The hypocrisy of Lou Dobbs on the immigration issue has finally been exposed .
It now turns out according to a ‘Nation’ magazine report that Dobbs hired illegal immigrants to work on his horse farm in New Jersey, all the time castigating employers in America who did the same.
Dobbs,remember, was the man who lit the torch against illegal immigrants here in America. Night after night his CNN show slammed them and abused anyone who made a case for them to be legalized.
It was the beginning of a nasty nativist era in American politics that continues to this day where immigrant are demonized and some have been killed by thugs weaned on the nasty rhetoric of Dobbs and others.
Now it turns out that Dobbs was having it both ways, slamming the hiring of illegal immigrants while benefiting from their cheap labor to keep his house and manage his fancy stables.
And the upshot of ‘The Nation’ article is that Dobbs clearly knew that the workers were undocumented
Macdonald spoke to a man named Rodrigo Ortega. Ortega told her about meeting Dobbs. Ortega told her that Dobbs "knew very well that the majority of us didn't have papers," but that this "was never a problem."
it is hardly surprising that Dobbs never paid overtime to the illegal workers who often worked very long hours.
After all Lou Dobbs always thought he could have it both ways.
Now that facade has come tumbling down thanks to some outstanding reporting.
The title of the article says it all: “Lou Dobbs American Hypocrite.”
29 Comments
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Switch to the desktop site to post a comment.Monsoonman | Oct 11, 2010, 11:09 PM EDT
uh, there is a qualuudese which used to be spoken a lot but I think it is a dead language now, sort of like latin.
IrishAndProud | Oct 11, 2010, 09:41 PM EDT
If there's a 'spanglish,' is there also an Engliol?
Monsoonman | Oct 11, 2010, 08:20 PM EDT
I habla spanglish to my caddie, so there is an alternative language here in Mexifornia.
IrishAndProud | Oct 10, 2010, 11:59 PM EDT
Plasticpaddy, CLoghry1938 did not say that English was the 'official' language of the USA. He/She simply (and correctly) said that English is the language of the USA -- it always has been, defacto. That is indisputable. Additionally, there are many, many Americans (the majority, I do believe) who do indeed support codifying it as the official language, into the U.S. Constitution. I'm one of them. And 'multiculturalism' is by essence and definition the ANTITHESIS of national cohesion, because it places whatever nationality and/or race a person was or is AHEAD of being an American (you're fill-in-the-blank first, and American second, if at all). Fortunately the 'multiculturalists' are the minority, and the people are agitated.
rpmschevy | Oct 10, 2010, 01:01 AM EDT
Ms Murphy they are illegal. Every country has rules about travel into and length of stay. Look it up. So what do you call someone who steals from you, a legal person or a CRIMINAL? My wife and daughter are from Ukraine. I can go visit their country, with a VALID passport for up to 90 days. I cannot work there. If I work or stay more than 90 days, I am ILLEGALLY there. Plain and simple. I am no less human, but I am a criminal. They are criminals, and their employers are criminals. Period.
2BorNot2B | Oct 09, 2010, 12:38 AM EDT
jamthecat (where do you want it jammed?) I think you are confusing Dobbs, Limbaugh and Beck with Al Sharpton, Ben Jealous (the NAACP blabbermouth), AFL-CIO's Trumka with the 'very popular' with his all of about 15 viewers Ed Schultz, with the forked- tongued Keith Olbermouth, with the testosterone-laden Rachel Madcow, with the 'thrill up his leg when he sees oVomit Chris Matthews, and with the rest of the old dinosaur lame-stream media who can do nothing more than color themselves green with envy while comparing their ratings with those of the lowliest of FOX commentators. -- People like you should be formally challenged and demanded to provide more than democRat-generated fumes, smoke and mirrors for the idiotic and demonstrably false allegations you let fly, and then be sued for libel until you are actually able to provide verifiable evidence. -- As for exploiting racial hatred, you should refer to contrived astro-turf gatherings put on by the left, like the recent "One Nation" rally where people picked their nose, were shooting the breeze with each other, and littered the Mall with their un-eaten box rations while their 'speakers' frothed at the mouth and wasted their breath on the podium.
Monsoonman | Oct 09, 2010, 12:25 AM EDT
"rich, white, loud-mouthed" Pretty good rorsarch soundbyte to the core of your character there jam, right out of the seiu/alinsky playbook. Racial hatred, class envy & personal insult. You should be proud of yourself.
jamthecat | Oct 08, 2010, 11:55 PM EDT
When will people understand these rich, white, loud-mouthed commentators don't really give a damn about 90% of the crap they spew; they only do it to keep the paycheck going. Lou Dobbs found his way, just like Rush and Glenn found theirs -- by exploiting racial hatred. One of these days their supporters are going to wake up, see these hyenas for what they are -- BS artists using their voices to help their rich owners pick the pockets of the poor and middle class -- and realize they've been took by nothing more than the modern version of a snake oil salesman.
