Danny Boy


Irish politics a lost cause.

Posted on Tuesday, June 22, 2010 at 07:09 PM

RSS


Recent Posts

Archives

submit to reddit


People who don’t have an interest in politics are often berated and belittled by those who do.

To not care about who’s running the country is a sign of ignorance to such people; proof that you truly are an imbecile, or ‘gombeen’ in the Irish way of throwing insults.

Yet there are plenty of young people in Ireland, like myself, who refuse to engage with politics because we’re just so damn fed up with it and see it as an exercise in circuity, a pointless endeavour incapable of grafting badly needed change onto Irish society.

This week gone by is a good example of just why many young Irishmen and women are beyond caring about what’s happening in the Dail.

One headline I read this week really epitomized just what’s wrong with Irish politics.

Kevin Myers, perhaps one of our most outspoken but brilliant political commentators, began a piece with the following headline: “Timid Fine Gael leaves us at mercy of toxic ruling caste”. It captures in just one succinct sentence why Irish politics is so enraging.

We just had a failed leadship coup in Fine Gael. Fergus O’Dowd and co.’s attempt to usurp the battle-worn Enda as leader of the main Opposition party brought me some long needed political excitement for Ireland. Change, I finally thought, was on the horizon.

I think it goes without saying that we’re all fed up with Fianna Fali. Yet where’s the Opposition and why aren’t they doing more to dislodge such a woeful and obviously incompetent government?

Fianna Fail have presided over Ireland’s economic ruination. A once vigorous roaring Celtic tiger lies economically and emotionally maimed. To call Ireland a shadow of its former self would perhaps even be going too far. I believe that in any other functioning democracy there would have been a national uproar with the presiding party immediately deposed of. Not in Ireland, though.

If the people aren’t going to exercise enough clout to clamour for a general election, then surely the Opposition party should?

Yet who can honestly say that Fine Gael is an exciting alternative to Fianna Fail, or that they have shown a dynamism and courageousness that begs for their immediate instatement as the ruling class, whether alone or in coalition?

For that reason Fine Gael have now sunk below Labour in opinion polls and rightfully so.

Admist so much incompetence, isn’t it only right that the leader of that party should be gotten rid of?

Obviously it’s not just I who holds onto that belief, as a sizeable chunk of Fine Gael’s frontbench came out publicly against the party’s leader. Yet Enda managed to shirk off the affront to this leadership in the most undiplomatic and ruthless way possible by firing the challenging party. Democracy, it seems, was flushed down the toilet.

What we’re left with in the wake of the Fine Gael fiasco is a political system even worse off than it was before, which is saying something. Swearing is becoming more and more common in the Dail, leadership challenges are dealt with by firing the challengers, and no-one seems capable of change.

What the Fine Gael leadership challenge briefly promised to bring was change into the Opposition party, which perhaps could lead to a change of leadership. It was a brief and wonderful moment that seemed - and was - too good to be true.

Even today the petty squabbles continue. Fine Gael refuse to co-operate with Sinn Fein because of an Army Council which even the Northern Ireland Independent Monitoring Commission thinks has ceased to exist. Noone seems capable of working together and even within parties ties are breaking down.

Is it any wonder, then, that young Irish have all but given up on their political system?


7 comments

Page 1 of 1 pages
nobody knows why that pack of idiots are in power. roll on the next election and let's get them out once and for all.
The electorate vote them in. So, why do they keep voting FF in? I guarantee FF will do ok in the next election. Perhaps they won't win, but they'll not be annihilated, which is arguably what should happen to them. They're exactly like the Christian Democrats were in Italy. Catch all. No ideology. Just in it for the power and willing to do anything to retain it.
Dan, I think hoping that Bruton would bring new vibrancy and more potency to Fine Gael's attempts to take power was not illogical but you're despair at how things eventually played out is a little misguided. Firing Bruton from the front bench might have been ruthless, but that is just the trait the Irish people have moaned about Kenny lacking all these years. As for firing him as his Deputy, he had little alternative. Cynical as it may have seemed at the time, he has also put it behind him by reappointing him to the front bench. Why Bruton chose to challenge when he did worries me more and should worry the young Irish more too. This guy had higher approval ratings than anyone else for some time (Gilmore has changed that of late) and was deemed to be one of the few capable of change and intelligent enough to lead. I'm not certain that confidence remains. He challenged his party leader 6 days before the most important Dail debate of the term, rendering both himself, his leader and his party utterly incapable of making any meaningful impact that morning. Kenny, to this young Irishman, came out the other side a statesman; decisive, strong and still inclusive and consensus building (not that he's always been so). Bruton did himself and any hopes that had been pinned on him a great disservice. As for SF, army council aside no sensible party could form a coherent programme for government with SF policy on board. Kevin Myers, I would have thought "intelligent, though occasionally ludicrous". That said, KM and Kerrymen don't mix well.
I am at a loss to know how we are all taking this crap from the politicians. Every day you hear of new bonuses being paid to this banker or that some politician has scammed another €80,000 in expenses and nothing seems to be done about it. I was at the Dail the day of voting on the Enda Kenny saga i never saw such hype and bullshit in my life. Why doesn't the opposition be the opposition and get rid of what is there.
This young man is current. The Irish political system is rotten and worthless. One example is the fact that in over a decade of Mass Immigration, neither Dail nor Seanad has devoted ONE minute to debating whether or not the Fianna Fail policy of importing huge numbers of foreign settlers is a good idea.
For somebody who refuses to engage in politics I find it a bit rich that you can write an article berating both the demographically elected government and opposition TD's. You clearly have no grasp of the body politic, in that you claim Fergus O'Dowd lead the leadership challenge against Enda Kenny, when in fact it was Richard Bruton, Fergus just happened to support Richard. You state "If the people aren’t going to exercise enough clout to clamour for a general election, then surely the Opposition party should?", what to you propose the oppostion PARTIES should do? They have called for a general election on numerous occasions, have moved writs for bye elections yet unless they have the majority of the house they cannot, force an election. You state you refuse to engage in politics, well why then do you write on this topic to berate and belittle the very people who are engaged in politics in Ireland? Perhaps it is you who is the "imbicile" or "gombeen"
No, it's no wonder - but where's the real MEN and WOMEN of the country? Only samples nowadays apparently. All the parties are alike if not the same. There's no REAL shadow government either, they all know the ins and outs of everything that goes on on all sides, and the people are just as responsible in a way, for allowing it to be. Time for a radical change - bring on new parties with new and strong men and women who won't rip everyone off, and will EARN their paychecks and actually do some honest GOOD.
Page 1 of 1 pages




Log into IrishCentral with your Facebook account


or sign-in directly

E-Mail:
Password:
 Remember me Forgot my password
Not a member? Register Now!
print this article Print
email this articleE-mail