Bullying is violence, it should be considered a crime
Posted on Monday, October 03, 2011 at 09:56 AM
RSS 
Recent Posts
- Daily Mail unloads on 'drunken young' Paddys with booze-baiting rant - British tabloid continues its anti Irish attitude
- Marco Rubio: 'If immigration bill gives Cubans immigration rights, it kills the bill. I'm done' - VIDEO
- Diaspora should work both ways - time for global Irish to vote
- Ireland needs a new James Joyce - new voice of the Irish people is on the way
- Fox News Lou Dobbs panel: selfish working mothers are destroying the natural order and America
Archives
What if - at an age when you were least equipped to deal with it - you were handed the biggest challenge of your life? What if it was life-changing, something that would define you, but that you could speak to no one about?
And what if, as you watched your friends run out to dances and teenage parties, you realized that you would never find anything you were looking for there? What if you watched the doors to love and life opening for your friends, but all you saw were doors being slammed shut?
Then things get weirder. Suddenly you became a stranger in your own home. Your parents, once the source of all comfort to you, became potential jurors. Your siblings started to give evidence against you. You start to dread coming home.
The majority of your friends, sensing trouble, became distant or they abandon you entirely. Your religious leaders condemn people like you, your teachers openly mock people like you, your society writes laws to oppress people you, even the kids on the street knew your name is mud.
----------------------
READ MORE:
Bullying concerns: 11-year-old disabled child commits suicide after assault
Bully writes ‘accomplished’ on Phoebe Prince’s Facebook page on day of death
Irish government denies rift with Vatican over Cloyne Report
----------------------
And all this before you turned 15? Would you think you had it rough?
If your child is gay and he or she has navigated their teenage years successfully and in one piece then they should be your inspiration for the rest of their lives. You'll never know all the anxiety and abuse they went through, often all day every day, just so they could grow up and be themselves.
And if you don't know how terrifyingly bad it can get, and just how unfair the fight is, it's because you may never have had to grapple with the issue yourself. Isn't that why anti-gay bullying is still tolerated in America's schools, after all? Because it happens to other people's kids?
If your own kid dodged that particular bullet and the abuse that goes with it, you'll probably be relieved and more likely to look the other way. Life's already tough enough, God knows. I mean, how else to explain most parent's tacit acceptance of complete injustice as it stands?
The truth is many parents would rather tolerate or overlook the bulling - and the social cues that drive them to it - than embrace the gay kids for who they are.
Bullying a gay kid is supremely easy because the scales are so tilted: gay kids already have their hands tied, there's a centuries-long history of intolerance directed against them, churches preach against them, politicians speak out against them, many well funded national organizations exist solely to deny them their dignity and personhood, the internet can be a tool of unimaginable hate directed at them, and federal laws and state laws discriminate against them from sea to shining sea. If it was a sport you couldn't watch it.
It's an unfair fight in other words, and unfair fights are what bullies live for. That's why it's an epidemic in America's schools.
If gay kids are being targeted by their peers in the United States in record numbers it's because those kids have already seen them openly targeted and baited by every major political, legal, religious and social organization in the nation. They have usually heard gay people condemned in their own homes too.
And recently they have watched candidates for president stand silent when a gay solider is openly booed on a public stage. You can't imagine the damage that does to a gay child. That recognition even startled the president this week, because on Saturday Obama admitted that if your Commander In Chief doesn't have your back, no one will.
Once your neighbors puts a scarlet letter on someone's back and you say nothing, you really can't claim to have clean hands when the consequences arrive.
Nor should you be terrifically surprised to discover your own kids might have had a hand in driving vulnerable gay kids to suicide. Not taking action is a form of action, after all.
If friends, family and schools are not supportive of gay teens - and lets face it the majority are still openly hostile - it is remarkably difficult for a gay teen to thrive or do well. That fact, and often daily verbal and physical harassment, the perpetual hostile atmosphere, can lead gay teens to despair.
Studies have shown that gay kids are no more mentally unstable than other students, but they are much more susceptible to victimization by their peers. 93 percent of Americas teens reported witnessing anti-gay bullying last year. That's a shocking statistic that has no equal nationally.
Recently the suicide of 14 year old Jamey Rodemeyer caught the headlines. The slight and softly spoken teen had been bullied daily for years for being gay. Kids to to Facebook to july him writing: 'JAMIE IS STUPID, GAY, FAT ANND UGLY. HE MUST DIE!' Another read, 'I wouldn’t care if you died. No one would. So just do it. It would make everyone WAY more happier!'
When Jamey's 16-year-old sister, at the suggestion of her parents, attended a school dance just hours after she attended Jamey's wake on September 22 some students started chanting that Jamey was 'better off dead.'
