Manhattan Diary


GOP’s 'War on Women' is real - keeping the government out of your uterus

Posted on Thursday, August 30, 2012 at 09:13 AM

RSS


Recent Posts

Archives

submit to reddit

Arizona Governor Jan Brewer 
Just when women were starting to think that what happened in their own uteri was their own business, along comes the Republican Party to remind them that GOP style “small government” can find its way into the most unwelcome places.

Forget keeping the government out of your bedroom. Now, thanks to an unprecedented new Arizona law you'll even have to struggle to keep them out of your ovaries, ladies.

In case you missed it, a controversial new law was signed by Arizona Governor Jan Brewer last Thursday with the Orwellian sounding name of the Women’s Health and Safety Act. Experts say it effectively bans abortions after 18 weeks and declares that a woman could be pregnant even two weeks before she had sex.

You read that right. Arizona’s new law starts the clock on pregnancies at the woman’s last menstrual period, which of course could be two weeks before fertilization even happened.

The new law bans abortions at 18 weeks of pregnancy, which is at about the same time a doctor would begin to perform ultrasounds to detect abnormalities. That means if any are found the mother will still be expected to carry it to term, even if they are expected to die within hours or days of birth.

As goes Arizona, so goes the Republican Party. But here’s another fact -- 77 percent of Americans don’t think birth control should be up for debate at all, according to a Bloomberg national poll.

Full disclosure -- I’m not a woman or heterosexual so clearly I’m not directly affected by this controversy (and when I read about legislation like Arizona’s I’m thankful of the fact because I think it might enrage me in a way that I might not enjoy).

Mitt Romney has also recently revealed that if elected he plans to shut down Planned Parenthood because he doesn't agree with its mission (and I imagine he wants to cut all spending on programs that don’t directly benefit millionaires).

Now if I was a woman that is something I would probably find quite upsetting, since curbing women’s health services has never struck me as a good idea.

I know what’s coming now, of course. The name-calling. It seems conservatives in the U.S. have long ago decided that anyone who supports abortion rights anywhere under any circumstances will be told they have no morals, no conscience and no guiding principals.

I can certainly understand their profound opposition to abortion, and I can agree that it is hardly a procedure that anyone should pursue lightly, but I don’t believe that anyone actually does. I cannot accept that a complete ban on it would only benefit society in the ways that they insist.

Last week we learned that GOP Congressmen (and now vice presidential candidate) Paul Ryan and Todd Aiken are against abortion even in cases of rape or incest, which they apparently see as unfortunate but final methods of contraception. That kind of absolutism seems high handed and cruel to me, punishing the victim and in a real sense re-victimizing her all over again.

Ryan and Aiken have also offered us two deeply problematic new definitions of sexual assault, with their calibrated talk of “forcible” rape and “legitimate” rape, which rightly appalled the nation. And for the record, their bill to redefine rape as “forcible” had 227 Republican cosponsors.

There have been other recent Republican moves to make abortion expensive, difficult or even unobtainable.

Texas, Oklahoma and North Carolina have all passed transvaginal ultrasound mandates, whereby any woman seeking an abortion is now mandated by the state to have a painful and invasive procedure that seems expressly designed to humiliate her.

Perhaps most startling of all was conservative pundit Rush Limbaugh’s recent decision to demonize Sandra Fluke as a “slut” and a “prostitute” for daring to suggesting that mandating insurance coverage for contraceptive pills would be worthwhile, since they help women with a number of health problems quite unrelated to their contraceptive properties.

Limbaugh, who reportedly makes about $40 million a year, lost multiple advertisers for his outburst, which most people rightly saw as shockingly sexist.

So I am not sure why, in an election year, the GOP have opened this multi-pronged war on women’s reproductive rights.

Republicans say they champion “small government,” but it’s amazing how invasive that “small government” can be to your personal life.

It seems to most observers that today’s GOP is more interested in tackling the challenges facing the nation with faith rather than reason. Perhaps it because we live in a time when many of its most ardent supporters now claim that men and dinosaurs once lived peacefully together on Earth, that our planet is only 6,000 years old, and that any moment Our Lord will return -- so why worry about unemployment or health care or the environment or even tomorrow?


