News


Emergency crew told mom to give dying son soda

The mother feels ‘guilty’ for the death of her 11 year old boy



Guinness PubFinder Ad

A mother claims that paramedics advised her to give her fatal son 7UP, after she placed a call to 999 to have the sick child transported to a hospital.

Her son, Leonardo Sala, 11, of Mount Andrew Court in Lucan, Co Dublin, died of acute inflammation of the colon, secondary to chronic constipation at the Children's University Hospital in Temple Street, Dublin on July 21, 2010.

The mother, Marial Sala, told the coroner’s court that she placed a phone call to the emergency telephone number twice on July 20 as her son, who had an underlying condition called mitochondrial disease, appeared to be tremendously ill.

The grieving mother explained that she placed the first phone call at around 5 pm, and the ambulance arrived minutes later. In tears, Sala told the hearing she expected the first ambulance to take her son to the hospital right away. Instead, she says the paramedic told her there was "not a problem" with Leonardo and that all he needed was water and 7Up. Sala said the paramedic also suggested for the child to stop the laxative medication after she showed it to him.

-------------------

READ MORE: 

New inquest into 1973 Satanic killing that shocked Ireland

Dead man found with golf ball lodged in his mouth

Irish mother who died of hypothermia had begged for heating

-------------------

The second phone call was placed later on, and at 10:27 pm the ambulance arrived to take the child, accompanied by his father Antonio, to Tallaght Hospital. He was then transferred to the Temple Street hospital for intensive care where he died the next day.

Sala, who speaks Portuguese, told the coroner she felt "guilty" for son’s death. "The way the young man explained the situation. He was so confident…so sure there was no problem… they (the parents) did not ask him to take the child (to hospital). The way he said it, they thought there was no problem," said her interpreter George Mopinga.

The paramedic of the first ambulance, Gary Marson, told the coroner he had no recollection of the event.  He then said that as a paramedic, he would never refuse to take a patient to the hospital, especially if the mother was requesting for her child to be taken.

"There was obviously a language barrier,” Marson said. “All of the information was not communicated to us," he concluded.

The Irish Independent reports that Sergeant Mark Campbell told the coroner's court that there was a language and communication issue which led to the misunderstanding, and subsequently to the child’s death.


Nster.com


13 Comments

See all comments

@ Pittsburkid, your comment sounds like it is coming from a person who speaks English as a second language. There's nothing wrong with that except in the context of your comment about languages, America and immigration "problems". The nonsense about President Obama sounds like it's coming from a person who doesn't have a clue.
Since when do paramedics wait for the parents to tell them to take a child to the hospital? And if there was any sense of a language barrier the paramedic should have erred on the side of safety and brought the child in or else gotten someone to translate. This incident does sound fishy.
This is a fishy story. The paramedic cannot give medical advice as he said himself. They are trained for emergencies not diagnosing and managing medical conditions. Nor do they get to decide who needs to go to the hospital and who doesn't. That is not their training. Why did they leave without the patient....the parents didn't insist? why didn't the Paramedics just take the child? Someone is lying.
kinvara7 he is a racist and bigoted pig who shouldn't even be addressed..Well said though!
@Pittsburghkid: 'America is great because we speak one language.' Yeah, that's not accurate, but if you are referring to English might I remind you that that is a European language which was brought to America by migrants. In any event, you are not an authority on what makes America great, so you should desist from posting ignorant comments. This was a tragic and unfortunate event and my sympathies go out to the family of the deceased.
Another immigrant problem. People do not understand the importance of communication. In America, we have people that want to have two language. Obama said he was ashamed of Americans, because most Europeans can speak two or three languages. America is great because we speak one language. So much for that fool Obama. Migrants should not live in a country, unless they can speak the language. Now this person, who should have stayed in Portigual, then her son would be alive. Next she is going to sue the poor people of Ireland for malpractice. After she gets her million, then she will go home. Wait a minute, wasn't the first story about an Irish migrant in New York, because there is no work in Ireland. Maybe if they through out the migrant the wages would go up. Illegal Aliens bring poverity to the country they migrate to. Americans can tell you that.
Ignorant people!!! Who said the parents of the deceased d child weren't trying to learn English??!! It takes 5-7 YEARS to achieve native-like fluency. Perhaps they were newly arrived or just panicked about their sick child. I'm willing to bet that all those who scream about learning English have never lived in a foreign country and been forced to live their daily lives in a strange language! Try it some time and you might have some empathy for those millions who have done it. It isn't easy. My city has a "language bank" for situations just like this one where miscommunication can be the difference between life and death. A simple telephone conversation with someone who speaks both English and Portuguese could have averted this tragedy.
@akellyny, there was no universal American Indian language. There were as many tribal languages and dialects as there were different tribes of Indians found across the U.S. The French and English who traded with a tribe, often learned the language of that tribe and many of the Indians learned English to varying degrees. I think if you choose to live in a foreign country, you should learn the native language of that country and its culture. If I moved to Ireland, I would expect to have to adapt to Irish culture and learn Irish ways of doing things.
Hell NO , I speak English. If the Spanish speaking people can't learn English let them go back where they came from.
Then why isn't anyone in America speaking American Indian? It won't be long before everyone in the states has to speak Spanish as well as English. Will you all be willing to do so?
I think people who don't make an effort to learn the language of the place they live should realize they are at a disadvantage. I'm sorry if the child died when he could have been saved but these things happen when there is a language barrier.
I took my daughter in for her written driver license test. If you do not speak English you can bring an interpreter so you can take the test.
This is what happens when people arrive in a new country and do not make a concernted effort to learn the native language. In California the state administers the driver's test in 27 languages - and I do not want to be on the stree with someone who cannot read simpe signs.
 




Log into IrishCentral with your Facebook account


or sign-in directly

E-Mail:
Password:
 Remember me Forgot my password
Not a member? Register Now!
print this article Print
email this articleE-mail