Conservative Christians creating next generation of atheists and agnostics
Posted on Saturday, June 30, 2012 at 10:00 AM
RSS 
Recent Posts
- Daily Mail unloads on 'drunken young' Paddys with booze-baiting rant - British tabloid continues its anti Irish attitude
- Marco Rubio: 'If immigration bill gives Cubans immigration rights, it kills the bill. I'm done' - VIDEO
- Diaspora should work both ways - time for global Irish to vote
- Ireland needs a new James Joyce - new voice of the Irish people is on the way
- Fox News Lou Dobbs panel: selfish working mothers are destroying the natural order and America
Archives
Ask yourself, what have been the most signature events in worldwide religious faith in the last two decades?
It’s a simple enough question and the answer is mostly horrifying.
It’s planes flying into skyscrapers, it’s child molestation, it’s woman being stoned and murdered, it’s gays being bashed in the pulpits and on the streets, it’s women who use birth control being called sluts on the national airwaves, it's clergy secretly practicing what they publicly condemn, it’s Koran burnings, it’s hardworking nuns being persecuted by their out of touch superiors, it’s funerals being protested with placards and abuse, and on and on – so are you surprised that more and more young people don’t want to touch religion with a barge pole?
Ask yourself, is there anywhere on earth right now where religious faith is actually brightening the lives of millions as it builds for a peaceful tomorrow?
Or is it more accurately depicted like this: in daily portraits of Christians who are bracingly righteous in their own beliefs and intolerant of all others; in Muslims who oppress women and each other with their intolerant and restrictive religious codes; in Jews who oppress their Arab neighbors. Just turn on your television and these are the images of religious faith in action that the world sees.
So it’s not a trickle, this march of disillusioned and alienated young people leaving the church, it’s a flood, because the truth is they’re leaving in droves. Religion equals intolerance now, thanks to decades of undeniably supporting evidence. Research conducted by the pro-Christian Barna Group in 2007 on Americans age 16-29 found that 'anti-homosexual' was the dominant perception of modern Christians. Decades of God being used as a battering ram to bash gays have appalled them.
The biggest mistake that conservative church leaders are making here in the US is to double down increasingly on the positions that have already turned young people off. In recent years Tea Party politics have become so intertwined with conservative Christian faith here that they have become indistinguishable. Religious leaders have allowed and encouraged this, in fact.
The hardening of ideological attitudes on the right can also be explained by the pervasive influence of religion on conservative politics. Christian conservatives on the right have been increasingly blatant about their desire for religion to shape public policy – you need only look to candidates like Rick Santorum or political action committees like National Organization for Marriage or Focus on the Family to see that’s true. We’re at the point now that the Republican Party could be renamed the Christian Brotherhood without much difficulty.
But while the older generation of Christian conservatives have been flexing their political muscles they appear to have missed the fact that instead of crafting an enduring victory they’re actually shooting themselves in the foot.
Among America’s young, the rise of ‘none of the above’ on religious surveys has increased in recent years from traditional numbers like 5–10% to new numbers like 25–30%. That’s astronomical. That’s what you get for seeing the speck in other people’s eyes whilst you ignore the beam in your own.
4000 years ago God could flood the world from pole to pole and start all over again; He could level cities and part seas. But for the internet generation growing up now He's mostly seen by kooks in their toasted cheese sandwiches.
If conservative Christians want to remind us why He was celebrated in the first place they'll have to start by reminding themselves: will it be Fox News or Good News?
It’s a simple enough question and the answer is mostly horrifying.
It’s planes flying into skyscrapers, it’s child molestation, it’s woman being stoned and murdered, it’s gays being bashed in the pulpits and on the streets, it’s women who use birth control being called sluts on the national airwaves, it's clergy secretly practicing what they publicly condemn, it’s Koran burnings, it’s hardworking nuns being persecuted by their out of touch superiors, it’s funerals being protested with placards and abuse, and on and on – so are you surprised that more and more young people don’t want to touch religion with a barge pole?
Ask yourself, is there anywhere on earth right now where religious faith is actually brightening the lives of millions as it builds for a peaceful tomorrow?