Jamey was better off dead. We're glad he's dead. Jamey didn't deserve to live, they chanted.
He was just 14. His life hadn't even started. He probably hadn't even had his first kiss.
Almost every gay person alive has heard people shout the same evil things at them: sometimes in veiled religious language, other times the hatred is unvarnished, but the message is always the same: you don't deserve to live.
Isn't that what the resistance to gay equality is ultimately all about?
We have to end this. The cruel students who bullied Jamey, abusing him physically and mentally, should be criminally charged. Although Jamey put up a strong front, it is quite clear how deeply those bullies hurt him.
And who do these kids think they are? Who raised them? What law or bible verse could justify their hatred? And after they drove a child to despair, to then exult and celebrate his passing? Is this how we're raising our children? Is this who we want them to become?
Bullying is violence, violence done to both body and soul. Many bullies grow out of it but too many of their victims don't. We need to grasp that message and act upon it. It should be prosecuted like any other form of violence to an individual.
And what if, as you watched your friends run out to dances and teenage parties, you realized that you would never find anything you were looking for there? What if you watched the doors to love and life opening for your friends, but all you saw were doors being slammed shut?
Then things get weirder. Suddenly you became a stranger in your own home. Your parents, once the source of all comfort to you, became potential jurors. Your siblings started to give evidence against you. You start to dread coming home.
The majority of your friends, sensing trouble, became distant or they abandon you entirely. Your religious leaders condemn people like you, your teachers openly mock people like you, your society writes laws to oppress people you, even the kids on the street knew your name is mud.
----------------------
READ MORE:
Bullying concerns: 11-year-old disabled child commits suicide after assault
Bully writes ‘accomplished’ on Phoebe Prince’s Facebook page on day of death
Irish government denies rift with Vatican over Cloyne Report
----------------------
And all this before you turned 15? Would you think you had it rough?
If your child is gay and he or she has navigated their teenage years successfully and in one piece then they should be your inspiration for the rest of their lives. You'll never know all the anxiety and abuse they went through, often all day every day, just so they could grow up and be themselves.
And if you don't know how terrifyingly bad it can get, and just how unfair the fight is, it's because you may never have had to grapple with the issue yourself. Isn't that why anti-gay bullying is still tolerated in America's schools, after all? Because it happens to other people's kids?
If your own kid dodged that particular bullet and the abuse that goes with it, you'll probably be relieved and more likely to look the other way. Life's already tough enough, God knows. I mean, how else to explain most parent's tacit acceptance of complete injustice as it stands?
The truth is many parents would rather tolerate or overlook the bulling - and the social cues that drive them to it - than embrace the gay kids for who they are.
Bullying a gay kid is supremely easy because the scales are so tilted: gay kids already have their hands tied, there's a centuries-long history of intolerance directed against them, churches preach against them, politicians speak out against them, many well funded national organizations exist solely to deny them their dignity and personhood, the internet can be a tool of unimaginable hate directed at them, and federal laws and state laws discriminate against them from sea to shining sea. If it was a sport you couldn't watch it.
It's an unfair fight in other words, and unfair fights are what bullies live for. That's why it's an epidemic in America's schools.
If gay kids are being targeted by their peers in the United States in record numbers it's because those kids have already seen them openly targeted and baited by every major political, legal, religious and social organization in the nation. They have usually heard gay people condemned in their own homes too.
And recently they have watched candidates for president stand silent when a gay solider is openly booed on a public stage. You can't imagine the damage that does to a gay child. That recognition even startled the president this week, because on Saturday Obama admitted that if your Commander In Chief doesn't have your back, no one will.
Once your neighbors puts a scarlet letter on someone's back and you say nothing, you really can't claim to have clean hands when the consequences arrive.
Nor should you be terrifically surprised to discover your own kids might have had a hand in driving vulnerable gay kids to suicide. Not taking action is a form of action, after all.
If friends, family and schools are not supportive of gay teens - and lets face it the majority are still openly hostile - it is remarkably difficult for a gay teen to thrive or do well. That fact, and often daily verbal and physical harassment, the perpetual hostile atmosphere, can lead gay teens to despair.
Studies have shown that gay kids are no more mentally unstable than other students, but they are much more susceptible to victimization by their peers. 93 percent of Americas teens reported witnessing anti-gay bullying last year. That's a shocking statistic that has no equal nationally.
Recently the suicide of 14 year old Jamey Rodemeyer caught the headlines. The slight and softly spoken teen had been bullied daily for years for being gay. Kids to to Facebook to july him writing: 'JAMIE IS STUPID, GAY, FAT ANND UGLY. HE MUST DIE!' Another read, 'I wouldn’t care if you died. No one would. So just do it. It would make everyone WAY more happier!'
