They are a part of the history of the Irish nation. Their relatives signed the Proclamation of the Republic and led the Easter Rising in 1916. And, these descendants of the executed leaders of the Provisional Government today are leading a different movement, one which seeks to preserve and protect the last battlefield of 1916 from the commercial interests and crass development which threatens to destroy the National Monument, which is Moore Street.
Just as their relatives joined together to fight the British forces in 1916, today the descendants of those brave leaders are members of the Save Moore Street Committee which seeks to commemorate the 100th anniversary of the Easter Rising by creating a living monument to the revolutionary era by preserving and restoring the street where the GPO Garrison sought shelter and five members of the Provisional Government made the decision to surrender to the British forces to prevent further bloodshed.
Right now, that street faces an assault by commercial interests which could destroy its remaining eighteenth century architecture and eliminate the small shops and street market flavor that has characterized Moore Street since the nineteenth century. And, most importantly, those actions could destroy an important historical treasure, making it simply a footnote in a Dublin guidebook.
“As you can imagine, our heritage was drummed into us at an early age. ”, said Muriel McAuley, granddaughter of Thomas MacDonagh, one of the seven signatories of the Proclamation and Commandant of the Jacob’s Biscuit Garrison, during the Rising, who was executed by British firing squad on May , 1916. “It was also suggested that we not speak politically, as it would not be seen as we speaking, but our forebears”, she continued. “Many of the other descendants have the same attitude. We tend not to get involved in committees and organizations, but when it became obvious that not only the last headquarters of 1916, but also the last command headquarters which had not been either demolished or virtually rebuilt was about to be just about flattened, with just a cursory shell remaining, then we felt that we could not stand by and let it happen without protest. We owe this to coming generations. “
Mrs. McAuley, in fact, has connections to three of the executed leaders. Her mother, the daughter of Commandant MacDonagh, also was a godchild of Padraig Pearse, and a niece of Grace Gifford, who married Joseph Mary Plunkett, at Kilmainham Jail on the eve of his execution.
The 1916 relatives hope that their involvement in the campaign to preserve and protect the Moore Street Terrace will raise awareness of the significance of this area, designated a National Monument in 2007, and the events which occurred in the streets, shops and apartments of Moore Street on April 27 through 29, in 1916.
Joseph Plunkett’s grand-niece Honor O Brolchain points out that, until she became involved in the Save Moore Street Campaign, she was unaware of the importance of the street to the story of the Easter Rising, despite the fact that Joseph and his two brothers all surrendered on Moore Street.
She believes that many Irish people simply presumed that the Rising ended when the members of the GPO Garrison walked out of that building and surrendered on what is now O’Connell Street, a presumption supported by Hollywood’s version of events depicted in the movie Michael Collins.
But the GPO Garrison did not surrender as Hollywood tells the story. Rather, after days of bombardment from British guns, and with the GPO in flames, the garrison evacuated the Post Office, under fire, through Henry Place, and on to Moore Street. They first stopped at No. 10, but then broke through the interior walls of the attached buildings.
The provisional Government set up their last headquarters in the back room of No. 16, Plunketts Poulterers. The volunteers continued tunneling through to No. 25, thus occupying the entire block. Structural evidence of the rebels’ tunneling remains in several properties within the terrace, according to Committee members. And the brickwork on some of the buildings reflects the scars inflicted by British ordnance.
James Connolly Heron, great-grandson of the Commander of the Irish Citizens Army and Proclamation signatory, the executed James Connolly, feels the fight to Save Moore Street, is very important because “it is incumbent on the State to honour the memory of all the men and women of 1916 through the creation of a 1916 cultural and historic quarter in this area - the very birthplace of our nation. They were, after all, our golden generation - a generation prepared to sacrifice their lives for their country unlike those of a later one - prepared to sacrifice their country for their lavish lifestyles.”
And it appears that the government may be listening. On April 24th, the 96th anniversary of the start of the Easter Rising, Ireland’s Minister for Tourism Leo Varadkar annonced that he plans to commission a feasibility study to determine whether the upper end of Dublin’s O’Connell Street could be turned into a 1916 heritage quarter.
