NEW YORK BOSTON |#Popular: Irish Celebrity Gossip Irish in US Politics Irish Festivals Irish Roots Irish Entertainment Offbeat Irish

Home Page > News > Dublin Archbishop calls for independent inquiry into pedophile Fr Brendan Smyth

Dublin Archbishop calls for independent inquiry into pedophile Fr Brendan Smyth

Stance puts him in direct opposition to Vatican who oppose external inquiries

DARA KELLY,

IrishCentral Staff Writer

Published Monday, May 7, 2012, 7:21 AM

Updated Monday, May 7, 2012, 10:18 AM

Larger Text

E-mail

14 Comments

Archbishop of Dublin Diarmuid Martin

Photo by Google Images

He said, “I don’t know what the relationship between him and bishop [McKiernan of Kilmore] was. I don’t know what the bishop did, what he knew the bishop did...Looking back at the Dublin inquiry I’ve seen that these are complex questions and I wouldn’t like to judge a person on things that I don’t know.”

Commenting on the Vatican censures of liberal Irish priests, he said: “I believe, and I’ve said this before, we do need to have a way in which if things are said or written which go outside the realm of Catholic teaching, they should be resolved in an area of dialogue.”

“I think the theological commission of the Irish bishops has not carried out its function as in other countries where this dialogue would take place as a first stage and then be resolved without it necessarily being dealt with from Rome directly.”

Colm O'Gorman, an abuse survivor and director of Amnesty International Ireland, said that an inquiry would have to also examine the role of the Vatican and thus would require its cooperation.

“An investigation that required Vatican cooperation would of course offer them the opportunity to show they would not undermine or obstruct!” O’Gorman tweeted.

Meanwhile, a chorus of voices have called for the resignation of Cardinal Sean Brady, who failed to protect the children he knew were being abused by Smyth.

Cardinal Sean Brady's method of interviewing victims of the sexual abuse in the 1970s, without the knowledge of the parents, has been described as "bizarre” by The Bishop of Ardagh and Clonmacnoise.

Speaking to RTE's "This Week" Bishop Colm O'Reilly agreed that the practice of secretly interviewing such children was wrong but also said that in his view Cardinal Sean Brady should not resign as he acted in good faith and did what was required of him at the time.

Last page < 1 2

Nster.com

E-mail

14 Comments

See all comments

pilib04 | May 08, 2012, 08:15 PM EDT

Gaelic scholar, IrelandNorth does the blog a service by providing such interesting information. Go raibh maith agat.

Report abuse

eiriamach | May 08, 2012, 02:42 PM EDT

I just read in the Belfast Telegraph that Cardinal Brady will not resign. How did he decide? you might ask. Well, he decided not by praying and asking for enlightenment from God, not by consulting public opinion, not by asking why still more Catholics are exiting the Church in anger, nor even by examining his own conscience. He decided by asking the Vatican: "Dr Brady said there was no indication from the Holy See that it wanted him to resign." Is there anyone besides the cardinal who does not see what's wrong with his decision procedure?

Report abuse

McNamara31 | May 08, 2012, 12:19 PM EDT

The Vatican will be VERY concerned if a bishop or cardinal were to resign because they are the legal buffer and storm wall between what was carried out between the churches (worldwide) and the Vatican during decades of abuse claims. All the Vatican needs is a very “disgruntled” cardinal or bishop opening up and naming names and internal policies. Why else was Cardinal Law given prestige and beautiful basilica in Rome when such crimes had occurred on his watch in Boston? His silence was rewarded.

Report abuse

eiriamach | May 08, 2012, 07:57 AM EDT

casualMBA, what kind of English language do you speak? Excluding women from fully participating in their religion, such as in the priesthood, IS misogynist. Do you have the delusion that you can blatantly discriminate against an entire group and still consider them equal to you? Has some male priest convinced you that it's morally OK to exclude women and not consider yourself a hypocrite when you say you believe in the equal moral value of everyone?

Report abuse

IrelandNorth | May 08, 2012, 06:03 AM EDT

Shalom, EpharimKibbey! Avoiding inheritance ri[gh]tes was a major motivating factor in the Holy Roman Catholic and Apostolic Church's (HRC&AC's) proscription of it's clergy marrying. But patriarchal and misogynistic failure to appreciate the concept of sacred sexuality and the divine feminine was not without its consequences. Surnames in Irish like Mac An Aspeg (Mock-un-Osspig)/(AngSax translit - Mc Anespy, literally means "son of the bishop". And Mac An t'Saggart (phon/pron Mock Un Toggirt - AngSax translit - McEntaggart literally means "son of the priest". Cleary inferring clerical matrimonialism early on. Anyone with such names might qualify for an unanticipated windfall.

