Manhattan Diary


Have our political divisions reached crisis point?

Posted on Friday, September 09, 2011 at 10:10 AM

RSS


Recent Posts

Archives

submit to reddit

The other evening I visited an art gallery opening in Chelsea. There was the civilized clink of champagne glasses and women in high heels that probably cost more than some nations GDP's.

It was an upscale gathering, in other words, catered by a group of lively waiters who hissed at the monied hordes behind their backs.

I had received the invite from a friend and I felt awkward for not enjoying the evening. But the gap between the people attending and the people catering to them was so pronounced. It didn't help that the art works on the walls were stupid, literal, one note, just slogans really. Once you got the joke - and you got it instantly - they were over. I don't know how many were sold the other night. I hope not many.

If art reflects and describes the society and culture in which it's created (and it certainly does) then it's hardly surprising that it's now as balkanized and fractured as the wider nation it reflects.

It's finally possible now to have a long and successful career as an artist without ever really engaging with or contemplating all the centuries that came before us. All those struggles and achievements, straight down the memory hole.

Why, I wondered, is everything in our own era reduced to a simple punchline? Why do we need things spelled out?

Then it struck me: it's because most of us aren't looking forward, or looking back; instead we're just living in an eternal now. It's the age of Facebook updates, Twitter posts, instant polls, real time blogging: happening now, in this moment, not tomorrow, and forget yesterday.

There's a good reason for the relentless focus on the now: I think we're all increasingly fearful of what might be coming.

That's the sort of observation that doesn't get you invited back to parties, I know. Americans prefer optimism. I usually prefer optimism myself. But a journalist should describe what they are seeing, shouldn't they?

The country is in an ever deepening political deadlock; the international economy is in a rolling crisis, the ordinary American worker is being squeezed and squeezed of every last social, medical and legal protection as our Congress openly defies our president on the deficit and jobs bills - meanwhile the super rich in America are watching their portfolios explode in an alternate reality that no longer comports with rest of the nation's.

Some of the super rich are even crying out to pay their fair share, but to lawmakers in the GOP that idea has become blasphemous.

So lately, because of all the collapse and crisis I see around me, I've been thinking a lot about some lines from a W.H. Auden poem:

I sit in one of the dives
On Fifty-second Street
Uncertain and afraid
As the clever hopes expire
Of a low dishonest decade...

Auden was talking about the late 1930's and what they led to, but the poem feels very timely.

We live in an age where networks, radio stations, newspapers­, even national broadcasters are now all owned by one man, promoting his politics, globally. For years now we have watched the powerful politicians he has bought and paid for targeting civil rights, education, science, environmental laws, healthcare, unions, Social Security, Medicaid and Medicare - everywhere and all the time - and all to scalp the many to maximize profits for the few.

Whilst working stiffs toil even longer hours for less reward from coast to coast our CEO's have implemente­d increasingly profitable free trade agreements, they've unfettered the global markets, they've outsourced the nations jobs, they've lowered their own taxes to historically insignificant levels, and they've avoided paying any taxes for their corporatio­ns entirely.

It truly is the best time ever to be filthy rich in America.

So our politicians are talking past each other because our social classes are. As above, so below. We live so far apart in terms of opportunity and lifestyle that we no longer know how to talk to each other. Our politicians reflect and enshrine that division.

Currently we're looking at each other across and ever-widening political gulf. What worries some is that eventually, if this continues, we may be looking at each other across barricades.




