Manhattan Diary


Guns lose elections as well as lives -- Tens of thousands shot dead each year in the US

Posted on Wednesday, January 23, 2013 at 08:32 AM

RSS


Recent Posts

Archives

submit to reddit

A protest against the NRA on Capitol Hill


Go to the mall, get shot. Go to the movies, get shot. Go to the gun show, get shot. Go hunting, get shot. Go to the rifle range, get shot. Go to university, get shot. Go to school, get shot. Go to kindergarten, get shot.

It’s a wonder we go out at all here.

Some 30,000 people are shot dead in America each year. To put that in perspective, if you shot every man, woman and child in Naas, Co. Kildare you’d just start to grasp the full horror of it. The mind blanks at the bloody scale of it.

And we’re being asked by some to accept that this is not a national crisis? Don’t look at that terrifying pyre of the voiceless dead, look instead at the attack on your Second Amendment rights? Really?

The Second Amendment was written not to protect your gun. It was written to protect your freedom.
Freedom, the Founding Fathers knew, is a condition that is both tangible and intangible. It can vanish just as easily with a pen stroke or with a court ruling.

You actually don’t need to fire a single shot to maintain or to lose it. But history has taught us that if you’re pursuing your freedom with bullets, you’re almost always heading in the wrong direction.

I’d much prefer to live in a society free of rapid repeat-fire assault weapons, and I’d prefer to think the chances of being caught in their lethal crossfire were going down, not up. I mean, wouldn’t you?

It’s been amusing and repulsive, in about roughly equal measure, to see the contortions the NRA and their arms industry supporters have gone through to protect their own blatantly contradictory message, which goes like this -- guns don’t kill people, people kill people.

But people with guns have to pull the trigger before they kill people, so guns really have nothing to do with killing people. Got it? No? What’s the matter with you?

Their shorthand version is people are a**holes and they will shoot you if you don’t shoot them first, so you better holster up. It’s the Wild West.

The Irish poet Seamus Heaney once wrote about firing a gun. The violence of the action startled him, and he described it memorably: “I felt that I had committed a grave sin against life,” he wrote.

So he put the gun down and never fired another bullet. Having come from a society where he saw first hand the pain that guns inflict must have strengthened his resolve. In the North, the real carnage that guns create puts the idiotic sophistries of the NRA in their proper context.

In America, for various reasons, we’re fated to watch as the latest eye-popping outrage or scandal always becomes the news, as everything else gets pushed aside to make room for it.

This week it’s Manti Te’o’s phantom girlfriend. But I don’t care about Manti Te’o phantom girlfriend, do you?

I care that 20 children and six women were shot dead by another crazed young man with a grudge and access to assault weapons. I can understand why people would prefer to think about Manti Te’o, but the time has finally come to act to address this crisis.

President Obama did not propose a ban on guns last week. He has not taken a match to the Constitution.
The paranoiacs and kooks who are talking of an approaching “civil war” over their Second Amendment rights are deluded and self-defeating.

Let’s be clear -- 70 to 80 percent of the public supports common sense measures like universal background checks on gun sales. Predictably, women are more open to gun control measures than men. But is Washington and the GOP-controlled House getting the message?

If a gun massacre can happen in the leafy suburbs of Connecticut, one of the richest states in the union, it can happen anywhere.

If the Sandy Hook massacre cannot make us reconsider the wisdom of providing unfettered access to high powered weapons, what will? This was a line in the sand event. Even the most ardent politician knows it.

So if I was a Republican politician I’d be increasingly leery of the perceived inter-dependency of the NRA and the GOP.

As the last election cycle showed us, the NRA and all the frothing evangelical and anti-immigrant groups that form the party’s base are, in voters’ minds, increasingly defining the GOP as the party of angry, white Southern men.

That simple fact cost them the election. Flubbing on guns now will cost them the next one.

