NEW YORK BOSTON |#Popular: Irish Celebrity Gossip Irish in US Politics Irish Festivals Irish Roots Irish Entertainment Offbeat Irish

Home Page > Roots > Who were the 'Black Irish'?

Who were the 'Black Irish'?

Those of darker skin or a derogatory term?

Ireland-information.com,

Published Saturday, March 10, 2012, 7:16 AM

Updated Saturday, March 10, 2012, 8:22 AM

Larger Text

E-mail

88 Comments

Illustration of the "Shanty Irish" / "Black Irish" by F. Opper

Photo by Google Images

It is possible that the term 'Black Irish' may have referred to some of these immigrant groups as a way of distinguishing them from the 'Gaels', the people of ultimately Celtic origin.

Another theory of the origin of the term 'Black Irish' is that these people were descendants of Spanish traders who settled in Ireland and even descendants of the few Spanish sailors who were washed up on the west coast of Ireland after the disaster that was the 'Spanish Armada' of 1588.

It is claimed that the Spanish married into Irish society and created a new class of Irish who were immediately recognizable by their dark hair and complexion. There is little evidence to support this theory and it is unlikely that any significant number of Spanish soldiers would have survived long in the war-torn place that was sixteenth century Ireland.

It is striking though how this tale is very similar to the ancient Irish legend of the Milesians who settled in Ireland having traveled from Spain.

The theory that the 'Black Irish' are descendants of any small foreign group that integrated with the Irish and survived, is unlikely. It seems more likely that 'Black Irish' is a descriptive term rather than an inherited characteristic that has been applied to various categories of Irish people over the centuries.

One such example is that of the hundreds of thousands of Irish peasants who emigrated to America after the Great Famine of 1845 to 1849. 1847 was known as 'black 47'. The potato blight which destroyed the main source of sustenance turned the vital food black. It is possible that the arrival of large numbers of Irish after the famine into America, Canada, Australia and beyond resulted in their being labeled as 'black' in that they escaped from this new kind of black death.

Immigrant groups throughout history have generally been treated poorly by the indigenous population (or by those who simply settled first).

Derogatory names for immigrant groups are legion and in the case of those who left Ireland include 'Shanty Irish' and almost certainly 'Black Irish.' It is also possible that within the various Irish cultures that became established in America that there was a pecking order, a class system that saw some of their countrymen labeled as 'black'.

The term 'Black Irish' has also been applied to the descendants of Irish emigrants who settled in the West Indies. It was used in Ireland by Catholics in Ulster Province as a derogatory term to describe the Protestant Planters.

While it at various stages was almost certainly used as an insult, the term 'Black Irish' has emerged in recent times as a virtual badge of honor among some descendants of immigrants. It is unlikely that the exact origin of the term will ever be known and it is also likely that it has had a number of different creations depending on the historical context. It remains therefore a descriptive term used for many purposes, rather than a reference to an actual class of people who may have survived the centuries.

Source: ireland-information.com

Last page < 1 2

Nster.com

E-mail

88 Comments

15 - 88 | See all comments

Beedee | Jul 02, 2012, 03:02 AM EDT

Seriously wondering, do you all live in the past?

Report abuse

oldboreen | Jul 01, 2012, 02:55 PM EDT

Er, wasn't the cartoonist F.Opper American???? Don't believe me? Look it up!

Report abuse

Celtlaw | Jun 22, 2012, 10:59 AM EDT

You say "The Celts arrived in Ireland about the year 500 B.C." Your information is out-dated. The Celts were not a race, but a culture. The inhabitants of Ireland, including my ancestors who have lived in Northwest Ireland since about 7,000 B.C. embraced that culture, which came from Anatolia and Central Europe. There was no invasion or mass migration by an alien race called the Celts. My ancestors, Ireland's original post-Ice Age inhabitants, were dark-haired and dark-eyed, like their close relatives the Basques.