Moore Street, Dublin already had a long history before April 1916. The area was developed on land which originally was part of a 12th century Cistercian monastery, and during the 18th century, the Moore Street Terrace, currently Nos. 10 to 25, was built to provide housing for tradesmen and professionals who served the grand houses which lined what was then called Sackville Mall and is now O’Connell Street, just one block away, according to history provided by Mr. Heron.
As time passed, storefronts replaced the homes and the area developed into a market street, where Dubliners shopped for fresh meat and poultry.
Helen Litton, the grand-niece of executed Rising leaders Thomas Clarke, who was a member of the Provisional Government and Ned Daly, who commanded the Four Courts Garrison, and the granddaughter of a Volunteer who made a charge up Moore Street to clear the way for the evacuation, recalls shopping at the outdoor market stalls with her granny and as a young housewife. She believes that an important part of the preservation effort on Moore Street is maintaining the character of the area by providing for a street market.
In 1916, the shops of Moore Street were diverse, and included T.F. Cogan provision dealer at No. 10; Mrs. Norton’s china and glass at No. 14; Miss O’Gorman’s clothes dealer at No. 15; Patrick Plunkett’s poultry and fish at No. 16 and R.J. Gore druggist at No. 17. These shops and the gardens behind them bore witness to the final hours of the struggle of the Provisional Government after it evacuated the burning GPO until its leaders made the heart-wrenching decision to surrender.
Stories from Moore Street demonstrate the bravery, love of country and love of family exhibited by the Volunteers in the waning days and hours of the Rising.
Honor O Brolchain recalls the letter written by her great-uncle, Joseph Plunkett “somewhere in Moore Street” on the day of the surrender, to his fiancée Grace Gifford, in which he wrote that he had tried to arrange for them to meet and get married but had been unable to do so. He went on to say,” my other actions have been as right as I could see and make them and I cannot wish them undone.”
Another Plunkett brother, George, and two Volunteer friends, while erecting a barricade near No. 10 heard moaning across the street, and George rushed across, under fire, and retrieved the injured man, a British soldier, who was well-cared for by the Volunteers until the end.
And it was in No. 16 that the leaders of the provisional Government, including Padraig Pearse, Tom Clarke, Sean MacDermott, Joseph Plunkett and the badly wounded James Connolly met in a Council of War on April 29th to consider surrender after observing civilian
casualties occurring on Moore Street, as British guns continued to strike at the Volunteers.
Elizabeth O’Farrell left No. 15, under a white flag of truce, and walked up Moore Street to arrange the terms of surrender with the British commander on the afternoon of April 29th and Patrick Pearse signed the Decision to Surrender here on Moore Street.
It was in the yard behind Nos. 20 and 21, O'Hanlon’s Fishmongers that the members of the GPO Garrison were addressed by Sean McDermott, and informed of the surrender.
And, finally, as Ms. O Brolchain stated, recalling the bravery of her great-uncles and their comrades, “To make the decision to surrender for humanitarian reasons and not know what the outcome would be must have left them desolate and yet they were courageous to the end and, with Plunkett, already dying of tuberculosis, and Willie Pearse leading and Clarke and McDermott bringing up the rear, they marched out in such style as to take the British military aback.”
Moore Street, Dublin…an important market area for generations of Dublin families…Once filled with market stalls and provisioners, it now bears the scars of urban blight and decay, but almost 100 years ago, that area witnessed the agony of the Irish nation at war, as it struggled to free itself of the yoke of British colonial power.
But now… The relatives of the 1916 heroes have been in the forefront of the movement to create a living monument to the men and women who fought and died to reawaken the spirit of freedom among the Irish people. And they hope to create a living memorial that honors Moore Street’s past…her market roots, her heroic deeds, the brave men and women who struggled there for the ideals of freedom…and focuses on her future…as a dynamic part of Dublin.
If you believe that Moore Street should be preserved as a historical and cultural memorial to Ireland’s heroic age, and the men and women who fought for its freedom, let the Minister for Tourism Leo Varadkar (minister@dttas.ie ) know how you feel or write to the Board of Fáilte Ireland, 88 – 95 Amiens Street, Dublin 1, Ireland, info@failteireland.ie, and let them know that heritage tourism interests you.
