Minister's ban on blood from gay men 'irrational' declares judge
High Court judge rules against Northern Ireland's lifetime ban on gay blood
A High Court judge has ruled that the ban in Northern Ireland on gay men giving blood is "irrational." The judge, Justice Treacy, also held that Health Minister Edwin Poots breached the ministerial code by failing to take the issue before the Stormont Executive.
A prohibition on gay blood donation was put into place during the AIDS threat in the 1980s. In November 2011, the ban was lifted in England, Scotland and Wales and replaced by new rules, allowing blood from men whose last sexual encounter with another man exceeded 12 months, reports U.TV.
Following a Government Advisory Committee report identifying a much shorter period during which infection with blood-borne viruses could not be detected, the 12-month deferral was left in place. In Northern Ireland, Poots maintained the lifetime ban on the grounds of public safety.
The minister had said previously of the issue,"I think that people who engage in high risk sexual behavior in general should be excluded from giving blood… And so someone who has sex with somebody in Africa or sex with prostitutes, I am very reluctant about those people being able to give blood."
A gay man, who chose to remain anonymous, launched a judicial review challenging the prohibition. Lawyers for the man had revealed that the man is now a Christian who is opposed to homosexual activity.
"Although the applicant, perhaps curiously in these circumstances, shares the view that homosexual practice is wrong, he simply takes the view that homosexuals should not be banned from giving blood," David Scoffield QC had said earlier in the case, according to the Belfast Telegraph.
"The applicant's case is that the approach displayed by the Minister on this issue goes beyond the expression of orthodox religious views and amounts to prejudice."
Attorney General John Larkin QC, chief legal adviser to the Stormont Executive, questioned the legitimacy of the man's challenge because he had previously had sex for money. Larkin also rejected arguments that the matter required full Executive approval and questioned whether the Minister had made a decision to maintain the current ban.
Justice Treacy concluded that Poots decision to continue the lifetime policy was made against the recommendation by the Secretary of State that the report from the advisory committee on the Safety of Blood, Tissues and Organs (SaBTO) should be followed.
"The Minister has decided that MSM (males who have sex with other males) behaviour creates such a high risk of infection to the donor that such donors must be permanently deferred, with the result that such blood cannot enter the Northern Ireland blood stock," said the judge.
- Gay teacher fired from Catholic school after...
- Nelson Mandela was against IRA decommissioning.
- Racist incidents in Ireland up by 85 percent...
- Nelson Mandela once considered a terrorist...
- Unionists regret US envoy Haass’ call for...
- Hollywood star Gabriel Byrne brands new Pope...
- Bill O’Reilly slams Nelson Mandela as an...
- Top ten negative terms used to describe Irish...
- Irish students told “No Irish Need Apply”...
- Irish radio presenter suspended after anti-Isra
He seems to have a strange effect on these womenPhoto shows Irish revolutionaries three years before Easter Rising
It is very unlikely that McDiarmada, Pearse,Ceannt, and Markevievick would Never have supported Partition or pretended that the Southern Irish state iScandal as Rory McIlroy’s former lover Holly bares all in saucy photo shoot
Why not??American widow left out of will of suicide husband who killed their daughter
Some men loose faith in themselves & their manliness & blame anyone & everyone else especially their wives--he probably had a delusion or