
Source: The Civil War Society's "Encyclopedia of the Civil War.
There is perhaps no other ethnic group so closely identified with the Civil War years and the immediate aftermath of the war as Irish Americans.
Of those Irish who came over much later than the founding generations, fully' 150,000 of them joined the Union army. Unfortunately, statistics for the Confederacy are sketchy at best; still, one has but to listen to the Southern accent, and listen to the sorts of tunes Southern soldiers loved to sing, to realize that a great deal of the South was settled by Irish immigrants. But because the white population of the Confederate states was more native-born than immigrant during the Civil War years, there did not seem as much of a drive in the Southern army to recognize heritage in the names and uniforms of regiments as there was in the Union forces.
In the Federal army there was the fabled Meagher's Irish brigade, led by the flamboyant Thomas Meagher; they went into battle with an emerald green flag with a large golden harp in its center, celebrating their heritage even in the midst of death.
In the North, centers of Irish settlement were Boston and New York, both of which had sizeable Irish neighborhoods. There were major immigration periods in the 1830s, 1840s, and 1850s; the numbers steadily increased until, according to the 1860 census, well over one and a half million Americans claimed to have been born in Ireland. The majority of these lived in the North. There were periods of severe economic difficulties both before and after the war when the immigrant Irish were singled out for the distrust and hatred of their fellow Americans; "No Irish Need Apply" was a frequently seen placard sign above the doors of factories, shops, warehouses, and farms.
The Irish were chiefly distrusted because they were Catholic, and there was much opposition in the United States to the Church of Rome. The frustration this prejudice caused led indirectly to the boil-over of tempers in July 1863, when the first official draft was held; a mob of mostly immigrant laborers gathered at the site of the draft lottery, and as names were called and those not wealthy enough to purchase a substitute were required to join up, the mob's temper flared.
The situation escalated into full-scale rioting; for three days, cities like New York and Boston were caught up in a rampage of looting, burning, and destruction. Many of the rioters were frustrated Irish laborers who could not get jobs, and their targets were draft officials, as well as free blacks living in the North, who seemed able to get jobs that the Irish were denied. it took the return of armed troops from the fighting at Gettysburg to bring the cities back to peace and quiet.
Such events did little to help the image of the Irish in America, until many years after the war. Despite their wartime heroics, many Irish veterans came home to find the same ugly bias they faced before going off to fight for the Union. Many of them chose to go into the post war army.
Still others followed Thomas Meagher into Canada, where they joined up in an attempt to free Canada from British domination. Many simply chose to remain in the Eastern cities, hoping matters would improve as time went by. Eventually things did get better for the Irish, but it was many long years before ugly anti-Irish prejudice faded.
IRISH BRIGADE
The Irish Brigade was, probably, the best known of any brigade organization, it having made an unusual reputation for dash and gallantry. The remarkable precision of its evolutions under fire ; its desperate attack on the impregnable wall at Marye's Heights; its never failing promptness on every field; and its long continuous service, made for it a name inseparable from the history of the war. It belonged to the First Division of the Second Corps, and was numbered as the Second Brigade. The regiments which properly belonged to the Irish Brigade, together with their losses, were :
Killed and Died of Wounds
63rd New York Infantry 156
69th New York Infantry 259
88th New York Infantry 151
28th Massachusetts Infantry 250
116th Pennsylvania Infantry 145
Total (during the war) 961
The Irish Brigade lost over 4,000 men in killed and wounded; it being more men than ever belonged to the brigade at any one time. With the exception of the Twenty-eighth Massachusetts, the regiments were small. At the start they were not recruited to the maximum, but left New York with about 800 men each. The three New York regiments became so reduced in numbers that, at Gettysburg, they were consolidated into two companies each; the One Hundred and Sixteenth Pennsylvania had been consolidated into four companies.
The brigade, which was organized in 1861, consisted originally of three New York regiments, which selected numbers corresponding to those of certain famous Irish regiments in the British Army. The One Hundred and Sixteenth Pennsylvania and Twenty-eighth Massachusetts were added in the fall of 1862. Each of the five regiments carried green flags, in addition to the national colors. While on the Peninsular and Antietam campaigns, the Twenty-Ninth Massachusetts was attached to the brigade, but after Antietam it was detached and its place was taken by the Twenty-eighth Massachusetts. In September, 1864, the remnant of the Seventh New York Heavy Artillery was added; but it was detached in February, 1865, and the Fourth New York Heavy Artillery took its place. In July, 1864, the One Hundred and Sixteenth Pennsylvania was transferred to the Fourth Brigade. But the Irish Brigade was composed, substantially, as above; and, each of the regiments having reenlisted, its service was continuous and unbroken. It was commanded, in turn, by General Thomas Francis Meagher, Colonel Patrick Kelly (killed), General Thos. A. Smyth (killed), Colonel Richard Byrnes (killed), and General Robert Nugent.