45 Comments
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Switch to the desktop site to post a comment.seanomelb | May 04, 2012, 11:50 PM EDT
Ciara has found Patriotism. Ciara when you have marched in as many easter military parades as I have wearing the uniform of the Republic then you can question my Irishness,until then go back to your west Brit existence.
ciaradexy | May 04, 2012, 03:38 PM EDT
All non-Americans should organise a mass boycott of the US till the non natives get out and give the country back to the natives.
ciaradexy | May 04, 2012, 02:45 PM EDT
George, I agree with you! Please organise a mass boycott of Ireland by Americans such as yourself! Your 'culture' has introduced McDonalds and obesity to my country. Seano, west brits? Youre the one living in a country run by the Queen. I live in the Republic of Ireland and spent this week paying my respects to Pearse, Clarke and McDonagh who were executed 2 minutes from my house in Kilmainham Gaol on the 3rd of May.Joseph Plunkett married his fiancée, Grace Gifford, in Kilmainham Gaol chapel at 1.30 am on 4th May so I have laid flowers and paid my respects. What have you been doing over there in the Queens country?
GeorgeDillon | May 04, 2012, 03:04 AM EDT
I think folks who read the loony tunes of our two Mass Immigrationist boosters ciaradexy and bythebay (or is that just one??) can now see what the mass Immigrationist project is: deny Irish people a sense of their own identity and culture, and swamp them with foreigners. As bythebay puts it, knock down historic buildings in downtown Dublin in order to give room to Afghans, Paks, Poles etc to take over the neighborhood. I urge a boycott of Ireland by American tourists. If we wanted to go visit some slum in Kandahar we'd catch a plane for Afghanistan.
seanomelb | May 03, 2012, 10:58 PM EDT
I believe Moore st. should be preserved as a memory to those who fought and died for liberty that fateful Easter. Pearse and his buddies lit the torch of freedom which so many west Brits wish to extinguish, or cast into oblivion as it hurts their sensibilities and makes it easier for them to forget the debt they owe our heroes of Easter week
Bythebay | May 03, 2012, 07:45 PM EDT
merefalow, Moore Street isn't the US Declaration of Independence. Have you ever visited Moore Street? I doubt it. There is absolutely no reason to save those buildings. There are thousands of buildings in Dublin and Ireland with some historical connection. Not all should be saved at all. But your opinion won't affect what happens them.
Bythebay | May 03, 2012, 07:40 PM EDT
clelander, very unfortunate you would jump to labeling me a bigot simply because I described the area. Nowhere in my message did I make any negative comments about our new Irish at all. It's indicative of the quick to judge Americans whose comments are baseless.
Bythebay | May 03, 2012, 07:36 PM EDT
Searlit, I'm surprised with your interest in 1916 you didn't go to the GPO.
clevelander | May 03, 2012, 06:33 PM EDT
@bythebay It aybe that I jumped to a conclusion. But Searlit wished to visit the area in question and you wrote to Searlit, "then be prepared for the Romanian Gypsies living there as well as the Chinese, and immigrants from India and other countries. The entire area is in disrepair." How should I take it. I see at least a bit of bigotry in that! No!
Bythebay | May 03, 2012, 06:28 PM EDT
GeorgeDillon, great idea, all the Americans can stay away since they're so offended by Ireland's self-determination. ciaradexy, I'm well aware of heritage efforts in Dublin and elsewhere in Ireland since I live in Ireland. However, not all buildings should be saved for obvious reasons.
Bythebay | May 03, 2012, 06:21 PM EDT
Curitiba, don't worry about it. Lots of heritage for you to save in England.
Curitiba | May 03, 2012, 06:20 PM EDT
Just because a building is privately owned, it does not mean that the owner can do whatever he pleases. The local council and the heritage people decide what is appropriate, if major changes are proposed.
Bythebay | May 03, 2012, 06:19 PM EDT
Curitiba, fantastic! We in Ireland aren't aswerable to either you or England where you live.
Curitiba | May 03, 2012, 05:58 PM EDT
I've got two eyes, Byethebay. I can focus on on the UK and ireland.
Bythebay | May 03, 2012, 05:36 PM EDT
johnshiel, you also have never been to Moore Street have you? Hilarious you can have such a strong opinion about a place you've never seen. They are privately owned buildings, all fully occupied. They will continue to be such until the owners decide to do otherwise.