2BorNot2B | Oct 08, 2010, 10:20 PM EDT
Hear,hear MaryM232!!! McDonald was called on the carpet by Dobbs for lying and she folded like a cheap umbrella -- Bottomline, libs cannot run on the issues because they have nothing but FAILURE. They cannot run on accomplishments because they have none to claim. The economy has tanked despite -or mabe because of-- TARP. The nationalized auto companies have not managed to sell cars, therefore continue their downfall, hence the waste of the taxpayer's money. The economy has tanked because of oVomit's socialist policies. oVomitCare is a farce that is already increasing taxes and costs despite the contrived promises. The safety of America and its citizens is in jeopardy because of oVomit's policies and percieved jello backbone.... So what do they have left but to smear, deride and marginalize their opponents? -- These are Alinsky tactics, something the usurper in chief knows a gread deal about since he used to teach then as 'lecturer' and practice them as 'community (communist) organizer.'
maloney | Oct 08, 2010, 06:24 PM EDT
Lou's just misunderstood, give him a break, good christian man that he is.
Conchubar | Oct 08, 2010, 06:08 PM EDT
As I understand some of these posts; if I hire a licensed contractor to install a sidewalk, and that contractor hires an "undocumented" (aka:illegal) alien to finish the concrete, then I'm guilty of employing an undocumented alien? Some of you had better be very careful the next time you buy a tofu-burger because it may have been made by an undocumented alien that you "in effect" hired!
kevinhayes | Oct 08, 2010, 02:16 PM EDT
Lou Dobbs was shown to be a hypocrite by The Nation and, yes, @IrishandProud, that does matter! The point is, @MaryM232, that Lou Dobbs has been a frequent attacker, on his own shows, of US employers who hide behind the sub-contractor excuse and now is trying to use the same excuse. Pathetic! And calling a really patriotic publication like The Nation names like Marxist and Communist does not invalidate Lou's hypocrisy one iota. Patrick Roberts, you're a great liberal American. @judiron, you must be a ditto head, foxnqewsaholic to say that CNN is liberal and biased. ,
Dompedro | Oct 08, 2010, 02:06 PM EDT
does Patrick plan to reply to MaryM232's post? does the Irish Central? will The irish Voice print Patrick;s article as it now stands?
killowen | Oct 08, 2010, 01:13 PM EDT
Illegals are everywhere, had young-un on bicycle slam into the side of my car with handlebars scraping my driver side doors. We'll have to get used to the fact that such day-laborers have no appreciation of traffic laws. An uninvolved driver (police rept, wording) who left scene, one whom officer never went across the stree to question - was the triggering agent. Such a person whom youngster somehow conveyed to officer - that he was invited to bicycle across the street in front of his left turning helper's vehicle resulting in what befell my vehicle - as I tried to ease on by. One wonders at motive of such a US citizen setting a soul up for harm. Being tired of the many seeking a day's work that swarm across both sides of the road in or around his home or office. The feigning of concern by wave-on Samaritan before I called 911 whose shoutings made me aware that a human was involved while I was trying to ascertain what was thrown or bounced up to hit my vehicle. My calling 911 the hero zero had him talking with a difference - he had a German sounding name which he may or may not have been. More than likely not. The takeover and loss of what the founding fathers had strove to achieve is close - very close. We have to serve one Master, our own Master not Masters positioned to control mankind. Keep voting for a going nowhere future with bought scared puppets. Obama Biden Bushies McSame ... you know its so. IT's nigh OVER. Protecting our Masters, tread lightly, being careful of not saying wrong thing. Jon Stewart - such power - got a fallen bro in Sanchez' job. say h
TheOldPerfessor | Oct 08, 2010, 12:20 PM EDT
To be fair, I read Dobbs' story here. He starts off by attacking The Nation for being a liberal journal. That's true. It is. Since we still have a Constitution, they have the right to print articles with a liberal point of view. Then he goes off on a long, legalistic, "I didn't know the gun was loaded" kind of a defense. Like every cornered right wing weasel in my lifetime, he admits that mistakes were made, but blames somebody else. Apparently, he was so busy saving America that he didn't look out the window and get a good look at the guy on his lawn with the weed-whacker. Same old tune.
maloney | Oct 08, 2010, 11:48 AM EDT
Patrick Roberts... another liberal Irish American liar.
plasticpaddy | Oct 08, 2010, 11:46 AM EDT
Actually the Us doesn't have an official language so English is not the language of the country. If anything would it not be something Native American. For such a multicultural country such statements are astounding.Also Karen Murphy, well said, they seek to hat people only trying to better their lives, just like the ancestors of those on here making hateful statements.