This Page last updated 01/26/02
"
34 Comments
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Switch to the desktop site to post a comment.Kilsally | Jul 04, 2011, 11:52 AM EDT
The earlier settlers were more likely to be Scotch-Irish or Ulster-Scots from Ulster / Northern Ireland with strong Presbyterian & Calvinistic inclinations from their Scottish heritage.
LainieMcEl | May 06, 2011, 06:39 PM EDT
I just recently learned, while researching my roots, that my great great grandfather Samuel Jackson McEldowney and his brother George were prisoners at Andersonville Prison. George became very ill and Samuel bribed an officer to release George who went home to regain his health. Grandfather Samuel escaped from the prison but they sent a patrol with blood hounds after him and brought him back. He also later made it home. I have yet to learn when they left Ireland and where they landed.
GeorgeDillon | Apr 19, 2011, 03:04 PM EDT
jamieLM--Your beloved Midwestern "soldiers of liberty" wouldn't be the same who committed the Mass Murder of American Indians at Mankato Minn.?
GeorgeDillon | Apr 19, 2011, 03:02 PM EDT
Bishop England of Charleston was, ironically perhaps, given his name, a native speaker of Irish.
lostgold | Apr 18, 2011, 09:24 PM EDT
Not meaning to be facetious but who the hell could be interested in a thing like states rights when you didn't have stuff like toilet paper then to clean yourself right. I mean get with it Johnny Yuma must have stunk like you-know-what
tigercat1945 | Apr 18, 2011, 02:22 AM EDT
Hi there, TheYank An addition, and a correction: it's the gunboat Clifton, not the Franklin (that was the name of the Union Navy commander) Sorry for the confusion. As for the addition: well within hailing distance of Beaumont is the Clifton Steamboat Museum. Google the words for best results. Beaumont has lots to offer: the Clifton walking beam captured by the CSA Davis Guards is in a park that also features a tiny chapel called Temple to the Brave. Overlooks Beaumont's port on the Neches River. And don't miss the St. Anthony Cathedral Basilica near downtown. Catholic or Protestant, a beautiful edifice. Slainte!
yakimak | Apr 16, 2011, 09:03 PM EDT
It is quite true that a lot of Germans,Scandinavians Poles also died in the civil war but the Irish were prime meat. The great majority already knew English.They had already lost their own tongue furthermore its harder to issue orders to men who don't know ones own language. The Scandinavians,Poles Germans didn't yet know the English;the Irish did.
yuricksl | Apr 16, 2011, 12:33 PM EDT
If memory serves, the immigrant Irish were offered a quicker path to citizenship in the North, much as Mexican and other Latino immigrants are today. All it takes is a quick read of the lists of those killed in Iraq and Afghanistan to see that Spanish names are more numerous than the percentage of the population would suggest.
TheYank | Apr 15, 2011, 10:17 AM EDT
jamieLM,
I will definitely look for what I can find on Fr. Whelan. I'm always interested in chaplains. A close relative of mine was a chaplain in the Army during WWII (& Irish history professor at Notre Dame).
By the way, if you have an interest in chaplains you might like this that I wrote about Fr. Doyle, who served with the Irishmen who fought with the British Army during WWI.
TheYank | Apr 15, 2011, 10:02 AM EDT
tigercat1945,
I'm almost ashamed to admit I never heard of Dowling until recently. I wrote briefly about him on this site last Memorial Day.
Would love to get to that part of the world someday to see the statues and the city park in Beaumont.
tigercat1945 | Apr 15, 2011, 03:06 AM EDT
PS: the crossbeam of the Union gunboat Franklin is in a city park near the Port of Beaumont, Texas - my hometown. Also, excellent statues of Dowling at Sabine Pass TX and in Houston, too. Thanks again!
tigercat1945 | Apr 15, 2011, 03:05 AM EDT
I must have missed a mention for one of Ireland's most heroic sons - Dick Dowling (perhaps because he fought for the "losing" side). Dowling commanded a force of some 47 Irish dockworkers from Houston known as the Davis Guards. Dowling's crew sunk and damaged Union gunboats and transports at the Battle of Sabine Pass, at the mouth of the Sabine River that is the Texas/Louisiana border, in 1863. Dowling and his men were hailed by the Confederates as heroes (instead of, forgive me for saying, the so-called 'dirty Irish'), so the victory for the Irish was more than just on the field. I recommend you Google "Dick Dowling" and read Wikipedia's account. BTW: a Connemara-born friend of mine, Danny O'Flaherty, wrote an excellent song about the battle some 20 years ago. Thanks for letting me write.
