Manhattan Diary


America’s super rich have no plan for the middle class

Posted on Wednesday, March 13, 2013 at 09:29 AM

RSS


Recent Posts

Archives

submit to reddit

The nation’s super-rich have decoupled
themselves from the fate of the nation


Something happened the other day that spooked me.  I was caught off guard by a casual comment made in my presence by a fantastically wealthy former senior economic adviser to the Obama administration.

I happen to know that this man (and let’s face it, senior economic advisers still tend to be men) has paintings by Picasso and Cezanne on the walls of his cavernous penthouse overlooking Central Park. You could say he represents one percent of the one percent, the cream of the cream. The very sunlight seems to rearrange itself around him to illustrate that he’s a person of some stature.

Even from a distance he looks like a fabulous emissary from a world of superior tailoring and hairdressing.
Perhaps its because his skin glows courtesy of what I presume are the organically farmed sustainable vegetables his live-in chef prepares for him nightly.  Further study reveals, for a man in his fifties, a notable absence of worry lines.

People like this, and there are many of them, now live in an alternate Harry Potter universe of comfort and ease that we mere mortals can never enter.

They are not bad people, mostly. I have some experience of being in their rarefied orbit and I have learned this much -- their concerns are not as yours or mine.

In fact we might as well be speaking Urdu to them these days. Increasingly we’re just a kind of hive-like background noise they hear in the time it takes to walk from the cab to the club.

I listened as someone asked this man this week if he was at all worried about the growing sense most Americans have that the nation’s super-rich have decoupled themselves from the fate of the nation?

He was worried, he replied. It’s very worrying to think that the majority of people in the nation are starting to think dark thoughts about what the future really holds for them and the rest of the middle class.

That wasn’t the part that spooked me. Asked if he had any suggestions about what to do to stop the one percent from their increasing isolationism, their retreat from the life of the nation, he said this -- no. He had not one idea.

This is one of the senior economic advisers to the Obama administration. He was charged with the task of rescuing America from the sea of economic troubles that surround it. He was stumped.

In fairness to him, he was given a particular job to do involving a targeted industry and he performed his task to the satisfaction of all.  I don’t doubt his competence.

What I do worry about is the strength of his (and other people in his income bracket) commitment to the democratic ideal of equality.

There was a time when our lofty plutocrats saw the point in promoting the general health of the nation as a worthwhile consideration. Now, in the era of the global markets, nation states and their fortunes aren’t nearly the pressing or patriotic concern they once were. Obamacare can take a hike too, they’re telling us.

F. Scott Fitzgerald was right -- the rich are different. The problem is they keep on getting more and more different from the common herd.

When you are living in a country, but no longer of it, you can start looking and acting like the Anglo Irish lords and ladies our ancestors came here to escape. It’s why men like this one can sound so stumped by the problems confronting the people who actually live in it.

The thing about the last decade, the era of George W. Bush, is that economically, politically and often spiritually it felt like a lost one.

If a functioning middle class is the key to a functioning democracy (and it is), by the time of the housing crash it was becoming harder to make the case we still have one, and our gridlocked Congress makes it even harder.

In addition to losing a major share of America’s income in the last decade, the country’s middle class saw most of its wealth wiped out. A volatile stock market (boom times for Wall Street and a major housing bust for the us) have stripped middle-class assets, decreasing their net worth by almost 30 percent and erasing two decades of solid growth, according to a recent Pew Research Center report.

We can’t rely on the highborn doyennes of Washington or the party they bankroll to bail us out of this mess.

These days they have neither a plan or a need to.

Like the Anglo Irish of the 19th century, they’ve retreated to their castles and in every way we’re on our own. It’s time we admit it.

 
See more: Irish Democrats , Irish GOP , Irish in US Politics , Right-wing Irish , US president , Irish Voice