14 Comments

See all comments

Cahir You seem to be saying that the U.S. is livng in a glass cage or is it a permanent ground hog day.I wonder why corporations and banks are making huge profits and no jobs are been created,so much for the GOP/teaparty mantra.
Economic Facts scream for attention: In 2009, 40,000,000 Americans were living in poverty. According to "Unnecessary Austerity, Unnecessary Shutdown" (Collins, et al), "individual wealth in the US ... has risen 23 percent since 2000, to $236,213 per American adult. Reversing tax giveaways to the super-rich and the nation's largest corporations could raise $4 trillion within a decade.... We are taxing the dollars that go to our ever-richer rich — and the corporations they own — at levels far below the tax rates that America levied just a few decades ago. We have ... shifted our tax burden off the shoulders of those most able to bear it and away from those who disproportionately benefit...." Another study shows that top hedge-fund managers make more money in 10 minutes than average workers make all year. "Executive Excess 2011: The Massive CEO Rewards for Tax Dodging" reports that GE received a tax refund of $3 Billion and paid its CEO $15.2 Million. And 25 of the highest paid CEOs earned more in salary than their corporations paid in taxes." From Pew Research: "economists ... compute that the share of income going to families in the top 1% of the income scale doubled from 8% in 1980 to 16% in 2004 even excluding capital gains." If these facts have not brought us to crisis point, the reason is that the GOP cannot see the abyss between "haves" and "have-nots" that is obvious to the rest of us (See Pew Research Study 593). But EphraimK says they know just what they're doing. Do they?
EphraimKibbey I agree with all you have said.
@McNamara31 - Pt. II - They care nothing for the United States because they have not surrendered the Civil War yet. They wish to take us all back to the ante-bellum south where each plantation was a little kingdom and each property owner a noble with the power of life and death. They will not be satisfied until the nation's economic disparity is that of owner and slave. That is their goal for the American Worker. If they do not get their cheap labor here, they will find their slaves in Columbia or North Korea. Look at the three new trade agreements that Obama mentioned last night. That's right, the ones HE is endorsing! Not much market in those three smal countries for our goods but another ready supply of almost free labor. Look at the sweat shops and slave-like conditions in our island possesions in the Pacific. If you are an old school Republican, it is time to wake up and smell the smoke of the ashes of your beliefs. If the new GOP and their corporate bosses have their way with the United States Government, it will make Sherman's March look like a child's prank.
@McNamara31 - Pt. I - If you have been a Republican, as I once was, you must recognise that this party has changed. It is not Lincoln's GOP nor even our father's GOP. In the 60's, the southern Democrates, KKK and John Birchers, included, switched to our old GOP as the Democrates moved in the direction of Human Rights. When they tried to swing their weight around in the old GOP, the great financial conservative, William F. Buckley used his TV program to put them in their place. For a time they sat quietly but when George Bush almost destroyed the GOP, and the old GOP leadership was about to die, the far right pounced and took control.
Our country has been torn apart by political operatives who work manipulating the masses with fear and bigotry to gain their desired results. These tactics and the “new era” of choose the "news" that fits “your perspective” rather than "just the news" has people so confused they do not know who to believe and left primed for the political opportunists to jump in and tell them what to believe. Never in my life would I think the GOP No 1 candidate (Perry) would be a man who desire is to enable college students to “carry guns on college campus.” And while this political "sideshow" goes on like the Oldprofessor said below our present and future savings are being devalued monthly. And if this wasn't bad enough wait till the new "Citizens United" kicks in right before the 2012 election giving further power to the corporate interests to manipulate the American voter. The country has been bought and sold by corporate lobbyists and even if you send a "good man" to Washington he soon discovers he has no power unless he plays ball with the lobbyists. If anyone does not believe the extent of this they should Google the story of Michael Taylor (and GMO’s) the present head of the FDA. Taylor was a major lobbyist for Monsanto the chemical company and was the major force in getting growth hormone placed in our dairy products and genetically engineered crops into American life. These same products are “banned” in most of Europe yet here in America Taylor has insured that the labeling of these products "could not" even appear on American packaging giving the public an option to make an informed choice. And now this man who has lobbied Washington from the time of the Clinton administration sits as the head of our FDA making decisions every day that potentially affect our health. It's sickening.
"What worries some is that eventually, if this continues, we may be looking at each other across barricades." You will know it has reached that point when the masters of the GOP direct their minions to switch their traditional support from the principles of the NRA to anti-2nd amendment legislation and to begin the processes to deny the right of peaceful assembly. Much of the traditional GOP vote has come from the middle class working families across the nation. In Wisconsin, Ohio, Indiana and Michigan, those workers are seeing, for the first time, how little they and their votes are valued by the real constituency of the GOP. They are beginning to see behind the curtain of "only we can create jobs" to the reality of the GOP's job destroying agenda. How long will it take for those super-rich to think of those gathered in Madison or Columbus as behind those barricades. It is essential that we use votes to stop this slide toward 18th century France before it comes to the barricades. Those in France and those in Ireland in the centuries that followed lacked the power that we wield with our votes. We have the peaceful means of avoiding our own destruction in our own hands.
If they have, it is due to divisive rhetoric like this. Putting a Utopian society on hold for a moment, there is no socio-economic system that does not have special interest groups. Our responsibility, as citizens, is to be politically informed and active, not ideologues. It is true that politicians can be bought and paid for with a variety of incentives. It is true that there is corruption in the world. Enron was a most extreme case of fraud. It devastated the lives of thousands of families. The banking crisis did the same, only on a much larger scale. If we attribute these events to 'the bad guys', whether they be the CEOs, bankers, or corrupt and misguided politicians, we will not make America better and stronger. The media has by and large abrogated its responsibility to explore ideas and examine plans and methods to improve these situations, choosing instead to advocate a single political position and vilify the opposition. This article, veiled as a moment of enlightenment, is a case in point.
The situation in America is like the classic story of the frog and the pot. If you throw a frog into a pot of boiling water he will hop right out. If you put him in the same pot with cool water and gradually heat it up, you will fool him into staying put. Tea Party congressmen are federal employees sent to Washington to solve the obvious glaring problems in this country. Instead, they spend their days working for their parties at the expense of the country. Their war against gay people and abortions has not created a single job that I know about. Their "All tax is evil" stunt cost me thousands in my IRA last month - far more than I would have paid if they had simply raised my taxes to help the country. In a sense then, the Republicans raised my taxes. Big time. I thought the 1960s were bad. They don't care if they ruin the country - they think Jesus will come down and send all of them up to Heaven one of these days. Pathetic.
This is the most realistic, tell it like it is article I've read in months. I wish more writers were exploring what's happening to the country instead of who Speaker Boehner has dissed this week.
The lobbyists have too much power and influence over Congress. The SEC is a worthless entity because they're doing nothing to clean up Wall Street. Too many lawyers in Congress and not enough people with business and econmic sense. I'm really tired of all the polarization and stalemates in Am. politics caused by the constant vitriol spewed daily from the left and right wingers on TV and radio. Where's moderation, cooperation, and ACTION?
Last line s/b: The one thing to become more devalued than the American economy is the American vote.
Soon our democracy will become only an illusion; a front show to hide the backroom activity of lobbyist’s wielding their power insuring the control of government and the politicians on their bank roll. The only hope to stop this slippery slide of American politics is to get the money out of Washington. Presently lobbyists write the regulations and corporate tax codes. They control the quality of the air we breathe, the food we eat, the taxes we pay, and the health care we receive. The one thing more has become more devalued than the American economy is the American vote.
Yes.
 




Log into IrishCentral with your Facebook account


or sign-in directly

E-Mail:
Password:
 Remember me Forgot my password
Not a member? Register Now!
print this article Print
email this articleE-mail