When Jamey's 16-year-old sister, at the suggestion of her parents, attended a school dance just hours after she attended Jamey's wake on September 22 some students started chanting that Jamey was 'better off dead.'
Jamey was better off dead. We're glad he's dead. Jamey didn't deserve to live, they chanted.
He was just 14. His life hadn't even started. He probably hadn't even had his first kiss.
Almost every gay person alive has heard people shout the same evil things at them: sometimes in veiled religious language, other times the hatred is unvarnished, but the message is always the same: you don't deserve to live.
Isn't that what the resistance to gay equality is ultimately all about?
We have to end this. The cruel students who bullied Jamey, abusing him physically and mentally, should be criminally charged. Although Jamey put up a strong front, it is quite clear how deeply those bullies hurt him.
And who do these kids think they are? Who raised them? What law or bible verse could justify their hatred? And after they drove a child to despair, to then exult and celebrate his passing? Is this how we're raising our children? Is this who we want them to become?
Bullying is violence, violence done to both body and soul. Many bullies grow out of it but too many of their victims don't. We need to grasp that message and act upon it. It should be prosecuted like any other form of violence to an individual.
14 Comments
See all comments
hollabackgurl | Oct 04, 2011, 05:11 PM EDT
When parents start throwing their children out of the house and refusing to talk to them again for being overweight or ginger say, then I'll accept that they have it as tough as gay kids. I'm not saying it's any less worthy of our attention - it certainly is - I'm just saying (and I'll argue this with anyone) that gay kids get it worst.
Report abuse
phinsman | Oct 04, 2011, 04:15 PM EDT
I completely agree that bullying should be a crime. Children should learn from a young age that bullying is never appropriate. I was so fortunate to go to a very liberal Catholic school where our teachers taught us to not judge others based on gender, race, ethnicity, sexual preference, socioeconomic status or level of education. They taught us well... and I have never judged others based on these characteristics.
Report abuse
jamieLM | Oct 04, 2011, 10:35 AM EDT
@eiriamach - good post. I do see your point, hollabackgurl, but plenty of straight kids have killed themselves in spite of all the family, societal, and institutional support because bullies made their lives just too intolerable to live. One child lost, gay or straight, is one too many. Btw: Are you kidding? There's huge pressure for kids to have the right body image in order to fit in, especially in h.s. I don't see the need to debate who is more miserable from bullying, gay or straight kids, when it too often ends up in suicide for both. I don't have to keep score, to know the sexual preference of a kid, and to see how high he/she rates on the Suffering Scale to have empathy for anyone being bullied. It's up to adults everywhere to put an end to bullying and protect ALL children from bullies. Zero tolerance for bullying ANYONE for any reason and stiff penalties to those who persist in this despicable behavior is long overdue.
Report abuse
eiriamach | Oct 04, 2011, 05:38 AM EDT
We know why the bullies do it: sadistic individuals get their kicks out of beating up on others, physically, verbally, and on the internet. Their victims realize that they do not wish to live in a world where people continually assault them while others laugh or help the bully or ignore the bully, in the schoolyard or cafeteria, dorms, clubs, offices, neighborhood hangouts, blogs, social network sites. Would any of us choose to live in a world where bullies reign? We can try to toughen kids up so that they can withstand at least the verbal abuse, but there is a limit to what children can put up with, and adults need to recognize it. IF the bystanders do nothing to make it clear to the abusers that they will not tolerate their behavior, the victim has no recourse, no way out of an intolerable situation except suicide. If adults do nothing, then this seems to a youngster the ONLY way out. I can take legal action through police and courts against those who bully me, but a child cannot! Children are completely dependent on protection by responsible adults. If we want to prevent suicides by young victims of bullies, we all need to STOP THE BULLIES-- speak up, confront the bullies publicly when their friends are present, fill out reports for law enforcement, plaster the walls of their schools with their photos and the word "Bully!" in large font, publicly confront their parents and their peer helpers, alert other parents, and make it clear that we will hold teachers and administrators accountable. Get angry about it and let your anger show.
Report abuse
leadwithlove | Oct 03, 2011, 08:38 PM EDT
While it is certainly true that bullying affects many children regardless of their sexual orientation, it is also true that bullying is particularly difficult for gay kids. This occurs in part because of the institutional support for anti-gay bullying like the last person's comment described, but also because when a child is gay, parental rejection is not uncommon. When a child is bullied for some other characteristic, they typically find support at home or among loved ones, but this is not always the case for gay kids. If you have a gay child or know someone who does, you should go to http://www.leadwithlovefilm.com. This is a new film created by a professor at the University of Utah that addresses a lot of these really important issues. There are also other resources on the website that are really useful.
