Is the US Conference of Catholic Bishops becoming the new religious right? - VIDEO
Posted on Wednesday, April 18, 2012 at 09:43 AM
RSS 
Recent Posts
- Will New York Senator Chuck Schumer ditch gay couples for an immigration deal?
- If nobody's happy, it's working – the abortion debate and Irish politics of stalemate
- Conservative news entertainment complex claim Barack Obama leader of Al Qaeda
- Why Irish grudges are passed on - a long tradition of never forgetting
- Boston man confronts Infowars conspiracy nuts over 'false flag' claim
Archives
![]() |
| Cardinal Timothy Dolan |
His greatest plea to humanity was to oppose every form of birth control. In the case of sex trafficking victims or unaccompanied minors, he wanted to make particularly sure that they and all statutory rape survivors should give birth against their will.
That, believe it or not, is the face of Christian compassion as currently practiced by the US Conference of Catholic Bishops.
You think I exaggerate? The fact is that our Bishops have taken a massive rightward tilt in recent years that now has them comparing President Barack Obama to Hitler and Stalin from the pulpit, using the kind of extremist language that's endearing them to Pat Robertson and the Tea Party right.
Here's Bishop Daniel Jenky of Illinois discussing the president this week:
"Hitler and Stalin, at their better moments, would just barely tolerate some churches remaining open, but would not tolerate any competition with the state in education, social services, and health care. In clear violation of our First Amendment rights, President Obama – with his radical, pro-abortion and extreme secularist agenda, now seems intent on following a similar path."
Really Bishop Jenky? Do you fear you're about to be thrown in a Siberian gulag to break stones and be re-educated? Really?
----------------
Read more:
Priest flees to Ireland after civil jury finds him guilty of child sex abuse- VIDEO
Auction for lock of Michael Collins’ hair abandoned after family protest
----------------
Apparently Bishop Jenky is genuinely feeling very Armageddoney these days. "Now things have come to such a pass in our beloved country," he grouses, "that this is a battle that we could lose, but before the awesome judgment seat of Almighty God this is not a war where any believing Catholic may remain neutral."
Battle, War, Stalin, Hitler. Them’s fighting words. Boy things have gotten kooky in religious right land.
In contrast, may I inform you of a truly Christian act that almost - but not quite – received no mention in the press recently?
It involves Carl Siciliano, the Executive Director of the Ali Forney Center, the organization in New York City that provides food, shelter and dignity to the epidemic numbers of young LGBT teenagers rejected by their religious parents and forced into homelessness here.
Siciliano recently wrote an open letter to Cardinal Timothy Dolan to call his attention to the crisis issue.
Siciliano pointed out that ‘studies indicate that religious parents are significantly more likely to reject their LGBT children, and that he and other religious leaders who fight against the acceptance of LGBT people as equal members of our society bear some responsibility for the hundreds of thousands of LGBT youths suffering homelessness on the streets of our nation.'
Siciliano invited the Cardinal, who is President of the Conference of Catholic Bishops, to visit the Ali Forney Center in the city to see first hand the harm caused to children by religious homophobia.
Instead, Dolan sent a stung reply to Siciliano, claiming that he had felt personally attacked by the letter, which he called inflammatory. Dolan wrote that he was simply following the church's teachings.
But, glaringly, Dolan didn’t say a word to say about the plight of the gay kids who had been kicked to the curb by their own parents. He didn't plan to meet with them or hear about their plight at the center, because he made no mention of Siciliano's invitation in his reply.
If the Cardinal was asked for bread, he instead threw stones. I'm sure he probably told himself that Siciliano (who founded the center in 2002) was simply using the kids as political pawns. You could almost believe that too that if it weren't for the fact that Siciliano runs the shelter and Dolan does not.
Jesus would have gone, I bet. In fact, Jesus would have ministered to them. But these are gay kids, so Cardinal Dolan needn't bother with them because it would compromise the clear teachings of the church. Better that the Cardinal should adhere to his church than busy himself with the plight of homeless teenagers who nobody knows and with no to family support them and nowhere to turn.
It's what Jesus asks of him, after all.
Let’s face it, Dolan is a man of the world, it's how he got the job. He knows that gay kids have no political clout and that no powerful people will champion them. If he felt free to utterly ignore their plight in his letter it is because powerful people can still do so without consequence.
Interestingly, not everyone within Dolan's orbit shares his hard right views. Recently Joseph Amodeo resigned from Catholic Charities after reading Cardinal Dolan's dismissive reply to Siciliano. To underline his objection, Amodeo has just launched a petition again asking Dolan to meet with some of NYC's homeless LGBT youth.