Bythebay | May 03, 2012, 05:32 PM EDT
like2tweet, obviously you know nothing about Moore Street at all. It's not at all like Federal Hall, it's privately owned dwellings and businesses all fully occupied.
Bythebay | May 03, 2012, 05:23 PM EDT
Curitiba, you live in England, not Ireland. You need to focus on your own country, not Ireland.
Bythebay | May 03, 2012, 05:19 PM EDT
clevelander, how unfortunate you immediately interpreted my statement as bigoted. I mentioned the Romanian Gypsies living there as well as the Chinese, and immigrants from India and other countries and did not say one word against any of them nor make a negative comment about them. You Americans come to Ireland in complete denial about our multiculturalism. You need to be well aware you will find the buildings on Moore Street privately owned and occupied by many of our new Irish.
casualMBA | May 03, 2012, 04:27 PM EDT
Applause
Curitiba | May 03, 2012, 03:53 PM EDT
So Ciara, Ireland is a club anyone can join then, rather than a country where where the people have a shared ancestry, ethnic identity, language and culture? A completely made-up thing that panders to the current crackpot political ideology, where people turn up and get enthusiastic about it like the latest ipad, then move on somewhere else when they tire of it, because they don't have any real ties or ancestral connection to the place? Sounds great.
ciaradexy | May 03, 2012, 02:46 PM EDT
Maybe everyone should boycott the US until you migrant spawn give the country back to the natives?
ciaradexy | May 03, 2012, 01:39 PM EDT
George, thats a great idea but heres a better one. Boycott Ireland until an asteroid wipes out the earth, that would suit everyone. Bythebay, Im from Dublin and there has been a on ongoing campaign to save and rejuvenate Moore St just like there now is a campaign to spruce up Thomas St and the Liberties. IrelandNorth, varadker is Irish. this is not the US where we feel the need to pigeon hole people. He is Irish as Alan Shatter is Irish. Their colour, religion or the place of birth of their grandparents means nothing here.
GeorgeDillon | May 03, 2012, 12:41 PM EDT
Irish-Americans should boycott Dublin until the city shows that it respects its history.
johnshiel | May 03, 2012, 10:43 AM EDT
"you don't know what you've got,,,,until you loo-oose it" so says the song, the saying, the sidewalk sage... maybe this applies, too, to waking up when you've ALMOST lost it...?
johnshiel | May 03, 2012, 10:34 AM EDT
save it!
IrelandNorth | May 03, 2012, 08:37 AM EDT
A partitioned Ireland is not what it said on the 1916 biscuit tin. And IRISHMEN AND IRISHWOMEN fought and died for somthing much grander than a tourist attraction - important though that may be. The current Irish Government (including its Indian-Irish Tourism Minister), needs to be reminded that it is still the Provisional Government referred to by Pearse in the Proclamation of the Irish Republic. The 26 county (81%) republic is not the definitive article. And that the Island in question is Ireland and not the Cayman islands! Younger Irish posters, (as accidental victims of a revisionist education and press/media censorship), need to be told that Pearse and Connolly are not members of Boyzone or Westlife. And that 1916 is much more than a minute after a quarter past seven in the evening. Alas, Mé Feinism has predominated over Sinn Feinism - at least up until now! And if that wasn't ideological autism, I don't know what was?
like2tweet | May 03, 2012, 06:52 AM EDT
its abloody disgrace. This is like destroying Federal Hall
merefalow | May 03, 2012, 04:21 AM EDT
its like destroying the american declaration of independence.unbelievable that it could be even contemplated.they are destroying one of the most important historical site in our history.shame shame whoever contemplates this.must be stopped.
Collette2 | May 03, 2012, 02:31 AM EDT
It was a wonderful idea having put this into comic form a few years ago. Placed where a child could pick it up and read it at random is a sure way to have this historical event memorised.
