The Keane Edge


The Keane Edge by Brendan Patrick Keane

Assimilating differently, Irish Americans re-discover Gaelic Ireland

Posted on Monday, September 20, 2010 at 03:28 PM

RSS


Recent Posts

Archives

submit to reddit



President O'Bama said it best when he said "is féidir linn," "yes we can," at a Saint Patrick's Day reception last year in the White House.

More and more these days, Irish Gaelic is returning to Irish American life at functions and in art, as perceptions of what makes something Irish shift towards more detail and care. In multi-cultural America, the old Irish American assimilation model is giving way and making it possible for Irish Americans to rediscover what they were once told to give-up in the past.

Irish Americans have battled on behalf of "The Others" (themselves foremost) in American history for a hundred years, giving-up their language and culture as payment for acceptance. They did this until it became easier to become American for everyone. Subsequent cultures won more and more acceptance with less absolute assimilation demands.

Nowadays, the pride of other ethnic groups has taught Irish Americans to make use of the boon that cultural groundedness gives a person, and to reconnect to Ireland and Irish culture.

President Clinton has taken classes in the Irish language, for example. It goes with being Irish American now--to have some kind of familiarity and esteem for our ancient Gaelic heritage. The shamrock stuff has become a conduit to something deeper. Retaining this humbling connection to Irish history, Americans learn empathy, as we can see the Irish experience/potential in all other peoples.

Irish cultural centers have opened in scores of communities across the United States, helping to give center to people scattered across suburbs. Irish has become a common language-option for college students all over America, from Harvard to CUNY.

The popularity speaks to deepening connections between diaspora and Ireland, where popular renaissance in the ancestral language is rumbling across the Irish world.

Irish Americans were told to assimilate by proving their Americanness. The Irish have loved the American flag in the most sincerely kitschy ways possible. As we discover the richness of our Gaelic culture in America, we feel we can explore it, the way other ethnic groups have a kind of cultural safe space amidst so much questionable and sometimes dehumanizing pop culture.

American culture is frightening, I'll admit it, if you look at it with another eye. Irish Americans are opening their súil eile, and finding there is benign power to see and contribute to this rich cultural Babylon. Bob Dylan and Liam Clancy talked much about the artist's outside-inside relationship to belovéd America.

I'll be a guest on Dr.Séamus Blake's Irish Gaelic radio show, Míle Fáilte, on Saturday morning on the 25th of September on WFUV where we'll talk a little about Irish Gaelic in New York.


29 comments

Next Page 1 of 2 pages
to Searlit and the others: thank you for your input. I will most definately look into all of the avenues you put before me :) Slainte!
You're right, searlit, the death of any language is not nice, especially when it embodies a tradition of a millenium and a half. Something important dies when any of the 5 or 6 thousand languages of the world dies. I mourn the dying Irish language, and I despise all who have collaborated in its imminent death. Most of these were of course Irish.
That's not very nice GeorgeDillon.
Keane: "Irish does not thrive on despair." Ain't that the truth. That's why the langauge is on life support, and will effectively be dead as a living community language, within my likely life-span. I'm about 40. Of course it'll hang on, with study groups in places from Buenos Aires to Manhattan. And there'll be people learning it on the internet, just like right now there are people learning Klingon.
I had a sociology professor who said, "If there were colonization on the moon, there would be a 'little Ireland' to represent the Irish." I think that the Irish are clannish by nature, or perhaps it is because of the Irish experience. The same could be said for the Orthodox Jewish population who live their culture in the midst of multi-cultural America in order to prevent losing their culture. Everywhere one travels to, there is an Irish community. However, it would be wise to learn the old language and traditions. I make it a point to do so for my own cultural background which is Italian. My kids are "gimmicks" so I try to teach them both the Irish background and the Italian. By the way, I've tried to learn the Irish myself. Needless to say, it is not easy.
For people who want to brush up on their Irish, I believe by now there are Irish speaking groups who chat on Skype. There's a directory with several fields you can select who you're looking to chat with. One is last name, another is country, and still a third is language.