IrishTierney | Oct 08, 2010, 11:19 AM EDT
I agree with all the posts here. CLoghry1938 hit the nail right on the head. Learn our English language instead of thumbing your nose at it. We make it too easy for them not to have to learn our language, and it's sickening. Plus, come here LEGALLY. Our borders are a porous sieve. We should make so that only the children born here whose parents are LEGAL citizens, then become U.S. citizens. No more pregnant women racing over here to give birth, and thus, making their child a citizen (a.k.a.) anchor baby. No more illegal woman over here popping out multiple babies (because they don't believe in contraception), and making them all citizens. Crazy broken, and needs to be fixed!
KarenMurphy | Oct 08, 2010, 11:13 AM EDT
Please stop using the term "illegals". It only dehumanizes undocumented workers and speaks volumes about the people who use it to describe others.
judiron | Oct 08, 2010, 10:36 AM EDT
Thought he was a politician, Don't watch CNN, to liberal and biased
CLoghry1938 | Oct 08, 2010, 10:18 AM EDT
I know that this kind hypocrasy exists also with our politicians,judges, etc. I also believe thate that only those who come here legally should be allowed to stay. Also English is the language of this country and there is no reason to print everything in both english and spanish.If they want to come here do it legally and learn the language.
Fran Connor | Oct 08, 2010, 10:05 AM EDT
Patrick, will you issue an apology to Mr. Dobbs when the truth comes out? Stop drinking so much kool-aide.
borefield | Oct 08, 2010, 10:03 AM EDT
Patrick, this is so below all forms of truth. Research your story and print FACTS, check out your sources and show me the proof. These are desperate times indeed for Liberals. I see it more and more every day. I love it.
MaryM232 | Oct 08, 2010, 09:25 AM EDT
No, Lou Dobbs did NOT hire illegal aliens. Are you morons so desperate that you have to slander this man, with lies? Lou Dobbs doesn't have a horse farm. His daughter (who is in her twenties) is a show jumping champion. Her horses are stabled at a private stable, owned by a third party. If there had been any illegal aliens employed, they were employed by the stable owners, and Mr. Dobbs stated yesterday that he had nothing to do with it. He doesn't go to the stables, and would have had no way of knowing this. I listened to Isabel MacDonald, the writer for the Marxist magazine, The Nation crumble when she had to answer questions, and she admitted that Dobbs in no way broke the law or personally hired illegals. It turns out that the landscapers she was referring to, were hired by a contractor, not Dobbs. And this was a contractor who was hired to maintain the landscaping on Dobbs' family's vacation home in Florida. It was also revealed that Ms. MacDonald had also been found to have been lying, because initially she was trying to claim that Dobbs had been trying to get visas for illegals, but was told if she printed that lie, she'd open the magazine and herself up to a lawsuit. The Nation is a propagandist publication, owned by a billionaire communist, who gives nothing to charity, doesn't care about the poor and actually seeks to profit from the exploitation of things she pretends to be against.
Gaelicpiper | Oct 08, 2010, 09:09 AM EDT
This is so typical. The horse industry and, a majority of the horse want-to-be people, hire criminal aliens purely for the cost benefit. The good paying jobs, that once existed for citizens and legal immigrants, have all gone. Where have all the great Irish horse people gone?-- Looking for a living wage and benefits. It is so odd that the horse people would put million dollare horses in the hands of criminals. These horse people put their horses in the hands of some one who is probably using a false name and hiding a criminal record. Go figure?
GeorgeDillon | Oct 08, 2010, 03:19 AM EDT
Mad Mass Immigrationist Roberts does not have the courtesy to seek Dobbs' response to these allegations. Anyone who wants common sense on immigration is the victim of a witchunt from fascists like Roberts.
IrishAndProud | Oct 08, 2010, 03:17 AM EDT
If you're going to try to make the argument that something is suddenly 'okay' because someone was being a hypocrite about it, then you might as well toss out all laws and statutes everywhere, because over the course of human history most of them have been violated by people who claim to support them. Yeah...that makes sense (so spaketh Patrick Roberts at Irish Central).
IrishAndProud | Oct 08, 2010, 03:10 AM EDT
(correction: that's 'majority of the USA doesn't want them here, either)
IrishAndProud | Oct 08, 2010, 03:09 AM EDT
Well, I speak out against the presence of illegals, and I've NEVER hired them. So, I guess that cancels out Dobbs' transgressions. Besides, whether he did or didn't actually do this, what does it change about the fact that illegals shouldn't be here -- and the fact that the majority of the USA doesn't, either? All this has done is point out one man's hypocrisy (assuming it's the case); it doesn't negate MILLIONS of people entering illegally. So then, what exactly IS your point with this article, Robert, since you are pro-illegal, anyway? Do you think this really 'changes' anything?