Searlit | May 03, 2012, 12:42 AM EDT
89west, Ha, ha, you're right. I was just trying to be concise. I meant we traveled on to the West of Ireland. Lisdoonvarna and Doolin. The Cliffs of Moher, a favorite place. This is where I always like to spend a few days, since the rest of the time we're staying only one or two nights along the way.
donal1951 | May 03, 2012, 12:13 AM EDT
Other than visiting family, heritage tourism, including ancient religious sites, are the main reasons I would visit Ireland again.
penelopemurphy | May 02, 2012, 09:52 PM EDT
We were there in Dublin in 2004, 2006 & 2008. My husbands grandparents were there - Grannie was laying down bullets to allow the men to get safely across from the GPO to HEnry then to Moore st. Go Grannie!
89west | May 02, 2012, 09:09 PM EDT
Searlit.........just curious; if you went to Skellig Michael off the S/W coast of Ireland and then traveled west you would have gone to Newfoundland or beyond.
warrenpoint00 | May 02, 2012, 08:46 PM EDT
I hear ye Seano, some bunch of wannabe wankers on here hi. God save and protect our island of Ireland from All things foreign... I wish. Ireland is not yet a restored nation (thanks to the brits)but when we do and we take our place along with all of the great nations of the world it is our responsibility to ensure the there is a repose in Ireland for the unfortunate, the disposessed, the tired and the weary of todays world. Somewhat like us the Irish all those years ago.May god bless our nation of Ireland.
Searlit | May 02, 2012, 06:54 PM EDT
Byethebay, I was there in 2005. We spent the first night in Dublin and the following day went sightseeing. We went to Stevens Green, walked by St. Patrick's Cathedral, went to the National Museum and the library at Trinity College to see the Book of Kells. We went out to Skellig Michael, then headed west for the remainder of the trip.
seanomelb | May 02, 2012, 06:34 PM EDT
George wants to save Moore st. for the wrong reasons,Byethebay is on his usual bigoted rants and Murph wants the chair.I hope Georgy boy or Byethebay don't find it or the may execute all the immigrants on it and throw Murph and yours kindly into the mix.
clevelander | May 02, 2012, 05:08 PM EDT
@bythebay you amaze me. You chastise georgieboydillon, (who I have not one thing in common with and I know he is well able to defend himself,) but then you show your own bigotry and intolerance of the new Irish "be prepared for the Romanian Gypsies living there as well as the Chinese, and immigrants from India and other countries." Please STOP, you are making us Irish look like fools and bigots.
89west | May 02, 2012, 05:00 PM EDT
Too long a sacrifice can make a stone of the heart (WBY), how prophetically revealing of the sentiments of those that have inherited the terrible beauty that was born on that day.
Bythebay | May 02, 2012, 02:43 PM EDT
GeorgeDillon, your one trip to ireland results in your self-sppointed authority on all things Irish. Your bigotry and foul language characterize you American perfectly!!
GeorgeDillon | May 02, 2012, 02:37 PM EDT
The neighborhood has really become run down because some of the native Irish gangster capitalists own property around there which they refuse to clean up or develop. For example, the Carlton cinema site on O'Connell Street has been derelict for maybe 25 years now. What other nation would allow a few rogue capitalists bring their capital's main street to such decay, and leave it so for a quarter of a century? Only Dopey Ireland. And of course on Moore Street you see another rotten fruit of gangster Irish capitalism. Namely Mass Immigration, the Irish capitalists' project--the place is full of Africans, Poles and Mongols. In fact a few years ago African migrants were publicly slaughtering sheep on nearby streets. I support the efforts of the people mentioned in the article to Save Moore Street, but to Save Moore Street you first need to Save Ireland from the way it's headed, and I don't see much sign of that.
Bythebay | May 02, 2012, 12:00 PM EDT
Searlit, when were you in Ireland last?
Bythebay | May 02, 2012, 11:58 AM EDT
Searlit, then be prepared for the Romanian Gypsies living there as well as the Chinese, and immigrants from India and other countries. The entire area is in disrepair.
Searlit | May 02, 2012, 11:50 AM EDT
I will write to them. I didn't know about Moore St. though I have been to Ireland 3 times. I would've gone to see it while staying in Dublin, had I known then. It's a location, definitely on my list, now.
Bythebay | May 02, 2012, 11:07 AM EDT
There isn't much support for this in Ireland. It's been ongoing for a number of years.
Murph46 | May 02, 2012, 09:55 AM EDT
Save the chair they shot prisoners in!