Report abuse

casualMBA | May 07, 2012, 11:36 PM EDT

By way of clarification, OPPOSITION to women priests does NOT imply a "misogynist" policy...all of which, is not germane to the Archbishop's call for independent inquiry.

Report abuse

casualMBA | May 07, 2012, 11:23 PM EDT

BytheBay, Are you drunk? An end to celibacy is one thing; women priests are another. And, No, women as priests is NOT a concept of APOSTOLIC CONTINUITY, OR proof (or even intimation) of "misogynist" policy.

Report abuse

Collette2 | May 07, 2012, 09:06 PM EDT

Your exacly right Ephraim. An international investigation is the only way to deal with this, beginning at the top. Have the United Nations et al take it on, we've sat back and watched the others brought to account, why the reluctance to deal with the Catholic church.

Report abuse

Bythebay | May 07, 2012, 03:09 PM EDT

Kudos to Father Ignatius O'Donnell and the other Irish priests in the Association of Catholic Priests at the Conference on the Future of the Catholic Church in Ireland today in Dublin. Calls were made for an end to clergy celibacy as well as for women priests. Well done, long past time to take control of the church. Out with Martin, Brady et al.

Report abuse

EphraimKibbey | May 07, 2012, 01:40 PM EDT

@Messiah - you bring up a good point. This problem is not just a Smyth/Brady problem. If there is going to be an INTERNATIONAL investigation, it should be empowered to look into pedophilia worldwide and the Roman Catholic Church should be required to provide ALL their records of accusations against their personel. The only way this evil that infests the church is ever going to go away is for them to make full disclosure and surrender ALL the criminals to the world court for trial. Once the nest of evil has been cleaned out, pedophiles will know that they are no longer going to be able to find a safe haven in the ranks of the priesthood and will stop joining. I just learned yesterday that celibacy and the ban on marriage stems from the middle ages when the church became worried that priests and church officials were willing church property to their heirs. The church stopped this practice by saying that priests could not have any legitimate heirs because they had to take a vow of celibacy and were not allowed to marry. Greed and avarice seem to make the world go round even in the church! Once again we see that the solution to one problem has created numerous others.

Report abuse

Messiah | May 07, 2012, 12:44 PM EDT

All Glory to Achbishop Martin, I have ecently eported after many an occasion beore a FurtheR Teasonious Cover up in the Archdiocese of Dublin. i made a Statement to a Monsignor who Lied to me about his knowledge of the Priest Harry Moore that abused me in 1983 as a minor. The Statement was made in Feb 1999. Late that year the Priest Reported himself in his Guilt and remorse as I his only ever Victim. Coincidence Looms. The priest ran a Statute of Limitations challenge on Delayed reporting for 5.5 years. After Conviction I sought Justice in Civil Court as priest given Lenient Sentence of non custodial. Then at Settlement evidence produced by church proving he was in Psychiatric Treatment in England for similar offence from 1982. Then after a Persecution that continues today the Murphy Report proved the Monsignor I made a Statement to knew the Priest and was his actual Supervisor since the early 90's. The Monsignor failed to provide that Decades of evidence to the Gardai in 1999 and any period After. The archbishop recognised at our meeting last March the Handwriting of the Monsignor involved. But he is not calling for an Investigation into that Corruption and obvious Cover up. They destroyed my Life Recovery plans and stripped me by crimes of my Right and the settlement which the archbishop seemingly Supports. The Solicitor involved in my Persecution is Colm O'Gorman ex Solicitor.

Report abuse

CelticQueenUSA | May 07, 2012, 11:51 AM EDT

We already know what a crimminal Smyth was. He is dead and I think his crimes have been sufficiently substantiated. Let's get on with prosecuting the living, breathing crimminals that are due punishment TODAY for what they ARE DOING!!!

Report abuse

ejclizzie | May 07, 2012, 10:30 AM EDT

Asking the Bishop to resign over the fact that he did not do enough in some people's estimation sounds a lot like Joe Paterno and the Penn State mess. He was not even given the dignity of being able to resign.

Report abuse

Murph46 | May 07, 2012, 10:12 AM EDT

Puuleease move on!

Report abuse