17 comments

Next Page 1 of 2 pages
hmm how's george soros doing these days.
Wonderful article. The rich Cahir described are now called "meglomaniacs," brain disordered people who cannot comprehend anything beyond the end of their noses. Their world revolves totally around themselve and they don't have an ounce of compassion or feeling for those they hurt or kill. I suppose they could also be called psychopaths. In the past they would kill and maim with raised armies but now they have the banksters and Hollywood to help with their plundering. They are now in the process of attempting to take over the world but science has identified their personality types. In the past these monsters have killed their mothers, brothers, sisters, friends and fellow countrymen so they can live idle, depraved lives. However very often they have fortunately breed themselves into nonexistence, being so inbred they were unable to reproduce. With the election of the new Pope, although we are not that religious, we wonder at Christ's prouncement that "The meek shall inherit the earth."
Well said, EphraimK!
Seanmor, it seems to me,a vet who uses the VA,that Republicans hate vets. Maybe because we did what they were afraid to do.Their are some cuts coming down the pike. Some of Obama's efforts for the VA has helped me.
Scott Prouty, a REAL "joe the bartender" working guy, took a camera to a fancy shindig of Romney's so he could preserve the moment and was astonished by Romney's flaunting of his investments in Chinese sweatshops that siphoned off American jobs. He was amazed to hear that Romney didn't think he needed to be concerned with the problems of 47% of the country. You know him, the Romney who thinks that the median income in the US is $250,000. Thanks to "Scott the bartender," America got to see and hear the ONLY time that Romney actually said what he really believed. Recently, on Fox, Romney whined that it was NOT what he really believed and that he was just SAYING it for the benefit of the group of wealthy supporters and then immediately said that he lost the election because of all the stuff that Obama was giving folks. You know, like the phone give aways that were started under REAGAN and continued under Clinton and both Bushes. Definitly an Obama plot to be sure! America, that was a close shave. We almost fell for that charlatan. Thank you Scott Prouty, that was one for truth and the 99%. If not for you that LIAR might be our president. Ugh!
Nice article Cahir and how chillingly correct. Be afraid you tea party types!! You may wake up one morning and say Cahir was correct!! by then it will be to late.
"Again I tell you, it is easier for a camel to go through a needle's eye, than for a rich man to enter into the Kingdom of God." When your god becomes the accumulation of wealth and all the goodies that can go with it, you become disconnected from the brotherhood of man and what really matters in this life!
Cahir, I think this is the best article I've read that you wrote. I especially like the comparison of the Anglo lords, etc.. I hope that people like the economic advisor will wake up to the reality that destroying the wealth of the middle class has a way of taking the rich down with it. Similar to sawing a grand Redwood at it's base.
Number one, Why do you complain about the super rich not having a plan for the middle class ? Are they supposed to ? ------------- Number two, where is your plan ?
I do not believe in punitive income tax and wealth redistribution. If you made it, it's OK to flaunt it. As a successful person who comes from a poor background, my concern is "inherited" super wealth. I would allow inheritance of a certain sum without tax liability, e.g., $5M, and heavily tax all wealth over that at death with the proceeds to be used for education and training. No one, rich or poor, should have things handed to them. Everyone should work for what they obtain. Inherited super wealth is just as onerous as those among us who have given nothing to the country standing in line for a handout. In both cases, the person is not justifying their existence. Work for what you get. Don't expect either the government or your family to support you.
@Fran Connor, well said. Why should those who've worked hard, got an education, took advantage of their opportunities, made good choices, and became successful, pay, from cradle to grave, for all those who did not? I do help those who are less fortunate than I am - a lot - but I don't owe them a living and a hefty share of my bank account. Habitat for Humanity found out that the people they were building houses for needed to be invested in them by contributing a certain number of hrs. of physical labor. Constant hand-outs don't encourage initiative in people or develop people's self-esteem.
The writer seems to support the idea of redistributing the nation's wealth, which on the face of is a worthy idea. But does that mean that veterans such as I who honorably served in the nation's dedfense forces should no longer be treated in in veterans' hospitals, so that these facilities could be used be used for the sole purpose of providing care for ILLEGAl aliens.
OMG, we're on our own! The nanny state should take care of us, cradle to grave. How's that been working out in Greece, Spain, Italy, and, yes, in Ireland? How did it work out in the soviet union? I was there when it was still the soviet union. I saw everyone living in unbelievable (to me) poverty. They figured it out. The government got out of the way. The last time I was there (2011), there were building cranes all over Moscow.
The story teller Cahir watches to much MSNBC. What our present government wants is 2 classes, the government and the poor. Figure out where that will lead us to.
Another piece of worthless Journalism from Herr O'Doherty, "America’s super rich have no plan for the middle class" You have every opportunity to do anything you want in this country...get any amount of education, start any business,, Its all the basics...and yet that just doesn't cut...for every excuse maker...farewell rich folks, you have no right to anything because your money doesn't belong to you...It belongs to Cahir and his merry band of shakedown artists who have decided that an obsessive inability to do anything for themselves they are better off with other peoples money. Con job,.. I'm neither rich nor poor and I don't need need the quality of life that Cahirs life-stylers want for me. Who f*&%ing cares what the rich are doing...
Next Page 1 of 2 pages




Log into IrishCentral with your Facebook account


or sign-in directly

E-Mail:
Password:
 Remember me Forgot my password
Not a member? Register Now!
print this article Print
email this articleE-mail