Or is it more accurately depicted like this: in daily portraits of Christians who are bracingly righteous in their own beliefs and intolerant of all others; in Muslims who oppress women and each other with their intolerant and restrictive religious codes; in Jews who oppress their Arab neighbors. Just turn on your television and these are the images of religious faith in action that the world sees.
So it’s not a trickle, this march of disillusioned and alienated young people leaving the church, it’s a flood, because the truth is they’re leaving in droves. Religion equals intolerance now, thanks to decades of undeniably supporting evidence. Research conducted by the pro-Christian Barna Group in 2007 on Americans age 16-29 found that 'anti-homosexual' was the dominant perception of modern Christians. Decades of God being used as a battering ram to bash gays have appalled them.
The biggest mistake that conservative church leaders are making here in the US is to double down increasingly on the positions that have already turned young people off. In recent years Tea Party politics have become so intertwined with conservative Christian faith here that they have become indistinguishable. Religious leaders have allowed and encouraged this, in fact.
The hardening of ideological attitudes on the right can also be explained by the pervasive influence of religion on conservative politics. Christian conservatives on the right have been increasingly blatant about their desire for religion to shape public policy – you need only look to candidates like Rick Santorum or political action committees like National Organization for Marriage or Focus on the Family to see that’s true. We’re at the point now that the Republican Party could be renamed the Christian Brotherhood without much difficulty.
But while the older generation of Christian conservatives have been flexing their political muscles they appear to have missed the fact that instead of crafting an enduring victory they’re actually shooting themselves in the foot.
Among America’s young, the rise of ‘none of the above’ on religious surveys has increased in recent years from traditional numbers like 5–10% to new numbers like 25–30%. That’s astronomical. That’s what you get for seeing the speck in other people’s eyes whilst you ignore the beam in your own.
4000 years ago God could flood the world from pole to pole and start all over again; He could level cities and part seas. But for the internet generation growing up now He's mostly seen by kooks in their toasted cheese sandwiches.
If conservative Christians want to remind us why He was celebrated in the first place they'll have to start by reminding themselves: will it be Fox News or Good News?
45 comments
CitizenWhy | Jul 01, 2012, 01:08 PM EDT
Now, now, Cahir, don't you realize that contempt, arrogance, sarcasm, unkindness and vitriol are gifts of the Holy Spirit? Just ask any "good" Chistianist out there. They know.
Report abuse
CitizenWhy | Jul 01, 2012, 12:59 PM EDT
Indeed Christianism and Christianists have made Christianity quite rejectable. Not only are people leaving the churches but once out for a bit the churches are not missed one bit. In the past people returned to the church when the siiue of how to raise children arose. But now more and more are finding moral, ethical, kind (how unChristian) ways to raise children without handing them over to cranky clergy and their even crankier superiors.
Report abuse
McNamara31 | Jul 01, 2012, 11:27 AM EDT
Jefferson was passionate about a "wall of separation between church and state" for the very reason that the founders had seen firsthand what the marriage of church and state did to oppress many in Europe. Karl Rove is the GOP operative who has married these again in the states primarily to get GWB into office and look what that got us. After leaving office both of the Bush women stated their beliefs were not in line with the evangelicals they wooed for the vote and was just another political farce.
Report abuse
oldboreen | Jul 01, 2012, 10:04 AM EDT
Just another anti-religion rant I thought-at first glance. But as a Catholic, I have to say there's a lot of truth in the article.'By their lights ye shall know them'!These so-called'Conservatives' have a lot to answer for. How about a little more charity and a great deal less condemnation? All that wasted energy spent on telling everyone else where they are in error, whilst there is so much real ministery they could be involved in! Less cant please-more action in the streets!
Report abuse
oldboreen | Jul 01, 2012, 01:45 AM EDT
let me get this straight, Conservative Christians, meaning those who hold to the immutable teachings of Christ as handed down via his Apostles, Church and Sacred scriptures, are somehow creating the next generation of Atheists/agnostics???
Now this wouldn't have anything to do with a decadent, debased culture that embraces hedonism and moral relativism whereby sinful life choices i.e. active homosexuality, abortion, adultery, drunkenness(which scripture says: will not see the gates of heaven)are now justified as "normal" and "conscience" choices?