Just for fun I looked if there are more Irish speakers in America than in Ireland, and indeed there are. Most of the Irish speakers in both countries also take Skype calls in English but there are a few - God bless them - who take calls only in Irish.

If you have enough Irish to ask questions of an Irish speaker, you can probably call one of these people up and ask if they know of a group that "meets" regularly.
GeorgeDillon: You diagnose pathological hatred, with something like expertise. Irish does not thrive on despair.
Keane, despite your silly advice, I am sure I know far more irish people than you do. That's how I know their attitudes to the Irish language. For 98% of them the attitude ranges from apathy to hatred. Sometimes that hatred is truly pathological. I will never hide my contempt for those Irish who sneer at Ireland's ancient language. You should have a bit more self-respect, Keane, rather than defending these anti-Irish language bigoted Irish. As to scarrvt's plea for advice, I suggest s/he purchase the Pimsleur tapes on line. They're advertized on a lot of web sites, and only cost about ten bucks for enough material to keep you going for a couple months. Very good value for a beginner, the only problem is that they are in the Kerry dialect which is almost dead.
People who maintain their ethnic identity are often accused of refusing to assimilate. Bandleader Lawrence Welk spoke with an accent and people thought he was foreign-born. In fact he was born in North Dakota and grew up there.
Rebelforce: Have you been to the Midwest? There are lots of Midwestern towns where the Germans, the Dutch, and the Scandinavians have maintained their ethnic identities. There are people in those towns who can still read and speak their ethnic language fluently. I don't disagree with your comments about the Irish, just that the Irish aren't the only ones to have maintained their ethnic identity quite well. You're right about the English - don't know of any just "English" towns. Btw, the Germans in Minnesota, Wisconsin, Illinois, & Iowa are gearing up for Oktoberfest.
Well written. Expresses my feelings, especially the reference to the consumptive and sometimes mindless pop culture. Irish Americans, at least most of the American's of Irish descent I know (not all) wish to reconnect to their Irish roots in some way. They like to know where their families hail from. The Famine had an affect that lasted generations into the future. The ordeal of leaving Ireland and assimilation to American culture left a scar that carries forward to this day.
srcarrvt, You can buy a "Teach Yourself Irish' book and CD at Borders. It's good. Of course, it's always better if you can find someone who speaks Irish because conversation is really what gives you fluency. Also, some High Schools offer Introductory Irish as a night class. It's a way to get started that's not too expensive, and it's fun!
When you consider that the great waves of Irish-Catholic immigration to America began over 165 years ago, I think Irish-Americans have managed to maintain their Irish identity in America quite admirably. Certainly much better than the English, Germans, Dutch or Scandinaivians have. And Ireland didn't have a particularly great and glorious history to rely on the way England, Germany or Italy did. All the Irish had was pride in themselves as a race of people who refused to disappear and refused to be conquered. They also were proud of their Church and they made it their mission to build the Catholic church here in America. And ofcourse the strong Irish Nationalist fervor in America had a direct influence on Britain's reluctant decision to let most of Ireland break free of the United Kingdom in 1922 at the very climax of their empire.
My mother spoke Irish only when she was angry...and lucky me I heard it often! I would absolutely love to learn Irish, but, like most folks my pocketbook is rather lean, and the funds are quite limited. Would someone please clue me into an inexpensive way of learning it ( other than making the move to Ireland! LOL ) thank's for your trouble...
Irish is in a strange state. It's growing and it's shrinking. It's growing in schools, publishing, government and media. Irish bands often record their hit songs in Irish after theyve release the familiar original in English. These things are the rumblings those of us in the Irish community know about and are trying to tell "Irish" people about. If the attitude shifts, and people can speak it in public without offending those who fear being excluded from this renewed Irishness, then the phenomenon of Irish resurgence would become more evident to tourists like GeorgeDillon who would do better to make friends with Irish people than calling them names. If you enter Irish community as a friend, you discover the secret language is very much alive and pure magic to learn.
Next Page 1 of 2 pages




Log into IrishCentral with your Facebook account


or sign-in directly

E-Mail:
Password:
 Remember me Forgot my password
Not a member? Register Now!
print this article Print
email this articleE-mail