hancock | Apr 15, 2011, 12:18 AM EDT
Scots Irish and Irish Catholic, they're all Irish.
hancock | Apr 15, 2011, 12:16 AM EDT
Irishman fought bravely on both sides, as in all American wars.
jamieLM | Apr 14, 2011, 09:34 PM EDT
Yank, I was just suggesting a great story about Fr. Peter Whelan who was called the "Angel of Andersonville." He was the ONLY minister/pastor to ever go to Andersonville to minister to men who had no shelter and were diseased and covered with maggots because of such poor sanitary conditions. The stench in the prison was unbelieveable. Fr. Whelan was sort of the Mother Theresa of the prison. He brought in food when he could and consoled the sick and dying men of all faiths. To learn more, google him and there's a summary of his life on Wikipedia. Fr. Whelan was born in County Wexford. He was a priest who was the Good Samaritan and lived his faith under difficult conditions which cost him his life. After reading so many stories about morally corrupt priests on IC and elsewhere, Fr. Whelan's story is very uplifting for Catholics and non-Catholics. I didn't mean to sound annoyed with Mr. Roberts. I just think Fr. Whelan's story would be of interest to Irish and Irish Americans. Many soldiers felt he never got the recognition that he so rightfully deserved. I realize that no one can cover the entire Civil War on IC, but Fr. Whelan's contribution is worth mentioning. He exemplified what it means to be a true Christian.
peterson | Apr 14, 2011, 09:26 PM EDT
You forgot General Patrick Cleburne, one of Lee's ten top generals, killed with four other generals at the battle Of Franklin, Tenn. in 1864. He had a brother who fought for the north.
donegalcali | Apr 14, 2011, 07:34 PM EDT
@bostonblakie. Your spot on. I watched a great documentary recently from 1996 called the san patricios by mark day. The treatment the irish got in the army was unimaginable.
TheYank | Apr 14, 2011, 05:58 PM EDT
It's clear to me that Patrick Roberts wasn't trying to provide the full Civil War experience, just a flavor of the Irish experience during the war. I doubt he would claim to be an expert on the matter.
I love reading all these stories. Rather than getting annoyed at Roberts, educate him and all of us. I know a little about Company H of the 8th Alabama Infantry, but would love to know more. I know nothing about Fr. Whelan. Tell me.
By the way, there is a fantastic blog that I only recently found. If you're interested in the Irish in the American Civil War. The blogger is based in Ireland, but he knows his stuff.
One of the more interesting stories he recently recounted was about the Union Army's recruiting efforts here in Ireland. I had never read nor heard that before.
bostonblakie | Apr 14, 2011, 03:59 PM EDT
The Irish Catholics of the northern states paid dearly for their admission to the USA during the Civil War. The vast majority simply wanted to become good Americans. All the bigotry they had to overcome still amazes me when I look around today.
PhlutiePhan | Apr 14, 2011, 03:30 PM EDT
I spent four years in the Navy in Charleston. Bishop England High School for many years stood proudly in the downtown area where the Civil War started. Recently, they moved to the "burbs". Bishop John England supported a sizeable Irish population. Indeed, not all of the Irish immigrants went North and many fought and died for the South. They attempted to "carve out" a presence in the New World.
jamieLM | Apr 14, 2011, 10:46 AM EDT
Mr. Roberts, I apologize for my error. It was about 13,000 Union soliders who died at Andersonville. There were about 620,000 who died in the Civil War. I regret mixing up the statistics.
jamieLM | Apr 14, 2011, 10:36 AM EDT
Mr. Roberts - when are you going to write about the heroic Irish priest, Father Whelan, who ministered to the sick and starving in that hell-hole prison for Union soldiers in Andersonville in SW Georgia where 620,000 Union soldiers died??? Father Whelan was a true saint! Most of these Popes who've been made saints never personally confronted the misery that Father Whelan did. He ministered to Catholics and non-Catholics everyday in that stinking pit of human suffering and death. Do you know what happened to him after Andersonville? I do.
