nav
\"Shamrocks

Shamrocks or clover? Photo by: graymalkn/Flickr

Everything you know about the St Patrick's Day shamrock is a lie

\"Shamrocks

Shamrocks or clover? Photo by: graymalkn/Flickr

I hope you have a bottle of good strong Irish whiskey stashed away all ready to fortify you for the St. Patrick's Day parade and for the ritual drowning of the shamrock through the big day.

If so, then my advice to you is to take a good shot from the bottle here and now before you read the rest of this quite shocking story. You will need it. Okay?

You're back with me and feeling stronger. That's good because this article is as difficult to write as it is to read.

Until I did a little bit of research this week, you see, I always believed that the beautiful green shamrock only grew in Ireland. That is what I was taught when growing up.

And I was also taught the shamrock is so special to us as a symbol of the Irish because St. Patrick used a fistful of shamrock on the Hill of Tara to explain the mystery of the Holy Trinity to the pagans around him at that historic site.
 Take another shot from the bottle...
The facts are that the first four letters of the word shamrock are brutally and cruelly accurate.

The facts are that there is no evidence at all that St. Patrick used the delicate little plant as a conversion tool at Tara or anywhere else for that matter.

The facts are that he never mentioned shamrock in his many writings about his conversion campaign at that time. 
The facts are that any link between the good saint and shamrock did not appear until English writers and botanists began mentioning the myth as hearsay about 1571.

The facts are that the Druids that St. Patrick displaced and shattered did have some respect for the shamrock as an edible and healing herb, but there is no hard evidence at all to substantiate the story.
Take another shot from that bottle...
There is no such botanical plant as the shamrock. It is wrong to think that shamrock only grows in the Emerald Isle.

The plant or plants that we call shamrock grow all over Europe and beyond – even in Mother England – and are frequently treated as weeds!

Even Irish botanists of great lore and learning cannot accurately identify a shamrock to this very day!
 The cruel reality is that the original Gaelic word seamróg, Anglicized to shamrock, means "young clover" and that is where the problem begins.

Even here in Ireland, different species of clover (and even other related plants) are pinned to our breasts on St. Patrick's Day.

Did St. Patrick ever visit the Hill of Tara? Photo credit: CooKeeN

As recently as 1988, the learned botanist Charles Jolson, then director of the famed Botanic Gardens in Dublin, attempted to solve the shamrock issue by asking folk from all over the country to send him
in their shamrocks.

It seemed a good idea at the time, but I'm sad to say that you now need another shot from that bottle!
 You see, what happened was that not alone did he receive totally different species of clovers from all over the land, he also received alleged shamrocks which were not even clovers.

Rakes of them! 
I could blind you with botanical names here but, since you are already feeling delicate, I will simply say that a clover called trefolium dubium was the most common shamrock selection across the land, but there was also a strong showing of hardy trefolium repens, trefolium pratense and various other mutations, and even a strong showing of three-leaved plants which were not clovers at all. A fair percentage of the specimens he received were actually of wood sorrel!

So even when the bands play and the parades begin through the home towns and villages of Ireland on St. Patrick's Day, there are many separate species of clovers being paraded. And not a genuine mythical shamrock amongst them.


(At this point please forgive me because I need to take a healing shot from my own bottle because I fear I've worn sorrel on my bosom more than once 
in the past. I'll be back with ye in a moment…)

It is customary for our political leaders to travel in numbers over to the USA for St. Patrick's Day and to present your President with a basket of luxurious 
alleged shamrock. President Obama will use all his considerable social and political skills to be seen as President O'Bama during the green hours and days. 
I just wryly wonder will his breast be adorned with trefolium dubium or trefolium pratense or even some other species of common clover.
 What will our Taoiseach (prime minister), Enda Kenny, bring with him to the White House? Will it even be a clover at all?

That 1988 astonishing survey apparently revealed that a good number of Mayo folk actually wear wood sorrel on their hardy breasts. And Enda is a Mayo man to the core.

If it is indeed wood sorrel which will be presented to President O'Bama I hope he will be informed that, though it has a bitter taste, it also has considerable medicinal properties. The old Druids swore by it. 
Incidentally, we might have lost the trademark use of the shamrock altogether about 30 years ago were it not for the intervention of another famous Mayo-born leader of the country, none other than the frequently maligned late Charlie Haughey.

The Irish government had long registered the shamrock as a national trademark, but this was successfully challenged in the German courts in the 1980s by a company which, I understand, wished to emblazon our shamrock on their fleet of refuse trucks and bulldozers. 
Haughey, however – fair play to him – saw to it that the case was powerfully appealed to the German Supreme Court in 1985. We won, and the (alleged) shamrock has been safe as our trademark ever since.


We don't have exclusive rights though. The shamrock is still the official symbol of the Danish town of Viborg and a range of other towns and cities which include the German city of Furth. It is also attached to the flags and banners of many sporting clubs both in the USA and right across the world.


Regiments in many armies march behind images of the shamrock. It is central to leading soccer club Panathinaikos in Greece, has been inscribed on the walls of Buckingham Palace since the Act of Union in 1801 (as a trefolium dubium beside the leek, thistle and rose) in the Royal Coat of Arms, and, in general, English writers down the centuries have been intrigued by the clovery connection between the Irish and the trefoils. 

Time to take another swig out of that bottle. 
We ritually drown whatever species of clover we have worn on the big day and, as we all know, some of us drown it more thoroughly than others. However, that is only half the story.

The English writers Edmund Spencer and Edmund Campion were amazed to report in the 16th century that the Irish were actually devouring large quantities of shamrocks, especially (they said) poorer Irish living through hard times.

There is the possibility, given the botanical confusion involved, that they were actually seeing folk eating the aforementioned wood sorrel.

Photo credit: Feedloader (Limelight Networks)

That is an interesting factor because, forgetting our patron saint's work altogether, the wise old Druids often advised the Irishmen of their time to consume wood sorrel because it would make them strong and speedy in battle. I kid you not.

Given the daily battles that face our countries' leaders, 
is it possible that we might see Enda Kenny and President O'Bama devouring their shamrocks/sorrels before the day is out? They could do worse.
 And if you wish to be strong and speedy for the duration of the parade maybe, knowing what you now know, you should consider carefully if there is a better way of disposing of your own shamrock than simply drowning it!


Sorry for smashing a few fables, but I know well you will have a mighty day anyway no matter which species of clover adorns your person 
during the marching hours in question. In the end it does not matter at all.

And in conclusion, I would like to send special greetings to all the surviving residents of the small town of Shamrock in Texas and add the suggestion that they consider renaming it Trefoil or Oxalis before this time next year.

A name change needed for Shamrock, Texas? Photo credit: Billy Hathorn

* Originally published March 2014.

COMMENTS