51 comments

Next Previous Page 2 of 4 pages
All you Liberal, Democrat "choicers" are very welcome to come on over to the Emerald Isle and demand the Irish politicians declare themselves "PRO-CHOICE". You'll be run out on a rail. Funny how certain Liberals (The Irish) are only liberal about things they believe they should be liberal about. And abortion ain't one of them!
About 85% of fertilized ovum become viable fetus. So killing the fetus will kill a forming human 85% of the time. In the US woman have the right to do this and unless the supreme court changes that it will be the law of the land. People on ventilators with no hope of getting off are more dependent on life support that a 6 mos baby which are killed everyday. Let's just pick ax the old geezers on the ventilators as they have no viability whereas the baby does. Sounds like Yobama care. No neurosurgery for bleeding stroke patient over 70.
The miscreant below whose ignorance of birth control and womens rights should have been aborted. Maybe when they find the "hate gene" this will happen. Be careful what you wish for michealhoulihan it might come back to bite you on the bum.
Mairint, you claimed you attended 'a pro-life / pro-family conference in Toronto. The pro-aborts and pro-homosexual 'rights' folk hired buses to ship the rent-a-mob out to our hotel. We had to have the police swat team on roof and on horseback (shields over horses faces)in order to safely attend the conference.' I don't believe a word you wrote. When was this exactly? And why would a gay rights lobby agitate for abortion rights? Why would they harass you to the point were you needed SWAT teams on the roof (did you know Canada does have a SWAT team?)? We have seen you like to demagogue, let's see you back up your claims.
What makes you so against preborn children Cahir O'D? What a miserable fellow you must be esp. when you see children happily playing because their Mom did not go into a Planned Parenthood abortuary. And by the way the comment about PP providing abortions so women do not go to dangerous 'backstreet' places - hardly a month goes by that a woman does not lose her life in a PP centre in the U.S. Abortion clinics are regularly found to be filthy. One abortionist was found to keep the babies bodies in jars in a frig., others thrown in dumpsters while more are sold to macabre industries for processing. Pres. Obama pushes your taxes to fund abortion. He must not like Americans. Face the truth Cahir. America needs to protect her future citizens even if they are conceived when a woman was only out for a good time. Over 55 million babies have been killed thus. Why should babies pay the price for irresponsible behaviour?
Not only has the GOP waged war on women, but its woman-hating policies are igniting a war between the sexes. They invent inane definitions of "rape" and "personhood" and "pregnant" to distract voters from the fact that they're writing laws to control women's bodies. Ryan co-sponsored a bill that would give employers a VETO over any woman employee's health care decisions by refusing to cover contraceptives if they violate the employers' moral values. His budget not only ends all government financing for Planned Parenthood, but also slashes spending on prenatal care and infant nutrition. Of course he opposed the Lily Ledbetter Fair Pay for Women Act. To vote for Romney/Ryan, you'd have to think females are brainless sub-human beings, walking wombs, needing to be controlled by men in government. I used to enjoy political conversations with people I disagreed with. Now I find the thought of chatting with anyone who would vote for Romney/ Ryan absolutely chilling. I'd rather shake hands with Charles Manson!
Howareya- it IS my body and a foetus will not grow there unless Im willing to provide it with nurture. Im not going to be an unwilling life support machine. If I needed your kidney or blood to ensure my survival, would you just hand them over? No, I didnt think so.
Hopefully we'll get abortion into ireland soon. Women should not be forced to maintain a foetus without their consent.
Cahir-What are you going to do when scientists discover the "gay gene" and parents start selectively aborting all babies with the gene?
Pretty shameful when Irish Central is giving space to supporters of partial birth abortion. Why doesn't IC post videos of the procedure, so that we can have an informed discussion?
They call for the federal funding for planned parenthood to end, if planned parent hood can run their abortion business on their own and it is legal they will exist, the federal funding of planned nonparenthood is what should not be taking place.
Republican war against the culture of death is more like it. Why if a man is married to the same woman and stands by her through thick and thin, and believes that life is worth defending, is he considered a war monger. I would think a man who disparages his grandmother for being white, barely visits his dieing mother, and votes for infanticide would be closer to a war on women mentality.
The worst part about obamadontcare is nobody knows whats in it, even after they think they know whays in it, its a flawed piece of legislation, who ever heard of paying for health insurance by taxing granny when she sells her house 3.8% more than most real estate agents get.
Two of the commenters below repeated Rush's misinformation that the Affordable Care Act (ObamaCARES) would use tax dollars to pay for contraception. The ACA simply requires Insurance Companies to pay for the cost of it (to which they agreed since it is much cheaper for them than covering a pregnacy.) So NO TAX DOLLARS are involved! Most of the ACA is regulation of the Insurance Companies for OUR benefit. The most controversial part, the individual mandate, was REQUIRED by the Republican members of the committee to pass the ACA to the house for a vote. The Democrates were infavor of Medicare for all but COMPROMISED! Once they had gotten their demands included in the ACA, most of the GOP voted against a bill that was the GOP counter proposal to the Clinton Health Care bill. The only reason they now demonize the ACA is that supporting it would reinforce Obama's chance at winning the election.
MegK311 there's only a shade of difference between you and obvious trolls like Porkheaven and Micky74007. Take a lesson from Paul Ryan last night - he didn't run on his record or what he would do, he intentionally mislead the nation and has been roundly called out for it today. You shouldn't participate in his cycle of ignorance by pretending you don't understand he apposes all forms of abortion and would do so as president.
Next Previous Page 2 of 4 pages




Log into IrishCentral with your Facebook account


or sign-in directly

E-Mail:
Password:
 Remember me Forgot my password
Not a member? Register Now!
print this article Print
email this articleE-mail