 
See more: Irish in US Politics , Irish Politics


41 Comments

15 - 41 | See all comments

Is mereflow advocating an armed revolt against the democratically elected government of the USA. He surely would not pass a psyche test. Away with his guns!!!
its true about gun crime in uk,very little,and the majority of guns kept by private landowners,not much chance then of the plebs and peasants having a successfull armed up rising then, when they are getting shafted,hang on to your guns yankees,you might need them one day.
I note happy alex ignores the state with the most stringent anti-gun lawsN.Y. and violent crime is down by 1/2 over the last few years.
The Truth is that the states with the strongest anti-gun stand have the worse violent crime record: Illinois for example. Florida on the contrary, enacted Castle doctrine and the crime rate went down 70%. The 90% of the murders the author of this article mentions are related to GANG activity. On the other hand, in England, after the anti-handgan law of 1998 or 1999 the violent crime rate doubled. The government should enforce the laws that exists, and take away the guns from criminals, and put them to jail, otherwise I have a hard time accepting not having a gun. I need it to protect my family, because the police always comes too late. The Gun ownership is not the problem, it is the corrupt government, the inability of the state to enforce its current laws. On the other hand, the video programs that train children to be violent need to be either outlawed. It is the culture of violence that is the problem not gun ownership. In Colombia, for example, the gun ownership is about 6% compared to 75% in the US, yet the murder rate is twenty times as high per capita. Until the government proves to law-abiding citizens that they can protect our families, and until they take away the guns from gangs and other criminals and put them to jail for life, I do not believe it is fair to ask people to give up their guns.
Some would say the NRA is an armed terrorist group. Certainly Wayne LaPierre parades around making a fool of himself.
some teabaggers below have a selective memory "fast and furious was a Bush initiative.
olovely, Wrong again. There are just as many neo-Nazi groups in Ireland as there are in Boise...which is hardly any in both cases. Moreover, Boise, Idaho does not have any armed terrorist groups using political violence to achieve their aims. Just a few weeks ago, there were some "Real IRA" clowns parading around in Limerick making fools of themselves.
falconflash, i'm not sure where you live but it's clearly somewhere where a Google search is unheard of. Irish traditional music is a hotbed of revolutionary leftist politics. Irish people need no lectures from you about their culture or the danger of guns.
olovely.... Irish country/celtic music is what liberals hate -- preserving one's culture they would call neo-nazi even if it isn't
If go with Boise every time....
The non-presence of Neo Nazi festivals in the Irish Republic should be your first clue that Cork and Boise are - what's the term - dissimilar.
Wow. You must have looked long and hard to find that one. The only problem is that these clowns hold their annual hatefest at a different location each year. They are not a locally based organization. It would be like inferring that Washington D.C. or any other location is full of bigots because the Westboro Baptist Church showed up there at a military funeral. Maybe you should address my previous comments and then we can all understand what you mean by "chances", "apples" and "oranges." But then again, it seems like you really do not know what you are talking about, so don't bother.
Neo-Nazi's held their national music festival in Boise, Idaho in October. You'll wait a long time to see that happen in Cork. Cork wins.
Olovely, Really?! Have you ever been to Boise, Idaho? So you would prefer your "chances" in Cork. If you mean safety, then you did not read my last comment. Check Cork city's homocide rate with Ireland's CSO. If you mean employment, Boise's is half that of Cork (a few years ago the UI rate was practically zero in Boise). If you mean housing costs, you can buy a brand new home, 1500sf with central heat/air conditioning in a quiet, safe neighborhood for less than 100,000 euro. If you mean weather, then Boise's sunny, mild, dry climate from the end of February to the end of November blows away Ireland's. Interestingly, Maureen O'Hara, the famous Irish born actress, chose Boise, Idaho over any part of Ireland. I have shown you the "apples" and "oranges." Now, perhaps you can explain what you meant by "chances."
Olovely - there is no such thing as a rapid firing clip. You have no idea what you are talking about. Go educate yourself so that you at least can express an informed opinion.




Log into IrishCentral with your Facebook account


or sign-in directly

E-Mail:
Password:
 Remember me Forgot my password
Not a member? Register Now!
print this article Print
email this articleE-mail