, music, dance, pottery; you name it, Ireland has it all and it's stellar. The people in Ireland need to celebrate the arts, too and welcome those who come to feast in what Ireland has to offer the world. Countryside is up there, too. The money should follow.
antoman | Jun 12, 2011, 11:43 AM EDT
@sirpeter-Appreciate the sentiment mate.Personally I think it was cowardly what he done and yes its a direct result of the economy.Upset me dog?..hardly,she's in dog heaven chasing rabbits :)Passed away before Xmas,she was 16 years old.Thanks for the kind words sirpeter I'll be grand.Like you said just a case of holding tough,,have a good one biy.
EdinCali | Jun 12, 2011, 11:41 AM EDT
Niall: Sounds like the Tea party would welcome you into the fold. You are talking free market principles to solve the financial crisis we face. Socialism only enslaves the people it is supposed to free. "We should also look at our corporation tax, but with an idea to lower it, not raise it." BINGO!!!
sirpeter | Jun 12, 2011, 11:34 AM EDT
@antoman.Sorry about your cousin,that's tragic.Words can't describe the pain and anguish you're cousin must have left behind him. I hope it wasn't a direct result of the economy because that would make me even more angry at those feckin' idiots up in Dublin.But the wheel will turn again.It's just a question of holding tough for a couple of years until things bottom out.I heard all this doom and gloom in the early 80's.If you are stuck for cash let it be known,opportunity will arise from those you know.Take every week as it comes and stay optimistic man.Besides you're upsetting your dog ;))
SeamusMor | Jun 12, 2011, 11:18 AM EDT
Ireland could be as important to the Irish diaspora as Mecca is to Muslims if they made it so. Muslims must make the journey to ecca, called the Haj, at least once in their lives. The Certificate of Irish Heritage should only be issued to those who travel to Ireland to get one. Add the right to apply for Irish citizenship to those who obtain the certificate and you'll have tens of millions, not just hundreds of thousands of the diaspora honoring their ancestors and their heritage by making the pilgrimage to Ireland. I would like to retire to a place with a view of Lough Derg and die in Ireland so that my bones can burried in the same soil as that which has recieved those of my ancestors for three thousand years before the famine drove us to places like Iowa and Perth.
SeamusMor | Jun 12, 2011, 11:08 AM EDT
Conor O'Brien is the best choice for President of Ireland.
jacersagain | Jun 12, 2011, 10:36 AM EDT
These admirable sentiments and aspirations expressed by Niall are spot on – but don’t face the reality (which Niall acknowledges above) that the business of the President’s office is not about the matters he writes about e.g. making a presidential charge on Govt initiatives. These matters are handled by the elected Government of the day - its Taoiseach, its Government Ministers and Departments and most all its Ambassadors to foreign countries. In other words, there are people who already have remits for these objectives. Just recently, the Irish Govt called all Irish Ambassadors home for a meeting in which they were encouraged to promote Ireland abroad. This is what Niall talks about above. I think Niall would be much better suited in an ambassadorial role – perhaps American Ambassador to Ireland or Irish Ambassador to the USA or as a Head of Mission. As Niall says, we are in a situation of national crisis and crises demand extraordinary responses and measures. I would think there is no reason why a Special Head of Mission role could be created by the Irish Govt suited to Niall’s talents where he could co-ordinate the work of Ireland’s Ambassadors in selling Ireland to the Irish Diapora and beyond. As Special Head of Mission, Niall would be free of the constraints of the Office of the Presidency as laid down by the Irish Constitution; he might use his contacts to propose such a Special Head of Mission role to the Irish Government. And the job need not last as long as seven years, which he would be stuck with as President. As an Irishman living in Ireland, I appreciate Niall’s interest and concerns and wish him well whatever route he chooses to improve Ireland’s lot abroad.
cillowen | Jun 12, 2011, 10:32 AM EDT
they could not do any worse than trying something different. Is there a Mrs Dowd? such a pair would show balance and not "me partner" and our kids comedy.
LoyalCitizen | Jun 12, 2011, 09:50 AM EDT
The only way to deal with the "diaspora" is to tax them. Tax the "diaspora" and pay off the debts and get normality going again.
antoman | Jun 12, 2011, 09:49 AM EDT
Limited powers.Before two or more men handed Ireland and our future over to foreign bankers why did'nt the current President of Ireland use her limited powers to convene the Dail and have the matter addressed by all the parties?Rather than surrender Ireland into the greedy hands of foreign bankers.Ineptitude?Whats left..President of what?A country of depressed suicidal unemployed people who now only survive on a week to week basis rather than living.Who must also cope with escalating crime and addiction to hard drugs.There was never a heroine problem in Cork..there is now.Sad to say a few months ago my own cousin took his life leaving behind his wife and two very young daughters.We've reached the end of our tether.The race for the Presidency holds little interest for the common man or woman in Ireland.We have become disenchanted with our politicians and politics.Indeed we regard some of them as traitors to Ireland deserving only of a firing squad.Even I must decide soon do I want electricity or do I want to continue paying for the internet..which is a luxury.Its hard to keep being optimistic when the hole through which the light at the end of the tunnel seems to be closing on a daily basis.Soon it will all be darkness.The Presidency of Ireland could be handed over to the Germans and French for all I care at this stage.Or advertised in foreign newspapers as a novel 5 year holiday for the rich and famous.Or abolish it entirely along with the Seannad and allow the money recuperated from the abolition to go towards our futile debt.Sorry if I come across as glib or down in the mouth but it is what it is.
antoman | Jun 12, 2011, 09:49 AM EDT
Niall, you have some great talking points. Much of what you say I believe is possible and would be beneficial to Ireland. Much of what you say is pure common sense and needs implementing. Alas, I also believe that your 70 million Irish diaspora is a myth. Reaching back eight generations to folks who claim Irish ancestry - along with six other ancestries is a reach too far. Most probably couldn't find Ireland on the map - and care less. Maybe a tenth of the 70m is a more realistic target. Still, you bring a fresh and interesting perspective to the scene. Good Luck.
sirpeter | Jun 12, 2011, 09:28 AM EDT
I still think it's a good idea.Nothing wrong in testing the water and seeing if it's a runner.The Irish people are in the mood to try something new.This article makes alot of sense to me and a really active Irish/American president appeals to me as well.I think I could easily convince 30 or 40 voters to go along with this if Niall does run.There is a lot going for this idea I think.
Gearoid4 | Jun 12, 2011, 09:00 AM EDT
I have always thought that if the concept of an 'Irish Diaspora' mean't more than sentimental greetings issued by an Irish President around St Patrick's day, then there should be a concerted effort to draw upon the talents of this globalized extended family network. Niall makes some key points concerning this and it would be interesting to see how his perspective is greeted by the electorate in Ireland. Good luck to him if he throws his hat into the Presidential ring.
Towngate | Jun 12, 2011, 05:58 AM EDT
Niall: You are still: " contemplating a run for the job". This gives a indication of a timerous toe-dipper, when you talk of positive action! Please forget living in the Aras if you truly want the achieve your laudable aims, and concentrate on Organising and becoming the President of the American Irish Diaspora (PAID)and offering their services and influence to the Irish President and Government through your good offices. Don't dither and squirm like Obama ~ stand up and be counted ~ or sit down!
WoundedKnee | Jun 12, 2011, 02:51 AM EDT
You'd have my vote. In fact the Irish need someone with an outsider's perspective.