Fashion retailer Urban Outfitters’ decision to mark St. Patrick’s Day by selling goods that promote negative Irish stereotypes has attracted the attention of Congressional leaders this week.
On Monday Congressman Joe Crowley of New York, along with nine members of the Congressional Ad Hoc Committee on Irish Affairs, sent a strongly worded letter to the CEO of
Urban Outfitters, calling on the retailer to end the sale of clothing items and accessories depicting negative stereotypes of the Irish and Irish Americans.
The story about the Urban Outfitters line of alcohol-themed Irish products was exclusively reported in last week’s Irish Voice and has since sparked outrage on both sides of the Atlantic, with a Northern Irish politician also expressing outrage.
“By selling and promoting these items, Urban Outfitters is only fueling stereotypes that many Irish Americans, as well as the people of Ireland, work so hard to dispel,” Crowley said in a statement to the Irish Voice.
Congressional members who signed the letter took exception to items advertised by the company as St. Patrick’s Day wear, such as a hat which refers to “Irish Yoga” with an image of an inebriated man falling down and vomiting shamrocks, or a beer bottle with the words “Leprechaun Pi--,” and a green T-shirt with the slogan “Irish I Were Drunk.”
Continued Crowley, “We understand that such items may have been created with the intent of good humor. And, as members of the Ad Hoc Committee on Irish Affairs, we know that Irish and Irish Americans often revel in self-deprecating and blunt humor. However, we believe these items represent a step too far, crossing a line into stereotyping and denigration.”
The letter also asked whether the items in question help promote a culture binge drinking, which they called a serious and deadly problem among young people in the U.S. and around the world.
“We strongly urge you to review your St. Patrick’s Day clothing line and consider its effects on the 35 million-strong Irish American community, as well as its implications for binge drinking. We also hope your review results in the withdrawal from distribution and sale of the items in question,” continued the lawmakers.
The letter quoted World Health Organization statistics that show 2.5 million people around the world die each year from alcohol-related causes.
“About 2,000 alcohol-related deaths occur each year among American college students. Alcohol or drug abuse is a factor in more than a half-million injuries each year -- and also in sexual and other assaults, unsafe sex, poor academic performance and many other problems.”
To that end, the lawmakers claimed, American families understand that binge drinking is no laughing matter.
The letter concluded, “We strongly urge you to review your St. Patrick’s Day clothing line and consider its effects on the 35 million-strong Irish-American community, as well as its implications for binge drinking. We also hope your review results in the withdrawal from distribution and sale of the items in question.”
In addition to Crowley, the letter was also signed by House members Peter King, Richie Neal, Eliot Engel, James McGovern, Bill Pascrell, Jr., Carolyn Maloney, Frank Pallone., Tim Holden and Christopher Smith.
Last week America’s largest Irish organization, the Ancient Order of Hibernians (AOH) called on the Irish community to rally together to have Urban Outfitters remove its offensive St. Patrick’s Day line from their stores, and apologize to the Irish people.
Meanwhile in a letter to Urban Outfitters, the Irish Anti-Defamation Federation stated, “The Irish community is fed up nationwide, and the vast Irish organizations we partner with are working to stop these attacks. We will start email, phone, and letter writing campaigns until this merchandise is removed.”
Last week an SDLP member of the Northern Ireland Assembly, Karen McKevitt, called on Urban Outfitters to remove the items from all of its retail stores.
“I think it was reckless for Urban Outfitters to use this offensive image…A lot of businesses rely on
St Patrick's Day to generate some revenue but when we see big companies trying to make money like this we should not be standing for it,” she said.
14 Comments
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Switch to the desktop site to post a comment.IrelandNorth | Mar 02, 2012, 07:19 AM EST
Seanmor! Thanks for the observations. It's a indication of the insideous nature of imperialist-inspired racism and ethnocentrism that one can end up self-debasing one's own kind unconsciously. Point taken. The use of the epithet "Paddy", particularly in England, is undoubtedly intended as insulting and offensive.
jerryoneill | Mar 02, 2012, 12:46 AM EST
I really think their next brilliant promotion should be a vest with bombs on it with the koran covered with blood and the slogan Allahu Akbar.My guess is that would end our problems with Urban Outfitters.
pilib04 | Feb 29, 2012, 09:36 PM EST
The Navaho Nation is also suing Urban Outfitters for trademark infringement. The scumballs at UO deserve the heat they are taking.
Jimbo1955 | Feb 29, 2012, 02:58 PM EST
I think that we need to lighten up and not take a silly apparel company's tacky clothing too seriously. Who cares? If anyone holds negative opinions or stereotypes of the Irish, they are grievously ill informed and much to be pitied.
DaithiSuibhne | Feb 29, 2012, 02:48 PM EST
The only thing corporations care about is money, they don't give a damn about who they slander just as long as it sells. The only thing anyone can do is not to buy items which they themselves find demeaning.
Seanmor | Feb 29, 2012, 02:45 PM EST
There are many examples of disparaging -some even maligning - phrases and depictions of the Irish as St. Patrick's Day approaches. One of these is calling the day of Ireland's patron saint "Paddy's Day". Sad to say but many one our own people use that term, apparently not realizing that it is a form of self-abasement A few years ago the newly elected chief of the Irish clan to which I belong used the objectionable term without knowing is was the least offiensive I soon e-mailed this gentleman ard reminded him that as a former marine, I always find the term "Paddy's Day" as objectionable as I do "jarhead". The chief promptly issued a statement to all the clan members saying that he hadn't known the term was unacceptable and offered his apologies.
peterson | Feb 29, 2012, 02:25 PM EST
It was dumber than dumb !!
dunning | Feb 29, 2012, 01:23 PM EST
It's about time!!!!The shirts,hats,mugs etc are uncalled for!!!!!!
Rebelforce | Feb 29, 2012, 11:48 AM EST
If Urban Outfitters were encouraging insulting ethnic stereotypes against any other group the story would be all over the news. Apparently, when it comes to "Political Correctness" in America, it's "No Irish Need Apply".
Murph46 | Feb 29, 2012, 10:23 AM EST
Best way to defeat them is to let their inventory rot on their shelves.
Suivness10 | Feb 29, 2012, 10:17 AM EST
I agree w. Hermit Talker and I think an uproar should be made from the Irish community. Stereotyping ISN'T funny and neither is alcoholism. Somebody should shut Urban Outfitters up.
Nelsonbarry | Feb 29, 2012, 10:13 AM EST
The Irish people should just not buy anything from Urban Outfitters. Just boycott their merchandise.
hermitTalker | Feb 29, 2012, 09:59 AM EST
Amazing with all the highly-touted Political Correctness we still have companies, media outlets and others piling on their anti Irish insults and anti-Catholic Church insults which many associate with Ireland from many historic and contemporary sources. try it on Islam and Judaism and see the reaction. It is also very true that the Irish and their friends can reduce the stereotype by getting restaurants and merchants and local media to cut down on the crude rude presumption that St Patrick's Day is not "spring break" for rowdy adults of any ethnicity.
JohnKinMD | Feb 29, 2012, 09:31 AM EST
Get a life people!