News


21 Catholic priests suspended in Philadelphia over sexual abuse allegations

'Astonishing' suspensions follow grand jury report which names 37 offending priests


Cardinal Justin Rigali, Archbishop of Philadelphia
Cardinal Justin Rigali, Archbishop of Philadelphia
Photo by AP

Guinness PubFinder Ad

Read more: Dramatic scenes as Archbishops wash abuse victim’s feet - SEE POLL
 
The Archdiocese of Philadelphia has suspended 21 priests following accusations of sexual abuse and inappropriate behavior with minors.  This is the largest suspension taken by the Roman Catholic Church in its history, the President of BishopAccountability.org told “The New York Times.”

This action follows a damning grand jury report issued on February 10.  It accused the archdiocese of a massive cover-up stretching over decades. The report said as many as 37 priests remained active in the community despite the serious accusations against them.

As of now 21 of these 37 priests have been suspended, and three have been placed on administrative leave. Five others would also have been suspended, but the archdiocese said three of them were no longer active and the other two no longer served in the archdiocese.

A statement issued by the archdiocese said the accusations ranged from "sexual abuse of a minor to boundary issues with minors.”  It did not name the 21 priests who were suspended.

Initially Cardinal Justin Rigali denied there were any active priests in the archdiocese "who have an admitted or established allegation of sexual abuse of a minor against them.”

Just days later he placed three of the priests on leave. The statement released on Tuesday did not explain why he was initially so sure about their innocence, or why they had not been suspended earlier.

Leonard Norman Primiano, a Roman Catholic and chairman of the religious studies department at Cabrini College in nearby Radnor, Pennsylvania, called the suspensions "astonishing.”

Rigali apologized for the behavior of the offending priests. "I am truly sorry for the harm done to the victims of sexual abuse, as well as to the members of our community who suffer as a result of this great evil and crime,” he said.

The priests who have been suspended cannot celebrate Mass, wear collars or hear confessions. They were given just a few hours to leave their parishes.

Once their identities become public, it is believed that there could be a dam-breaking effect, just like Boston in 2002, when the initial reports lead to further sexual-abuse claims.

Since the grand jury filed the report two more people have file complaints. Lawyer Jeff Anderson, who represents these two people, said he had received dozens of calls from others.

He said, "We’re approaching this with a new vigor.  Like Boston, this is a watershed moment, where all of a sudden the secrets are no longer kept and permission is given to break the silence to this whole survivors’ community.”

The Catholic Church could face a payout of millions of dollars in settlements if the complaints are upheld. Membership and parochial school enrollment in the church have declined.


