Entertainment


Saoirse Ronan says she's glad Jackson refused to film rape and murder scenes

'Why would anyone want to see the rape and murder of a 14-year-old?'


Saoirse Ronan: Irish actress defends 'Lovely Bones' producer for keeping out rape and murder scenes
Saoirse Ronan: Irish actress defends 'Lovely Bones' producer for keeping out rape and murder scenes

IrishCentral.com Poll

Do you think 'Lovely Bones' should have included rape and murder scene?

No. What kind of monster needs to see that in a movie?


Yes. The movie should stay faithful to the book's author


Irish actress Saoirse Ronan has defended Peter Jackson for refusing to film the rape and murder of Saoirse's character in his adaptation of "The Lovely Bones."

Fans of the Alice Sebold book have blasted Jackson and his co-producer wife Fran Walsh for leaving out the scene.

Ronan - who plays the 14-year-old Susie Salmon - said she can't understand why anybody would want to see such horrific images.

She says, "To be honest, I really don't know why anyone would want to see a 14-year-old girl raped in a movie and killed.

"I feel very strongly about this. That's certainly not the type of movie that... (we) wanted to make. And Peter Jackson or not, that was not the kind of movie that I would want to be in. Plus, Susie actually runs away from her murder so the story is fuelled by that. By her going on this journey to trying to understand what happened to her body.

"That scene is very, very intense. So I think if we had put something else in, anything else, it would have completely overwhelmed the story."

Saoirse is a hot contender for a 2011 Oscar nomimnation for her role in the movie. Critics have raved over her portrayal of the story's murdered heroine.

Saoirse of course was nominated for Best Supporting Actress in 2008 for her portrayal of Briony Tallis in "Atonement."


Nster.com


3 Comments

See all comments

Bravo Peter Jackson for thinking it through and determining that a great movie can be made without teenage rape scenes. To those bozos who read the book and demanded the same content in the movie, one must remember that the paper page and the silver screen are two very different media that require different approaches.
It is a most difficult topic to begin with. The film was excellent, those scenes were unneccessary. The horror of the event was well telegraphed to the audience. Saoirse you did a fantastic job, we love you darling!
It's not necessary to rub people's nose's in something as disturbing as a rape and murder of a young girl. A book is one form of art, and a movie is another! The imagination will enable the reader or watcher to get the point. There is no need for lurid and gory displays of such a horrific act!
 




Log into IrishCentral with your Facebook account


or sign-in directly

E-Mail:
Password:
 Remember me Forgot my password
Not a member? Register Now!
print this article Print
email this articleE-mail