But Cardinal Dolan will never meet with them. His church's clear teachings would be tarnished by the association. He needn’t even mention their existence.
Besides, he has bigger fish to fry. Catholic bishops are currently planning to oppose the administration on contraception, the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) and New York State's law granting marriage equality to gay couples.
They're not going to do this quietly. In fact the USCCB is reportedly planning an election-year public relations blitz that may include TV and radio ads, social media, and pastors and priests raising these subjects continuously from the pulpit.
Playing politics in an election year, whilst claiming their religious rights are being attacked, and doing all this without ever paying a dime of tax, they’ll be hard to believe. Either this is Stalin and Hitler's America or it isn't. Until they're taxed for their political pronouncements like every other PAC they probably won't care.
20 comments
Previous
Page 2 of 2 pages
PiperMac52 | Apr 18, 2012, 05:53 PM EDT
The church can neither be on the side of the "left" or "right". It needs simply to enforce the immutable teachings as handed from Christ to the Apostles, which included natural law as established by the Creator. It is because of apathy among the Hierarchy and allowing liberals to control the Seminaries and educational institutions where heresy and moral relativism reigned with a wrong headed interpretation of VII, why the church is in the state it is. Finally the Hierarchy realizes they must step forward.
Report abuse
rugbyplayer | Apr 18, 2012, 02:58 PM EDT
Of course, the RC Church leadership historically has always been on the side of Fascism. Cardinal Dolan of New York and his other episcopal loud mouth cohorts in the USA and elsewhere, pompous and arrogant, are promoting class hatred, hatred of persons in the LGBT community, and stealing taxpayer monies to further their venomous cause. And let's not forget that the Vatican, Pope and Curia, are supporing these follies.
Report abuse
PhlutiePhan | Apr 18, 2012, 02:54 PM EDT
Obama has already sent a message to Putin that once he is reelected that he will have more flexibility. Putin is a Communist and Putin finds no problem with because he is centimeters away from being the same. Catholicity is run in America by Irish Men. In the book by Jodi Kantor (who is Jewish), she related that Michelle resented deeply the influence of Irish male Catholic politicians in Chicago. This is all about the "revenge of the nerds" and his Nebuchadnasser view of world socialism. He wants this vision of radical Jesuits in which there is a religion which is democratic in the true sense of Communism. Women want freedom from the restrictions of motherhood through abortion as a type of contraception. The Irish Catholic bishops are resisting this and once the election is fait accompli, he will take off his sheepskin and once again show himself for the decadent wolf that he really is. He will go after the American bishops. Cardinal George of Chicago has already stated that he would "die in his bed, his successor die in prison, his successor will be publicly executed". As a Navy veteran, this is no joke. There is no paranoia. There is only angst over the truth.
Report abuse
jimgordo1 | Apr 18, 2012, 11:00 AM EDT
Let's get a few facts straight - USCCB SUPPORTS the ACA (Obamacare), but opposes the mandatory birth control (contraception/abortion) provisions of it, as they should. The Choice lobby have always proclaimed that contraception and abortion are a matter of conscience. Doesn't that work in boht directions? If my conscience tells me that contraception and abortion are wrong, why should I be forced to support it and offer it to my employees? Is that not Freedom Choice? The Church has ALWAYS opposed contraception and abortion, so that's nothing new! Both Bishop Jenky and Cardinal Dolan are INDIVIDUALS who are expressing their own personal opinions. BTW, while the USCCB is opposing gay marriage, I think you'll find they are SUPPORTING the Defense of Marriage Act. The Church has never opposed LGBT persons. The Church has always said that if you are inclined in that fashion, so be it, but remain celibate. In fact, the Church delivers that same message to those who are straight.
Report abuse
CelticQueenUSA | Apr 18, 2012, 10:50 AM EDT
Dusgusting man of the cloth! No Christian compassion coming from his vile heart. What would Jesus do? He created these people as well as the self rightious. Our world if going back to Hitler like times but the enemy is WITHIN!!!
Report abuse
hollabackgurl | Apr 18, 2012, 10:17 AM EDT
The speech by this Bishop Jenky is one of the most ignorant and divisive (he even encourages his congregation to challenge their own families) I have ever heard. I'm amazed. It's like he hasn't opened a newspaper in 100 years.
Report abuse
Previous
Page 2 of 2 pages
20 Comments

Report abuse