When the Catholic Church does not know best - Ireland’s abortion law reform
Irish government's proposed abortion bill best that can be done for tough issue
The abortion bill being proposed by the Irish government is the best that can be achieved on this incredibly difficult issue.
There are objections on several levels, mainly that it does not cover abortion in the case of rape or incest, leaving the deeply distressed women in these situations to take the path to Britain as thousands of Irish do for a legal abortion.
The response of the Catholic Church, making noises about excommunication for politicians who support the new bill, is beyond disgraceful.
They are perfectly entitled to criticize the bill on its merits, but to threaten excommunication for those who are in favor of it is a step too far.
This, remember, is the institution that disgraced itself with the pedophilia crimes of so many of its priests.
The man making the comments about excommunication is Cardinal Sean Brady, who should have stepped down once it was reported that as a church inquisitor he had forced two young boys to cover up abuse by Father Brendan Smyth, the worst rapist of all, who went on to injure and abuse hundreds of other innocent children.
Brady is lucky that he and scores of other priests are not the ones excommunicated for failing in their duty to protect the most innocent in Irish society.
Taoiseach (Prime Minister) Enda Kenny made a remarkable response to the church’s criticism, saying the Constitution, not the Bible, was the law of the land in Ireland.
It was a brave statement by a politician handed a poison chalice, the Supreme Court verdict of 1992 in the X case that Ireland had to legislate for abortion in certain circumstances following the suicidal plea of a 14-year-old girl woman raped by a neighbor who was turned down for the right to travel for an abortion in Britain.
It is these all too human cases that the anti-abortion forces always ignore.
Like everything else there are many shades of grey in cases of rape, incest and abuse that they do not want to consider.
The latest was highlighted by the death of Savita Halappanavar, a young Indian woman living in Ireland who was forced to keep a non-viable fetus, suffered sepsis and died as a result.
Her doctor, fearful of transgressing an 1861 abortion law, refused Savita the abortion until it was too late. The fact was that the fetus at 19 weeks could not possibly have survived anyway.
There are no absolutes on these issues, only human beings muddling through as best they can.
What Kenny has done is put forward a narrow bill aimed at satisfying the legal framework put forward by the Irish Supreme Court in answer to the X case.
Members of his own party, many of them conservative, have many questions, but those can be sorted out in parliamentary debate and inquiry.
15 - 43 | See all comments
- An open letter in strong defence of capitalism.
- Racist incidents in Ireland up by 85 percent...
- Gay teacher fired from Catholic school after...
- Sarah Palin is saving Christmas
- Nelson Mandela once considered a terrorist...
- Irish drugs mule to escape full trial and...
- Virginia governor slammed by doctor over...
- Hollywood star Gabriel Byrne brands new Pope...
- Nelson Mandela was against IRA decommissioning.
- Top Christmas Irish ads that will be bring...
Wow. A lot of people here haven't heard that 'The Protocols of the Elders of Zion' was a forgery, it seems. Schlomo - you're wasting your time tryinSarah Palin is saving Christmas
Ah! There goes the Gutter hate mongering O'Doherty again. I guess It's the season to spread Hate for some. His misery is very unattractive. Merry ChSarah Palin is saving Christmas
Ooops, sounds like another attack on a women. F/XSarah Palin is saving Christmas
Angry Sarah Palin is setting herself up as the Atheist Finder General. Will she hold agnostic trials and condemn non-believers? What happens to peopl