Report abuse

ciaradexy | Jun 17, 2012, 11:59 AM EDT

White people can have red, brown, black or blonde hair. we can have blue, brown, grey, green, hazel eyes and we can be pale or sallow. No one combination of these makes anyone 'more irish' than another but if youre not from ireland, then youre not irish.

Report abuse

JoePatAl | Jun 15, 2012, 10:33 PM EDT

Well, as the son of a "Black" irish Woman, I am well aware of its 'origin.' These folks come from the original settlers of Spain & Portugal. Well before the Armanda event. Afterall, as we should all know - Hibernia and Iberia come form the same root word of those early ancestors who continued the travel Up north to the Island back before the folks were seriously writing history. And yes, we do have A- blood! My mom, grandmother, and sister all share that link. Brother and other sister are closer to my father's Irish folks (looks and blood).

Report abuse

buslane | Jun 11, 2012, 02:35 PM EDT

Hermittalker , you say that the cartoon is "hateful British Propaganda" yet the cartoonist is American and has no link to the British. Why did you say this ?

Report abuse

occassio | Jun 09, 2012, 02:56 PM EDT

Seanmor. Ireland may not have been invaded by black Africans, but whether through war and capture, trade or adventure, Africans most assuredly traveled with Viking raiders in 795 and beyond. There were blacks in and ruling the Roman Empire around 190AD. African Moors were in Southwest Europe during the middle Ages. It is profoundly unfortunate that the true and accurate history of Africans and African-Americans has not been told. Louis Latimer (light bulb), Garret Morgan (3-way traffic signal), Matthew Alexander Henson (Arctic Explorer), Patricia Bath, MD (apparatus for cataract lenses), Ruane Jeter (digital toaster). The greater tragedy is that many African-Americans don’t know their history. This is as much the result of oppression and persecution as was the British treatment of the Irish along with a reductionist and distorted version of Irish history. Read, my friend. Read.

Report abuse

Springfield9 | Jun 09, 2012, 11:52 AM EDT

The Celts (Gauls) were noted by Julius caesar as universally blue eyes. The Norse culture were overwhelmingly blue eyed. The Normans were Vikings with (perhaps a bit of mixing). This article says nothing intelligent on the topic. You might note that the word "dubh" is not simply a color. "Dubh" can mean "dark" in having a quality of ill will.

Report abuse

culchiewoman | Jun 08, 2012, 01:14 PM EDT

Forget the whole Spanish Armada myth (that only accounts for a smattering of cross-bred dark folk in Ireland); forget what we think we know about the Celts, because truthfully, we don't know much about them and that migration is currently under study. For those of us dark Irish with A- blood and other distinctive bone structures, here's the real possibility: Basque migration. And a correction: the surname Fitzpatrick is not of Norman origin. It is the only "Fitz" surname that is of actual Irish origin.

Report abuse

GuinnessGrrl | Jun 08, 2012, 10:54 AM EDT

Many of you forget that your child can be as light as their lightest ancestor or as dark as your darkest. For example, a couple having a red-headed, green-eyed child when neither parent can remember anyone in their family with that coloring, but a grandmother remembers one of her grandparents with red hair. We always joked that my dad was "Black Irish" because he was from Galway, had black hair, green eyes & was pale-skinned until he was out in the sun where he would tan very darkly.

Report abuse

Scottmcgowan | Jun 07, 2012, 02:57 PM EDT

My father and five of his 11 siblings inherited their "Black Irishness" from their mother. However, while they had jet black hair, they were fair-skinned. That was my understanding of what "Black Irish" meant, sans the dark or sallow complexion. I thank the writer for avoiding the myth that the "Black Irish" are the descendants of survivors of the Spanish Armana, most of whom were slain by the Irish when they made it ashore. If the Spanish influence did occur, it was more likely that because of the great trade between Spain and Galway, there was some intermarriage - but certainly not enough to create the "Black Irish." Actually, the Normans were descendants of Vikings who had invaded and settled in France. The people of France are presently a mixture of Celts (the primary people of France when the Romans invaded Gaul), the Vikings who became Normans and Germanic tribes who also invaded France. So, the French are our cousins! Paris is named after the Parisi Celtic tribe. Of course, the people of Brittany are almost 100% Celtic. The above is really common knowledge that I have gleamed by reading about Celts - not because I am a historian, which I am not.