Nster.com


64 Comments

15 - 64 | See all comments

Name names! Out of the closets you freaks!
Hope ye all keep the faith. We/I need you up front before us/me to keep showing us the right path to our Lord. Stay strong (I'll even pray for ye)There are not so many behind my generation. I seem to be my only peer on Sundays now, especially in my parish. It's not easy but I feel comfort to have your generation leading the way and it keeps me strong. When your generation is called by our Lord, I'll draw comfort in knowing that you were there before me. Thank you!
@mamaginnty - You're too kind. As I have said previously, I'm really nerw to posting stuff ANYWHERE. I am just so profoundly saddened and angry at all that has come to pass within my church. I still dont know if I should stick with it or leave it to its fate; I dont really want to leave so I stick with it, but now look at it through a totally new set of eyes!!
I am not going to talk about the church, said my bit weeks ago, just wanted to say I really enjoyed reading the comments between sirpeter and barnyjoe, nice change to see two people having an intelligent conversation with just a hint of banter, thanks lads.
St.Peter and St.Paul who are as high up as it gets are the dual Patron Saints of Philadelphia. They will be having a pint with Patrick tomorrow March 17th to celebrate not only himself but this 'historic event' They have a wearisome time with us mortals. Takes centuries to get any done. Slainte.
I think the Catholic church should be abolished, and these perpetrators should be imprisoned for life - forget suspension, what's up with that? If they worked for any other institution, they'd be in jail.
The Catholic Church has alot to make up for because of these perverts. Just think of all of the money the Church has spent in payments made to those who have suffered at the hands of these priests. There are retired nuns who have given their lives in service to the Church & today they live on donations from people. The Church won't even support them.. It looks like the Church is a old boys club run by old boys for old boys. It just makes you sick to see these men getting bailed out for their misdeeds & holy nuns left out in the cold by the Catholic Church. Where is the Charity in this? No wonder so many young women don't go into the convent these days!!
@anyonewhocares - I just watched the second part of a dramatiisation of the Father Brendan Smyth affair which in large measure was the catalyst for the revelations of Clerical Child abuse in Ireland. The drama is based on the book "Brendan Smyth - Betrayal of Trust" which was originally published in 1995. I read it when it was first published. I had forgotten the impact it had on me until this evening when I watched this. My God I am so angry I could scream!!!!
@sirpeter - absolutely;I couldnt have put it better myself.....save but for one element that is missing from your thinking; that is choice. All the societies, races and individuals took the paths they did; but they had a choice; they could have taken a different path, and by definition history would have been different. Such is the case with your standpoint with reference to English maltreatment of the Irish through the ages. You choose (as do others) the right to hold the present British Establishment to account for past wrongs. For many Irish, and in particular those who are almost a generation removed from the "Troubles" they take a different view. We are all "victims of circumstance" to a greater or lesser extent. For myself, I do know I was a victim of the divisions within Irish Society. I also now realise that I was a victim of the Catholic Church and its dogma of "feel the guilt" With age comes wisdom and I now realise that I can "choose" not to be a second class citizen in my own land, and I can choose not to be a victim of dogma, which I am doing on both counts and it is a path I intend to continue upon!!
barneyjo..Quoet"show me one colonial power that hasnt done the same in history, in preservance of its own self interest"Unquoet. Since the dawn of man,there has been the Oppressor and the Oppressed.England was oppressed by, let's say the Roman's, and then became the oppressor. The logical conclusion to that argument,to which I agree, is once a nation becomes militarily strong,it inflicts pain on other less powerful nation's.This has been the way through out history.Therefore if you happen to be the one been oppressed,that's tough luck.To be honest I have no problem with that. As you say a case of wrong time, wrong place!! BUT!! Then you would have to agree that Hitler and Germany was just keeping the trend going, and it was just tough luck on the Jews and the rest of Europe.Another case of wrong time, wrong place!! for the Jews. Germany got what it deserved,and no one would disagree with that (not many anyway)Even the bombing of Hamburg and Dresden. Case of wrong time, wrong place!! Many Muslims believe they are been oppressed by the USA and it's support for Israel.Sometimes a few of the oppressed resist and fight back in the limited options that the oppressed have.Therefore 9/11 is just another case of wrong time, wrong place!! The people in the Northern Ireland were oppressed too.The IRA chose their limited options to resist. This to is a case of wrong time, wrong place!! If this is the case, and the oppressor nation chooses to throw morality to one side and oppress,then what right has the oppressor to make a moral judgment on anybody.
Wow. 21. That's blackjack. The church is a real winner
"Suspended" thats all???? This makes me glad I am not Catholic. I thought a priest was supposed to protect children, to teach, guide, be God's right hand man. I think they need to be strung up by their 'bal..' I will supply the twine, tie it tight and they will fall off. There is no amount of pain that can be inflicted to a spoiler of children.. NO matter what religeon, nationality, race, or what ever you may be..I commend your soul to the devil for eternity.
@sirpeter - hard to argue with your views on England. The sad truth though is that Ireland is but one country which had colonialism inflicted upon it by an Imperial Empire. And I could never accept that there is a "sliding scale" for injustice or victimhood. Britian as a colonial power has used its size 10s to walk over the rights and aspiratons of many peoples throughout the centuries. But then again, show me one colonial power that hasnt done the same in history, in preservance of its own self interest. Ireland's fate was to be the closest and most easily conquerable landmass to Britain, which was subdued by sheer weight of numbers; a case of wrong time, wrong place!!
Pat - you have hit the nail on the head. The very notion of Catholic is blown out of the water by your post. As you rightly say, there are Orthodox churches in eastern europe that permit their clergy to marry, though their bishops may not. Add to that their "affiliation" to the Holy See, and recognising the Bishop of Rome as their titular head. So the Pope recognises one set of rules for one church, and different rules for another. Little wonder then that the reference from Scripture comes to mind "A House divided against itself will not stand!!"
'Tis sad, but the fact is that the Church cannot back down from it's many wrong policies. Celibacy for priests didn't go into effect until the Eleventh Century, about the same time that the Church proclaimed the Pope infallible and the head of the Church. Priests can still marry in the Orthodox Church, and some Eastern Rite Roman Churches allow marriage by the priests. It is time that the rest of the Catholic world stops letting Rome dictate how Priests conduct their lives. We need to stop supporting the Church - that would stop the idiocy in a hurry.




Log into IrishCentral with your Facebook account


or sign-in directly

E-Mail:
Password:
 Remember me Forgot my password
Not a member? Register Now!
print this article Print
email this articleE-mail