Manhattan Diary


First Wisconsin, then America

Posted on Friday, March 25, 2011 at 09:23 AM

RSS


Recent Posts

Archives

submit to reddit

When you give away tax cuts to the rich someone else has to pay.

That's why in Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker, with behind the scenes help from the billionaire Koch brothers, recently managed to gut the collective bargaining rights of the states public employees. The state couldn't afford them, he pleaded.

If balancing the budget means eroding the quality of public services that make local communities functional and attractive, so be it.  What Walker didn't anticipate was the consequences.

Here's how the Wall Street Journal put it: “In Wisconsin, where lawmakers voted in mid-March to end workers' collective bargaining for future employment contracts, 3,362 people have applied to retire this year, a 73% jump from last year. And 10,975 people since the beginning of the year have taken the first step toward retirement—flooding the Wisconsin Department of Employee Trust Funds with requests for estimates of their potential benefits. That's up 134%.”

Teachers are demoralized, fearful and they want out. They realized they were just collateral damage in a larger power grab.

Let's remember America's teachers didn't cause the economic melt down and recession we've just lived through. Wall Street did. The rich called for the free wheeling deregulation that eventually led to the crash.

So where is the public anger at the record breaking bonuses Wall Street titans are awarding themselves after almost destroying the nation they held to ransom? Why pick on teachers when they're such insignificant players in comparison?

America is not broke. Scott Walker isn't broke. The Koch brothers most certainly are not broke and neither is Wisconsin's quite substantial moneyed class.

Instead, as has become increasingly clear, what Walker really hoped to break was the public employee unions, a major source of funding and volunteers for Democratic candidates.

How do we know this? In Walker's recent 20-minute phone call with a man he believed was David Koch, he openly agreed that Wisconsin would be the first domino in a much wider campaign among current Republican governors to neutralize public employee unions.

Walker's strategy is simple as it is time honored: divide and conquer. Walker pitted worker against worker, all the better to lose sight of who was really pulling the strings.

Here's an example of a Walker stump speech: "Every factory worker I talked to this last week, who is paying 25 to 50 percent for their health care premium, who doesn't have a pension, who has to pay into a 401(k) and in some cases had that suspended, every one of them looks at this and says, 'You know what? Not only do I not get that, I have to pay for it.' That guy has to pay the difference. He has to foot the bill for everyone else."

When a Republican in a Brooks Brothers blazer and gold cufflinks is suddenly tearing up over his deep concern about workers conditions and the cost of their health care, you should tighten your grip on your wallet. But when billionaires have mobilized against you, you better fear for your future and your nation.

The truth is America is flooded with cash. In fact it's possibly the greatest time ever to be rich in America. The sad fact is that none of that money is in your bank account - but do not doubt for an instant that its out there, by the truckload.

Remember that in Wisconsin, cuts to the unions were suggested because Walker had blown the budget with tax cuts for the wealthy. And Walker's aim, wrote Paul Krugman recently, is to make Wisconsin and eventually America less of a functioning democracy and more of a third-world-style oligarchy. He isn’t interested in making a deal with the unions,  he wants to end workers’ ability to bargain.

Take away the voice of the people through their unions and you can dominate them more effectively. Manipulating a crisis is just a time honored and handy way to achieve your ends with the minimum effort.

 