slainte9 | Apr 14, 2011, 10:25 AM EDT
150,000 is an underestimate of the number of Irish-born in the volunteer infantry regiments. There were more than another 30-50,000 in the Union navy and regular army. The volunteers are underestimated because the army didn't record place of birth at the beginning of the war. Perhaps another 100,000 to 20,0000 Union soldiers and sailors were the children of Irish immigrants. Sherman, Sheridan and George G. Meade were all raised by Irish Catholic families.
jamieLM | Apr 14, 2011, 10:23 AM EDT
colkelley: Midwestern Irish were mixed in with all the immigrants from other countries and with American-born soldiers. In the Midwest, many of the Irish were VOLUNTEERS. The muster rolls give their names. I totally disagree with your last statement. Please read the history of the establishment of Colored Troops. Btw: the non-Irish also had inferior weapons. Face-to-face fighting was common among everyone. When the soldiers couldn't reload their weapons, they bayoneted each other. Many non-Irish were also cannon fodder due to the blunders of their generals. The history of the Union in the CW can't be defined by the experiences of a few regiments. Every soldier suffered during the CW, regardless of nationality.
carrickcourt | Apr 14, 2011, 09:45 AM EDT
Doing research for the Gunn Museum in Washington, CT on Washington men who enlisted for military service in the Connecticut Volunteer I found three Irish born men who enlisted from Washington. One of lads, Henry Armstrong, ended up in New York City after the Civil War as a policeman. At Ancestry.com in the 1870 census of New York City I found two Irish born Henry Armstrongs of the same age and listed as policemen!
colkelley | Apr 14, 2011, 09:19 AM EDT
The "Emerald Guard" - Company H of the 8th Alabama Infantry -FIRST had the gold harp on a green flag with the battle cry "Faugh A Ballagh' (the other side featured George Washington). They fought toe-to-toe against the Irish Brigade at Frazier's Farm and drove them from the field. The Union continued to issue smoothbore muskets to the Irish Brigade so they would have to close face-to-face with Confederates and used the Irish as cannon fodder (especially at Fredericksburg) because in the North "No Irish Need Apply." When the Union ran out of Irish to die in the forefront they created the United States Colored Troops to be the new cannon fodder.
maloney | Apr 13, 2011, 02:08 PM EDT
After surrendering to Grant, Lee said something to the effect that had the south had as many Irish as the north, the south would have won the war.
harryfee | Apr 13, 2011, 10:19 AM EDT
my family tree states that we had a John Fee who a captain in the Civil War. i'm assuming on the northern side.
jamieLM | Apr 13, 2011, 10:16 AM EDT
In doing genealogical CW research, I discovered many immigrant soldiers from Germany, Norway, Sweden, Denmark, Holland, Scotland, and Ireland. The little state of Iowa had more soldiers fighting PER CAPITA than any other state. In the frontier Midwest, almost no one who was rich enough to pay anyone to fight for them. According to the records, these Midwest immigrant soldiers VOLUNTEERED to fight for the Union. Among the 620,000 men who died in the CW, there were also thousands of American-born "farm boys" from the Midwestern states who fought on the Union side, including 2 of my ancestors.
TheYank | Apr 13, 2011, 05:52 AM EDT
Many Irishmen joined the Confederate cause. One such man was General Patrick Cleburne, probably the greatest Irish-born leader during the war.
I covered a bit of this ground here.
triangle98 | Apr 13, 2011, 01:23 AM EDT
The Regimental Battle Cry "Faugh A Ballagh" was first used by the Regiment during the American Civil War.
triangle98 | Apr 13, 2011, 01:22 AM EDT
Riamh Nar Dhruid O Sbairn Lann - Motto of the Fighting 69th.
yakimak | Apr 12, 2011, 08:59 PM EDT
A great loss and entirely uncalled for that so many dumb old Paddies were dying for either side in the Civil war while so many of the rich Confederates who were responsible for it didn't volunteer at all and please don't tell me that they cared about states rights who cares about a thing called states rights when either you or your parents have just lived through "an ocras mor" the great hunger. Also in the north a lot of the wealthy bought themselves out of military service while poor Paddy went to replace them on the battlefield. What choice did he have be sent back to the horrors of post-famine Ireland.
manhattan | Apr 12, 2011, 07:01 PM EDT
My family went to Savanna Ga. to see there St. Patrick's day parade. I heard it is the second largest after New York. I really never knew about the Irish in the south. But in Savanna they are very proud of there heritage. In the civil war the Savannah soldiers were called the" Jaspers". So on those bloody battlefields a New York Irishmen and A Southern Irishman were killing each other. The New York Irish wanted to be accepted and thought fighting for the Union would do it. The Southern Irishman wanted states rights. It wasn't all about slavery either.