Reactions to an American in Ireland – the good, the bad, and the ugly
Posted on Friday, December 02, 2011 at 06:42 AM
RSS 
Recent Posts
- A Merry Christmas in Cork and saying goodbye to my new home in Ireland
- A fairytale Irish ball - a dream come true for our American student in Cork
- Ireland's love of music discovered - from buskers on the street to Guinness Jazz Festival
- Reactions to an American in Ireland – the good, the bad, and the ugly
- Taking advantage of the ‘Savage’ party scene – having the ‘craic’ in Galway city
Archives
![]() |
| A leprechaun greets two ladies |
“The lads in the back are being silly,” the waitress says, rolling her eyes, as my friends and I look at each other in total bafflement and then back at the heart – and then at the door to the kitchens, where more than one dishwasher is peeking through and laughing uproariously. Apparently, they wanted to send some kind of token to our table: “the table of cute American girls.”
We all turn bright red, of course – but we do take plenty of pictures, with the plate of bread in our midst. I mean, really. How often does that happen?
I wish all of my stories were that charming, but I have to be honest: being an American in Ireland definitely elicits mixed reactions.
In fact, it was one of the things I worried about most before coming here. I hadn't traveled much outside the United States before coming to do my study abroad in Cork. Granted, I have been to Canada a couple of times, and I enjoyed one memorable trip to London at the tender age of sixteen, but other than that, I hadn't really traveled internationally. As a result, I was unbelievably excited about spending three months in a foreign country... but also a little nervous. Let's be real: we are all aware of the negative American stereotypes, and I was a bit wary of coming into contact with them.
My fears were not unfounded. Two months into my semester, I can honestly say that I have received the full spectrum of reactions.
Luckily, most are positive! After all, many people have traveled to the States, or have family there, and as a result they have a largely pleasant and realistic impression of it. Those who have never been, on the other hand, usually carry much more lavish images in their minds, thanks to films and TV. After learning that I'm from an obscure Colorado city, they brush the information aside and demand dramatic stories of Florida, California, or New York, which have received the most media hype. “I've always wanted to see the States,” they sigh.
________________
Read More:
More from the Gaelic Girsl on IrishCentral
It’s hard to get to know a guy who just wants sex - Irish men really want no such thing as a first date
More news from Ireland on IrishCentral
__________________
Some even confess to me that they plan to move there, once they've got their degree. Miami, San Francisco, or Manhattan are the most common locations, although that's a generalization. My favorite reaction came from an Irish friend of mine, who was in ecstasy over my nationality when we first met. He confessed to me that his life’s dream was to pack up, leave County Kerry forever, and move to North Carolina. Obviously, I told him he had excellent taste (I love the South dearly).
Another friend holds the dear ambition of taking a road trip from sea to shining sea. Every state is so beautiful, she says; how can you only visit a few?
But others have not been so flattering.
One particularly vicious lad in Galway, after catching a hint of my American accent, accosted me in the street and informed me that I was from the single most ignorant country in existence, and that I probably didn't know a single thing about the rest of the world. I was speechless for a full five minutes, I think. What a thing to say to a stranger!
Another girl immediately wanted to discuss our policies regarding Native Americans, which I will be the first to admit are far from stellar... though I don't think she particularly cared whether or not I agreed with her, in retrospect.
A third person launched into an attack on the state of the political system in our country, including the lineup of candidates for the 2012 election (this was after Perry's televised gaffe, if you were wondering).
Upon reflection, I'm glad I had all of these conversations. I love my country as anyone loves their home nation: in spite of her flaws, and because of her virtues. But this whole entire semester has been a learning experience, and rightly so. Whatever your nationality, the point of study abroad is to take a step back and look at your culture with a fresh perspective, isn't it? And in order to do that, you need the wisdom that comes from a full range of opinions – which Ireland has certainly provided.
22 comments
Next
Page 1 of 2 pages
kaydog1 | Jan 02, 2013, 12:59 PM EST
Many Europeans will try to come at you with an attitude, as if they are somehow 'superior' because they live in a sh*t*ole. I think this is likely encouraged by Americans who then try to justify, defend, and convince them of our 'rightness.' MISTAKE!!! Do NOT try to educate or encourage these people.
I approach it as if Europeans are just like our own brain-dead, uneducated, Leftist, Democrat Obamabots. They are the enemies of Freedom. I DON'T thank them for their 'opinions', or in any way encourage a dialogue. A lot of times, I'll simply pretend that I cannot understand their bad English, as this REALLY pi**es them off. Mostly, I just look at them and walk away while they're still talking. And THAT'S how you do that!
Report abuse
Mousey123 | Jan 01, 2013, 08:48 AM EST
zzz-zzzz-zzz-zzzz.
