Are British making same mistakes with Muslims they made with Irish?
Gareth Peirce is famed for her fierce commitment to her clients, meticulous attention to detail, tireless hard work and for not wanting the spotlight to fall on herself, rather her clients. The acclaimed human rights lawyer, whose career has spanned over 30 years, has appeared for the Birmingham Six, Judith Ward, the family of Jean Charles de Menezes and Moazzam Begg, among others.
It has been said that when Gareth Peirce takes a case, both journalists’ and lawyers’ ears prick up. It’s little wonder. For more than 20 years, Peirce has represented many wrongly accused Irish men and women who stood trial in England with over 20 successful appeals, including the case of the Guildford Four, who were convicted of an IRA bomb attack in 1974. They were later freed by the Court of Appeal.
Her recent essays for the London Review of Books were written, she says, as an urgent SOS in relation to torture and complicity in Britain.
Speaking last week at the LRB bookshop in central London she spoke about how the moment is here to confront these issues, helped in part by the fact that there is a new Government in place under whose watch these did not happen.
Peirce’s essays call for an accounting of the British Government’s activities in the torture, rendition and internment without trial of those suspected of involvement in terrorism. She notes that while the Obama administration - under pressure from its anti-war base - has begun to release select evidence of the widespread use of torture in the War on Terror, Britain remains almost completely in the dark about the part its intelligence services and Government played. A judicial review into Britain’s role in torture and rendition since September 2001 was only announced in July by the coalition Government.
Peirce has been at the heart of some of the biggest cases heard in British courts. Since the 1970s she has represented many in their appeals against wrongful convictions made on the basis of disputed scientific evidence, misidentification and police malpractice.
She started life as a student at Cheltenham’s Ladies College, later studied at Oxford and then began working in the United States, where in the 1960’s she experienced the civil rights movement. On her return to Britain she completed a postgraduate at the London School of Economics and was recruited by the law firm run by Benedict Birnberg.
But despite her fame and fierce reputation – Peirce was played by actress Emma Thompson in the controversial film about the Guildford Four, In The Name Of The Father - she is in person a softly spoken woman, eyes gazing out serenely from beneath an unruly fringe.
Her first question to a captive audience at the LRB bookshop is to ask if she can be heard at the back of the room. “I know I have a quiet voice,” she says into the microphone with a smile, “which is useful only sometimes for getting into police stations when I’m not expected.”
24 Comments
See all comments
Report abuse
Frankly, it sounds like saloon talk to me. In idle conversation, nybody can get up and make the most extreme statements about people they've never even met. That's why, when you publish something likely to be controversial, you're usually prepared to support your own statements. However, maloney shares his secrets only with people whom he "respects" - a group that does not include the readers of Irish Central.
It's still worth a try to ask somebody to document their reasons for their opinions. Who knows? From time to time, you may encounter somebody who genuinely plays it straight.
Report abuse
Report abuse
Your opinions aren't based on anything real. You put more care into whether or not you'll carry an umbrella in the morning than your enmity towards people of the Muslim faith. Tell the truth. You get everything you know about Muslims from tabloid newspapers or tabloid television, don't you?
Report abuse
Report abuse
Report abuse
Report abuse
Research out of the University of Chicago shows that certain policies promote suicide terrorism as certainly as night follows day. Professor Robert Pape's book Dying to Win: The Strategic Logic of Suicide Terrorism shows that suicide terrorism is mainly a response to foreign occupation. Unfortunately, both the American and the British governments have adopted policies that maximize the likelihood of local terrorism, possibly because at some level they seek to justify deprivation of civil liberties.
Eventually there may be an incident so brutal, tragic and unnecessary that even right wingers may seek more humane policies. In the meantime, however, it's easily seen which groups are personally affected by preventable tragedy and which aren't. George Bush, at no risk to himself, famously provoked Middle East terrorists, saying Bring it on.
Report abuse
Report abuse
Report abuse
Report abuse
Report abuse
Report abuse
Report abuse
- Michelle Obama and daughters trace their...
- Former church spokesman criticised for using...
- Daily Mail unloads on 'drunken young' Paddys...
- President Obama’s visit to North comes at...
- Sinn Fein deputy leader speaks out against...
- Body of Irish immigrant tossed in medical...
- Good Morning America says Sasha and Malia...
- North’s Minister for Finance accuses Republic...
- Irish kids receive almost $700 in Holy Communio
- Shock as Irish priest praises Prime Minister’s.
24 Comments



Irish Central readers could take your statements at face value if they knew you by reputation. But this is an anonymous forum! The only way we'd know to believe you is if you support your arguments with facts from credible sources. In this regard you are not being singled out.
Report abuse