27 Comments

See all comments

Please if you are a reporter, stop with your bashing of Republicans....PLEASE
hollowbuttcow..get a life, on another planet.
2bornot2be, people might take you seriously if you didn't feel the need to express yourself with the rhetorical flourishes of a third grader. You want to sound caustic but you actually sound like a heel.
By the by, the Wisconsin budget was balanced until Walker got in and declared a massive tax cut for the super rich. Probably a kickback to Koch or the Fitzgeralds (they are the leaders of the house and senate in wisconsin).
The vicious attack on unions and collective bargaining by Republicans in a number of states could have been predicted. They have been waiting to blame America's woes on the Unions. As if Unions had anything to do with the Bank/wall street thefts! I just want to know who is going to be willing to spend $100000 to get a masters in education and then be paid peanuts???
1st- my district does NOT buy their insurance through WEA Trust-not all Wisconsin districts do. 2nd- Yes, many teachers are retiring to maximize their benefits(you would, too), but many districts are not going to fill the vacancies. The teacher's job will just be absorbed (larger class sizes, less teacher prep time, less classes for students to choose, teachers with less expertise and experience...) I know,but who cares about that-- it's all about our benefits. We don't deserve them, right? Everyone knows teachers went into the profession because they're greedy. When I was in college I thought which profession would make me rich? hmmmm teaching... How would you like to work for a company for 25 -30 years and lose your senority? IF you're doing an excellent job, why should you have to look over your shoulder and worry about school board member's niece that just graduated with a teaching degree. If you say this won't happen, you're naive. I wouldn't encourage my child to go into education. Would you? There are too many unknowns... @ McNabb, you're right, the budget cuts will not go into effect until July - just in time for the next school year. I may be off base, but I'm going to guess if you have children they are either out of school or in private school. I suggest you attend a local school board meeting and listen to what is happening in your district OR better yet, sub in a classroom for a week. Well, I have to go and write a college recommendation letter for one of my students. Ive written eleven this year. I know, I know-- it's high time I earn my massive salary and pay off my graduate degree.
@allentown...That's exactly right. And, of course, the reason they're opting for early retirement is because they want to maximize their very generous benefits package. But there are plenty of job-seekers ready to take their places.
Over 14,000 public employees putting in for early retirement. I read that as 14,000 public employee job openings in Wisconsin.
With so many distortions and idiotic non sequiturs in one article it's difficult to know where to start spraying the disinfectant of truth. But let's start with this bit of reality in Wisconsin: According to the non-partisan Legislative Fiscal Bureau, if the budget that ends on June 30, 2011 had been strictly adhered to then there would be $121 million in the bank. However, thanks to the Democrats who were in control until a couple of months ago, the state is facing $258 million in unpaid bills or expected shortfalls in programs such as Medicaid services for the needy ($174 million alone), the public defender’s office and corrections. Additionally, the state owes Minnesota $58.7 million under a discontinued tax reciprocity deal. When you do the math you realize that Governor Walker is correct that the state will wind up in the hole by $137 million. As PolitiFact pointed out (when it debunked the myth of Wisconsin’s “budget surplus” as touted by Lefty shills such as Rachel Maddow) the shortfall would be closer to the $340 million figure if the amount included the $200 million owed to the state’s patient compensation fund, a debt courts have declared resulted from an illegal raid on the fund under former Gov. Jim Doyle, a Democrat. A court ruling is pending in that matter, so the money might not have to be transferred until next budget year. As for the much-maligned Walker tax cuts and how they affected Wisconsin’s budget problems the simple answer is that the tax cuts have nothing to do with the current crisis. They don’t even go into effect until the NEXT budget cycle, which begins on July 1. Walker is not responsible for the budget shortfall but he IS faced with the challenge of cleaning up a mess created and left behind by Democrats, who are routinely in the pockets of Big Labor.
Wait a minute: Property Taxes pay for teachers. In America, your house and land our taxed to pay for very high teacher's salaries, pensions, and healthcare. The Teachers Unions force the School Boards to buy Healthcare from the Union's healthcare insurance company at a high cost. The pensions are very expensive for the homeower's of Wisconsin. The Unions have a problem. There are more tax payers then union members, so the unions will lose at the polls. I hope Walker is Irish. Walker is one of those names that can be Irish or English. Regardless, I proud he's an American like me.
I'm a Wisconsin teacher with a Master's degree. I am also a Wisconsin tax payer. Think of a teachers' salary and benefits as 5 fingers- we negotiated to have 2 fingers: salary, 2 fingers: health insurance, 1 finger: pension. We choose to make a smaller pay check because we have a good benefits. It is true we don't work summers, but we're not paid through the summer either. We also do not collect unemployment. Many teachers teach summer school or work a summer job to make ends meet. Our bills don't stop just because our job does... . We knew this going into the career. In any given year, the turnover rate of teachers is 15% - 25%. 85% of these teachers are not retiring; they are leaving for more attractive careers. Both Obama and U.S. Education Secretary Arne Duncan speaks of "elevating the teaching profession" and attracting high quality individuals to the profession...but then they remain quiet while Walker disrespects and demoralizes us. We've become Wisconsin's #1 villian! Everyone has their opinion. One district in WI reduced everyone's salary to a starting teacher's salary...$34,000 a year. Imagine working 25 years for a company and being reduced to a beginners' salary. Districts need to make up for Walker's reduction of state aid to schools - $900,000,000. That's right, 900 million! We didn't start the fire......... I hope I have a job next fall, but like most teacher's in the state... who knows?
Walker and all those other Republican Governors, together with the likes of John Boehner and Mitch McConnell, are trying desperately to establish a type of dictatorship. I hope that the citizens of the United States wise up pretty quick and put a stop to all the Republican nonsense.
Right on target! You should also check out what is happening in Michigan. Much less publicity but perhaps even more sinister than Wisconsin.
The sight of the Kock brothers telling working people of Wisconsin they need to tighten their belts is what's hard to take.
It amazed me how many working class people decided that it was a good idea to let billionaires dismantle their own collective bargaining rights. That's turkeys voting for Thanksgiving.




Log into IrishCentral with your Facebook account


or sign-in directly

E-Mail:
Password:
 Remember me Forgot my password
Not a member? Register Now!
print this article Print
email this articleE-mail