Report abuse
Irishphotograph | Dec 08, 2011, 02:44 PM EST
I am a descendant of John Devoy, check out his Wikipedia page but we Irish have a lot to thank for for those of Irish heritage in the USA. From my website you can see my journey around the USA and the mad night in Boston. imagesbydavid dot net
Report abuse
IrelandNorth | Dec 05, 2011, 07:02 AM EST
Well done, Tess! There's a certain residual petty-minded mean spiritedness amongst parochial Ireland. Funny thing is, it's actually inspired by a jealousy and resentment for America and Americans. There's a "sneaking regard" for Americans here, one we most people don't like to own up to. Come back soon.
Report abuse
CitizenWhy | Dec 04, 2011, 11:27 AM EST
@bogsidebunn Ha ha. My mother, when finally convinced to go to Ireland after 50 years (she was born and raised in Ireland), upon her return to the US stated that it was nice but if she got to do it over again she would go to Paris and meet her relatives there. The family have three younger branches in Paris so this was an appropriate idea.
Report abuse
joycean | Dec 03, 2011, 06:30 PM EST
bogsidebunny, Nice succinct observations. I agree. I also think those 70 year old tourists may be an important issue. MOST Americans do not go to Ireland.When I was a kid I wondered why a certain group of my parents friends always went to Ireland. I would have gone to Paris, London, or Rome. I think the70-somethings, are a little timid and have been brought up with stories about their parents' or grandparents' native country.Many of them have dreamed about going there for their entire lives. I think it would be nice to give the old geezers a break, but understand they are not typical Americans.
Report abuse
Murph46 | Dec 03, 2011, 05:47 PM EST
Clevelander-I'm a Veteran who gets a little riled at everyone bashing the US.Are you a Vet,do you defend the US or are you like our President who tells the world that Americans are lazy.I guess Steve Job was lazy!
Report abuse
Murph46 | Dec 03, 2011, 05:44 PM EST
If newnation has enough gumption to say who started it,why then is THE GUY who started it (clinton)invited to talk Economics in Ireland in Feb.?
Report abuse
joan1954 | Dec 03, 2011, 04:25 PM EST
I visit Ireland every year and base myself in the west but only once have I come across people who genuinely dislike Americans. And, by the way I look at myself as American-Irish not Irish American. My great-grandmothers on my late mom's side were from Ireland. My grandmother, Mom and I were all born in the United States. I try, when in Ireland to be sensitive of the culture and respect it and maybe that is why when I return every year people that I know well say "welcome home." Nice compliment. isn't it?
Report abuse
edmundburke | Dec 03, 2011, 04:03 PM EST
I am quite weary of the not uncommon European sentiment that Americans are boorish and ignorant on all things beyond their shores. Frankly, the same could be said for many Europeans -- the claim that Americans are ignorant war-mongers is a false stereotype. However, I was told one story about a particularly ill-informed American in Ireland. In the mid 1980s, an American tourist visited Tralee and told his new friends in the pub that he sympathized with their plight. Curious, these Kerrymen asked what he was talking about, and he said that he knew that after midnight after all the pubs and businesses were well closed for the night, the British Army patrolled the streets of Tralee! The Kerrymen tried to convince him that that hadn't happened since 1921.
Report abuse
canadianirish | Dec 03, 2011, 03:56 PM EST
The Irish seem to like we Canadians. I've yet to receive one negative comment concerning my nationality while visiting Ireland. I hear only praise for our Canadian banking system and our beautiful country. I must admit that I do stress I'm a Canadian as opposed to an American..and they get it :)
Report abuse
Sparklet | Dec 03, 2011, 01:46 PM EST
I love America and the American people are wonderfully warm, and decent people. I'm just not keen on American tourists. A lot of them do come across as patronising, and those who are Irish-American seem to think that nothing has moved on since the 18th/19th century. I do think their reputation as the world's policeman goes against them. Especially with the Irish who definitely have a problem with any kind of authority. :)
Report abuse
clevelander | Dec 03, 2011, 12:41 PM EST
Murph46 you are the type of American the world dis-likes. I love America and what it stands for but not everything they do is right and perfect. There are mistakes and regrets. On the other hand the idiots in Ireland/Europe who berate or cast all Americans with the same brush or who think and tell Americans that Europeans are better in any way are just as wrong. We can all thank the USA for the fact that we are not speaking German.
Report abuse
JBRAFTREE | Dec 03, 2011, 12:20 PM EST
Always stand up for the American flag, and, onthe other side of the coin, the Tri-Color.
Report abuse
Next
Page 1 of 2 pages
22 Comments


Report abuse