The priest wrongly accused by Irish television of raping a teenager in Kenya and fathering her child has revealed how he was advised not to take on the might of state broadcaster RTE.
Fr Kevin Reynolds has received over $1.5million in libel damages from the Irish station after the false accusation were made earlier this year in the Prime Time Investigates programme ‘Mission to Prey.’
The priest, asked to stand down from his current parish work in Galway while he fought the case, had to take a paternity test which proved negative and take RTE to Dublin’s High Court before the station admitted they were wrong.
Speaking to the Sunday Independent, he said: "I feel very relieved it's all over. It has been an awful and devastating experience. So, so, so distressing -- not only for me but for my family and for my parish.
"I want to say now, I do not have any feelings of revenge or anger. I just want to get over this and on with my life.
"I am not looking for blood. I'm not looking for any revenge. As a priest, of course, whoever wrongs me, I will forgive them and I can say from the bottom of my heart they are forgiven."
---------------------------
READ MORE:
Catholic priest organization slams Irish media bias
Anti-Catholic insults rife in 'A Very Harold and Kumar 3D Christmas'----lesbian nuns, topless angels, playboy Jesus all add insult to injury
Canada seeks thousands of Irish immigrants urgently
---------------------------
Reynolds had offered to take a paternity test to prove he was not the father, but the program went ahead and accused him anyway.: "Of course, it tested my faith. It rattled me in every respect. Not only socially, but also spiritually.
"But I knew from day one I had a clear conscience; I knew it was not true. And my faith remains intact as it was -- as strong as ever.
"The worst day was signing a form to say that I would freely withdraw from all public priestly ministries. That was very difficult.
"But the lowest point of all was driving to Dublin alone on the eve of when the programme was to be aired. Driving out of my priesthood, out of my parish in a complete daze, wondering what on earth had happened. My whole world had collapsed.
"That's an experience I wouldn't like to relive. I didn't sleep that night and there was no sleep for many, many nights after that."
He was seen laughing on the program when he was first accused.
"Mother of God, says I. Is there some truth that this is actually going to air?"
"Kenya is the land of rumours and fabrications and allegations. But not one person I contacted had ever heard that rumour or said there was any truth in it."
"The morning after the programme, I didn't want to be seen. I was afraid in case someone would recognise me and take a pot shot at me. But I got over that pretty fast. After a while I said, 'No, I have to face the world'."
"I must say the second day after the programme was aired, I was in Galway and I met with legal people who recommended that I go for a long holiday and that I would be rather foolish to challenge the might of RTE. That was a pretty low point but there was never a time that I was going to give up.
"I must give it to the Association of Catholic Priests. I got in contact with them and they put me in touch with solicitor Robert Dore. And once he got the legal team moving on it, I became more hopeful."
When the DNA tests confirmed his innocence, Reynolds said: "Everyone was over the moon and congratulations were coming in from all over the place, but it didn't really excite me because I knew I could not have been the father of that child.
"Somebody said to me, 'Now it's time for a mighty party' but I said, 'No. I just want to get all of this cleared up.'"
"There will always be people with lingering suspicions and what can I do? I have to live my life and I know tomorrow morning I will be able to stand outside the door of St Cuan's Church in Ahascragh with confidence and can finally stand tall again, thank God."
23 Comments
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Switch to the desktop site to post a comment.edmicca | Nov 24, 2011, 08:19 AM EST
Collette2, a priest is wrongly accused by the RTE of raping a child. He didn't do it. Rather than comment on the great injustice done to him, you go off on an idiotic jag, saying the woman was probably paid off, etc. What a fool. You wouldn't know a bone if you fell over one.
Collette2 | Nov 23, 2011, 01:35 AM EST
What's the matter edmicca, getting to close the bone. You know damned well I'm right.
edmicca | Nov 22, 2011, 10:43 PM EST
Collette2 and BeHonest aren't just stupid - they're amazingly, uniquely stupid. You hand a moron a keyboard and suddenly it fancies itself a mind.
Collette2 | Nov 22, 2011, 03:34 PM EST
eiremudg, how can you be so gullible, whose to know if the woman wasn't paid off to retract her claims. It happens more times that you would care to know, so too with sex-abuse issues, charges are dropped, and you hear no more because of confidentialities signed.