Report abuse
bushmanirish | Jun 30, 2012, 11:44 PM EDT
Mr. O'Doherty, you've expressed what many have sensed for some time. Personally, I was trained as a Protestant theologian, then converted to Catholicism and now, well, I'm cautious. The Christian and Muslim extremists you cite are just that; they are not the humble folks who really do exist out there in large numbers and honestly try to please their "God". You have seen, and probably intuited, the firestorm that would result from your article. So I leave you with a lesson I learned in Central America after grabbing hold of a bush overflowing with fire ants. There are black ants; they're the nice ants. There are red ants who can hurt you a lot. Then there are fire ants who bite with such ferocity and pain it transcends any earthly scale. You, sir, have just stepped into a pile of fire ants. How I admire your courage but encourage you to take care with fire ants. Your courage means nothing to them.
Report abuse
MarkLFromGA | Jun 30, 2012, 11:21 PM EDT
What is so difficult to understand? Young people are leaving religion behind because of the atmosphere of intolerance, yet we have, here on this comment thread, people demonstrating the exact reason WHY youth are fleeing religion.
Personally, I don't give a single rip what these people think about "liberalism" - to them, it's just a generic blanket term used to describe those they don't like personally (Don't toy with me on this, I've got enough psychological background from my college days to know the routine), a term used in the same manner as a racial slur is used by a Klansman. Nor do I really care, at this point, how hurt or indignant the right gets at comments that take them to task for their behavior; they've gone full guns after the left for decades, even think that "declarations of open hunting season on liberals" is funny. But turn the guns of criticism around at them, they squawk like little children who just got the wedgie of the century by the big kid on the playground.
You, the fundamentalists of the world, are the reason for the downfall of religion on the world stage. Live with that.
Report abuse
MarkLFromGA | Jun 30, 2012, 11:14 PM EDT
"I don't need to see this leftist propaganda unbalanced views of the author, or by dam wise-ass Anti-American, Anti-Protestant foreigners, or even my own countrymen. There are more problems here with the author than with those he is slandering. It is apparent that he has not concept of what is or isn't "teleological ethics" in either Judaism or Christianity".
Then what, pray tell, are you doing here? Do you not understand the storyline, or are you just demonstrating to those of us here exactly why the youth of the world are avoiding Christendom like the bubonic plague?
Report abuse
hollabackgurl | Jun 30, 2012, 10:19 PM EDT
Even the Pope has hired Fox News anchors to do the Vatican's reporting now. It's beyond a joke how embedded religion/politics/conservative Christians are, it's worrying now.
Report abuse
timbobdennehy | Jun 30, 2012, 10:02 PM EDT
lets see boobs at the altar.seriously,women are more faithful to god and yet are only seen as servile helpers for the priest.bring equality to the cloth.
Report abuse
seanomelb | Jun 30, 2012, 07:00 PM EDT
Unfortunately Nicoletta cannot rise above her bigotry, Cahir's big picture is to broad for her to comprehend his central point. Borefield is just the type Cahir is referring to a teaparty bigot.
Report abuse
ProudCanadian | Jun 30, 2012, 06:53 PM EDT
What an incredible article, thank you Cahir, your insight is fantastic. The only thing that I may differ with is that it is not religion but the fanatasim of man that creates these attrocities. People just can't seem to live with open minds they have to follow. It is the same in politics, the politicans are so bad the kids nowadays have very little to choose from. I myself vote because it is my duty and I vote for the party/person who I think will take me down the road the slowest because they all will. I just ask the young people to give God a chance no matter what he/she is called but go in with an open mind and don't be swayed by anyone. Thanks again Cahir and Irish Centrel for this article.
Report abuse
hollabackgurl | Jun 30, 2012, 05:06 PM EDT
You're right, BrianO. Love will always defeat all those who try to dismiss it.
Report abuse
BrianO | Jun 30, 2012, 03:04 PM EDT
Hollabackgurl, In order to lose one must give up.
Report abuse
45 Comments

Report abuse