News


The sacrifice of the heroes of 9/11 must not be used as a justification for torture


2The sacrifice of the heroes of 9/11 must not be used as a justification for torture" Paul Hill
2The sacrifice of the heroes of 9/11 must not be used as a justification for torture" Paul Hill

Guinness PubFinder Ad

Listen to Niall O'Dowd speak about "Threats of attacks on 9/11 anniversary" on RTE's "Morning Ireland"

September 11, 2001 will always remain an infamous day to the world. But to the men and women of the NYPD  and FDNY it remains indelibly stamped in their minds. For on that tragic September morning in the dying embers of summer, they raced towards lower Manhattan by any means necessary.

Battling their way through the sea of humanity, fearfully fleeing the devastation, these men frantically checked their pagers and mobile phones for any information that may enlighten them with regard to the inferno which was about to engulf them. They stood in ranks on Liberty, Church and Barkley Streets as terrified civilians by the thousands fled north on the elevated West Side Highway.
Paul Hill

These individuals whose aspirations in life were the most humbling – save enough for a house in the ‘burbs, enough to put their children through college, that long dreamed-of trip back to the old sod or whatever country bore their ancestors, the highlight of their week shooting the breeze over a few ice-cold beers – for many hundreds of these men these dreams and aspirations were to lay unfulfilled in the ruins and the wreckage of the World Trade Center.

As they donned their breathing equipment and held their torch-fire axes, many stood in silence, attempting to comprehend the incomprehensible as they stared skyward at what appeared to many as Dante’s Inferno. Some made frantic cellphone calls home, fully knowing it may be their last, some blessed themselves and prayed to their god, many thinking they may see him soon. If they were fearful, they did not show it, for it was not fear and self-motivation that propelled these individuals into the World Trade Center and up smoke-filled stairwells.

It was, to quote Chief Edward F. Croker, an Irish-born American of the fire department of New York from 1899-1911, “an act of unselfish bravery.” Chief Croker said, “When a man becomes a firefighter, his greatest act of bravery has already been accomplished.” These sons and daughters of immigrants were the finest examples of bravery humanity has ever produced. The compassion beating in the hearts of these individuals will remain unsurpassed in our lifetime. They defined everything great about the nation and the unconquerable soul of the human spirit.

On the morning of this barbaric act, as millions viewed throughout the world on TV screens, questioning the very existence of a god in the face of such barbarism, the individuals of FDNY and NYPD restored my faith in the existence of a just compassionate god. For their actions exemplified that. They shall forever remain deep in our hearts and in our memory, as those who sacrificed their lives so that others might live. No greater tribute can be bestowed upon them.


Nster.com


5 Comments

See all comments

What ever it takes to defend us. We can play the rules if they don't. They will harm our children if we give them the chance. I just hope its not mine.
@PiperMac52 - While Cheney, Rumsfeld, et al. insist that valuable information was gained as a result of water boarding Kahlid Shake Muhammad, the men actually doing his water boarding tell it differently. They say that the information they got from him during the water boarding ALL turned out to be false and that the VALUABLE information came after they treated him with kindness and stopped the TORTURE (it IS, by international agreement, and our guys go through it incase they are captured by a backward, rogue country that does not abide by "civilized" warfare rules.) This latter description is perfectly inline with the US Military's Studies of torture results and the validity with which they should be credited. *** Thanks for the addendum, jamthecat. Lying (as in for personal gain,) hummmm, I wonder if Haliburton supplied the water at some exorbitant price. I hear that these guys can't leave the US (even to sell their phoney self-serving books) for fear of international arrest so we are stuck with them.
While I don't approve of "torture" as used by Islamist terrorists against innocent civilians as well as captured military personnel: i.e., beatings, dismemberment, and beheadings, defining torture to include water boarding(which our own specila forces go through)in training, sleep deprivation, exposure to loud music etc. does a disservice to recognizing real torture. Kahlid Shake Muhammad gave up important info saving many lives as a result of water boarding, which only gives the sensation of drowning but causes no permanent harm. let's properly define torture. Then we can have a discussion.
What EphraimKibbey said with an addendum -- torture is never excusable. Period. It is immoral, as well as illegal, and achieves nothing except the destruction of the person being tortured as well as the person committing it. Every study that has ever been done has shown without question it is only counter-productive. Anyone who says otherwise is either lying or delusional.
This is the most troubling aspect of America's last, very troubled, decade. Troubling because it has revealed a very scary character flaw in us as a nation. We are supposed to be the "GOOD" guys in white hats (or fireman's helmets) that stand up against evil. That fear could reverse our national identity making us a nation that sanctioned torture in the name of our own safety has helped to create America's feeling of malaise as much or more than all the things that happened "to" us. I had, at first, hoped that international courts would have held us responsible for our actions but now it seems that the most we can hope for is the reversal of our on going human rights abuses. Thank you for your article, it is very important that our moral failures be pointed out until we face them as a nation.
 




Log into IrishCentral with your Facebook account


or sign-in directly

E-Mail:
Password:
 Remember me Forgot my password
Not a member? Register Now!
print this article Print
email this articleE-mail