Manhattan Diary


First Wisconsin, then America

Posted on Friday, March 25, 2011 at 09:23 AM

RSS


Recent Posts

Archives

submit to reddit

When you give away tax cuts to the rich someone else has to pay.

That's why in Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker, with behind the scenes help from the billionaire Koch brothers, recently managed to gut the collective bargaining rights of the states public employees. The state couldn't afford them, he pleaded.

If balancing the budget means eroding the quality of public services that make local communities functional and attractive, so be it.  What Walker didn't anticipate was the consequences.

Here's how the Wall Street Journal put it: “In Wisconsin, where lawmakers voted in mid-March to end workers' collective bargaining for future employment contracts, 3,362 people have applied to retire this year, a 73% jump from last year. And 10,975 people since the beginning of the year have taken the first step toward retirement—flooding the Wisconsin Department of Employee Trust Funds with requests for estimates of their potential benefits. That's up 134%.”

Teachers are demoralized, fearful and they want out. They realized they were just collateral damage in a larger power grab.

Let's remember America's teachers didn't cause the economic melt down and recession we've just lived through. Wall Street did. The rich called for the free wheeling deregulation that eventually led to the crash.

So where is the public anger at the record breaking bonuses Wall Street titans are awarding themselves after almost destroying the nation they held to ransom? Why pick on teachers when they're such insignificant players in comparison?

America is not broke. Scott Walker isn't broke. The Koch brothers most certainly are not broke and neither is Wisconsin's quite substantial moneyed class.

Instead, as has become increasingly clear, what Walker really hoped to break was the public employee unions, a major source of funding and volunteers for Democratic candidates.

How do we know this? In Walker's recent 20-minute phone call with a man he believed was David Koch, he openly agreed that Wisconsin would be the first domino in a much wider campaign among current Republican governors to neutralize public employee unions.

Walker's strategy is simple as it is time honored: divide and conquer. Walker pitted worker against worker, all the better to lose sight of who was really pulling the strings.

Here's an example of a Walker stump speech: "Every factory worker I talked to this last week, who is paying 25 to 50 percent for their health care premium, who doesn't have a pension, who has to pay into a 401(k) and in some cases had that suspended, every one of them looks at this and says, 'You know what? Not only do I not get that, I have to pay for it.' That guy has to pay the difference. He has to foot the bill for everyone else."

When a Republican in a Brooks Brothers blazer and gold cufflinks is suddenly tearing up over his deep concern about workers conditions and the cost of their health care, you should tighten your grip on your wallet. But when billionaires have mobilized against you, you better fear for your future and your nation.

The truth is America is flooded with cash. In fact it's possibly the greatest time ever to be rich in America. The sad fact is that none of that money is in your bank account - but do not doubt for an instant that its out there, by the truckload.

Remember that in Wisconsin, cuts to the unions were suggested because Walker had blown the budget with tax cuts for the wealthy. And Walker's aim, wrote Paul Krugman recently, is to make Wisconsin and eventually America less of a functioning democracy and more of a third-world-style oligarchy. He isn’t interested in making a deal with the unions,  he wants to end workers’ ability to bargain.

Take away the voice of the people through their unions and you can dominate them more effectively. Manipulating a crisis is just a time honored and handy way to achieve your ends with the minimum effort.

 



