Irish woman carrying her father’s child claims they’re in love

Oh my god, this guy played with his daughters feelings, how does she know that he not going to eventually sleep with their baby when it grows up? These two are sweet talking and sugar coding an terrible action they have committed. This is evil act, this what athiesm leads to, relationships and blood just becomes water, blood has no meaning but genetics and DNA, you just need consent of two adult parties to do any action including sexual relationships and incests. They do not need therapy they need public punishment but thats never going to happen in the west. Peace

Oh ya he was born with his skin hanging off his bones no muscle tone at all much like a severe case of cancer he had extreme gargoyle features that at first sugessted downs syndrome which would have been more pronounced as he grew older, n as time went on he could have gone on to be blind, deaf n went on to have encephaly n seizures. His mother I guess because she was shuned by his care givers in the hospital un hooked his stomach tube n tried to walk out with him only to be talked into allowing them to care for him in his first three months in the hospital, he was also addicted to cocaine n extasy as well !! In his two yr short life he was a happy lil guy some days he could roll back n forth on a small bed type playpen my friend had made for him while on a gel pad for his his bones n see lights above him n play with toys dangling from a make shift canopy, n he was very much loved too !! He didn't live long enough to go blind or deaf n never had any seizures either he was smart too she taught him sign language n could tell you when he wanted his bottle, having no muscle tone meant having to assist in bowel movement with suppositories as he would signal with clicking sounds from his throat to tell her !! N of course no one was charged with anything, again no justice for the innocence !!

I have seen the effects of this first hand, one of my friends took a baby in at 3mos old as a catholic hospital was goin to just starve him to death !! He was born with many bone fractures after a difficult labor, which ended up him bein born by ceserian section, he could not suck n had to have special nipples on his bottles. He had a hole in his heart, an enlarged spleen n liver, brital bones that looked like osteoporitis (sp)" , an emlarged tougue that protruded from his mouth, even his skin was effected as he couldnt maintian a constant body temperature, he nevr walked talked or grew any teeth, these poor kids should they live passed the age of two yrs go through a lot n that depends on how close the genetic make up is ( he was the product of a brother n sisiter)r he was put on morphine for his bone pain after a nurse tried to burp him n broke his rib, you could not really hold him because he hurt constantly his digestive system was severly compromised as he could not digest milk or meat he had to survive on a milk substitute n fruit n veggies alone, he couldn't even sit comfortably in an upright position for any length of time cause of his bone problems, during his short 2 year life he contracted pneumonia twice in his last four months of life, n his tiny 2 yr old14 lb body could not utilize antibiotics at all as he was on them just after his birth that caused him to develop an ingruinal hernia, and again when he had the 2 bouts of pneumonia, so all in all the docs said that they couldn't even operate on the hernia because the force of putting an oxygen tube down his throat would have broke his neck, so anyone who thinks this father daughter thing isn't a bad idea what ya think now ??

Hermittalker, what does any of this stuff about abortion have to do with this article about incest?

I agree with hermitTalker on this. Well said. Wish America would wake up.

This is as unnatural, and hence immoral (what is deemed unnatrual is also immoral) as any mother who desires to abort her own baby. That sadly is legal in most nations now and the Lefties are pushing for it in Ireland. When will we stop, look, and listen to the Law nature plants in our bodies and hearts? The Lefties are now trying to legalise same-gender attraction to children by adults and also advocating the killing of an unwanted baby. Those who blasted the Human Nature dam with their immoral nuke language have one heck of a flood to answer for.

How sad that they couldn't see that their love was for Father and Daughter and it took a different path... It is both of their faults for letting this happen. She is of age of making her own decisions and he as a father should not have let it go in that direction.... Their may not be anything showing abnormal in the child at this time, but there are hidden defects that may show in the next or later generations.. the odds are for that to take place... This is a situation that a court should take over. If you were the child how would you feel about this when you grew up??? I would want to be adopted and not know the situation of my real parents... Real dilemma for this child...

They both need mental help! He should have been a father to her, not a lover. That's unnatural and against nature. They really need to seek counseling!

If ever the word Poxy was going to apply to a situation! YUK! So the baby could be a poxy boggard..YIKES

Murph46, Im mortified to think that you and I share the same surname. You are an embarressment to the Murphy name and any Irish link you may have. Idiot.

Ballindaggin, what does the royal family have to do with this? Am I missing something? I think this is a very sad situation. I was under the impression that the reason behind it being illegal is the basic genetics issues, not necessarily the moral implications which is really none of my business. I personally don't like it but it's not up to me to decide how others should live their lives. It's between them and their God. There are certainly enough "redneck" jokes about finding your wife at the family reunion here in the US.

What a filthy b*****d this 'father' is. Should be put before the courts and jailed for life.

It's a sad state of affairs. Very sad. Very wrong. Intensely wrong. Horrifically wrong.

I could not finish the story, it is sicking, ...incest! As her Father donated DNA to her Mother, and she is the result of that union, regardless if he stuck around or not! Where ever they are, the laws of the land should judge their "union" whether it is legal or illegal, as per that area where they are and coupled! And both should face any consequences from their fornication, regardless of my thoughts or view-point. It is sick and gross and both knew of the genetics before meeting! Premeditated?

Where is the boundry between a long lost father and daughter??? Quite upsetting, I think.