Health Matters


Charles Fiscella
Health Matters by Dr Charles Fiscella

Mitt Romney and Barack Obama miss a trick in their debates – what happens when presidents don’t drink

Posted on Thursday, October 25, 2012 at 06:37 AM
submit to reddit

Mitt Romney and Barack Obama - laying off the booze makes for better Presidents
History teaches us that problems arise when the White House is forced into abstention; an important point missed in the last presidential face off. 

During last week’s town hall style presidential debate, a questioner asked Mitt Romney how he would differentiate himself from President George W. Bush.

Romney answered by saying that “President Bush and I are different people and these are different times.” He went on to say he’d be better on energy, trade, deficits and small business concerns.

President Obama returned by pointing out that Bush never proposed turning Medicare into a voucher system, nor did he call for self-deportation of illegal immigrants or the elimination of funding for Planned Parenthood as Romney has.

Obama clearly missed the mark in his retort when he did not link Romney to George Bush’s abstinence from alcohol. Alcohol has been linked to some of the most successful presidencies including all of this nation’s founding fathers. Abstinence on the other hand has been tied to some of the most disastrous presidencies on record.

In addition to George W. Bush one of the nation’s worst presidents of the modern era, the abstainers include Jimmy Carter, William Howard Taft, William Henry Harrison and Millard Fillmore. 

George Bush gave us two unjustified wars and the worst recession in a hundred years. Carter presided over crippling high interest rates and the Iran Hostage Crisis. Taft failed to obtain critical international agreements, and turned a blind eye toward racial injustice. William Henry Harrison spent his entire 30-day presidency in bed with a cold which ultimately killed him. Fillmore, was a racist who enacted the Fugitive Slave Act of 1853 which required free states to return slaves to their owners, making their failure to do so a federal crime. He also despised Irish Catholic immigrants.

So much for the abstainers.

Former Governor Romney doesn’t appear to be faring much better. In the only state he ever held public office, Massachusetts; poll numbers show that Obama leads Romney by almost thirty points. The vast majority of Massachusetts’ residents are non-abstainers.

Gee, Mitt must have done a really good job there!

Perhaps Mitt best summed things up a year ago when he told the press:

“I tasted a beer and tried a cigarette once as a wayward teenager and never tried it again.”
Sounds like another abstainer.


3 Comments

See all comments

This is off subject but could not help but pass it on I live in Del Webb Spruce Creek Golf & County Club. As I made my turn today. On a billboard , it was Christmas wrapped gift and the writing read Rommey/Ryan
It would be hard to blame sobriety for the negative characterestics of any president, or anyone else. I live near an upstate village that doesn't have any bar, and boooze is sold only at the American Legion post, of which I have been a member for the past 12 years. Seldom does any local Legionnaire - many of whom are Vietnam veterans - ever have a drink at the post. And as loyal, law-abiding, tax-paying, patriotic citizens, few if any of these veterans support Obama.
It's a wee bit of a stretch to connect teetotalism with bad presidential decisions unless you mean, for example, that George W.'s alcoholism damaged his central nervous system before he quit drinking. It's possible. But if I thought that abstaining from alcohol could cause Romney's mean-spirited politics, I'd favor federal subsidies for bars and liquor dealers. Slainte, Mr. Pres!
 




Log into IrishCentral with your Facebook account


or sign-in directly

E-Mail:
Password:
 Remember me Forgot my password
Not a member? Register Now!
print this article Print
email this articleE-mail