27 comments

Previous Page 2 of 2 pages
I just saw that the AP sued Walker for his emails under the freedom of information act and got the emails that he said supported him and his illegal union busting bill in the vast majority. The AP released the real numbers - 5 to 1 against him and his bill. Now either he is not a product of public schools and is therefore math challenged or, like some office seekers before him, was not taught about lying by his parents. Over a decade and a half ago there was a saying about republicans that I believe is appropriately applied to many (not all) of the newly elected republicans that pretended to be interested in finding jobs for Americans and are, instead, privatizing everything that we, the public, own, wiping out jobs, lowering salaries and giving tax breaks to the obscenely rich and corporations that are sitting on vast profits. It went: "How can you tell if they are lying? Their lips are moving." In Ohio 40% of the OEA affiliated teachers were fooled and voted republican. You can bet they will not make that mistake again. Many other union people have been solid republicans in the past and now see that the party has stabbed them in the back as the republicans bow to their real masters. Vote your wallet!
It's clearly 'them' versus 'us'. The 'them' for Walker don't look or act at all like him and the rest of his 'us'. It remains a Calvinistic approach to social structure. God meant some to be wealthy, wise and wonderful, while others were not deemed so. Get used to it, and be happy with the crumbs we choose to brush off our polished tables.
To all of the Copperheads who have been ragging on the liberal, Christian belief in social justice, inform yourselves of the Church's teaching, from Rerum Novarum (1891) to Caritas in Veritate (2009), and then look up "cognitive dissonance"---Please.
Truth spoken...only to be ignored and derided by those who've chosen to drink the Tea Party's Kool-aid and love all things GOP, no matter how bad it is for them. It would be sad if they weren't so close to destroying everything America stands for.
In 1947, with 31.4 members per 100 workers, US union membership reached its pinnacle just before the Taft-Hartley Act became law. By 1975, the number was 26.4, and in 2000 just 14.1, and the decline continues. The unions have been pillars not only of the Democratic Party, but also of democracy itself. By the late '90s, women comprised 40% of union membership, as we shifted from industrial-worker base to the public sector and service workers. Most workers have gotten a free ride on the achievements of unions, as unions battled for sustained employment through recessions, for safe working conditions, against child labor, against employers' discrimination, for an 8-hour, 5-day work week, and for higher wages and health and pension benefits. These successes have benefited all workers and families, not only those who pay dues. Unions were once among the most important educational institutions, teaching skills and English to immigrants, improving literacy and civics, and helping newcomers to assimilate. Without state support, it is unlikely that this remnant of the American Labor Movement--one of our great democratic movements--can long survive. As Gerald Friedman writes in "Labor Unions in the US" (EH net), "[W]hen American employers broke unions, they revived when a government committed to workplace democracy sheltered them from employer repression. If we see another such government, we may yet see another union revival." Soon, I hope.
Mr. O'Doherty nails it! The Republicans are out to kill what's left of the middle class. I've worked union and non-union and only union jobs made it possible for me to retire with a pension and health care. The companies forgot about me as soon as the job was finished. For all they care, I can live on cat food. Some care about people, others only about profits. I know whose side I'm on.
The unions don't speak for me. The higher ups get more than what is needed. The greed that permeates this country from the top down is the cause of a lot of this nation's distress. But whether the Dems liked what Wisconsin did is beyond the point, they ran like chickens and were not willing to stay and fight. In effect broke the law.
Of those unqualified borrowers" More than 1 in 7 homeowners with loans in "excess of a million dollars" are seriously delinquent or "just walking" away from their loans. I don't think "most millionaires" make their loans with Freddie or Fannie as some would like you to believe. In 2004 the Bush administration after being lobbied by Goldman allowed the banks to increase their debt from 12 to 1, to 40 to 1 and the banks then made many loans that they would never have approved during the regulations of the lower debt ratios feeding the collapse which then destroyed middle class housing markets, college funds and 401's. The effects of those losses are "now" drastically impacting state and town budgets. The GOP wants you to believe these deficits should be closed up again on the "backs" of the middle class. When are we going to wake up and see the facts as they truly are.
Its the intention of Gov. Walker and Radical Republicans like him to destroy unions, simply because the unions are an essential pillar of the Democratic Party. Rather than attack unions, we should all be checking the influence of the socially regressive Koch Brothers; two very wealthy men that possess an extreme and unhealthy distrust of the Federal Government, and who are willing to use their vast wealth to subvert democracy. (And thanks to the Roberts Court they can now do this with greater ease.) I can only hope that Gov. Walker, this pathetic shill for the rich, is soon recalled by the people of Wisconsin, and sent packing. Perhaps he could drive David Koch's car, or answer his mail.
Thanks for spelling it out for those who can accept what is actually happening. JGH apparently has the money to spurn the collective bargaining interests of the gov't employees. I have worked at almost every level of gov't and can assure you, they need the strength of numbers vs. big money. Some benefits were too liberal in the 80's especially with health benefits. Then the health insurance industry made it's moves for higher profits which forced gov't to take a look to better health management. But the insurance industry did not have that motivation---it was just greed. As for pensions, all should contribute, but how does one ensure that those with the power aren't investing them in higher risk entities because some Wall Streeter told them to do it! How did those pension funds lose so much money in the crash?!!! Shame on the rich guys getting greedier! Just how much is enough money to meet their needs? Or is just the gamesmanship? STOP THE KOCH BROTHERS (and thank your Supreme Court Justices!)
This article is nothing but left wing BS. TO JOHN G HOGAN-you are right on. Go Wisconsin-other states take a look and consider it a lesson in economics-so many dollars in and only the same number can be spent-taxing the rich is not the only answer.
Blame???........start with Carter, Clinton, Dodd, Frank, Freddie Mac, Fannie Mae, etc........how can a person buy a house if that person can't afford to pay for it. Just because you string a lot of words together, doesn't make the sentences true.
Previous Page 2 of 2 pages




Log into IrishCentral with your Facebook account


or sign-in directly

E-Mail:
Password:
 Remember me Forgot my password
Not a member? Register Now!
print this article Print
email this articleE-mail