Irish refuse Canadian citizenship because of swearing oath to Queen
No bowing to a monarch, fight to have requirement declared unconstitutional
Instead, according to the Globe and Mail, the group will be in a Toronto courtroom on Friday in a high profile showdown with the federal government to have the citizenship requirement of an oath to the queen declared unconstitutional.
Among the prospective citizens now suing is Michael McAteer, 79, a long-time anti Monarchist who grew up in Ireland but has lived in Canada since 1964. He has never been able to become a citizen because of his refusal to swear the oath.
McAteer, a former journalist at the Toronto Star, calls the monarchy an anachronistic institution ill-suited to Canada’s multicultural society.
'I obey the law. I’ve probably seen more of Canada than most Canadians. I’ve shovelled my sidewalk, and you know, paid taxes,' he said. 'I feel very comfortable here, in Canada. But still, after all that, I still cannot become a Canadian citizen.'
Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper has recently dedicated his administration to reviving the country's connection to the monarchy, so the republican group may have quite a fight on their hands.
The government is expected to argue that immigrants who disagree with the idea of a hereditary head of state, and refuse to swear an oath of loyalty to the Queen, simply do not deserve the benefits of citizenship.
'The inability to enjoy the benefits of citizenship – to hold a Canadian passport and to vote – are amongst the costs reasonably borne by individuals whose personal beliefs run contrary to Canada’s foundational constitutional structure,' a lawyer for the federal Attorney-General says in the written arguments submitted before Friday’s hearing.
But the Toronto lawyer for the group fighting the oath, Peter Rosenthal, said that position was surprising: 'The Attorney-General has taken the position that if you don’t believe in the monarchy, it’s appropriate to deny you the right to vote. That’s pretty extraordinary, given the fact that more than half of Canadians don’t believe in the monarchy.'
Friday's court fight is not the first of its kind. In fact it's just the latest chapter in more than 20 years of failed legal challenges to the Canadian citizenship oath led by Trinidadian-born Toronto activist and lawyer Charles Roach, who died last year at 79, never having become a Canadian citizen.
Roach, a long-time friend of Rosenthal's, refused to swear the oath and become a citizen because he believed the Queen was a symbol of imperialism and because of injustices done to his ancestors in the name of the British monarchy.
15 - 45 | See all comments
- Gay wedding cakes latest target of anti-gay...
- Racist incidents in Ireland up by 85 percent...
- An open letter in strong defence of capitalism.
- A Magdalene Laundry US adoptee who holds...
- Irish radio presenter suspended after anti-Isra
- Gay teacher fired from Catholic school after...
- Families as well as Catholic Church and governm
- Nelson Mandela was against IRA decommissioning.
- Baby dies in horror birth at Belfast hospital...
- Bill O’Reilly slams Nelson Mandela as an...
was a scene in the film " the treaty" where Brendan Gleason as collins said that although we werent going to be a great power,we could makeNelson Mandela was against IRA decommissioning its arms during 2000 talks
Mandela would have sold his Soul to have kept the support of the Western Media. The Republican Irish were not fighting Racist Apartheid; They were wagGay wedding cakes latest target of anti-gay bigots
Lol, check out the comments below. The rural culchies and donkeys are getting their panties in a bunch over this. Bocktherobber takes the cake though,An open letter in strong defence of capitalism to Pope Francis
Curitiba - Thank you. I know. In the US, however and in Ireland where I live part time, a surprising number of people do not realise that.