Collette2 | Nov 22, 2011, 03:26 PM EST
Most sensible comment eiriamarch, but I doubt it. The innocent and decent priest's have their hands tied out of obedience, their bishops knowing full well "they have it all under control". The controversy of the spilling of seed and consequences would be averted if celibacy was otional and clergy could marry. No wonder there's no respect for children.
warlocks | Nov 22, 2011, 02:38 AM EST
Not all Catholic Priest's are Evil or Pedophiles. a few Bad apples can seem to make the rest Bad. but its not so many are Great Men of God who help mend broken souls. We have to be careful not to treat them all as Bad priest's
elremdg | Nov 21, 2011, 06:34 PM EST
i know 2 filipino priests who have been wrongfully accused of having affairs. the first one is from new jersey, and a gay seminarian accused him falsely of sexual harassment. the poor priest was proven to be innocent after the seminarian himself confessed he created the story to malign his pastor because he alleged he was not treated well; and wanted money, the next one is another filipino priest who was accused by his detractors as having fathered a son in australia. the woman came up to say that her son was the accused priest's son; and just by looking at the little boy, he didnt even show any features of the accused priest. the caucasian-looking boy is contrast to the very filipino-looking clergy. later the woman retracted her accusations and went into hiding back down under. what do we do to those wronged priests. they didnt get any back-payment for the wrongful accusations. i am beginning to believe that many other catholic priests were wrongfully accused to get money. let us pray for our beloved priests.
GeorgeDillon | Nov 21, 2011, 03:35 PM EST
Toornagrena: "The real culprit is the catholic hierarchy.." Oh look, another "Blame The Victim" idiot.
eiriamach | Nov 21, 2011, 03:01 PM EST
Thinking about it, I wonder whether the $1.5 million goes to the ACP rather than Fr. Reynolds himself. That money would be useful, considering that the ACP is planning a meeting of the Assembly of the Irish Church for May. I'd hope, though, that they'd reserve most of the award as a defense fund. Then innocent priests would have a financial as well as a moral reason to set a great precedent by cooperating with Gardai and standing trial if necessary to vindicate themselves, despite the maneuvers of the bishops. But most of all, I hope for justice for the victims of sexual abuse.
eiriamach | Nov 21, 2011, 02:44 PM EST
@CommonSenseNow: his lawyers worked pro bono, no fee, for the ACP. DNA testing and a sizable settlement have vindicated Fr. Reynolds. His good name has not been destroyed, and RTE looks like a villain for assuming his guilt. And since he was the victim of a false accusation, he will likely experience an outpouring of sympathy, like that below. All this, not suppression of news about allegations, IS justice. These outcomes provide a good reason for priests to trust in institutions of secular justice. Sometimes courts of law do the work of God; sometimes, religious institutions obstruct God's work. There is always a hearing for the voice that urges "innocent until proven guilty." This is a universally-respected principle of justice. Why did church insiders not shout "innocent until proven guilty"? Unfortunately, Church officials have been effectively obstructing the criminal investigations that could lead to trials and verdicts of guilty or not guilty. The silence of the bishops who have prevented cases from reaching the courts has thundered in the ears of the public to the point that Church voices calling for a restrained attitude of "innocent until proven guilty" would sound hypocritical. Nonetheless, I'd expect RTE reporters to strike a better balance after this precedent, if only to avoid liability. They should continue reporting because media attention may be the best way to deter pedophiles and cover-ups. Congratulations to Fr. Reynolds and to ACP! Let's pray that the many others who have been denied justice by the silence of Church officials will begin to share in the great blessing of justice accomplished.
CommonSenseNow | Nov 21, 2011, 02:07 PM EST
To BeHonest: "Why did he seek money ? Surely a vindication of his good name was all that was required." - Yeah right. How much money did he have to spend on lawyers to clear his name? Do you suppose the press might continue to shoot the reputation of priests without evidence if they only had to apologize every time? When a big dividend is paid out, the press might think twice about getting they're facts straight first - or they'll get hit in the pocket book. Besides, do you know if the priest kept the money? For all you know it could have been given to charity.
