News


Leading priest predicts the end of celibacy in the Catholic Church

Three-time Nobel Prize nominee makes remarks on Irish television

32 comments

Return to article

Next Page 1 of 3 pages
It is unfortunate that the Catholic Church does not allow priests to marry. The apostles were married. The restriction of marriage is un-natural. It also attracts those men that have a serious sexual problem & cannot face the real world. I truly hope that Rome changes things quickly. We've seen the results not only in Ireland & the U.S. but all over the world.
This is great news! The Church long allowed marriage and was egalitarian towards women in its hierarchy for a millenium or so, and I eagerly await it findings its roots. As a lawyer, I assure you that the Churche's assets can be structured to keep them out of the hands of spouses, children, etc. BTW, my ancestral name is Byrne (before my great grandfather from Laoighis-Kildare changed it.
I reckon all Irish people would rather the rape of children by priests ended first.
I worked with a woman, who had, sadly, lost a son to AIDS, in 1994. While he was in an HIV section, at old St. Claire's hospital, in NYC, he met many HIV afflicted priests. Though gay himself, this lady's son was dismayed that there were so many homosexual priests in the Catholic Church! He felt that the priesthood shouldn't be a "Gay Men's Club", as it was later described in a segment of "60 Minutes".
Fr. Cullen speaks the truth although he is a bit too tactful. The bishops like in every century were particularly territorial and tyrannical in there rule. They devised up celibacy to defang the married pastors who would pull away from the bishop after a dispute regarding money and other such hot topics. The pastor with the support of wife and family would leave the church property and finances to them. With celibacy every priest would lose his backing and would be forced to remain obedient to his bishop despite how crooked he was. Celibacy is not of God since marriage was God's plan for man and woman. Even in the legend of Christ he never directed any of his followers to be married and in fact, he was married. Scripture must be interpreted that way by necessity since every rabbi was married that is true without having the actual documents the church discarded about the marriage. When Jesus was asked by the young man how to be perfect he never called him to be celibate, but to sell all he had and follow him. The church will have to allow marriage soon because it attracts mostly homosexuals to the ministry. Nearly 8 out of 10 priests are homosexual and that is truly an understatement.
According to statistics and witnesses, who have abandoned the priesthood > The Catholic Church will have to move in the direction of 'Same sex Marriages' next... among the religious ones. That's ok! What is important is that they stop raping and abusing small children!
Reply tp Lambopolis: While your comment is it would seem meant with tongue-in-cheek Donna Woolfolk Cross presents, in her book, Pope Joan a good case for a short reign of a monk John Angelicus as Pope. So perhaps your idea may have some truth. 824 was a turbulent era, Sarecen invasion of the Vatican,poisioning of Pope Leo, presure from the Emperor to seat his man on the throne of Rome, by force if neccesary. The monk, a woman who had received a good Greek education with her brother, took his place when he was killed in a viking raid. She only wanted to serve God and learn the practice of Medicine. In 853 she chosen Pope, only to be found out 2 years later. The writer spent 7 years on research. it's not impossible in such times an inconvient piece of history could be removed. At the council of Nicea, 50 books in use by the early Christians were removed from what we now call the Bible. Those Christian priests and Elders married, Women were a part of the service. The Cathars were the last people who were Gnostic and they were wiped out in France, mid 1,000's. Theybelieved inservingthe poor, or sick in a selfless way, and did not believe in having riches, or having golden implements at their services. THEY seem to have been true followers of Christ's way, too bad Rome didn't see it that way.
About Time!!! Of course, the current backwards thinking and acting Pontiff won't agree but the time has come. Afterall, despite the Church's teaching, deep down I always did believe that Jesus WAS married to Mary (even before the Davinci Code came forth)and that the celebacy stuff was just 'man made.'
May I direct people to John Paul II's Theology of the Body and the Chapters explaining "Continence for the Kingdom" that clearly implied by Jesus as documented in Scripture. It is the best explanation I have read. Calling celibacy a "business arrangement" reveals an attituded grounded in the worldly view of life and a lack of spiritual depth.
I think the popularity of the missionary position will reach unprecedented heights.
Come to think of it, castration for RC priest is not a bad idea. It will cut down on the sex problems.
Well, in the Eastern Roman Empire the threat to alienation of royal property came from generals, not married priests, so priests were allowed to be married and generals were castrated. Of course this practice was surrounded with pious nonsense, such as the court of the emperor resembling that of God in heaven since the angels were sexless and so were the generals. Actually, those cynical Byzantines were probably just exercising a warped sense of humor by using that simile.
With the greatest respect Father John, it is the Catholic church that is falling apart, especially in the face of charismatic Protestant sects and Islam. There was a report in the UK papers about prisoners converting to Islam to get better food. They are better organised and aggressive in seeking converts than than we are. Less and less young Irish and other European people are going to church. I have seen many young European women dressed in hijabs lately. I even saw an Irish guy who had converted to Islam in my local supermarket. I was flabbergasted to hear his Irish accent. As others have correctly stated, celibacy for priests has been in existence since the First Lateran Council in 1123. If the Catholic Church survive the challenge posed by other religions, the first thing it must do is abolish celibacy. That way you will get a greater pool of talent willing to become priests. Secondly, more worldly and younger Popes must be elected. Goodness and holiness is not enough in today's political world. Leave celibacy to the monks. If the Church is not assertive enough in getting its message across to the masses and does not find a way to make itself a central part of people's lives, it will lose more young people who will drift away to atheism, evangelical churches, or be seduced by the uncompromising message of the other religion I have mentioned, which happens to be Europe's fastest growing faith.
FRJohn is out of touch with reality. It's not known if Jesus was married or not was "the Magdalene" his partner in life.Marriage was not forbidden until some pope signed off on it.
I think that ending celebacy would be a good thing. One thing we know is that the ban has not stopped all priests and nuns from sexual contact and then there is the fact that the church is a hiding place for pediphiles! Not that the end of celebacy will totally stop that, but perhaps if priests and nuns were free to marry, it would attract a better field of candidates for both callings.
Next Page 1 of 3 pages




Log into IrishCentral with your Facebook account


or sign-in directly

E-Mail:
Password:
 Remember me Forgot my password
Not a member? Register Now!
print this article Print
email this articleE-mail