Report abuse

hermitTalker | Jun 07, 2012, 11:58 AM EDT

The cartoon here showed British hateful propaganda, the Missing link of Darwin's theory about human evolution was that was the ape-like (simian) features of the Irish, who is still strangely the same caricature shown on the Notre Dame Fighting Irish mascot. Never knew why thet did not realise that. DOYLE is the black equivalent of McGinley DUBH GALL black foreigner. Donegal has a dominantly B blood type and black hair and short height is dominant there, I plan to pursue that with the DNA project but they were probably Phoenician/ Mediterranean, Semitic. DONEGAL is of course the DUN NA N'GALL, fortress of the foreigner. I heard once of an island people (Tory perhaps) off Donegal who spoke Irish but were from the Mediterranean area and quite suspicious of mainlanders. There was definitely trade and travel with Egypt, which is of course Africa during early Christian days due to persecution in the Eastern Empire; also trade with Celtic areas, including Galicia in Spain, see the Gall root- Paul's letter to the Galatians was to Celts, again the root word, in Asia Minor, today's Turkey.

Report abuse

Silling | Jun 07, 2012, 07:49 AM EDT

The Black Irish were the coal miners at Balingarry.

Report abuse

hughaed | Jun 05, 2012, 09:31 PM EDT

There are many theories about the origin of the "black Irish". My early years were in Donegal & the "black Irish" were the heavy drinkers who were given to easy anger, or they could be those subject to black moods. The author does not seem to have done his research very thoroughly in terms of Vikings. The Norse & the Danish, who made up most of the Vikings were the dark & light foreigners. I have relatives named McGinley, which in Irish is Mag Fhionnghaile, a name associated with the Vikings. All are light haired. Another family name is O'Gallchobhair (Gallagher), associated with "foreign warriors" which is descriptive with no specific point of origin. Although "Donegal" itself is associated with the clan Gallagher well before the O'Donnell clan came to power. According to Patrick Woulfe, the historian of Irish names, the Gallaghers are descended from the 7th century Maolchobha, King of Ireland. Another assertion I would question is the statement that Celts came to Ireland in the 5th century BC. Stephen Oppenheimer's book dealing with genetic history believes the Celts came in much much earlier to Ireland, closer to the date given by Lebor Gabala, the mythic history of Ireland (about 1700 BC). Archaeological discoveries & genetics are giving us a much clearer picture of the early history of Ireland.

Report abuse

bunkerhill | Mar 15, 2012, 04:02 PM EDT

I agree with Searlit as it has long been acknowledged that the Celts were a loose confederation of tribes spread across most of Europe from Russia to Ireland. Celtic red headed mummies have even been found inside the bounderies of China. They were known for their tremendous height still found among many Irish and their descendents worldwide. The Romans are said to have been terrified by their size in Helveti, ancient Switzerland. We have local Irish who are six foot eleven inches, and my wife has red headed Irish relative with women six foot three and men six foot seven. On the History Channel recently they had a derogatory program about huge red headed skeletans found in the Western USA, whose heads were kept hidden in a museum. Why is that I wonder? The Basques are another puzzle as their language is not connected to any other known language. Were they native Americans? Incidentally about 56% of the English have Basque genes and the A-S's invasion is a myth. If you remember your history you will recall that the natives in Central America thought the "white" men were returning "Gods" who had been there long before and told them they would return. They welcomed them unfortunately. This is all a big puzzle but DNA will solve it. My wife's family has a great many tall redheads and her family was predominately fair haired, blue eyed people.

Report abuse