Report abuse
hollabackgurl | Oct 03, 2011, 07:00 PM EDT
The difference between being bullied for being fat, or ginger, or having big ears and being bullied for being gay is that you don't have laws, religions, political parties, conservative interests groups, social programs, and entire communities agitating against you for being fat, or ginger or having big ears - gay kids catch it from all sides. You're determined to see an equivalence because you don't want to permit them their equality, that is all.
Report abuse
hollabackgurl | Oct 03, 2011, 06:56 PM EDT
Blaming bullied kids for their own victimization at the hands of thugs? You're a class act, katiemac - by which I mean, you have no class at all.
Report abuse
jamieLM | Oct 03, 2011, 06:41 PM EDT
I should have said I don't think it's JUST a gay issue. Kids have been viciously bullied by bullies who thought they were too fat, too skinny, too nerdy, not attractive enough, not smart enough, too smart, too poor, wrong clothes, not athletic, too shy, too ethnic, wrong religion, and the list goes on and on. It's not always about being gay. Lots of straight kids, too, have been bullied into killing themselves. Remember the girl from Ireland? I don't think she was gay. She made the "mistake" of being interested in some bully girl's boyfriend. It ended in suicide after she was bullied by a group of h.s. bully girls and their friends. She's just as dead as all the gay kids. There's no excuse for anyone, gay or straight, to be bullied into comitting suicide for whatever reason.
Report abuse
cindyohcindy | Oct 03, 2011, 03:11 PM EDT
an end needs to be put to all bullying..
A bully, is a bully is a bully..
Take the issure to the police and let the police go
to the parents of the bully..
No one, should tolerate bullying for any reason...
Report abuse
simplesandy | Oct 03, 2011, 01:18 PM EDT
I feel we not only have to stop the bullying but should help those being bullied to cope. This won't go away. But sometimes I think when a little scare into these bullied could make them think about the next time they bully. Why hasn’t a movie been made to put some scare tactics in play for the bullies? I remember a kid from my son's school was bullied so bad he came to the bus stop with a loaded gun. He shot it once in the roof of the bus and yelled leave me alone. Could anyone get hurt? Hell yes. But I tell you they wised up about picking on classmates. You see every time the kid that was bullied went to the principal the bullies made it worse on him. They spit on him, pushed him. Picked their noses and wiped it on him. Called him and his family names. Abuse all around. No one should have to go through that. but look what the bullied kid resorted to because he had no one else. I also remember a whole family move from the school district because he was being bullied so bad. And for all those out there saying bullying has been around for centuries makes me sick. The things kids do today is downright mean evil, and abuse.
Report abuse
eiriamach | Oct 03, 2011, 11:52 AM EDT
Bullying is not only a gay issue, but it is a gay issue, and 93% of teens know it. "That's so gay" is a frequent bully's taunt of straight kids as well as gay kids. It spreads homophobia. We must address the connection between religions, in particular, and anti-gay bullying. Extending hate-crime law to juveniles might be the way. A recent study, "Hate Crimes Reported by Victims and Police," found anti-gay violence averaging 191,000 crimes each year since 1992. In 2009 the US bishops (USCCB) expressed concern over a rise in hate crimes against Hispanics, but said nothing about hate crimes against gays. In fact, when they opposed an FCC proposal to regulate hate speech on radio talk shows, they asked the FCC, “would expressions of religious teachings be deemed hate speech? For example, would Roman Catholic teachings on marriage or homosexuality be deemed hate speech by some gay rights advocates?" They know that anti-gay preaching has contributed to an environment in which attacks on gays proliferate. As Enda Kenny would say, the law of the state must protect the young rather than the prerogatives of priests when the two come into conflict.
Report abuse
hollabackgurl | Oct 03, 2011, 11:23 AM EDT
Bullying is a gay issue. You can maintain a climate of hostility and inequality against gay people and not think that will play out in the schools. Besides which, did you read his article before commenting? 93% of US teens reported they heard or saw someone being bullied for being - or being suspected of - gay. He's not saying that antigay bullying is worse, only that it's shockingly prevalent for the actual numbers involved. Every school kid knows the gay kids are targeted the most.
Report abuse
jamieLM | Oct 03, 2011, 10:52 AM EDT
Bullying is bullying. This isn't a "gay" issue. Lots of kids are bullied who are not gay. Gay and straight kids are targeted for bullying because they're seen as weak and vulnerable. Immature, insecure, teen bullies bully others for attention, to make themselves feel better, and to hide their own insecurities. This is a power and control issue for teen bullies who are emotionally unbalanced. Too many of these teen bullies grow up to become loud-mouth, obnoxious, adult bullies who bully their spouses, kids, co-workers, and neighbors - real jerks. There should be zero tolerance for bullying and tough consequences for those who engage in it - from Day One.
Report abuse
14 Comments

Report abuse