Northern Irish children tortured to admit to murders

24 cases already overturned, more expected to be investigated

Larger Text

Print

E-mail

24 Comments

Charlie McMenamin complained of violent treatment during interrogation by RUC officers

Tweet

During the Troubles, hundreds of men and women were convicted of terrorist activities on the basis of convictions that in many cases were beaten out of them in the 1970s, 80s, and 90s.  Among them were children as young as 14 and 16 who were tortured for days on end.
The Diplock court system allowed for convictions  on the basis of  confessions only, and non jury trials.A pervasive culture of forcing confessions to win convictions has now been revealed by a Guardian newspaper investigation

The Guardian report probes the outcome of The Criminal Cases Review Commission, which investigates possible miscarriages of justice in England, Wales and Northern Ireland,. The commission to date  overturned 24 convictions in Northern Ireland and it says that it has received applications from 200 people who claim torture  while in custody during the Troubles.

According to officers of the Royal Ulster Constabulary (RUC,) interviewed by the Guardian the torture  began after the establishment of the Diplock Courts in 1973, a system of non-jury courts named after Lord Diplock. The courts treated terrorist offences as criminal rather than political, and with the case heard in front of a judge rather than a jury, a confession alone could secure a conviction.

According to The Guardian newspaper, Charlie McMenamin, from Derry, was 16 when he was arrested on suspicion of involvement in the murder of a police officer. He had neither an adult nor a solicitor present, but he claims he was beaten, slapped, kicked while on the ground, and threatened. Some of his hair had been ripped out, a contemporary medical report showed. He was entirely innocent and was 75 miles away from the location of the police officer’s murder at the time and the director of public prosecutions recognized this at the time and recommended the case be dropped.

It wasn’t and he was induced to plead guilty – by his solicitor and by the constant abuse by police officers – and was sentenced to a period in jail. The ordeal was so stressful that McMenamin removed a screw from a radiator in his cell and attempted to cut his wrist with it. He says that officers simply laughed at him when they found out.

Perhaps the most tragic case revealed by The Guardian is that of Robert Hindes and Hugh Hanna, who were only 14 and 16 when they were arrested in October 1976.

Hindes was taken into custody and questioned about the murder a few weeks  earlier of Peter Johnston, 28, a Catholic accountant who was killed by loyalist gunmen at his home in north Belfast.

Within hours after being tortured and beaten he  confessed, and named his accomplice as a Robert Hanna. Hanna was arrested and also confessed.

Print

E-mail

Tweet