BeHonest | Nov 21, 2011, 02:01 PM EST
Let's start the movement to get priest out their working for a changing, I have never ever received a house visit from a catholic priest, yet the mormons and Jehovah have called several times. I think Irish catholic priests are extremely lazy and do practically nothing to advanced the Word of God, I loved to be proved wrong, but all I see is very little from them, they are the authors of their own downfall. What you sow you reap ! When religion is removed from the primary schools curriculum, if priests don't start working there won't be a catholic church in 30 years. All I see from priest is All talk and absolutely no action, sermons are boring and little or no time spent on comprising them, who are they fooling, a few words jotted down on the back of a envelope and then they think they can inspire their flock, get real, wake up and start doing what the Lord ordained them to be doing, serve, serve serve. Noel
BeHonest | Nov 21, 2011, 01:51 PM EST
Can Fr Kevin tell everyone what on earth is he going to do with €1.5 million euros. Why did he seek money ? Surely a vindication of his good name was all that was required. I go to church most days, and day by day I grow more disillusioned by the greed I see with Irish priests ! Why do they look for money of pensioners, when they are paid a handsome salary from the parish ?.. I think ally of priest should get out more and roll up their sleeves and start working for a change. In the Bible the Word of God, Jesus tells his disciples not to take an extra tunic or sandals. So where this greed with priests come from, why do they need mansions when the poor haven't roofs over their heads ? Can anyone explain and tell me what all these singing priest do with the massive royalties they get from their CD and TV performances. And why do they beg when they have loads of money, please tell me. Noel
Tooreenagrena | Nov 21, 2011, 10:52 AM EST
Its justice that this priest has been found to be innocent and a reminder to journalists to be cautious in their approach and more professional in their research but they are only the messanger. The real culprit is the catholic hierarchy who created the conditions for this sort of persecution by their immoral cover up of the truth. Lets not forget that.
JOHNTOBIN | Nov 21, 2011, 04:48 AM EST
I fully agree with the comments made by Toronthab regarding the Catholic Church.Look at the wonderful reception Pope Benedict is receiving in Africa.The people that are usually attacking the Catholic Church on this site are strangely silent.I wonder why?
Toronthab | Nov 21, 2011, 12:41 AM EST
The media absolutely hates the catholic church. In the US, the John Jay College of Criminal Justice report said that the church was caught unprepared for the sexual and social degeneration that came in with the sixties and seventies. Treatment attempts were effective only 60% of the time. Some bishops were indeed incompetent. Many were just following the best scientific advice available. My point? Sexual abuse of minors was and is rife, but the media would have us focus only on the church. They are not deeply concerned or interested in the sexual abuse of minors. This wounded and fallible church is still the voice of Christ among us; the voice who decries the culture of death, abortion, AIDS, and that attitude that will literally countenance killing an innocent human being just to satisfy an urge. The 'entertainment' industry caters and promotes these killings. The church is hated because she unmasks these crimes against humanity. Criminals hate to see policemen or have their crimes exposed. Fr. Reynolds, God bless him, took one for the voiceless he speaks for. The priesthood is an immense blessing for us all. Thank you father.
IronMountainMovies | Nov 20, 2011, 01:46 PM EST
The question remains, are the highly paid journalists, producers and researchers whose negligence here was nothing short of criminal, still working as journalists, producers and researchers in RTE? If so what has the NUJ have to say about it or do journalists feel that they are above the law? Is it only ordinary mortals who have to pay for their sins?
Ms.Gail | Nov 20, 2011, 01:42 PM EST
Glad this man has his good name back. His time of trial must be his gift to God and his story should give pause to those who do not seek the truth when accusations are made.
GeorgeDillon | Nov 20, 2011, 01:41 PM EST
What penalty will Aoife Kavanagh, the "journalist" (sic) who put together this slander, suffer for her dishonesty and/or incompetence? How much will she pay toward the settlement of a couple million bucks? Nothing, I am sure. In a properly run country--which Ireland most certainly is not--Kavanagh would be fired. Failing that, she should have a couple hundred bucks withheld from her salary every month for the rest of her working life, to go towards the damages RTE has to pay.
katieherk | Nov 20, 2011, 12:34 PM EST
If you recall the same thing happened to Cardinal Bernardine of Chicago. He went face to face with his accuser and forgave him. Shortly after, because of the stress and emotional hell he went through, he was a victim of deadly cancer. This eventually took his life but after the accusation, even though he was proved innocent, his life was never the same. I hope Fr. Reynolds is strong enough to stand up to all the naysayers, especially people like PhlutiePhan!!!
Rwnevnstr | Nov 20, 2011, 11:49 AM EST
The vilification of priests everywhere has gotten so vicious and shrill that a look at genuine motivations by accusers, media, and even societies doing it is necessary. Who is served by it? It heals nothing, accomplishes nothing. God bless you, Fr.
PhlutiePhan | Nov 20, 2011, 10:46 AM EST
I have lingering suspicions. The Association of Catholic Priests is an anti-Vatican organization.
bunkerisland | Nov 20, 2011, 10:13 AM EST
Congratulations to Fr. Kevin. With so many sex related incidents within the Church it is tragic to see such accusations made falsely. That he initially wished to "not be seen" is very understandable. DNA testing saved the man's neck. The reporters that developed this story ought to be fired.