Kenny's Church attack marks end of the road for famous 'special position' relationship
Posted on Wednesday, July 20, 2011 at 05:05 PM
Larger Text
Print
E-mail
22 Comments
RSS 
Recent Posts
- National hero Donal Walsh loses battle with cancer - teen's optimism and courage inspired thousands
- Irish professor with multiple sclerosis Marie Fleming loses landmark right-to-die case in Irish Supreme Court
- Irish government cracks down on scam motorists - stamp out loopholes to scrub penalty points
- Terminally ill Irish teen Donal Walsh makes emotional plea to end youth suicide - VIDEO
- Drunk Irish teen charged with threatening to kill Guyanan president - 17-year-old told bodyguards he'd like to shoot Donald Ramotar
Archives
Irish Prime Minister Enda Kenny's sharply critical remarks of the Irish Catholic Church today will undoubtedly be remembered as a milestone moment in the history of Modern Ireland.
The scathing comments, which even prompted a response from the Vatican, seem set to serve as a long overdue curtain-call to a longstanding government policy of reverential deference to the Catholic Church that has its roots in De Valera's first controversial inclusion of a reference to the Church's 'special position' within Irish society in the Free State's first constitutional document, and which has been obsequiously followed by more or less every successive government since.
It's also a minor though undoubtedly importantly symbolic message to the hundreds of broken lives ruined by sexual abuse, as documented in the pages of the just-released and totally damning Cloyne Report, that one of the country's most powerful institutions is no more above the law than the man on the street, and will perhaps also afford them a small sense of vindication in the knowledge that the Government and law enforcement agencies are finally on their side, or sitting at least, as of course they also should have been, on the fence of law and justice.
The Prime Minister also made an unusually cutting remark about the Vatican's supposed control of Irish religious sovereignty, at least in the life of its mostly Catholic adherents - not so long ago, perhaps, a taboo question to raise even in itself - expressing his amazement that the type of obstruction to justice so rawly documented in the Report had taken place just three years ago, rather than three decades.
The Taoiseach (Prime Minister)also sent an unambiguous message to the Church's domestic agents that the sort of responsibility shirking they've been notorious for up to now would no longer be left continue. Kenny's language, directly attacking the 'disconnect, dysfunction, elitism, and narcissism' in the Church left few in doubt as to whom it was directed.
Most of all, though, the broadside was notable for the utter frankness of its criticism, shorn of all the marks of respect and reticence that have colored previous governments' dealings with the Church and the Vatican, once such a pervasive force in almost every facet of Irish life . It was a criticism without precedent in Irish history, but one which we can expect many more of.
As the comments also follow closely in the wake of Education and Skills Minister Ruairí Quinn's recent persistent pressing of sex abusing institutions for monetary compensation to abuse victims, it's fast becoming obvious that the Cabinet is clearly engaging in a collective effort to ensure it sends a clear message that it's the Government, and not the Church, that's now running the show in Modern Ireland.
Respect for all religions is a key principle for any modern democracy to follow, but showing special deference to none would seem like a logical corollary.
The days of the 'special position' seem well and truly over. It's undoubtedly for the better.
22 comments
Previous
Page 2 of 2 pages
barneyjo | Jul 21, 2011, 12:44 PM EDT
@AngelPrecious & Trealach - HELP!! Satan has takenover Dail Eireann. ALL IS LOST!!!!!
Report abuse
AngelPrecious | Jul 21, 2011, 12:23 PM EDT
Seems like Kenny is doing his best to destroy the Catholic Church in Ireland. What a sad, sad turn of events for this once great Catholic country. Next it will be abortion. Have so many Irish people really fallen to such low depths??
Report abuse
Trealach | Jul 21, 2011, 11:13 AM EDT
Kenny is one of the biggest, lying, twisted, bigoted and incompetent leaders this country has had in its history. It's interesting how a mealy-mouthed moron can hide behind a script written by a Civil Servant, when his own Party was an active party to the abuse of children during their several pathetic attempts of government since the foundation of the State. How convenient it is for him, to point the finger at others, while his Party oversaw countless thousands of children being committed to places such as the Magdalene Laundry. Even during their pathetic reign during the latter part of the 70's, when Kenny was elected, he and his Party's silence on child abuse was deafening, and they knew it was going on but did nothing about it. Certainly, members of the Magesterium and the Vatican have a LOT to account for, but so too has Kenny and Fine Gael. They betrayed the children of Ireland, and pointing the finger without accepting equal responsibility is nothing short of hypocrisy - something one can only expect from a snivelling moronic Taoiseach. The perpetrators of such heinous acts of paedophilia and those who covered-up for them, including Kenny and his ilk, will answer to God - of that, there can be no doubt - but IF Kenny, or anyone else thinks they can destroy the Church Christ established, then they know nothing about Christ - He said, "I will be with you 'til the end of time, and the gates of Hell shall NOT prevail. Only bigots and morons would believe otherwise.
Report abuse
keithocall | Jul 21, 2011, 08:38 AM EDT
About time
Report abuse
sirpeter | Jul 21, 2011, 04:58 AM EDT
Interesting times for Ireland
Report abuse
McNamara31 | Jul 20, 2011, 10:40 PM EDT
Bravo Enda Kenny. For decades Ireland gave the church more priests, nuns, missionaries and brothers than any other country. Possibly it will be that strong centered Irish faith that forces the church back to Christ like ways and away from as Mr. Kenny stated the disconnected, dysfunctional and elitist path they are following today. Or maybe it will be the beginning of the Irish Orthodox Church in Ireland.
Report abuse
Previous
Page 2 of 2 pages
Report abuse